Skip to content

Section 4.14 · PDF pages 159–170

Case-V finite-list deformation count and closure of the F8 window

The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.

4.14 Case-V finite-list deformation count and closure of the F8 window

Lemma 4.20 establishes the final numerical division step of CountV once a single finite list of pairwise noniso-morphic characteristic-zero unitary lifts simultaneously satisfies the graded deformation length comparison

a ≤V ≤2E_{𝒪}s and the congruence-number estimate s log ℓ≤(ℓNe)^{C} for a common separating element ϕ. This subsection reconstructs the complete proof of that finite-list count and closes the entire F8 win-dow stream into VWin: Proposition 4.71 proves the graded commutative-algebra length inequalities LemmaM and LemmaM'; Proposition 4.72 instantiates them on the universal framed deformation ring of a unitary-three frame to prove Abs.coord_count and abstract_count; Proposition 4.73 verifies the host-frame construction on K = ℚ(i), the upgrade unitary_lift_of_reduced_core from ThmS6Core_s to ThmS6_s, and the cohomo-logical vanishing suppliers X.So.hostVanE and X.xpp; Proposition 4.74 proves host rigidity hostRigidUE_alt and the separating-Frobenius congruence-number bound hostNumberUE_alt; and Theorem 4.75 closes CountV and summarizes the end-to-end unconditional assembly of VWin.

Proposition 4.71 (Graded Rees-ring length inequality and dual cotangent bound). Let 𝒪 be a complete discrete valuation ring of characteristic 0 with uniformizer ϖ and finite residue field k_{𝒪}.

(i) Dual cotangent length bound (LemmaM'): Let A =⊕_{j∈X}𝒜_{j} be an X-graded 𝒪-algebra (for a discrete abelian group X) equipped with an 𝒪-algebra augmentation x : A →𝒪, and fix j ∈X such that x(𝒜_{j}) = 0. Let (F_{i})_{i∈ι} be a family in 𝒜_{j}, let satSq(x) ⊂A denote the 𝒪-saturation of (ker x)^{2}, let cotLat(x, 𝒜, j) ⊂A/satSq(x) be the image of 𝒜_{j} ∩ker x, and let( cotSpan(x, F) be the 𝒪-submodule) generated by the classes of F_{i}, with cotLen(x, 𝒜, j, F) := len_{𝒪} cotLat(x, 𝒜, j)/cotSpan(x, F). Sup-pose c ∈𝒪 \ {0}, M is an 𝒪-module, and D : M → Hom_{𝒪}(A, 𝒪/(c)) is an injective additive map such that D(µ)(F_{i}) = 0 for all µ, i and each D(µ) is the mod-(c) reduction of a weight-j 𝒪-derivation D^{′}∈ PtDer_{x}(A, 𝒪). Then len_{𝒪}(M) ≤ cotLen(x, 𝒜, j, F).

(ii) Graded valuation-sum inequality (LemmaM): Let K be an algebraically closed 𝒪-field equipped with

a normalized additive valuation v : K → ℝ (IsNVal, meaning v(xy) = v(x) + v(y), v(x + y) ≥ min(v(x), v(y)), and v(c) = ord_{𝒪}(c) for c ∈𝒪 \ {0}). Let A =⊕_{j∈ℤ}𝒜_{j} be a ℤ-graded 𝒪-algebra with augmentation x : A →𝒪 satisfying IsWRing: 𝒜_{0} is a complete Noetherian local 𝒪-algebra with residue field k_{𝒪}, A is generated over 𝒜_{0} by finitely many elements of weights in {−2, −1, 1, 2}, and x(𝒜_{j}) = 0 for j ̸= 0. Let Q = (F, G, E, E^{′}, Z) be homogeneous equations in A with F_{0}, . . . , F_{r} ∈ 𝒜_{−1} (r ≥1), G_{1}, . . . , G_{s} ∈𝒜_{−2}, E_{1}, . . . , E_{r}′ ∈𝒜_{1}, E_{1}^{′}, . . . , E_{s}^{′}_{′} ∈𝒜_{2}, Z_{1}, . . . , Z_{m} ∈𝒜_{0} ∩ ker x, generating the homogeneous ideal I = Q.ideal, and let a ∈𝒜_{0}. Assume:

• (M1) x is a smooth point of graded tangent dimensions (s, r, m, r^{′} + 1, s^{′} + 1) in weights (−2, −1, 0, 1, 2), i.e. there is a graded formal chart φ : A → Frac(𝒪)[[τ]] matching x on constant terms, and F, G, Z rationally span cotLat(x, 𝒜, j) for j = −1, −2, 0 (SpansCot);

• (M2) the image of 𝒜_{0} in A/I is a finite 𝒪-module;

• (M3) at any x_{1} : A →_{𝒪} K vanishing on I and on all 𝒜_{j} (j ̸= 0) with x_{1} ̸= x, one cannot simultaneously have a point of I vanishing on 𝒜_{<0} but not 𝒜_{>0} and a point of I vanishing on 𝒜_{>0} but not 𝒜_{<0} with the same restriction to 𝒜_{0} as x_{1};

• (M4) at every two-signed point ξ : A →_{𝒪} K of I (nonvanishing on both 𝒜_{<0} and 𝒜_{>0}), the space of K-derivations D ∈ PtDer_{ξ}(A, K) vanishing on I has dimension at most 1;

• (M5) x(a) = 0 and ξ(a) ̸= 0 for every two-signed point ξ of I.

Then there exists a finite set T of two-signed K-points of I covering all 𝔾_{m}-orbits of two-signed K-points of I (Covers), the length cotLen(x, 𝒜, −1, F) is finite, and for every such covering set T,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ( )

cotLen(x, 𝒜, −1, F) ≤2 v ξ(a) . (117)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ξ∈T

Proof. Part (i) (mprime_holds). If cotLen(x, 𝒜, j, F) = ∞, the bound is trivial; assume finiteness. Every D^{′} ∈ PtDer_{x}(A, 𝒪) vanishes on (ker x)^{2} by the Leibniz rule, hence vanishes on satSq(x) because 𝒪 is a domain (der_satSq). Therefore each D(µ) factors through the finite-length quotient Q_{j} := cotLat(x, 𝒜, j)/cotSpan(x, F) as an 𝒪-linear map ψ(µ) : Q_{j} →𝒪/(c). Because each D(µ) lifts to a weight-j derivation, D(µ) vanishes on 𝒜_{i} for i ̸= j, so ψ : M → Hom_{𝒪}(Q_{j}, 𝒪/(c)) is injective. Writing (c) = 𝔪_{𝒪}^{k} over the DVR 𝒪, we have len_{𝒪}(Hom_{𝒪}(k_{𝒪}, 𝒪/(c))) ≤ 1, and induction along a composition series of Q_{j} (length_hom_le) gives len_{𝒪}(Hom_{𝒪}(Q_{j}, 𝒪/(c))) ≤ len_{𝒪}(Q_{j}) = cotLen(x, 𝒜, j, F) < ∞. Since k_{𝒪} is finite, a finite-length 𝒪-module N has cardinality |k_{𝒪}|^{len𝒪(N)}; injectivity of ψ gives |M| ≤| Hom_{𝒪}(Q_{j}, 𝒪/(c))| and hence len_{𝒪}(M) ≤ cotLen(x, 𝒜, j, F) (len_le_of_inj).

Part (ii) (main_holds). The proof proceeds in five stages:

(1) Smith normal form (sm_holds). By M1 and rk_holds, cotLat(x, 𝒜, −1) is a free 𝒪-module of rank r ≥1 containing the full-rank submodule N = cotSpan(x, F). Applying Smith normal form over the DVR 𝒪 to N ⊂ cotLat(x, 𝒜, −1) and lifting along the rank-r map 𝒪^{r+1} → cotSpan(x, F) (whose kernel has rank 1) produces an 𝒪-linear change of generators F_{0}^{′}, . . . , F^{ ′}_{r}∈𝒜_{−1} with the same 𝒪-span (hence the same ideal I), elements y_{0}, . . . , y_{r−1} ∈𝒜_{−1}, and exponents c_{0}, . . . , c_{r−1} ∈ ℕ such that F_{i}^{′}−ϖ^{ci}y_{i} ∈ satSq(x) for 0 ≤i < r, F^{ ′}_{r} ∈ satSq(x), and cotLen(x, 𝒜, −1, F) = ∑^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{i} < ∞. Replace Q by Q^{′} using F^{′} in place of F.

(2) Cutting out weight-0 chart variables and ensuring φ(a^{′}) ̸= 0 (cut_holds, nz_holds). Since Z_{1}, . . . , Z_{m} rationally span the m-dimensional weight-0 cotangent space, the graded formal implicit function theorem (ift_holds) solves φ(Z_{k}) = 0 for the m weight-0 variables and yields a reduced graded chart φ : A → Frac(𝒪)[[τ^{′}]] (IsChart0) with φ(Z_{k}) = 0 identically and variable weights in {−2, −1, 1, 2} of multiplicities (s, r, r^{′}+1, s^{′}+1). If φ(a) = 0, pick g ∈𝒜_{1} with φ(g) ̸= 0 (possible since r^{′}+ 1 ≥1) and an index k with φ(F_{k}^{′}) ̸= 0 (possible since F^{ ′} spans the r-dimensional weight- (−1) cotangent space with r ≥1); setting a^{′}= a + gF_{k}^{′} ∈𝒜_{0} gives a^{′} −a ∈I, x(a^{′}) = x(a) = 0, ξ(a^{′}) = ξ(a) on V (I), and φ(a^{′}) = φ(g)φ(F_{k}^{′}) ̸= 0. Otherwise set a^{′} = a.

(3) Finiteness of 𝔾_{m}-orbits (fin_holds, slice_holds). Choose finite 𝒜_{0}-generating sets s_{−2} ⊂𝒜_{−2} and s_{2} ⊂𝒜_{2}. For each pair (f, g) ∈s_{−2} × s_{2}, put C_{f,g} := (A/(I + (f −1)))[ϖ^{−1}g^{−1}]. By M2, C_{f,g} is of finite type over 𝒪. Any K-point ψ of C_{f,g} pulls back to a two-signed point ξ of I with ξ(f) = 1 and ξ(g) ̸= 0. For any derivation D ∈ PtDer_{ψ}(C_{f,g}, K), its pullback D^{′} to A vanishes on I and satisfies D^{′}(f) = 0, while the Euler grading derivation E(h) = jξ(h) (h ∈𝒜_{j}) vanishes on the homogeneous ideal I and satisfies E(f) = −2 ̸= 0. By M4, D^{′} and E are linearly dependent; evaluating at f kills the coefficient of E, hence forces D^{′} = 0 and D = 0. Thus C_{f,g} is finite étale over Frac(𝒪) and has finitely many K-points. Every two-signed point ξ of I has ξ(f) ̸= 0 and ξ(g) ̸= 0 for some f ∈s_{−2}, g ∈s_{2}; choosing t ∈K^{×} with t^{2}= ξ(f) moves ξ into the slice ξ(f) = 1 by the 𝔾_{m}-action h →→t^{j}ξ(h), so the finite union of all slices covers every two-signed 𝔾_{m}-orbit.

(4) Multi-graded Rees algebra and admissibility (admissibility_holds). Over the complete local ring B := 𝒜_{0}, define the three finitely generated B-submodules of A: N_{0} := 𝒜_{−2}, N_{1} := 𝒜_{2}, and N_{2} := B·(F_{r}^{′})^{2}+𝒜_{−}^{2}_{2}𝒜_{2}, and form the ℤ^{3}-graded Rees algebra R_{Rees} := ⊕_{µ∈ℕ}3 N_{0}^{µ0}N_{1}^{µ1}N_{2}^{µ2}T^{ µ} ⊂ A[T_{0}, T_{1}, T_{2}] (mR). Lift the squared/even-weight equations to homogeneous sections ts(Q^{′}) = ts_{F} ‖ts_{R}: ((F_{i}^{′})^{2}T_{0})_{0≤i<r} and (G_{j}T_{0})_{1≤j≤s} in multidegree e_{0}; (E_{j}^{2}T_{1})_{1≤j≤r}′ and (E_{j}^{′}T_{1})_{1≤j≤s}′ in multidegree e_{1}; and (F_{r}^{′})^{2}T_{2} in multidegree e_{2}. Let J := coefIdeal(ker φ) ⊂ R_{Rees}. Because φ(a^{′}) ̸= 0 in the integral domain Frac(𝒪)[[τ^{′}]], multiplication by a^{′} is injective on R_{Rees}/J. Moreover, every prime ideal 𝔭 ⊂R_{Rees} containing J + secs(ts(Q^{′})) + (a^{′}) and avoiding the irrelevant ideal Irr contracts to 𝔪_{B} in B (if not, M2, M3, and lifting along 𝒜_{0} →A produce a two-signed point ξ of I with ξ(a^{′}) = 0, contradicting M5); hence ts(Q^{′}) ‖[(0, a^{′})] is admissible for J.

(5) Koszul Euler-characteristic sandwich (core_holds). Denote by χ(seq, M)(d) the alternating-length Koszul Euler characteristic in multidegree d ∈ ℤ^{3}. We compare three quantities for

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d = (d_{0}, d_{1}, d_{2}) ≫0:

• Lower bound (low_holds). Define the homogeneous leading-filtration ideal 𝔮 := leadKer(Q^{′}, wt, φ) ⊂ R consisting of polynomials whose µ-coefficient has negative-weight order ≥2µ +4µ +1 Rees 0 2 under φ. Then J + (a^{′}) ⊂𝔮, ϖ is a non-zero-divisor on R_{Rees}/𝔮, and because F_{i}^{′}−ϖ^{ci}y_{i} ∈ satSq(x) we have (F_{i}^{′})^{2}T_{0} ≡ ϖ^{2ci}y_{i}^{2}T_{0} (mod 𝔮) (lk_holds). Monotonicity along the graded surjection (R_{Rees}/J)/(a^{′}) ↠ R_{Rees}/𝔮 (mono_quo) and the divisibility lower bound (la_holds) give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∑r−1 ) ( ) ( )
2c_{i} · ∆_{seq}h_{𝔮,ϖ}(d) ≤χ ts(Q^{′}), R_{Rees}/𝔮 (d) ≤χ ts(Q^{′}), (R_{Rees}/J)/(a^{′}) (d),
i=0

where h_{𝔮,ϖ}(d) = len_{B}(((R_{Rees}/𝔮)/ϖ)_{d}) counts τ^{′}-monomials of negative weight 2d_{0} + 4d_{2} and positive weight 2d_{1} + 2d_{2} (hf_holds), and the iterated finite difference ∆_{seq} along r −1 + s shifts by∑ e_{0}, r^{′}+ s^{′} shifts by∑ e_{1}, and one shift by e_{2} evaluates to 2^{r−1+r′} (num_holds). Since

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
′

(^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}2c_{i}) 2^{r−1+r} = (^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{i}) 2^{r+r′}, this yields

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∑r−1 )_{′} ( )
c_{i} 2^{r+r} ≤χ ts(Q^{′}), (R_{Rees}/J)/(a^{′}) (d).
i=0

• Order swap (chain). Because a^{′} is regular on R_{Rees}/J, permuting (0, a^{′}) past ts(Q^{′}) in the Koszul Euler characteristic (ruleNzd, order independence, and ruleUB) yields

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ( )

χ ts(Q^{′}), (R_{Rees}/J)/(a^{′}) (d) ≤χ [(0, a^{′})], R_{Rees}/(J + secs(ts(Q^{′}))) (d).

• Upper bound (up_holds). Put M_{d} := (R_{Rees}/(J + secs(ts(Q^{′}))))_{d}. For d ≫ 0, the right-hand side equals the Herbrand difference θ_{a}′(M_{d}) = len_{B}(M_{d}/a^{′}M_{d}) − len_{B}(M_{d}[a^{′}]), and B/ Ann_{B}(M_{d}) is 𝒪-finite. By prime filtration of M_{d} and the snake lemma (th_holds), primes P of B with P ∩𝒪 ̸= 0 have finite-length quotient B/P (contributing θ_{a}′(B/P) = 0), while primes with P ∩𝒪 = 0 yield 𝒪-finite integral domains B/P on which θ_{a}′(B/P) = len_{𝒪}((B/P)/(a^{′})) = ∑_{τ}v(τ(a^{′})). Every σ : B →_{𝒪} K in the support of M_{d} satisfies idD(𝒜) ≤≤ ker σ and extends to a two-signed point ξ of I, hence equals ξ^{′}|_{𝒜0} for some ξ^{′} ∈T (since 𝔾_{m} acts trivially on 𝒜_{0}). At each such σ, M2 and M4 (via slice_holds) force every weight piece (A/I)_{w} to have localized length at most 1 at ker σ (locLen_quotientWeightPiece_le_one). Replacing each of the r + 1 generators F_{i}^{′} and r^{′} generators E_{j} by its square in ideal2 at most doubles the localized length per generator (locLen_aPiece_sup_span_sq_le_add, locLen_aPiece_ideal2_le_two_pow), giving len_{Bker σ}((M_{d})_{ker σ}) ≤ 2^{r+1+r′}. Since v(ξ(a^{′})) ≥ 0 for all ξ ∈ T (by M2), we obtain ∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
θ_{a}′(M_{d}) ≤2^{r+1+r′} v(ξ(a^{′})).
ξ∈T ∑

Chaining the three inequalities and dividing by∑ 2^{r+r′} > 0 gives ∑^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{i} ≤ 2_{ξ∈T}v(ξ(a^{′})) = 2_{ξ∈T}v(ξ(a)), which is (117).

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/OrbitVanishingLocal.lean:9--129; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/MainCotSpan.lean:12--70; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/Mprime.lean:6--80; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/SmHolds.lean:5--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/CutHolds.lean:6--131; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/NzCoeffMul.lean:5--89; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/FinHolds.lean:8--98; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/SliceHolds.lean:7--209; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/AlgMemCoef.lean:17--143; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/AdmissibilityHolds.lean:12--77; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/AdmissibleMonoIdeal.lean:17--322; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/LkHolds.lean:8--79; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/TwoSigned.lean:17--95; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/HerbrandFinLen.lean:11--259; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/LocLenQuotientWeightPieceLeOne.lean:7--148; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/LocLenAPieceIdeal2LeTwoPow.lean:6--115.

Proposition 4.72 (Coordinate counting and abstract finite-list deformation count). (i) Coordinate count

(Abs.coord_count): Let 𝒪, K, v be as in Proposition 4.71, let R be an 𝒪-algebra with a weighted power-series presentation W : 𝒪[[W.σ]] ↠ R having origin h and graded pieces 𝒮_{j} = W.part(j) with variable weights W.wt(s) ∈ [−2, 2]. Suppose ker W.π is generated by homogeneous power series (f_{j,i})_{i<b(j)} of weight j with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{⎪{−1 j = −1,

b(j) + defect(j) ≤|{i ∈W.σ : W.wt(i) = j}|, defect(j) = 1 j ∈{1, 2},

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
⎪{

0 otherwise,

such that: (m1) linear differentials on ker W.π have trivial kernel in weights j ≤0; (m2) 𝒮_{0} is 𝒪-finite; (m3) every K-point of gradedSub(𝒮) vanishing in all nonzero weights agrees with W.origin(h); (m4) at every two-signed K-point ξ, every derivation D ∈ PtDer_{ξ} is a scalar multiple of the Euler derivation x →→jξ(x) on 𝒮_{j}; and (m5) a ∈𝒮_{0} satisfies W.origin(h)(a) = 0 and ξ(a) ̸= 0 at every two-signed point ξ. Then there exist n, V ∈ℕ and n two-signed K-points ξ_{1}, . . . , ξ_{n} of gradedSub(𝒮) in pairwise distinct 𝔾_{m}-orbits such that: every 𝒪-module M admitting an injection d : M ↪→(W.σ →𝒪/(c)) (c ̸= 0) supported in weight −1 and annihilated by the linear terms of ker W.π satisfies len_{𝒪}(M) ≤V ; and V ≤2∑^{n}_{i=1}v(ξ_{i}(a)).

(ii) Framed unitary-three count (abstract_count): Let ℓ be prime, let 𝒪 be a complete DVR finite over

ℤ_{ℓ} embedded in ℚ_{ℓ} with ramification index E_{𝒪} := ord_{𝒪}(ℓ), and let F be a unitary-three frame sat-isfying F.Ok, F.LocVan, F.Count, F.VanE, F.Cl1, and F.Xpp. Let g_{1} ∈ Γ be marked, let (R, u) be a universal framed deformation of F at g_{1} with wpart(𝒪, u, 0) finite over 𝒪, let ϕ ∈ Γ, and let Good be a predicate on representations Γ →𝒢_{3}(ℚ_{ℓ}) holding for every TypeI point arising from a homomorphism ξ : Sring(𝒪, u) →_{𝒪} ℚ_{ℓ} (IsPtHom). Assume that every IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, Good representation r satisfies F.Rigid(r) and tr r(ϕ) ̸= tr r_{0}(ϕ). Then there exist n, V ∈ℕ and n repre-sentations r_{1}, . . . , r_{n} : Γ →𝒢_{3}(ℚ_{ℓ}) such that:

• every r_{i} is IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, and Good;

• the r_{i} are pairwise nonisomorphic on ker(F.η) (MatIso);

• for every c ∈𝒪 \ {0}, F.shaLen(c) ≤V ; and

• with v_{ℓ}(x) := − log ‖x‖_{ℓ}/ log ℓ,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n ( )
V ≤2E_{𝒪} v_{ℓ} tr r_{i}(ϕ) −tr r_{0}(ϕ) . (118)
i=1

Proof. Part (i). If |{i : W.wt(i) = −1}| = 0, every map d supported in weight −1 forces M to be subsin-gleton, so n = V = 0 works. Otherwise, set r := |{i : W.wt(i) = −1}| ≥1, s := |{i : W.wt(i) = −2}|, r^{′} := |{i : W.wt(i) = 1}| −1, s^{′} := |{i : W.wt(i) = 2}| −1, and m := |{i : W.wt(i) = 0}|. Because b(j) = 0 for |j| > 2, exists_weighted_equations_presenting_ker rearranges the generators (f_{j,i}) into equa-tions Q in the free weighted graded ring FA(𝒪, W.wt) presenting the kernel of toA(W) : FA(𝒪, W.wt) ↠ W.A. Smoothness at the base point x_{0} follows from smoothPt_weightedGradedAlgebra_basePoint, and SpansCot in weights −1, −2, 0 follows from (m1) by spansCot_of_linear_terms_nondegenerate, proving M1. Hy-potheses M2–M5 transfer directly from (m2)–(m5) across the surjection toA(W). Proposition 4.71(ii) (LemmaM) yields a finite covering set T, finiteness of V := cotLen(x_{0}, Fgr, −1, Q.F), and V ≤2∑_{ξ∈T}v(ξ(a_{F} )). Pruning T to one representative per 𝔾_{m}-orbit (exists_cover_with_distinct_orbit_representatives) pre-serves Covers∑ and produces n := |T^{′}| distinct-orbit points ξ_{1}, . . . , ξ_{n} factoring through gradedSub(𝒮) with V ≤2_{i}^{n}_{=1}v(ξ_{i}(a)). For any c ̸= 0 and injective weight-(−1) tangent map d : M ↪→(W.σ →𝒪/(c)) annihilated by linear terms of ker W.π, length_le_cotLen_of_injective_tangent_map lifts d to derivations on FA(𝒪, W.wt) and invokes Proposition 4.71(i) (LemmaM') to conclude len_{𝒪}(M) ≤V .

Part (ii). By exists_adapted, hasOrigin, and exists_relations, the universal framed deformation (R, u) admits a minimal adapted weighted power-series presentation W with origin h pushing u to r_{0} and ho-mogeneous kernel generators indexed by b(j) = dim_{k𝒪} F.Ob(j). By F.Count and finrank_H1L_le, the weight counts satisfy the inequality of Part (i), and all matrix entry weights wt(x, y) lie in [−2, 2]. Define v(x) := E_{𝒪}v_{ℓ}(x); by norm_bound_of_integral_values, v satisfies IsNVal over 𝒪 (for c ∈𝒪 \ {0}, integral-ity over ℤ_{ℓ} pins ‖u‖_{ℓ}= 1 for u ∈𝒪^{×} and ‖ℓ‖_{ℓ}= ℓ^{−1}, so ‖c‖^{E}_{ℓ}^{𝒪} = ℓ^{−ord𝒪(c)}). Set a := tr u(ϕ)−tr r_{0}(ϕ) ∈ wpart(𝒪, u, 0); then W.origin(h)(a) = 0, and for every point ξ with associated representation r (IsPtHom, uniquely existing by existsUnique_isPtHom), ξ(a) = tr r(ϕ) − tr r_{0}(ϕ). We check (m1)–(m5):

• (m1) holds by tangent_coord_eq_zero_of_nonpos_weight: a weight-j (j ≤ 0) linear functional d : W.σ →𝒪 killing linear terms of ker W.π defines a local homomorphism τ : R →𝒪[ε]/(ε^{2}) lifting the origin; F.VanE forces τ_{∗}u = r_{0}, hence d = 0;

• (m2) is the hypothesis that wpart(𝒪, u, 0) is 𝒪-finite;

• (m3) holds because if ξ vanishes on all nonzero weights, its representation r is simultaneously upper-and lower-triangular (isPtHom_sign), hence equals r_{0} by eq_rz_of_diag (using F.Cl1), and isPtHom_act at t = 1 identifies ξ with the origin;

• (m4) and (m5) hold because for any two-signed ξ, isCharZeroPt_of_isPtHom gives F.IsCharZeroPt(g_{1}, r), typeI_of_twoSigned (using F.LocVan and F.Xpp) gives TypeI(F.η, r), hence Good(r) holds; the rigidity and trace-separation hypotheses then supply tangent_eq_orbit for (m4) and ξ(a) ̸= 0 for (m5).

Applying Part (i) produces n, V and distinct-orbit points ξ_{1}, . . . , ξ_{n}, with associated representations r_{i} = rr(ξ_{i}). Each r_{i} is IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, and Good. If r_{i} and r_{i}′ are isomorphic on ker(F.η) (MatIso), then

conj_of_matIso (using ‖2‖_{ℓ} = 1 and the ultrametric inequality on ζ(F.c, g_{1}, r_{i}) to rule out the opposite-

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
×

sign involution) yields t ∈ ℚ_{ℓ} with r_{i}′ = conjBy(tor(t), r_{i}), so isPtHom_act places ξ_{i}′ in the 𝔾_{m}-orbit of ξ_{i}, forcing i = i^{′}. For every c ∈𝒪 \ {0}, mprime_coord constructs an injective weight-(−1) tan-gent map F.ShaO(c) ↪→ (W.σ →𝒪/(c)) annihilated by linear terms of ker W.π, whence Part (i) yields F.shaLen(c) ≤V . Finally, substituting v(ξ_{i}(a)) = E_{𝒪}v_{ℓ}(tr r_{i}(ϕ) − tr r_{0}(ϕ)) gives (118).

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/AbsCoord.lean:18--280; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/AbstractCount.lean:21--164; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/NormBoundOfIntegralValues.lean:5--64; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/TangentCoordEqZeroOfNonposWeight.lean:8--120; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/IsPtHomAct.lean:7--51; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/NormTwoEqOne.lean:7--55; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/PrecompleteOfPowLe.lean:385--426; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/ContinuousCompOfFilteredContinuity.lean:262--399; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/LengthLeCotLenOfInjectiveTangentMap.lean:42--98; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/UnitEqOneOfPowEqOneOfResidueOne.lean:165--208; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/ExistsRelations.lean:53--257; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/IsCharZeroPtOfIsPtHom.lean:13--397; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/TypeIOfTwoSigned.lean:7--579.

Proposition 4.73 (Host-frame suppliers, unitary-lift upgrade, and cohomological vanishing). Fix an odd prime ℓ, a coefficient ring c over ℤ_{ℓ}, an even level N, e ≥1, and a Case-V Dirichlet character ψ ∈h.X(c, e) with h.R_{1}(ℓ, ψ) ≤2^{c2(ψ)}.

(i) Gaussian field, host frame, universal deformation, and Selmer exhaustion: The cyclotomic field K = ℚ(ζ_{4})^{∼}= ℚ(i) satisfies IsQi, with disc(K) = −4 and im(G_{K} →G_{ℚ}) = ker(η_{4}) (gaussian_field_range_eq_ker_quartic_char). The Case-V inequality yields HostData and XData (hostData_of_host). Taking S = {v | ℓN} and Γ_{Ω,S} = G_{ℚ,S} yields a host frame F (exists_hostFrame) satisfying F.Ok (hostFrame_ok), the finiteness condition PhiCond (hostFrame_phi, from GlobalFiniteness), F.LocVan (hostFrame_locVan, from LocalTateDuality and LocalEulerChar), F.Count (hostFrame_count, from local and global Euler characteristics and normalized Poitou–Tate duality), and F.Cl1 (frame_class_one). For any marked g_{1} ∈Γ_{Ω,S}, a universal framed deformation (R, u) exists (exists_isUniv, using ℓ∈𝔪_{𝒪} from l_mem). Moreover, if F.shaLen(a) ≤V for every a ∈c.𝒪 \ {0}, then Vlen(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤ V (vlen_le).

(ii) Reduced-to-full unitary lift (unitary_lift_of_reduced_core): ThmS6Core_s implies ThmS6_s, upgrad-

ing automorphy AutOnAlt on every TypeI point of the universal framed ring to the full BPrime_s clause (open-subgroup irreducibility in ker η_{4} and irreducibility on ker η_{4} ∩ ker χ_{ℓ}).

(iii) Non-positive weight vanishing (X.So.hostVanE) and weight-(−2) Selmer vanishing (X.xpp): Assum-

ing LemmaK, Poitou–Tate duality, and local finiteness, duality, and Euler-characteristic hypotheses, every host frame satisfies F.VanE (HostVanE). Unconditionally (via X.lemmaX, X.residual_bernoulli_nonvanishing, and X.corX), every host frame equipped with XData satisfies F.Xpp (HostXpp).

Proof. Part (i). In K = ℚ(ζ_{4}), ζ_{4}^{2} = −1 generates K/ℚ of degree 2, disc(K) = −4, and σ ∈ G_{ℚ} fixes ζ_{4} if and only if η_{4}(σ) = χ_{4}(cls_{4}(σ)) = 1. For hostData_of_host, 16 | N makes N even, cmDatum_char_two_adic_order_bounds supplies 4 ≤ c_{2}(ψ) and the T_{b} bound, and 2ℓq ≤ 16o(ℓq)^{2} gives

2ℓq ·4^{n0(ℓ,ψ)}≤h.R_{1}(ℓ, ψ) ≤2^{c2(ψ)} (XData). Constructing F on Γ_{Ω,S} factors η_{4}, χ_{ℓ}, and ψ through the max-imal quotient unramified outside S = {v | ℓN}. For frame_class_one, Minkowski’s bound | disc(K)| = 4 makes 𝒪_{K} a PID (pid4), so class field theory (artKer) forces every everywhere-unramified finite-order character of G_{K} to be trivial (char_triv). For hostFrame_phi, GlobalFiniteness on Shapiro permutation modules Γ_{Ω,S}/H → ℤ/ℓℤ proves PhiCond, whence exists_isUniv builds the universal framed deformation (R, u) from exists_univ and cuts out the local conditions by Cut. For hostFrame_locVan and hostFrame_count, at every v ∈T_{b} an element x ∈D_{v} with η(x) = 1 and Ψ(x)^{2}̸= 1 acts without fixed points on Gb(j) (j ̸= 0), killing H^{0} and H^{2} by local Tate duality and H^{1} for v ̸= v_{ℓ} by the local Euler characteristic; global Euler characteristic and Poitou–Tate finiteness then compute dim H_{Sel}^{1} (j) − dim Ob(j) = defect(j). For vlen_le, Vlen(Ω, c, e, ψ) is identified with len_{𝒪}(Sha^{1}(Γ_{Ω,S}, Ψ^{−1}⊗(K_{𝒪}/𝒪))), which is the increasing union of its ℓ^{k}-torsion submodules; each ℓ^{k}-torsion submodule injects into the image of F.ShaO(ℓ^{k}) (tors_le, sha_le), so ∀k, F.shaLen(ℓ^{k}) ≤V forces Vlen(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤V .

Part (ii). The quotient Γ_{Ω,S} = G_{ℚ}/N_{S} by the closed normal subgroup N_{S} is compact, Hausdorff, and totally disconnected (totDisc_quot), so isCharZeroPt_of_isPtHom produces F.IsCharZeroPt(g_{1}, r) from any IsPtHom point ξ. To establish matIrr_open on any open subgroup U ≤ ker(η_{4}), replace U by its finite-index normal core U_{0}, lift the unit 1 + ℓ ∈ ℤ^{×}_{ℓ} to an element σ ∈ I_{vℓ} via surjectivity of χ_{ℓ}|_{Ivℓ}, and set m := [G_{ℚ} : U_{0}] · φ(N); then σ^{m}∈I_{vℓ}∩U_{0} satisfies ψ(σ^{m}) = 1 and Ψ(σ^{m})^{2}= (1 + ℓ)^{2me}̸= 1, which forces irreducibility of r|_{U0} (and hence r|_{U}) from TypeI(F.η, r). To deduce matIrr_cyc on ker(η_{4})∩ker(χ_{ℓ}), suppose a proper invariant subspace existed; by Schur’s lemma on open subgroups of ker(η_{4}) (matIrr_open), the projective action would factor through a finite quotient of χ_{ℓ}(ker η_{4}), giving an open subgroup of ker(η_{4}) on which r splits, contradicting matIrr_open.

Part (iii). For X.So.hostVanE, So.vanEOf splits any weight-j (j ≤0) matrix cocycle γ into the 18 scalar cocycles z_{a,b,s}(g) := γ(g)_{a,b} −(−1)^{s}γ(g)_{b}rev_{,a}rev (s ∈{0, 1}) for the characters Ψ^{j}η^{s}. For j = 0, So.lineZero shows each z_{a,b,s}|_{ker(F.η)} vanishes modulo every power 𝔪^{M}_{𝒪} by F.Cl1 (frame_class_one), hence van-ishes identically by Krull’s intersection theorem, and finite-index averaging (So.cobIndex) makes a nonzero multiple of z_{a,b,s} a global coboundary. For j = −n < 0, So.lineNeg pulls z_{a,b,s} back to G_{ℚ} and invokes So.soCocL (powered by LemmaK and Poitou–Tate duality) together with So.cobIndex at v_{ℓ} to kill a nonzero multiple of z_{a,b,s}. Clearing the 18 nonzero denominators into a common product A and inverting the 2 × 2 sign system with factor 4 yields 4A ̸= 0 making (4A)γ a global coboundary.

For X.xpp, the weight-(−2) residual adjoint piece Gb(−2) is 1-dimensional with Galois character γ = Ψ^{−2}η. Under XData, X.lemmaX proves that the generalized Bernoulli number B_{1}(χ^{−1}) for the corresponding character of conductor f · 2^{n} is an ℓ-adic unit. In X.residual_bernoulli_nonvanishing, smoothing by an auxiliary odd integer a coprime to the conductor with χ(a) ̸= a turns (1−aχ^{−1}(a))B_{1}(χ^{−1}) into an explicit Stickelberger sum nonzero modulo ℓ, which annihilates every everywhere-unramified mod-ℓ cocycle for γ (X.corX). Because ℓ is odd and does not divide [Γ : ker(η × Ψ)] | 2(|k_{𝒪}| −1), vanOf and unrOf transport this vanishing to the weight-(−2) Selmer group on Γ_{Ω,S}, proving F.Xpp.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/GaussianFieldRangeEqKerQuarticChar.lean:7--134; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostDataOf.lean:9--33; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostEx.lean:13--113; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostOk.lean:22--329; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostPhi.lean:6--215; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostLocVan.lean:14--200; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostCount.lean:24--351; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/FrameClassOne.lean:12--268; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/ExistsIsUniv.lean:16--511; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/HostSha.lean:9--164; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Automorphic

Varieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/UnitaryLiftTheoremOfReducedForm.lean:11--39; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/IrrOpen.lean:340--382; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/UnitaryThreeDeformations/IrrCyc.lean:78--91; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/SoHostVanE.lean:11--18; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/SoVanEOf.lean:6--111; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/SoLineZero.lean:6--84; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/SoLineNeg.lean:10--64; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/Xpp.lean:11--84; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/ChrInvNeg.lean:175--210; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/LemmaX.lean:78--303; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/ResidualBernoulliNonvanishing.lean:174--263.

Proposition 4.74 (Host rigidity and separating-Frobenius congruence-number bound). Let h_{H} : HypothesesH' be the shared patching record of Theorem 4.50, let h_{U} := unlEnd3E(linkedUnlE_alt h_{H}) : UnlEndLogNorm be the logarithmic-norm unlinkedness supplier of Proposition 4.53(ii), let h_{L} := adjoint_lifting_of_cohomology h_{H}, and let h_{Num} := numberU3U_of_prints h_{H}.toClassicalTheorems : NumberU3U_s be the common-integer rank-three congruence supplier of Subsection 4.12.

(i) Host rigidity (hostRigidUE_alt): HostRigid_s holds: for every host frame F on K = ℚ(i), marked g_{1}, and characteristic-zero lift r satisfying BPrime_s, every continuous first-order deformation (y, r^{′}) into ℚ_{ℓ}[ε]/(ε^{2}) trivial on N_{v} (v /∈T_{b}), locally diagonal on S_{b}, and locally triangular at v_{ℓ} is a global coboundary (F.Rigid(r)).

(ii) Separating Frobenius and congruence-number bound (hostNumberUE_alt): HostNumber_s holds: let-

ting (a, b) be the uniform exponents furnished by h_{Num} for K = ℚ(i) and setting C := 2a+1+b+3, for every host datum (ℓ, N, e, ψ) and host frame F with marked g_{1}, there exists an explicit separating Frobenius element ϕ = toGS(σ^{−1}) ∈Γ_{Ω,S} such that:

• tr r(ϕ) ̸= tr r_{0}(ϕ) for every IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, BPrime_s lift r; and

• for every finite list r_{1}, . . . , r_{n} of IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, BPrime_s lifts that are pairwise nonisomor-phic on ker(F.η),

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n ( )

v_{ℓ} tr r_{i}(ϕ) − tr r_{0}(ϕ) log ℓ≤(ℓNe)^{C}. (119)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i=1

Proof. Part (i) (hostRigidUE_alt). First, selmer_h1_vanishes_at_rigid_point proves BlochKatoSelmerVanishes for ad(r ∘F.π). Unpacking F.IsCharZeroPt(g_{1}, r) gives a finite DVR subalgebra B ⊂ℚ_{ℓ}, a torus

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
×

element t ∈ℚ_{ℓ}, and an integral lift r^{′} with B.val_{∗}(r^{′}) = conjBy(tor(t), r). By ordPt_of_isPt, r^{′} ∘ toGS is an ordinary point, and BPrime_s supplies ρ : G_{K} → GL_{3}(ℚ_{ℓ}) matching r|_{ker η4} whose χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{1}-twist is conjugate-self-dual automorphic (AutOnAlt), together with TypeI from open-subgroup irreducibility on ker η_{4}. Applying hostUnlE_alt to h_{U} proves unlinkedness Unl(ℓ, N, (e, 0, −e), ρ), which transfers along the conju-gation isomorphism ρ^{∼}= ρ^{′} (by tor(t)) and upgrades via free_at_of_unlinked_of_automorphic_cyclotomic_twist to local freeness FreeAt(ℓ, ρ^{′}). Now rigEnd3_alt (using h_{L} and solvable CM base change isAutCsdA_twist_comp_galEmb_of_repIso_of_flagged) yields BlochKatoSelmerVanishes(ℓ, ad(B.val_{∗}(r^{′}∘ toGS))); conjugation invariance (h1f_vanishing_conj_invariant) transfers this vanishing back to ad(r ∘F.π).

Second, given a first-order deformation cocycle y of r, pull it back to z := y∘F.π ∈Z^{1}(G_{ℚ}, ad(r∘F.π)) and verify the Bloch–Kato local conditions at every finite place w of ℚ:

• if w /∈S, then F.π(I_{w}) = 1 by definition of Γ_{Ω,S}, so z|_{Iw} = 0;

• if w ∈ S \ {v_{ℓ}}, then rig_away shows z|_{Iw} is a coboundary: for w ∈ S_{b} by local diagonalizability (rig_diag), and for w /∈ T_{b} by finite-index averaging (cocycle_coboundary_of_finite_index, rig_avg) since y vanishes on the finite-index subgroup N_{w} ≤I_{w};

• at w = v_{ℓ}, rig_above proves z|_{Dvℓ} ∈ finiteCocycles by rig_loc, using the triangular deformation condition TriIn, the strict ordering e > 0 > −e of inertia exponents (since e ≥1), and distinctness of Frobenius eigenvalues (rig_eig, rig_sub).

Hence z ∈H_{f}^{1}(G_{ℚ}, ad(r ∘F.π)) = 0 is a coboundary s →→ ad(r(F.π(s)))(m) −m; by surjectivity of F.π, y(g) = ad(r(g))(−m) −(−m) is a coboundary on Γ_{Ω,S}.

Part (ii) (hostNumberUE_alt). By h_{Num} applied to K = ℚ(i) ([K : ℚ] = 2), there exist uniform integers a, b ∈ ℕ satisfying the common-integer bound NB over K. Set C := 2a + 1 + b + 3. Given (ℓ, N, e, ψ), exists_p chooses a prime divisor p ≡3 (mod 4) of 12ℓN −1 (which exists by strong induction because 12ℓN −1 ≡3 (mod 4)); then p ∤12ℓN, so p ≥7, p ∤ℓN, and p ≤12ℓN. Since p ≡3 (mod 4), −1 is a non-square in 𝔽_{p}, so any height-one prime w of 𝒪_{K} lying over p is inert with residue norm normV(w) = p^{2} (normV_inert). Fix a valuation B of Ω over p, choose a Frobenius element τ ∈G_{K} at B of degree p^{2}, set σ := τ|_{Gℚ} ∈ ker(η_{4}), and put ϕ := toGS(σ^{−1}) ∈Γ_{Ω,S}.

Fix any embedding f : K ↪→Ω and consider a subset s_{f} ⊂{1, . . . , n} of pairwise nonisomorphic IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, BPrime_s lifts whose AutOnAlt witness uses the embedding f (producing ρ_{i} : G_{K} → GL_{3}(ℚ_{ℓ})). We verify the hypotheses of key:

• By admissible_unitary_three_point (combining adm3 for continuity, irreducibility, and away/above levels with hostUnlE_alt from h_{U}), every ρ_{i} satisfies Adm3U_s; and pairwise non-isomorphism of r_{i} on ker(F.η) = toGS(im(G_{K} →G_{ℚ})) gives pairwise non-isomorphism of ρ_{i} on G_{K}.

• Since χ_{ℓ}(σ) = p^{2} (cycZ_of_isFrob), trace_rz evaluates tr r_{0}(ϕ) = ι^{−1}(eis_{3}(p^{2}, e, z_{0})), where z_{0} := ι(ψ(σ^{−1})) satisfies z_{0}^{φ(N)}= 1.

• Instantiate NB at the inert prime w | p (using p ≥7, p ∤N, and p ∤ disc(K) = −4) on the Aut(ℂ)-stable root-of-unity orbit Orb := µ_{φ(N)}(ℂ) of cardinality φ(N), placing {ρ_{i} : i ∈s_{f}} in the single slot o_{0} = z_{0} and ∅ in all other slots. This supplies a nonzero integer N_{0} ∈ ℤ with log |N_{0}| ≤ a φ(N)(N(e + 1))^{b} log p such that tr r_{i}(ϕ) ̸= tr r_{0}(ϕ) for all i ∈s_{f} and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
‖N_{0}‖_{ℓ}≤ ∏‖‖tr r_{i}(ϕ) −tr r_{0}(ϕ)‖‖_{ℓ}.
i∈s_{f}

• Since |N_{0}| · ‖N_{0}‖_{ℓ}≥1 (log_le_of_norm), taking − log gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑( ‖‖ ‖‖) (

− log tr r_{i}(ϕ) − tr r_{0}(ϕ)_{ℓ} ≤− log ‖N_{0}‖_{ℓ}≤ log |N_{0}| ≤a φ(N) N(e + 1))^{b} log p.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈s_{f}

Applying this on a singleton yields tr r(ϕ) ̸= tr r_{0}(ϕ). For an arbitrary pairwise nonisomorphic list r_{1}, . . . , r_{n}, partition {1, . . . , n} fiberwise over the [K : ℚ] = 2 embeddings f : K ↪→Ω; since v_{ℓ}(x) log ℓ= − log ‖x‖_{ℓ}, summing the fiberwise estimates gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n ( ) (

v_{ℓ} tr r_{i}(ϕ) − tr r_{0}(ϕ) log ℓ≤2a φ(N) N(e + 1))^{b} log p.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i=1

Finally, since ℓ ≥ 3 (odd prime), N ≥ 2 (even positive), and e ≥ 1, we have ℓNe ≥ 6, 2a ≤ (ℓNe)^{2a}, φ(N) ≤ℓNe, N(e + 1) ≤ℓNe, and log p ≤p ≤12ℓN ≤(ℓNe)^{3} (final_bound), yielding (119).

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/EHostRigidU.lean:23--440; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/EHostUnl.lean:17--138; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/FFreeCU.lean:15--106; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/AutUpA.lean:35--147; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/EHostNumberU.lean:21--363.

Theorem 4.75 (Discharge of Case V and end-to-end closure of the F8 window). (i) Case-V bound

(countV_of_finiteness_duality_euler_host, count_v_of_printed_bound_k_reduced_unitary_lift): Given h_{H} : HypothesesH', h_{K} := lemmaK_litN_alt h_{H}.litN, and h_{E,2} : ThmS6Core_s (Theorem 4.54), the Case-V predicate CountV holds with uniform exponent C + 1, where C = 2a + 1 + b + 3 is the exponent of Proposition 4.74(ii).

(ii) End-to-end closure of the F8 stream into VWin: Combining CountI (Theorem 4.17 and Subsection 4.12),

CountII and CountIII (Theorem 4.55 and Subsection 4.13), and CountV (Part (i)) with the auxiliary bounds Win.thmBab_of_lemmaK, Odd.thmBcFree_of, countZ, countVs, and countIV inside Core.of_four_alt and vwin_of_counts discharges vwin_of_hypotheses_H_E_alt, v_window_of_literal_automorphy_n, automorphic_window_of_inputs, and UpperTheory.One.vwin_of_row: the threshold window bound VWin holds unconditionally from the single geometric Galois-representation row input Row0b (proved in Theorem 7.116) and the base-change input baseChangeN (proved in Theorem 4.36).

Proof. Part (i). Fix K = ℚ(i) via gaussian_field_range_eq_ker_quartic_char and obtain the uniform exponent C from Proposition 4.74(ii) (HostNumber_s). Given a host h, odd prime ℓ, coefficient ring c, e ≥ 1, and ψ ∈ h.X(c, e) with h.R_{1}(ℓ, ψ) ≤ 2^{c2(ψ)}, Proposition 4.73(i) builds the host frame F satisfying F.Ok, PhiCond, F.LocVan, F.Count, and F.Cl1. Fix a ring isomorphism ι : ℚ_{ℓ}^{∼}= ℂ. Upgrading h_{E,2} to ThmS6_s by Proposition 4.73(ii) supplies a marked element g_{1} such that the universal framed deformation (R, u) of exists_isUniv has wpart(c.𝒪, u, 0) finite over c.𝒪 and every TypeI point of Sring(c.𝒪, u) satisfies BPrime_s. Proposition 4.74(ii) supplies a separating element ϕ ∈Γ_{Ω,S} for (F, g_{1}), and Proposition 4.74(i) supplies F.Rigid on every BPrime_s lift. Feeding these together with LemmaM, LemmaM' (Proposition 4.71) and F.VanE, F.Xpp (Proposition 4.73(iii)) into Proposition 4.72(ii) (abstract_count) produces n, V ∈ℕ and n pairwise nonisomorphic IsCharZeroPt, TypeI, BPrime_s lifts r_{1}, . . . , r_{n} such that F.shaLen(a) ≤V for all a ∈c.𝒪 \ {0} and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n ( )
V ≤2E_{𝒪}s, s := v_{ℓ} tr r_{i}(ϕ) −tr r_{0}(ϕ) .
i=1

By vlen_le (Proposition 4.73(i)), a_{len} := Vlen(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤ V < ∞, and Proposition 4.74(ii) gives s log ℓ ≤ (ℓNe)^{C} for the exact same list r_{1}, . . . , r_{n} and element ϕ. Since ℓ ≥ 2, N ≥ 1, and e ≥ 1, we have X := ℓNe ≥2 and log ℓ≥0; Lemma 4.20 (arith) therefore yields (a_{len}/E_{𝒪}) log ℓ≤(ℓNe)^{C+1}, proving CountV.

Part (ii). Inside Core.of_four_alt, the remaining auxiliary bounds feeding vwin_of_counts are dis-charged as follows:

• Win.thmBab_of_lemmaK combines h_{K}, the proved Ferrero–Washington theorem FW.ferreroWashington, and the cyclotomic-tower bound PropA.aBound_of_isTower (from Poitou–Tate and local dual-ity/finiteness) to prove ThmBab at C_{t} = 401;

• Odd.thmBcFree_of combines deg, the unconditional Stickelberger bound stickBound, and primeBound_of applied to ML.iv to prove ThmBcFree;

• countZ X.propZ proves CountZ: for the trivial character ψ = 1 at ℓ≥5 and even e ≥2, X.propZ splits on whether ℓ−1 | e (zOne vs. zQuad) to show Vlen(Ω, c, e, 1) = 0;

• countVs (from h_{K} via kBound_le and nrm_le) and countIV (unconditionally via ivField and lossLe) handle the remaining bounded-prime cases inside pointHV_of_counts.

Combining CountI, CountII, CountIII, CountV, CountZ, CountVs, and CountIV inside vwin_of_counts gives PointHV =⇒ ThmHV =⇒ JointWin 401 =⇒ VWin (vwin_of_hypotheses_H_E_alt). Instantiating h_{H} via

Theorem 4.50 (published_hypotheses_from_patching_alt on h_{N} and Theorem 4.43) yields v_window_of_literal_automorphy_n, and assembling h_{N} inside TopMainZj and vwin_of_row from Row0b (Theorem 7.116) and baseChangeN (Theorem 4.36) closes VWin unconditionally (with the established classical literature inter-faces of Proposition 4.45 isolated at their exact stated contracts).

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/CountVOf.lean:11--60; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/LinkedUnlE.lean:55--61; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/HVCore.lean:18--22; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/HeightAndVanishing/JointWinOfCounts.lean:16--33; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/ThmBabOfLemmaK.lean:9--12; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/ThmBcOfPsiBound.lean:291--295; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/HeightAndVanishing/CountZ.lean:5--32; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/PropZ.lean:11--16; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/HeightAndVanishing/CountIV.lean:39--89; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/HeightAndVanishing/CountVs.lean:86--171; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean:25--34; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/TopMainZj.lean:18--74; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/VwinOfRow.lean:4--5.

Remark 4.76 (Transitive audit and closure of the F8 stream). A transitive UTF-8 local-import audit over all nine local source roots verifies zero missing local modules, zero axiom declarations, and zero sorry or admit tokens across the entire Case-V and window-assembly cone: 9 local modules under Mprime.lean, 24 under AbsCoord.lean, 87 under MainCotSpan.lean, 151 under AbstractCount.lean, 2,145 under Xpp.lean, 2,176 under SoHostVanE.lean, 24,602 under UnitaryLiftTheoremOfReducedForm.lean, 24,806 under CountVOf.lean, 25,536 under EHostNumberU.lean, 34,993 under EHostRigidU.lean, 40,797 under HVCore.lean, 51,551 under LinkedUnlE.lean, 55,067 under WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean, and 157,604 under VwinOfRow.lean. Together with Subsec-tions 4.4, 4.7, 4.8, 4.9, 4.10, 4.11, 4.12, and 4.13, this discharges F8-V-finite-list and closes the entire F8 window stream into VWin.