Section 4.13 · PDF pages 147–159
Enlarged-coefficient symplectic congruence bounds for cases II and III
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
4.13 Enlarged-coefficient symplectic congruence bounds for cases II and III
Proposition 4.9 reduces CountII and CountIII to an enlarged-coefficient estimate (main_big) whose exponent depends only on the fixed primitive character χ, and Proposition 4.19 absorbs the explicit level, root-of-unity, and Bertrand-prime factors into (ℓNe)^{C′}. We now prove every remaining automorphic, cohomological, deformation-theoretic, and congruence-number producer entering GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.main_big and its dense-threshold realization sp4Main_alt / countII_and_countIII_of_printsH_of_sp4In, closing the entire symplectic branch for cases II and III and reconciling the two parallel entry points in SymplecticGSp4 and DenseThresholdCases.
Proposition 4.64 (Uniform symplectic congruence number and separating Frobenius). Let P : Hypotheses' (in particular P = h_{H}.toClassicalTheorems for h_{H} : HypothesesH' from Theorem 4.50).
(i) Uniform rank-four congruence integer (numberSp4_n_alt): there exist absolute constants C_{0}, A_{0} ∈ℕ (independent of host, prime ℓ, coefficient ring, weight e, level M, prime p, and root-of-unity order k) such that for every integer e ≥2, every M ≥1, every prime p ≥5 with p ∤M, every k ≥1, and every z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3} ∈ℂ with z_{1}^{k}= z_{2}^{k}= z_{3}^{k}= 1, there exists a nonzero integer NN ∈ℤ satisfying
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(
log|NN| ≤C_{0} φ(k) M(e + 1))^{A0} log p, (109)
such that for every odd prime ℓ̸= p, every algebraic closure Ω/ℚ, every isomorphism ι : ℚ_{ℓ} ≃ℂ, every Frobenius element σ ∈ G_{ℚ} at p, and every finite set X of pairwise nonisomorphic Galois representations r : G_{ℚ} → GL_{4}(ℚ_{ℓ}) satisfying AdmRAlt at (ι, M, (e + 1, e, 1, 0), e + 1), one has tr r(σ) ̸= ι^{−1}(eis_{4}(p, e, z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3})) for all r ∈X and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏‖‖ ( )‖‖
‖NN‖_{ℓ}≤ tr r(σ) −ι^{−1} eis_{4}(p, e, z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3})_{ℓ}, (110)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
r∈X
where eis_{4}(p, e, z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3}) = p^{e+1}z_{1} + p^{e}z_{2} + pz_{3} + 1.
(ii) Separating Frobenius on a good symplectic datum (exists_frob_nonvanishing_with_sha_bound and
count): from NumberSp4Alt (respectively, NumberSp4) with constants (C_{0}, A_{0}), for every good symplec-tic datum D : Raw Ωc, every level N ≥ 1 such that D.ψ, D.ξ, and D.om are trivial on µ_{N}-fixing automorphisms (KillsMu), every k ≥ 1 killing their kth powers, every prime p ≥ 5 with p ∤ N and p /∈ D.S, and every ι : ℚ_{ℓ} ≃ ℂ such that every irreducible characteristic-zero point of D satisfies IsAut4Alt (respectively, IsAut4), there exists a Frobenius σ ∈ G_{ℚ} at D.pl(p) such that D.aVal(σ, r) := tr r(σ) − tr D.r_{0,E}(σ) ̸= 0 for all irreducible r ∈D.EPt, and such that the inequal-ity D.Ineq σ implies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(
nrm_{ℓ}(𝒪, D.sha) log ℓ≤2C_{0}k N(D.e + 1))^{A0} log p. (111)
Proof. We establish (i) in four steps without assuming the Ramanujan conjecture for GL_{4}.
Step 1: Polarized CM eigensystem counting (countP_alt). Fix an imaginary quadratic CM field K/ℚ and an integer n ≥2. For any strictly decreasing weight tuple m : Fin n →ℤ with m_{i} + m_{n−1−i} = wt and |m_{i}| ≤H, any level M ≥1, and any prime p ∤M unramified in K with prime ideal w | p of norm q = N(w), consider the polarized automorphic family SigP(K, m, M) of cuspidal subrepresentations π of GL_{n}(𝔸_{K}) having infinitesimal character infOf(m) at every infinite place, admitting a polarizing Hecke character χ, and possessing nonzero vectors fixed by the congruence subgroup KLev(K, n, M). Passing to KLev(K, n, 3M) ≤ KLev(K, n, M) (klev_three), Borel injectivity P.borelC and Clozel cohomologi-cal realization P.cohC (Proposition 4.46) paired with Weyl dimension bounds (weyl_complex_of_printed_results) and cohomology growth (cohBoundFree) prove cardP_of_prints: at most c_{K}(M(H + 1))^{AK} pair-wise nonisomorphic representations lie in SigP(K, m, M). Automorphism conjugation P.conjC and Hecke-character conjugation (charConj) preserve SigP(K, m, M) and act compatibly on algebraic Satake multi-sets algSat_{n}(q, B) (conjP_alt, via dual_conj and polOfSat_of_thetaSat). Local slope integrality intP'_alt = intP_holds ensures that q^{a}b is an algebraic integer whenever −a ≤ m_{i} for all i. To bound the archimedean sizes of the inverted Satake parameters without Ramanujan, unitary_twist twists π by |det|^{−t} with t = (n −1 + wt)/2 so that the sum of infinitesimal character coordinates vanishes, producing a uni-tary cuspidal representation; the Jacquet–Shalika local bound (jacquetShalikaBound in winC_of_unitary) gives q^{−1/2}< |α| < q^{1/2} and |∏α| = 1, and untwisting (win_algSat) gives the window predicate Win for algSat_{n}(q, B): after inversion, every b in the eigenvalue multiset D.β(s) satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q^{wt/2}/^{√}q < |b| <^{√}q q^{wt/2}, ||| ∏ b||| = q^{n wt/2}. (112)
b∈D.β(s)By exists_eigData, the image of SigP(K, m, M) under its away-from-M Satake system forms a finite Aut(ℂ)-stable dataset D_{K} of size at most c_{K}(M(H + 1))^{AK}. For any r ∈ AdmPNAlt(ι, M, m) attached to π, local-global compatibility levelPA_alt (via levelCore_alt using compatT on rowOf', jumps_above_of_printed_results, globFixed_alt, fixedSs_of_prints, and satFrobT_alt, with potential unlinkedness above ℓ handled by guard_of) places π ∈ SigP(K, m, M) and matches Frobenius eigenvalues at every prime v ∤Mℓ; Brauer–Nesbitt / Chebotarev rigidity (iso_of_frobenius_of_printed_results) therefore makes the induced classification map injective up to RepIso, proving countP_alt.
Step 2: Uniform rational counting across n^{2}+ 2 quadratic CM fields (countQ_alt). Set N_{0} = n^{2}+ 1. By quadFam, fix N_{0} + 1 imaginary quadratic CM fields K_{0}, . . . , K_{N0} with pairwise coprime discriminants,∑ and obtain uniform pairs (c_{i}, A_{i}) from countP_alt for each K_{i}. Set c = 2^{n+1}N_{0i}^{N}_{=0}^{0} c_{i} and A = ∑^{N}_{i=0}^{0} A_{i}. Given any prime p ∤ M, at most one discriminant discr(K_{i}) is divisible by p, leaving an injective index selection u : Fin N_{0} → Fin(N_{0} +1) with p ∤ discr(K_{u(i)}) (exists_avoid). Above p, pick a prime v_{i} of K_{u(i)} with inertia degree f_{i} ∈{1, 2} and norm q_{i} = p^{fi} (exists_over), and let D_{i} be the dataset from countP_alt at (K_{u(i)}, v_{i}). By rootSum, extracting all f_{i}th-root multisets together with a binary tag yields an Aut(ℂ)-invariant dataset D^{′} at prime p satisfying |D^{′}.S| ≤2^{n+1} ∑_{i}|D_{i}.S| ≤c(M(H+1))^{A}, while preserving (112)
(Win.of_pow) and integrality. For any odd prime ℓ̸= p and any r ∈ AdmRNAlt(ι, M, m, wt), the N_{0} = n^{2}+ 1 quadratic characters δ_{i} attached to K_{u(i)}/ℚ are pairwise distinct (signNe); since an irreducible n-dimensional representation admits at most n^{2} self-twists (twCard), there exists i with r ≃≃r⊗δ_{i}, whence r|_{GKu(i)} remains irreducible (resTwo). By admissible_restriction_level_n_of_printed_results (which polarizes the base-changed cuspidal representation over K_{u(i)} via polarization_k_of_printed_results and upgrades SafeRA to SafePA via safeUP'_alt and safeRes'), r|_{GKu(i)} ∈ AdmPNAlt(ι, M, m). Since two representations over ℚ with isomorphic irreducible restrictions to K_{u(i)} differ at most by twisting by δ_{i} (resTwo), each fibre of the restriction map has at most two RepIso classes, separated by the binary tag in bit_of_fibre. Frobenius power compatibility (frobenius_power_compatibility) identifies the f_{i}th powers of the Frobenius eigenvalues of r at p with D_{i}.β, proving countQ_alt.
Step 3: Nonvanishing product integer (number_sp4_of_admissible_to_admissible_n). Specialize countQ_alt to n = 4, m = (e + 1, e, 1, 0) (strictly decreasing with m_{i} + m_{3−i} = e + 1 = wt and height bound H = e + 1), level M ≥1, and prime p ≥5 with p ∤M, obtaining D^{′} with |D^{′}.S| ≤c(M(e + 2))^{A}. Define f : D^{′}.S × (ℤ/kℤ)^{×}→ℂ by
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ( val(u) val(u) val(u))
f(s, u) = b − eis_{4} p, e, z_{1} , z_{2} , z_{3} .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
b∈D^{′}.β(s)Since m_{i} ≥0, D^{′}.int at a = 0 makes every b ∈D^{′}.β(s) an algebraic integer, and z_{j} are roots of unity, so every f(s, u) is an algebraic integer. Every σ ∈ Aut(ℂ) permutes D^{′}.S compatibly with D^{′}.β and acts on kth roots of unity by a unit∏ b_{σ} ∈(ℤ/kℤ)^{×} (exists_unit_pow), hence permutes the values of f. Therefore NN :=_{(s,u)}f(s, u) ∈ ℤ (exists_int_prod). To check nonvanishing and size (est), put x = p^{(e+1)/2} and y = p^{e}≥p^{2}. From (112), the product of the four moduli in D^{′}.β(s) equals x^{4}, so at least one element satisfies |b_{0}| ≤x (WinC.exists_le) while the remaining three satisfy |b| <^{√}p x; hence (WinC.sum_le)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||| ∑ b||| ≤3^{√}p x + x.
b∈D^{′}.β(s)Since x^{2}= py, p ≥5, and y ≥p^{2}, we have (2x)^{2}= 4py ≤y^{2} and (^{√}p x)^{2}= p^{2}y ≤y^{2}, so 2x ≤y and ^{√}p x ≤ y, yielding |∑b| ≤^{7}_{2}y. Meanwhile |p^{e+1}z_{1}^{u}| = py, whereas the remaining terms have modulus at most ^{7}_{2}y + y + p + 1 =^{ 9}_{2}y + p + 1 < 5y ≤ py (because 2(p + 1) ≤ 12 < 25 ≤ p^{2} ≤ y). Thus f(s, u) ̸= 0 for all (s, u), forcing NN ̸= 0, and |f(s, u)| ≤2py ≤(py)^{2}= p^{2(e+1)} (since py ≥2). Taking logarithms (log_abs_le) and using M(e + 2) ≤2M(e + 1) and e + 1 ≤M(e + 1) (size) yields (109) with C_{0} = c · 2^{A+1} and A_{0} = A + 1. Finally, for any odd prime ℓ̸= p, any ι, Frobenius σ at p, and any finite pairwise nonisomorphic set X ⊂ AdmRAlt, autQN'_alt maps X into AdmRNAlt, so r →→(cl(r), 1) is injective on X and satisfies tr r(σ) −ι^{−1}(eis_{4}(p, e, z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3})) = ι^{−1}(f(cl(r), 1)) (trace_eq_sum_of_inv). Because every ι^{−1}(f(s, u)) is integral over ℤ and therefore has ℓ-adic norm at most 1 (norm_le_one), dropping the remaining factors outside the image of X gives (110) (norm_le_prod) and nonvanishing of every factor. This proves (i).
Step 4: Proof of (ii). Apply (i) with M = N, e = D.e ≥ 2, prime p ≥ 5 avoiding N and D.S (hence ℓ ̸= p because ℓ ∈ D.S), and a Frobenius element σ at D.pl(p) (ML.placeBasic). Since ℓ ̸= p, the ℓ-adic cyclotomic character evaluates to p at σ (count_chi), and the diagonal characters of D.r_{0} sat-isfy tr D.r_{0,E}(σ) = ι^{−1}(eis_{4}(p, D.e, z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3})) where z_{1}, z_{2}, z_{3} are the ι-images of (D.om^{−1}D.ξD.ψ)(σ), D.ψ(σ), and (D.om^{−1}D.ξ)(σ) (count_trace), which are kth roots of unity (count_pow). Every irreducible r ∈ D.EPt satisfies AdmRAlt at (ι, N, (D.e + 1, D.e, 1, 0), D.e + 1): level (LevBasis.lean) yields Level (diagonalizing tame inertia via lev_diag and verifying the ordinary flag at ℓ via spPtL) and the symplec-tic similitude duality DualTw with θ = D.th (lev_dual), while safe4' verifies SafeRA by combining ℓ | N (Lev.teichDvd, since D.om has order ℓ−1 and kills µ_{N}) with unlAll_of applied to Th.spUnl. (In
the abstract sibling count of SymplecticGSp4/CountNormInt.lean, AdmR uses Lev.teichDvd directly for Keep.SafeU.) Applying (i) to singletons {r} gives D.aVal(σ, r) ̸= 0 for every irreducible r ∈ D.EPt. Now assume D.Ineq σ: there exists a finite pairwise nonconjugate set Ξ of irreducible r ∈ D.EPt such that nrm_{ℓ}(𝒪, D.sha) log ℓ ≤ 2∑_{r∈Ξ}(− log ‖D.aVal(σ, r)‖_{ℓ}). Applying (110) to Ξ, taking logarithms, and combining with − log ‖NN‖_{ℓ}= v_{ℓ}(NN) log ℓ≤ log|NN| (count_norm_int), (109), and φ(k) ≤k yields (111).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/VWLevel.lean:18--20; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/VWinNumN.lean:35--155; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/CountS.lean:14--70; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/CountNormInt.lean:9--123; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/FrobeniusTraceCountBoundOfCmEigensystemCount.lean:129--335; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/KeepLevel.lean:30--90; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/LevelAdmissibleRestrictionHolds.lean:16--24; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/BrCardP.lean:18--36; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/VConjP.lean:85--117; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/IntFinal.lean:10; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/UnderCPl.lean:21--55; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/SafeUP.lean:16--19; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/AutomorphyLifting/AdmissibleLevelRestriction/UnlAllOf.lean:17--44; De-velopment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/TheoremsMuLinked/GaloisRepresentationTypes/UnlPlace.lean:55--117; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/LevBasis.lean:10--188; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/GaloisRepresentations/AdmissibleResidues/SumThree.lean:7--102; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/GaloisRepresentations/AdmissibleResidues/WinSat.lean:15--78; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/GaloisLibrary/CongNum.lean:9--76.
Proposition 4.65 (Residual Bernoulli nonvanishing, good symplectic data, and level bounds). Let h be a host with h.χ = χ, let t satisfy h.Big t, let ℓ be an odd prime, let c : Coef ℓ be a coefficient ring containing all 2^{h.nII}th and 2^{h.nIII}th roots of unity, let 0 < e < t, and let ψ ∈h.X(c, e) lie in Case II or Case III.
(i) Bernoulli unit theorem and residual cocycle vanishing (lemmaX, residual_bernoulli_nonvanishing, corX): for every odd Dirichlet datum (φ, ξ) of conductor (f, 2^{n}) satisfying XData at (ℓ, d) (namely d > 0, 4 | ℓ^{d}−1, f odd, φ and ξ primitive, ord(φ) | ℓ^{d}−1, f·4^{v2(ℓd−1)}≤2^{n}, and φ(−1)ξ(−1) = −1), the generalized Bernoulli number satisfies ‖B_{1,φξ}‖_{ℓ}= 1, and consequently every locally unramified
continuous 1-cocycle on G_{ℚ} with coefficients in a characteristic-ℓ field k twisted by φξ^{±1} is a cobound-ary (CorX).
(ii) Good symplectic datum (dataEx): there exists a symplectic datum D : Raw Ωc satisfying
D.Good and OfCase for (h, e, ψ): with (n^{′}, p_{1}, m_{0}) = (h.n_{II}(ℓ, ψ), 1, 1) in Case II and (n^{′}, p_{1}, m_{0}) = (h.n_{III}(ℓ, ψ), p_{1}(χ), ord ψ) in Case III, one has D.e = e ≥ 2, D.ψ = dirG(ψ), D.S = primeFactors(2ℓh.Np_{1}), and D.ξ = dirG(ξ_{0}) dirG(ξ^{′}) for a primitive odd 2^{n′}-conductor character ξ^{′} and an even p_{1}-conductor character ξ_{0} of order m_{0}.
(iii) Strict-length comparison, level bounds, and Bertrand prime (shaEq, levOf, pZeroLe): one has
V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤ D.sha, c_{2}(ψ) ≤ n^{′}, and m_{0} | h.o. Setting M = ℓ2^{n′}h.Np_{1} ≥ 1 and k = (ℓ−1)2^{n′}(2h.o) > 0, the characters D.ψ, D.ξ, D.om each satisfy KillsMu at M and have kth power 1. Moreover, the least prime p = p_{0}(ℓh.Np_{1}) at least 5 not dividing ℓh.Np_{1} satisfies p ≥5, p ∤M, p /∈D.S, and p ≤2ℓh.Np_{1} + 10.
Proof. For (i), write v_{2}(ℓ^{d}−1) = e_{0} ≥2, ℓ^{d}= 1+2^{e0}a_{0} with a_{0} odd, and n = m+e_{0} so that f2^{e0}≤2^{m}. Let A ⊂ℚ_{ℓ} be the valuation ring with residue map red : A →k (exists_residue_map_padicAlgCl_integers), and let B ⊂A be the subring whose reductions lie in 𝔽_{ℓ}d. Because φ has order dividing ℓ^{d}−1 and 2 ̸= ℓ is a unit in B, partial summation (genB_prodX and lx_partial) writes B_{1,φξ} = ∑_{u∈ℤ/2}n_{ℤ}ξ(u)g(u) with g(u) ∈B satisfying the shift identity g(u) −g(u −s) = 2^{e0}c_{0} − 1_{u<s}φ(u) for s = f2^{e0}. Reducing modulo the maximal ideal and assuming ∑_{u}ξ(u)g(u) = 0, the Frobenius power sum identity sum_filter_two_pow_roots_eq_zero_of_sum_eq_zero in lx_core isolates the subgroup {x : ξ(x)^{2e0} = 1}, whose elements satisfy x ≡±1 (mod 2^{m}) (pm_of_pow, using ξ(1 + 2^{n−1}) = −1 from primitive_two_pow_character_one_add_half_eq_neg_one). Comparing the s-shift at u = 1 and u = s −1 against φ(1) = 1 and φ(s −1)ξ(−1) = φ(−1)ξ(−1) = −1 produces a contradiction, proving ‖B_{1,φξ}‖_{ℓ} = 1 (lemmaX). Next, residual_bernoulli_nonvanishing takes a nonzero character χ of modulus N > 2 with ℓ∤ ord(χ), χ ̸= χ_{ℓ}, and ‖B_{1,χ}−1‖_{ℓ}= 1, chooses an odd a coprime to N with χ(a) ̸= a (mod ℓ) so that 1 −aχ^{−1}(a) ∈𝒪^{×}, and expresses the Stickelberger element ∑_{b∈(ℤ/Nℤ)}× E_{1}(N, a, b)χ^{−1}(b) as (1 −aχ^{−1}(a))B_{1,χ}−1, which is therefore a unit modulo 𝔪_{𝒪} (sum_eone). Because any locally unramified 1-cocycle z restricted to fixMu(N) lies in the Kummer dual Kum.XDual (using prime-to-ℓ inertia-index killing zero_of_unr), Stickelberger annihilation (homKill) kills z on fixMu(N), and the commutator identity on a lift σ(b_{0}) with χ(b_{0}) ̸= 1 forces z(g) = (γ(g) −1) z(σ(b_{0}))/(γ(σ(b_{0})) −1). Combining lemmaX and residual_bernoulli_nonvanishing on (φ, ξ) and (φ^{−1}, ξ^{−1}) proves corX.
For (ii), the auxiliary construction core in DataEx.lean invokes rawEx to build D with D.S = primeFactors(2ℓh.Np_{1}), D.ψ = dirG(ψ), and D.ξ = dirG(ξ_{0}) dirG(ξ^{′}), and verifies every clause of D.Good:
• every v ∈D.T lies in T_{b}(ℓ, ψ) (t_sub), so v is odd and satisfies v = ℓ or v ≡1 (mod ℓ);
• the non-triviality D.condD at Frobenius elements D.sg(v) follows by raising (D.ξD.Ψ^{i})(D.sg(v)) = 1 to the power 2^{a}u killing ψ and ξ_{0}, lifting to dirG(ξ^{′})(D.sg(v))^{2au} = 1 via prime-to-ℓ congruence rigidity, and contradicting two_pow_lt_sq_mul_of_primitive_char_pow_eq_one under the inequality
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v^{2}2^{a}≤2^{n′};• the residual vanishing D.XVan for D.α^{±1}, D.β^{±1}, D.θ^{±1} follows from corX via dirX and xvOf once the conductor product is bounded by 2^{n′} (using f_{0}(ℓ, ψ) and n_{0}(ℓ, ψ) = v_{2}(ℓ^{f0}−1));
• non-triviality of D.Ψ follows from psi_ne using χ_{P} (ℓ, ψ) ̸= 1.
In Case II, the ceiling-logarithm definition of n^{′}= h.n_{II} yields c_{2}(ψ) + 6 ≤n^{′} and both conductor bounds; exists_primitive_odd_dirichletCharacter_two_pow supplies ξ^{′} over 𝒪 (using the 2^{n′}th roots of unity), and setting p_{1} = 1, ξ_{0} = 1, a = c_{2}(ψ) + 1 + v_{2}(h.o), and u = ordCompl_{2}(h.o) ℓ^{s} discharges core. In Case III, ord(ψ) is odd and nontrivial, so c_{2}(ψ) = 0, κ(ℓ, ψ) = 1, T_{b}(ℓ, ψ) = {ℓ}, and ord(ψ) | h.o | p_{1}(χ) −1; exists_primitive_odd_dirichletCharacter_two_pow gives ξ^{′} of conductor 2^{n′} (n^{′} = h.n_{III} ≥3), exists_dirichletCharacter_prime_of_orderOf_dvd gives ξ_{0} of conductor p_{1} = p_{1}(χ) and exact order ord(ψ) (hence ξ_{0}(−1) = 1), and a = 0, u = ord(ψ) discharge core.
For (iii), V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤ D.sha (shaEq) follows from vlen_le: at any prime p ∈ D.S not dividing ℓh.N, dirG(ψ) is unramified at p, so inflation-restriction (Chr.locUnr) makes restriction from Dec(A) to Ine(A) injective on the local cohomology module, showing the local conditions defining V_{len} imply those
defining D.sha. For levOf, h.N, p_{1}, 2^{n′}, and ℓ all divide M = ℓ2^{n′}h.Np_{1}, so D.ψ, D.ξ, and D.om each kill µ_{M}-fixing automorphisms (cls_one, dirG_one); similarly ℓ−1, 2^{n′}, and 2h.o divide k = (ℓ−1)2^{n′}(2h.o), and decomposing ψ into its 2-part (whose conductor is 2^{c2(ψ)} | 2^{n′}, hence φ(2^{c2(ψ)}) | 2^{n′}) and odd-prime parts (each of order dividing 2h.o) shows ψ^{k} = 1, while φ(2^{n′}) | 2^{n′}, m_{0} | h.o, and D.om^{ℓ−1} = 1 give D.ξ^{k} = 1 and D.om^{k} = 1. Finally, Bertrand’s postulate applied to ℓh.Np_{1} + 5 (pZeroLe) produces a prime p = p_{0}(ℓh.Np_{1}) with 5 ≤ p ≤ 2ℓh.Np_{1} + 10 and p ∤ ℓh.Np_{1}; since p ≥ 5, p ∤ 2, whence p ∤2^{n′}(ℓh.Np_{1}) = M and p ∤2ℓh.Np_{1}, so p /∈D.S.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/LemmaX.lean:32--303; De-velopment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/LxCore.lean:21--100; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/ResidualBernoulliNonvanishing.lean:174--263; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/ChrInvNeg.lean:175--210; De-velopment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/DataEx.lean:22--449; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ValProd.lean:31--105; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/DirGPowOne.lean:55--108; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/HeightAndVanishing/PZeroLe.lean:6--14.
Proposition 4.66 (Local charts, Galois cohomology numerics, and the global graded deformation model). Let D : Raw Ωc satisfy D.Good, and let h_{P} : CohomologyHyp (for h_{H} : HypothesesH', h_{P} = (adjoint_lift_of_prints h_{H}).coh). Then:
(i) Finiteness condition (phiGam): the S-ramified Galois group D.Gam = G_{ℚ,D.S} satisfies Mazur’s finite-ness condition PhiCond at ℓ.
(ii) Adjoint cohomology dimensions (nums): for every root weight j ∈ℤ^{2} of the 𝔾^{2}_{m}-graded Lie algebra
𝔰𝔭_{4} over the residue field 𝔽 of 𝒪, the framed obstruction space D.frame.Ob(ad_{j}) is finite-dimensional over 𝔽, satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{⎪{2, j = 0,dim_{𝔽} Ob(ad_{j}) = dim_{𝔽} H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) + 1, j = ±w_{Ψ}, (113)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
⎪{0, otherwise,
and satisfies H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) = 0 for all j /∈{0, w_{Ψ}, −w_{Ψ}}.
(iii) Local base deformation ring (locBase): there exists a completed coproduct L : LocBase D of the
universal local symplectic deformation rings at ℓ (ordinary with fixed inertia characters condL) and at every p ∈D.Sb (trivial on I_{p} ∩ ker D.ψ, condP), equipped with a ℤ^{2}-graded presentation whose origin D.r_{0} is smooth of weighted dimensions dimL + |D.Sb| dimP.
(iv) Global graded model (lemmaP and exModel): Alg.lemmaP holds unconditionally, and produces a global
graded symplectic deformation model M : Model D consisting of a ℤ^{2}-graded complete local 𝒪-domain (R, W) smooth at its origin of weighted dimensions tDims(r, r^{′}, m) with r = 1 + |D.Sb| + a(−w_{Ψ}) ≥ 1, a surjection π : R → S with kernel generated by r + 1 equations F_{i} of weight −w_{Ψ} = (0, −1), r^{′} equations E_{i} of weight w_{Ψ} = (0, 1), and m equations Z_{i} of weight 0 vanishing at the origin, a generating normalized lift r_{u} : G_{ℚ} → GSp_{4}(S) satisfying D.IsPt r_{u}, and a lifting map sending every normalized Sha cocycle z ∈D.ShaCoc a (a ∈𝒪 \ {0}) to a weight-(−w_{Ψ}) point derivation δ : R →𝒪 carrying ker π into (a) and reproducing D.th(g)z(g) and D.Ψ(g)z(g) on the (2, 0) and (3, 1) entries of r_{u}(g).
Proof. For (i), for any open subgroup H ≤D.Gam of finite index, continuous homomorphisms H →ℤ/ℓℤ inject into Z^{1}(D.Gam, Ind^{D.}_{H}^{Gam}(ℤ/ℓℤ)) (phi_condition_of_finite_cohomology using the permutation rep-resentation permR); since B^{1} is finite and H^{1} is finite by global cohomology finiteness h_{P} .gf (as ℓ∈D.S), there are only finitely many such homomorphisms, proving phiGam.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j
For (ii), the residue representation ad_{j} is scalar of character γ_{j} = D.α^{1}D.Ψ^{j2} and dimension dimP(j) (spAct, spDim). Global Euler-characteristic and Poitou–Tate duality (galCount and scalDim, fed by h_{P} ) com-pute dim Ob(ad_{j}) − dim H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) whenever dim ad_{j}= 0 or γ_{j}̸= χ_{ℓ} (nums_gen): at j ∈{0, ±w_{Ψ}} complex conjugation acts trivially (γ_{j}(D.cc) = 1 ̸= −1 = χ_{ℓ}(D.cc)), adding dimP(j) ∈{2, 1}; at the six odd roots
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
±1 ±1
j ∈ oddRoots, γ_{j} ∈{D.α , D.β , D.θ^{±1}} satisfies γ_{j}(D.cc) = −1, γ_{j}(D.sg(v)) ̸= 1 for every v ∈D.T (from D.condD), and D.XVan (from D.xvan), whence γ_{j}(D.sg(ℓ)) ̸= 1 = χ_{ℓ}(D.sg(ℓ)) and h1cZero forces H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) = 0 (nums_all); at all weights outside wts, dimP(j) = 0 forces H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) = 0. This proves nums.
For (iii), for each v ∈D.T, the decomposition group D.Gp(v) embeds openly into G_{ℚv} (decEmb) and inherits PhiCond from h_{P} .loc (phi_dec), so universal lifting rings exist (univ_lift). Both condL (at ℓ, en-coding GSp_{4}-similitude plus Ord via characteristic polynomial and projector equations ordSet) and condP (at p ∈D.Sb, encoding similitude plus triviality on I_{p} ∩ ker D.ψ) are closed conditions (closedL, closedP) sat-isfied by the diagonal lift D.r_{0} and stable under conjugation by the diagonal symplectic torus 𝔾^{2}_{m} (tstable, gsp_conj, ord_conj), so univ_cond and lift_grading endow their universal rings with ℤ^{2}-graded presenta-tions. The local smooth formal power-series charts spChartL (dimension dimL) and spChartP (dimension dimP) verify IsChart at the origin via lb_chart (pkL, pkP). Forming their completed coproduct (coprod, chart_sum, chart_gr in pk_sum) gives L : LocBase D with smooth dimension function dimL + |D.Sb| dimP.
For (iv), Alg.lemmaP (LemmaP.lean) constructs the universal framed global deformation ring over a graded local base (B, W_{B}) in four steps: representability (framed_univ, using 2 ∈𝒪^{×} and PhiCond), torus-invariant grading (framed_grading), weighted relative tangent generators matching dim H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) (framed_tangent), and a relative graded presentation (rel_pres) whose homogeneous relation counts in each weight j are bounded by dim Ob(ad_{j}) (and equalized by adding zero relations if needed). In exModel, applying Alg.lemmaP to (D, L, h_{Φ}, h_{N}) (nonempty_local_frames_of_good_data) produces a framed global ring F.U over L.B with universal lift F.r and framing matrices F.α_{v} (v ∈D.T, F.α_{ℓ}= 1), and nonempty_cover_of_relative_presentation_smoothPt lifts the relative presentation to a smooth formal cover C over L.B. To pass from framed deformations to normalized unframed deformations, let tOdd collect the 6|D.T| odd-weight entries (p_{6}(k)) of F.r(D.ph) (at v = ℓ) and F.α_{v} (at v ∈D.Sb), and let sEq collect the 4|D.Sb| + 2 even-weight entries (F.α_{v} −1)_{p4(k)} (v ∈D.Sb) and (D.hEl(F.r))_{p2(k)}. Because the diagonal characters of D.r_{0}(D.ph) have distinct residue values on pairs with distinct λ-weights (ph_ne), the six 𝔰𝔭_{4} root matrices rootVec yield independent point derivations isolating each entry of tOdd (tOdd_ind, via exists_pointDerivation_framed_commutator_tangent). By tower (exists_smooth_quotient_by_weighted_equations), quotienting the smooth cover by tOdd yields a smooth domain (R, W) whose weighted tangent dimensions satisfy n^{′}(j) + (|D.Sb| + 1) #{k : wp(p_{6}(k)) = j} = dimL(j) + |D.Sb| dimP(j) + a(j), where a(j) = dim H_{c}^{1}(ad_{j}) vanishes outside {0, ±w_{Ψ}} by (ii); explicit weight counting (dims) evaluates n^{′} = tDims(r, r^{′}, m) with r = 1 + |D.Sb| + a(−w_{Ψ}) ≥1, r^{′} = 2 + |D.Sb| + a(w_{Ψ}), and m = 2 + 2|D.Sb| + a(0). Quotienting R by the images of the relative relations of C together with sEq gives π : R → S: by (ii) and cnt, all defining equations lie in weights −w_{Ψ}, w_{Ψ}, and 0, with exact counts r + 1, r^{′}, and m (enum). Vanishing of tOdd and sEq on S forces (F.α_{v})|_{S} = 1 for every v ∈ D.T (al_one via sixBlock), hence D.Nrm(r_{u}) (nrm), local matching (loc_eq), and generation (gen). Finally, given any z ∈D.ShaCoc a, exists_quotientDerivation_of_shaCocycle produces a weight-(−w_{Ψ}) quotient derivation on F.U vanishing on sEq (since z(D.g_{0}) = z(D.g_{0}^{−1}) = 0) and on all weights other than −w_{Ψ} (since none of the odd-weight tOdd entries has weight −w_{Ψ}), which tower lifts to the required 𝒪-valued point derivation δ on R.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/PhiGam.lean:22--100; De-
velopment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/NumsZero.lean:14--168; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/LocBase.lean:64--533; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/LemmaP.lean:256--424; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/NonemptyLocalFramesOfGoodData.lean:117--214; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ExModel.lean:37--520.
Proposition 4.67 (Symplectic tangent rigidity and cyclotomic Selmer finiteness). Let h_{H} : HypothesesH' and let h_{K} := lemmaK_litN_alt h_{H}.litN : ∃C_{K}, LemmaK C_{K}.
(i) Symplectic tangent cocycles are Bloch–Kato (tanBK): for every good datum D : Raw Ωc, every r ∈ D.EPt, and every dual-number deformation r^{′}∈D.PtIn(DualNumber(ℚ_{ℓ})) lifting r, the map z(g) = snd(r^{′}(g)) r(g)^{−1} is a continuous 𝔰𝔭_{4}-valued Bloch–Kato 1-cocycle for ad(r) (Af.IsBK).
(ii) Rigidity at automorphic irreducible points (rigSp4_alt and rigid): taking U = adjoint_lift_of_prints h_{H}
and h_{ad} = adjoint_lifting_of_cohomology h_{H}, the theorem rigSp4_alt proves RigiditySymplecticFour: for every datum D satisfying Ctx2 D ∨ Ctx3 D, every N ≥1 killing µ_{N} for D.ψ, D.ξ, D.om, and every irreducible r ∈D.EPt satisfying IsAut4Alt at ι, one has D.RigidAt r (every dual-number lift r^{′} satisfies snd(r^{′}(g)) = Xr(g) −r(g)X for some X ∈𝔰𝔭_{4}(ℚ_{ℓ})). Under the abstract hypothesis Af.AdVanishQ, the identical symplectic-projection argument proves GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.rigid.
(iii) Cyclotomic Selmer vanishing and finiteness (soBar and soFin): from h_{K} and the cohomology fields
of h_{H}.litN, both SoV and SoFin hold for every algebraic closure Ω/ℚ and every prime ℓ.
Proof. For (i), direct computation on dual numbers verifies the cocycle identity tb_coc, continuity tb_cont, and z(g) ∈𝔰𝔭_{4} (tb_sp, because the similitude character D.th has vanishing dual part). At any finite place w ∤ℓ, r^{′} is trivial on an open subgroup of an inertia group I_{A} above w (tb_place, using D.condP at p ∈D.Sb and D.UnrT elsewhere), so averaging over the finite quotient I_{A}/(I_{A}∩N) (tb_avg) makes z|_{IA} a coboundary. At ℓ, tb_desc descends r^{′} to a finite extension K/ℚ_{ℓ}, ordLocal conjugates r^{′}|_{Dℓ} into an upper-triangular flag with strictly decreasing Hodge–Tate weights (D.e + 1, D.e, 1, 0) whose diagonal characters agree with the cyclotomic powers on an open normal subgroup U ≤D_{ℓ} containing D.sg(ℓ) (tb_sub), and uniqueness of the flag (tb_uniq) matches its first-component characters with those of spPtL, verifying the non-adjacent character condition κ_{i} ̸= κ_{j}χ_{ℓ} on U. Therefore Loc.pr6 and Loc.z1fCoef (tb_loc, tb_atL) place z|_{Dℓ} in Loc.finiteCocycles, proving Af.IsBK.
For (ii), let r ∈D.EPt be irreducible and satisfy IsAut4Alt at ι. First, exists_cm_field_twist_h1 pro-duces an imaginary quadratic CM field K_{0} = T.K ⊂ Ω with a fit deep tower T (spPt) and a rank-four unitary Hida link K (nonempty_link_of_fit_deep_unramified) such that r|_{GT.L} remains irreducible: autKQ0_alt establishes automorphy over T.K, freePUA_alt (fed by spUnl) establishes local freeness at ℓ, solv-able base change (automorphic_of_gsp4_rigid_solvable_galois and automorphy_up_base_change) lifts au-tomorphy and WitA to T.L, adjoint_vanishing_gsp4_rigid_point invokes h_{ad} : AdjointLiftingTheorem via nice0four_alt to prove AdZero over T.L, and adDown descends the vanishing H_{f}^{1}(ℚ, R) = 0 to every rep-resentation R satisfying Af.IsAdOf(r|_{GK0}, θ|_{GK0}, R) (with θ = D.th). (In GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.rigid, this vanishing is supplied directly by Af.AdVanishQ applied to an imaginary quadratic field from irrK.) Now let η : G_{ℚ} →{±1} be the quadratic character of K_{0}/ℚ (rg_sign, trivial on G_{K0} and −1 on complex conjugation D.cc), and let rgP(X) =_{2}^{1}(X −adj(X)) be the ad(r)-equivariant idempotent projection of M_{4} onto 𝔰𝔭_{4} (rg_adjConj). By rg_twist and rg_alg, define
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ( )
ρ(g)(X) = ad(r)(g) rgP(X) + η(g) ad(r)(g) X − rgP(X) .
Then ρ|_{GK0} = ad(r|_{GK0}), while for g = D.cc (where η(g) = −1) the identity rgP(X) −(X − rgP(X)) = − adj(X) and X^{T}J = J adj(X) (rgJ_adj) yield ρ(D.cc)(X) = −P^{−1}X^{T}P with P = Jr(D.cc)^{−1}, which
satisfies the conjugate-similitude pairing rg_pair. Thus ρ satisfies Af.IsAdOf, so H_{f}^{1}(ℚ, ρ) = 0. Given any dual-number lift r^{′} of r, part (i) produces z ∈ Z^{1}(ad(r)) with Af.IsBK and z(g) ∈ 𝔰𝔭_{4}. Because rgP(z(g)) = z(g) and rgP intertwines ad(r) and ρ, rg_bk implies z ∈ Z^{1}(ρ) and Af.IsBK for ρ. Hence z(g) = ρ(g)(X) −X for some X ∈M_{4}(ℚ_{ℓ}); applying rgP yields z(g) = r(g)rgP(X)r(g)^{−1}− rgP(X), so snd(r^{′}(g)) = (−rgP(X))r(g) −r(g)(−rgP(X)) with −rgP(X) ∈𝔰𝔭_{4}, proving D.RigidAt r.
For (iii), lemmaK_litN_alt applies lemmaK to the unconditional odd-weight class bound bOdd and the coho-mology hypotheses of h_{H}.litN to obtain (C_{K}, h_{L}) with LemmaK C_{K}. In soFin, given an open-kernel character ψ : G_{ℚ} →𝒪^{×} and e ≥1, form the totally complex finite abelian extension L = Ω^{ker(ψ×clsN)} (N = 4 if ℓ= 2 and N = ℓ otherwise, exists_ab), which contains µ_{N}. Then LemmaK supplies finiteness of the relevant Galois cohomology group over L, shaLeV bounds shaLen(e) < ∞, and inflation-restriction (Chr.upV and Chr.h0Nu, together with nu_ne_top on the open image of χ_{ℓ}(ker ψ)) yields Chr.V ℓe ψ ̸= ⊤. In soBar, given a continuous 1-cocycle c : G_{ℚ} → ℚ_{ℓ} for θ = ψ^{−1}χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e} that is locally trivial on all inertia groups and on decomposition groups above ℓ, the finite image of ψ lies in a finite extension K_{0}/ℚ_{ℓ} (char_finext). Cov-ering ℚ_{ℓ} by a countable family {K_{i}} of finite extensions (exists_countable_family), the closed subgroups H_{i} = {g : c(g) ∈K_{0} ⊔K_{i}} cover G_{ℚ}, so Baire’s category theorem produces an open subgroup H_{i} and ad-joining the finitely many coset representatives’ values places c inside a finite extension E/ℚ_{ℓ} (coc_finext), where soVec (driven by LemmaK) concludes that c is a coboundary.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/TbTriDiag.lean:19--404; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/ExistsCmFieldTwistH1.lean:28--104; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/AdjointVanishingGsp4RigidPoint.lean:31--101; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/RigSp4.lean:26--195; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/RgAdjConj.lean:14--205; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/ExistsAb.lean:14--99; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/FdAdjoinRange.lean:11--96; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/KFinal.lean:11; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/LemmaKOfLitN.lean:12--13.
Proposition 4.68 (Graded-ring length inequalities and the symplectic congruence bound). (i) Abstract
graded-ring length bounds (Alg.M.mprime_holds and Alg.M.main_holds): both LemmaM' and LemmaM hold unconditionally.
(ii) Symplectic length inequality (galoisRep_ineq_of_allIrreducible_nonvanishing): let D : Raw Ωc sat-
isfy D.Good, let M : Model D, and assume h_{L} : LocalPublishedTheorems, SoV Ωℓ, SoFin Ωℓ, D.Fin0, D.NoEnd, and D.AllIrr(D.RigidAt). Then for every g ∈G_{ℚ} such that D.aVal(g, r) ̸= 0 for all ir-reducible r ∈ D.EPt, the conclusion D.Ineq g holds: D.sha ̸= ⊤ and there exists a finite pairwise nonconjugate set Ξ of irreducible r ∈D.EPt such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑( )
nrm_{ℓ}(𝒪, D.sha) log ℓ≤2 − log ‖D.aVal(g, r)‖_{ℓ} . (114)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
r∈Ξ
Proof. We first prove (i). For LemmaM' (mprime_holds), any 𝒪-valued point derivation D^{′} at x : A →𝒪 van-ishes on the saturated square satSq(x) (der_satSq). Hence an injective additive map M → Hom_{𝒪}(A, 𝒪/c𝒪) whose values lift to weight-j point derivations vanishing on F_{i} ∈ 𝒜_{j} factors injectively into Hom_{𝒪}(cotLat_{x}(𝒜_{j})/ cotSpan_{x}(F), 𝒪/c𝒪). Because length_{𝒪}(Hom_{𝒪}(𝒪/𝔪, 𝒪/c𝒪)) ≤ 1 (length_hom_residue_le), dévissage (length_hom_le) and cardinality comparison over the finite residue field (len_le_of_inj) yield length_{𝒪}(M) ≤ cotLen_{x}(𝒜_{j}, F).
For LemmaM (main_holds), let A =⊕_{n∈ℤ}𝒜_{n} be a weighted 𝒪-algebra with smooth origin x : A →𝒪 of weighted dimensions (r, s, r^{′}+ 1, s^{′}+ 1, m) (r ≥1) and equations Q = (F, G, E, E^{′}, Z) satisfying M1–M5 for a ∈𝒜_{0}. Four commutative-algebraic steps establish the factor-2 bound:
(1) Smith normal form on the degree-(−1) cotangent lattice (sm_holds): since cotLat_{x}(𝒜_{−1}) is torsion-free of rank r (rk_holds) and cotSpan_{x}(F) has full rank r by M1, sm_smith and sm_lift replace F_{0}, . . . , F_{r} by an 𝒪-span basis F_{0}^{′}, . . . , F^{ ′}_{r} such that F^{ ′}_{i} ≡ ϖ^{ci}y_{i} (mod satSq(x)) for 0 ≤ i < r, F_{r}^{′}∈ satSq(x), and cotLen_{x}(𝒜_{−1}, F) = ∑^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{i} < ∞.
(2) Elimination of degree-0 equations (cut_holds) and non-zero-divisor adjustment (nz_holds): because Z_{0}, . . . , Z_{m−1} span the degree-0 cotangent lattice, the formal implicit function theorem (ift_holds) produces a graded formal chart φ : A → Frac(𝒪)[[τ]] vanishing on all Z_{i} with weighted variable counts (r, s, r^{′}+ 1, s^{′}+ 1, 0). If φ(a) = 0, pick g ∈𝒜_{1} with φ(g) ̸= 0 and k with φ(F_{k}^{′}) ̸= 0 and replace a by a^{′} = a + gF_{k}^{′} ∈𝒜_{0}; then a^{′} −a ∈Q.ideal, x(a^{′}) = x(a) = 0, ξ(a^{′}) = ξ(a) on V (Q.ideal), and φ(a^{′}) ̸= 0.
(3) Finiteness of two-signed 𝔾_{m}-orbits (fin_holds): using finite generation of 𝒜_{±2} over 𝒜_{0} (fg_holds), finiteness of 𝒜_{0}/(I ∩𝒜_{0}) (M2), and the dimension-≤1 tangent bound at two-signed points (M4, giv-ing finite slices slice_holds where a generator of 𝒜_{−2} is normalized to 1), all two-signed points of V (Q.ideal) fall into finitely many 𝔾_{m}-orbits, covered by a finite set T.
(4) Tri-graded Rees-algebra Euler-characteristic sandwich (core_holds): form the tri-graded Rees al-gebra mR(Q) over 𝒜_{0} for the three finitely generated 𝒜_{0}-modules N_{0} = 𝒜_{−2}, N_{1} = 𝒜_{2}, and N_{2} = (F_{r}^{′}) + 𝒜_{−}^{2}_{2}𝒜_{2}, with homogeneous section list ts(Q) consisting of (F^{ ′}_{i})^{2} ∈N_{0} (0 ≤i < r), G_{i} ∈ N_{0}, E_{i}^{2} ∈ N_{1}, E_{i}^{′} ∈ N_{1}, and F^{ ′}_{r} ∈ N_{2}, and set J = coefIdeal(ker φ) ⊂ mR(Q). Because φ(a^{′}) ̸= 0, a^{′} is regular modulo J. Passing to the leading-cone quotient 𝔮 ⊇J +(a^{′}) (lk_holds), each squared equation (F_{i}^{′})^{2} ≡ϖ^{2ci}y_{i}^{2} contributes 2c_{i} while the remaining squares contribute a multiplicity factor 2^{r−1}· 2^{r′}, proving the asymptotic lower bound (low_holds)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∑r−1 )_{′} ( )
c_{i} 2^{r+r} ≤χ_{ts(Q)} (mR(Q)/J)/(a^{′}) (d)
i=0for large multi-degrees d. Permutation invariance and monotonicity of the graded Euler characteristic (chain, using ruleNzd, euler_rule_two_of_graded_finite_iso, and ruleUB) give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ( )
χ_{ts(Q)} (mR(Q)/J)/(a^{′}) (d) ≤χ_{[(0,a}′_{)]} mR(Q)/(J + secs(ts(Q))) (d).
Conversely, by M2 and M3, one-signed points cannot persist in the support of the dth graded piece for large d (eventually_mQ_gr_finite_annihilator, tsp_holds), so its support lies in the finite set {ξ|_{𝒜0} : ξ ∈T}. At each such two-signed point, M4 gives localized weight-piece length at most 1 (locLen_quotientWeightPiece_le_one), so the r+1 squared degree-(−1) equations and r^{′} squared degree- 1 equations yield localized length at most 2^{r+1+r′} (locLen_aPiece_ideal2_le_two_pow), whence the Herbrand/valuation bound (th_holds) gives (up_holds)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ′ ∑
χ_{[(0,a}′_{)]} mR(Q)/(J + secs(ts(Q))) (d) ≤2^{r+1+r} v(ξ(a^{′})).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ξ∈T ′ ′ ∑
Dividing the combined inequality (∑^{r}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{i}) 2^{r+r} ≤ 2^{r+1+r}_{ξ∈T}v(ξ(a^{′})) by 2^{r+r′} > 0 yields cotLen_{x}(𝒜_{−1}, F) ≤2∑_{ξ∈T}v(ξ(a)).
We now prove (ii) (galoisRep_ineq_of_allIrreducible_nonvanishing). Let M.A =⊕_{n∈ℤ}M.gr n be the (0, n)-weight subalgebra of M.R, which is a weighted 𝒪-algebra (aGraded, aW) smooth at M.x_{0} (aSmooth) with equations M.eqns = (M.F, ∅, M.E, ∅, M.Z) of dimensions (r, 0, r^{′}, 0, m). Since diagonal entries have weight (0, 0), aElt constructs a =∑^{3}_{i=0}f_{ii}−tr(D.r_{0}(g)) ∈M.gr 0 with M.x_{0}(a) = 0 and ξ(M.toSS(a)) = D.aVal(g, M.rep ξ) for every ξ : M.SS →ℚ_{ℓ}. For every point x : M.A →ℚ_{ℓ} vanishing on M.eqns.ideal,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
×
ptLift lifts x to ξ on M.SS and ptScale conjugates M.rep ξ by a torus element t ∈ (ℚ_{ℓ})^{2} to a point r = ρ(x) ∈D.EPt (using D.Fin0) with unchanged trace, hence D.aVal(g, ρ(x)) = x(a). By the linkage trichotomy tri (TriComb.lean), any r ∈D.EPt is either irreducible, of diagonal type (DiagType), or block-linked with (0, 2) and (2, 0) nonzero and one off-block half vanishing. By diagCases (using SoV Ωℓ), every diagonal-type point is one-signed (either NegZero with corner entry D.th(D.s_{0}), or PosZero with corner entry D.al(D.s_{0})); in the third case, scaling to the block-diagonal limit (ptLimit) would produce a block-diagonal r_{0} ∈D.EPt with surjective top-left block, contradicting D.NoEnd. Hence every two-signed point yields an irreducible representation ρ(x) (twoIrr).
This verifies all five hypotheses of LemmaM for the normalized valuation v(z) = − log ‖z‖_{ℓ}· e_{𝒪}/ log ℓ (nval):
• M1 holds by M.one_le, aSmooth, and m1b (using SoV Ωℓ via spans_cotangent_of_derivation_test);
• M2 holds by m2 (embedding M.gr 0 modulo M.eqns.ideal into the finite 𝒪-module from D.Fin0 via fg_map_mk);
• M3 holds by m3 (since D.th(D.s_{0}) ̸= D.al(D.s_{0}), no two diagonal-type lifts sharing the same degree-0 specialization can realize opposite one-signed regimes);
• M4 holds by m4 (at a two-signed point x, ρ(x) is irreducible, so D.RigidAt ρ(x) forces every derivation killing M.eqns.ideal to be a scalar multiple of the 𝔾_{m}-weight derivation f →→ n x(f) on M.gr n, whence any two such derivations are linearly dependent);
• M5 holds because ρ(x) is irreducible for every two-signed x and D.aVal(g, ρ(x)) ̸= 0 by assumption.
Applying LemmaM (covers_and_cotangent_length_bounds) gives finiteness of cotLen := cotLen_{M.x0}(M.gr, −1, M.eqns.F), a minimal∑ 𝔾_{m}-orbit cover T of all two-signed points (exists_minimal_orbit_cover), and cotLen ≤ 2_{x∈T}(− log ‖x(a)‖_{ℓ}) e_{𝒪}/ log ℓ. Meanwhile shaCoc (using SoFin Ωℓ) proves D.sha ̸= ⊤ and produces an injective map from the Sha module into normalized cocycles D.ShaCoc a_{0} (a_{0} ̸= 0), so applying M.der and LemmaM' (mPrime) yields D.sha ≤ cotLen. Finally, if two points x, x^{′} ∈ T give conjugate irreducible representations ρ(x) ≃ρ(x^{′}), normalization (D.Nrm) forces the intertwining matrix to lie in the diagonal symplectic torus (conjTorus, via block_of_intertwine, corner_zero, and gsp_of_conj), whence x and x^{′} lie in the same 𝔾_{m}-orbit (same_orbit_of_conjugate_reps) and therefore x = x^{′} by minimality of T. Thus Ξ = ρ(T) is pairwise nonconjugate, ∑_{r∈Ξ}(− log ‖D.aVal(g, r)‖_{ℓ}) = ∑_{x∈T}(− log ‖x(a)‖_{ℓ}), and dividing D.sha ≤ cotLen ≤2∑_{x∈T}(− log ‖x(a)‖_{ℓ}) e_{𝒪}/ log ℓ by e_{𝒪} (real_ratio_bound) proves (114).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/Mprime.lean:6--80; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/MainCotSpan.lean:32--70; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/SmHolds.lean:5--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/CutHolds.lean:101--131; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/NzCoeffMul.lean:33--89; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/FinHolds.lean:49--98; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/AlgMemCoef.lean:22--143; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/Graded
ModulesLength/AdmissibleMonoIdeal.lean:191--322; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/CommutativeAlgebra/GradedModulesLength/TwoSigned.lean:17--95; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/GaloisRepIneqOfAllIrreducibleNonvanishing.lean:42--186; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/AVal.lean:5--30; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ShaCoc.lean:7--232; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/MPrime.lean:9--120; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/QuotientSaturatedSquareTorsionFree.lean:199--253; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/FgMapMk.lean:7--37; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/TorusConjugateCornerEntryEq.lean:24--72; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ExistsLiftOfDerivationOnIdeal.lean:234--250; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/TwoIrr.lean:42--66; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/TriComb.lean:7--34; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/DiagCases.lean:8--31; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ConjTorus.lean:22--246.
Theorem 4.69 (Enlarged-coefficient symplectic estimate and discharge of cases II and III). (i) Uniform
enlarged-coefficient bound (main_big): assuming the inputs of either GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.main (Aut.Sp4In, CohomologyHyp, LemmaM, LemmaM', LemmaP, Af.NumberSp4, Af.AdVanishQ, X.CorX, and SoV/SoFin) or UpperTheory.V.Th.sp4Main_alt (SymplecticFourImageDense, CohomologyHyp, LemmaM, LemmaM', LemmaP, Af.NumberSp4Alt, RigiditySymplecticFour, X.CorX, and SoV/SoFin), for every primitive character χ there exists a single exponent C^{′} = C^{′}(χ) ∈ ℕ, chosen before any choice of host, prime ℓ, or coefficient ring, such that for every host h with h.χ = χ, every t with h.Big t, every algebraic closure Ω/ℚ, every odd prime ℓ, every coefficient ring c : Coef ℓ containing all 2^{h.nII(ℓ,ψ)}th and 2^{h.nIII(ℓ,ψ)}th roots of unity, every 0 < e < t, and every ψ ∈h.X(c, e) in Case II or Case III, one has V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ̸= ⊤ and
v_{ℓ}(e, ψ) log ℓ≤(ℓh.N e)^{C′}. (115)
(ii) Coefficient descent and discharge from the shared patching package (sp4Main_alt and countII_and_
countIII_of_printsH_of_sp4In): descending (115) by Proposition 4.9 yields CountII∧CountIII over arbitrary coefficient rings. In particular, for every h_{H} : HypothesesH' (Theorem 4.50), instantiat-ing sp4Main_alt with h_{sp4} = sp4In0_alt h_{H} (Theorem 4.55), h_{K} = lemmaK_litN_alt h_{H}.litN, and Propositions 4.64–4.68 proves countII_and_countIII_of_printsH_of_sp4In, discharging CountII ∧ CountIII unconditionally from h_{H} and feeding vwin_of_hypotheses_H_E_alt (Theorem 4.57).
Proof. For (i), first invoke Proposition 4.64(ii) (exists_frob_nonvanishing_with_sha_bound in the dense-threshold branch, or count in the abstract branch) to extract uniform constants (C_{0}, A_{0}) depending on neither χ nor any host, prime, or coefficient ring. Then invoke Proposition 4.19 (arith) on (χ, C_{0}, A_{0}) to obtain a single exponent C^{′}= C^{′}(χ) before introducing h, t, Ω, ℓ, c, e, or ψ.
Now fix (h, t, Ω, ℓ, c, e, ψ) satisfying the hypotheses of main_big. By Proposition 4.65(ii) (dataEx, fed by corX), there exists a good symplectic datum D : Raw Ωc satisfying OfCase for (h, e, ψ). The symplectic automorphy input (SymplecticFourImageDense or Sp4In) supplies D.Fin0, D.NoEnd, and ι : ℚ_{ℓ}≃ℂ such that every irreducible r ∈D.EPt satisfies IsAut4Alt (or IsAut4). In the dense-threshold branch, OfCase directly yields Ctx2 D ∨ Ctx3 D. By Proposition 4.65(iii), shaEq gives V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤ D.sha, levOf gives level M = ℓ2^{n′}h.Np_{1} ≥1 and exponent k = (ℓ−1)2^{n′}(2h.o) > 0 (with (n^{′}, p_{1}) = (h.n_{II}, 1) or (h.n_{III}, p_{1}(χ))), and pZeroLe supplies the Bertrand prime p = p_{0}(ℓh.Np_{1}) ≥5 avoiding M and D.S. By Proposition 4.66, exModel (fed by lemmaP, phiGam, nums, and locBase) constructs a global graded deformation model M_{D} : Model D. Applying Proposition 4.64(ii) at (D, M, k, p, ι) yields a Frobenius element σ ∈ G_{ℚ} such that
D.aVal(σ, r) ̸= 0 for all irreducible r ∈D.EPt and such that D.Ineq σ implies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ′
nrm_{ℓ}(𝒪, D.sha) log ℓ≤2C_{0}(ℓ−1)2^{n′}(2h.o) ℓ2^{n}h.Np_{1}(e + 1))^{A0} log p_{0}(ℓh.Np_{1}). (116)
By Proposition 4.67(ii) (rigSp4_alt or rigid), every irreducible r ∈ D.EPt satisfies D.RigidAt r. There-fore Proposition 4.68(ii) (galoisRep_ineq_of_allIrreducible_nonvanishing, fed by Alg.M.main_holds, Alg.M.mprime_holds, h_{P} .loc, and SoV/SoFin from Proposition 4.67(iii)) proves D.Ineq σ; in particular D.sha ̸= ⊤ and (116) holds. Since V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ≤D.sha < ⊤, we have V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ) ̸= ⊤, and monotonicity of the normalized length (Chr.nrm_mono) combined with v_{ℓ}(e, ψ) = nrm_{ℓ}(𝒪, V_{len}(Ω, c, e, ψ)), (116), and Proposi-tion 4.19 ((84)) yields (115).
For (ii), Proposition 4.9 (reusing Lemmas 4.7 and 4.8) removes the root-of-unity assumption on c without changing the uniform exponent C^{′}(χ), proving both GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.main and UpperTheory.V.Th.sp4Main_alt. Finally, countII_and_countIII_of_printsH_of_sp4In instantiates every argument of sp4Main_alt on the single shared record h_{H} : HypothesesH' together with h_{K} and h_{sp4} = sp4In0_alt h_{H}, establishing CountII ∧ CountIII.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean:91--192; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean:68--172; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/AdjointLiftingOfCohomology.lean:27--39; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/SymplecticGSp4/TwoPowClogLe.lean:10--218; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean:25--34.
Remark 4.70 (Reconciliation of the two symplectic entry files and transitive Lean audit). The two files Sym-plecticGSp4/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean (GradeZeroInterpolatingElement.main, lines 91–192) and DenseThresholdCases/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean (UpperTheory.V.Th.sp4Main_alt, lines 68– 172) share identical proofs of coefficient transfer, datum construction (dataEx), level and Bertrand-prime bounds (levOf, pZeroLe), deformation model construction (exModel), length comparison (shaEq, galoisRep_ineq_of_allIrreducible_nonvanishing), exponent absorption (arith), and coefficient descent. They differ only in three upgraded interfaces on the dense-threshold branch: (1) Aut.Sp4In (using IsAut4) is replaced by SymplecticFourImageDense (using IsAut4Alt = IsAutQA, discharged by sp4In0_alt in Theorem 4.55); (2) Af.NumberSp4 + count (using AdmR) is replaced by Af.NumberSp4Alt + exists_frob_nonvanishing_with_sha_bound (using AdmRAlt and safe4', discharged by numberSp4_n_alt in Proposition 4.64); and (3) Af.AdVanishQ + rigid is replaced by RigiditySymplecticFour (receiving Ctx2 D ∨ Ctx3 D directly from OfCase and discharged by rigSp4_alt in Proposition 4.67). A UTF-8 transitive local-import audit over rh-main/lean/src verifies 0 missing local modules, 0 axiom declarations, and 0 sorry/admit occurrences across every entry cone: 9 local modules under Mprime.lean (LemmaM'), 51 under LemmaP.lean, 60 under LemmaX.lean, 87 under MainCotSpan.lean (LemmaM), 639 under ChrInvNeg.lean (corX), 675 under FdAdjoinRange.lean + ExistsAb.lean (soBar/soFin), 1,057 under ResidualBernoulliNonvanishing.lean, 2,154 under DataEx.lean, 2,293 under ExModel.lean, 2,358 under GaloisRepIneqOfAllIrreducibleNonvanishing.lean, 2,897 under SymplecticGSp4/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean, 25,437 under DenseThresholdCases/ConductorAtMapInjectiveCoeff.lean, 35,205 under RigSp4.lean, 42,936 under VWLevel.lean (numberSp4_n_alt), 48,502 under AdjointLiftingOfCohomology.lean (countII_and_countIII_of_printsH_of_sp4In), and 55,067 under WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean.