Section 4.4 · PDF pages 70–80
Source-model Bloch–Kato cohomology, Kato's Euler system, and the discharge of the two-character predicate
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
4.4 Source-model Bloch–Kato cohomology, Kato’s Euler system, and the discharge of the
two-character predicate
While Fact 4.10, Lemma 4.11, and Proposition 4.12 explain classically why the odd-weight twists V_{f}(e) and V_{f}(e) ⊗θ have vanishing Bloch–Kato Selmer groups, the Lean source does not import Kato’s Theo-rem 14.2(1) as a black box and does not require an external dictionary identifying its period ring Loc.Bcr l with classical B. Instead, katoTwoW_of_printsH proves the full predicate KatoTwoW directly on the source’s
cris own algebraic-closure representations Loc.colRep (Af.tw W 1) and Loc.colRep applied to the θ-twist Af.tw of W, with period ring Loc.Bcr l, via four self-contained stages: (i) finite-extension descent of algebraic-closure finite cocycles and reduction from the Bloch–Kato condition to the Greenberg ordinary condition at ℓ; (ii) sphericalization at ℓ from the quadratic window witness WitAQ and extraction of an unramified-at-ℓ ordinary weight-(2e + 1) newform and integral normal form; (iii) an unconditional construction of Kato’s Euler system and smoothed explicit reciprocity law yielding non-Greenberg-triviality; and (iv) Kolyvagin Euler-system descent, global reciprocity, and Greenberg–Wiles duality. The transitive Lean cone of KatoTwoWOfPublishedH.lean covers 36,168 local modules with zero axioms and zero sorries.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∼
Throughout this subsection, fix an odd prime ℓ, an algebraic closure Ω of ℚ, an isomorphism ι : ℚ_{ℓ}−→ℂ (where ℚ_{ℓ} denotes Qbar l = PadicAlgCl l), an integer e ≥1, and a continuous representation W : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ GL_{2}(ℚ_{ℓ}). We write Pl(ℚ) for the set of finite places of ℚ, q_{v} = N(v) for the residue cardinality of v ∈ Pl(ℚ),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
×
χ_{ℓ} (cycBar) for the ℓ-adic cyclotomic character into ℚ_{ℓ}, det W (dt W) for the determinant character, and W^{∗}(1) = W ⊗χ_{ℓ}(det W)^{−1} (dual1 W) for the Tate twist of the symplectic dual. For a coefficient ring c : Coef l (a finite free ℤ_{ℓ}-subalgebra c.O ⊂ ℚ_{ℓ}) and n ∈ ℕ, we write a ≡ b (mod ℓ^{n}) (Cg n a b) for
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
‖a −b‖≤‖ℓ^{n}‖ in ℚ_{ℓ}, and similarly coordinatewise for vectors in ℚ_{ℓ} (Cv n).
Proposition 4.13 (Source finite-cocycle model, algebraic-closure descent, and Greenberg containment). Let Loc.PP l and Loc.AIP l be the tied local period data witnessed by Loc.tiedP l, with crystalline and de Rham period rings B_{cr} = Loc.Bcr l and B_{dR} = Loc.Bdr l. For a continuous homomorphism φ : G →G_{ℚℓ} and a continuous A-linear representation ρ on V over a ℚ_{ℓ}-algebra A, let
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{ }Z_{f}^{1}(φ, ρ) = c ∈Z^{1}(ρ) : ∃x ∈V ⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr}, ∀g ∈G, c(g) ⊗1 = actC(φ, ρ, g)(x) −x (80)
be Loc.finiteCocycles. Assume the local Galois cohomology and Bloch–Kato dimension formula of Loc.LocalPublishedTheorems (supplied by LitCoh.bk together with local finiteness, local Tate duality, and local Euler characteristic). Let S ⊂ Pl(ℚ) be a finite set containing the place above ℓ, let A ⊂Ω be a valuation ring lying over ℓ, and suppose W is in ordinary normal form Nf e S A W: in particular, W is continuous, takes values in GL_{2}(c.O) for some c : Coef l, satisfies (det W)^{2} = 1, is upper triangular on Dec(A) (W(s)_{1,0} = 0), and obeys W(s)^{m}_{0,0} = χ_{ℓ}(s)^{em} for all s ∈ Ine(A) and some m ≥ 1. Then every global cocycle z ∈Z^{1}(Loc.colRep W) satisfying Af.IsBK l (Loc.colRep W) z is unramified away from ℓ (Unr W z) and Greenberg-ordinary at A (Gr W A z): there exists x ∈ℚ_{ℓ} such that z(s)_{1} = W(s)_{1,1}x −x for every s ∈ Dec(A).
Proof. Away from ℓ, the clause IsBK.away states verbatim that for every w ∈ Pl(ℚ) with w ∤ℓ there exist a
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
valuation ring B over w and x ∈ℚ_{ℓ} with z(s) = W(s)x −x for all s ∈ Ine(B), which is Unr W z.
At ℓ, we first transport the finite-cocycle condition from an arbitrary embedding j : Ω ↪→ Ω_{ℓ} to the prescribed valuation ring A (bk_locEmb). Applying IsBK.above to the canonical embedding ℚ ↪→ Ω_{ℓ} pro-duces j : Ω↪→Ω_{ℓ} such that z restricts on decJ(ℚ, j) to an element of Z_{f}^{1}. Composing with the embedding ι_{j} = Loc.iota j : G_{ℚℓ} →G_{ℚ,Ω} gives a finite cocycle for W ∘ι_{j}. Both A and the valuation ring placeJ(j) lie over the unique place of ℚ above ℓ, so there exists g ∈ G_{ℚ,Ω} with g · A = placeJ(j) (locEmb_conj). Define ι_{A} : G_{ℚℓ} → G_{ℚ,Ω} by ι_{A}(σ) = g^{−1}ι_{j}(σ) g. Then ι_{A} is a continuous homomorphism with image Dec(A), sends I_{ℚℓ} into Ine(A), and intertwines the local and global cyclotomic characters χ_{ℓ}. Because ℚ_{ℓ}-linear equivariant maps preserve Z_{f}^{1} (Loc.z1fCoef), the map v →→ W(g^{−1})v sends σ →→ z(ι_{j}(σ)) into Z_{f}^{1}(id, W ∘ι_{A}). By the cocycle identity,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
z(ι_{A}(σ)) = W(g^{−1}) z(ι_{j}(σ)) −(W(ι_{A}(σ)) z(g^{−1}) −z(g^{−1})).The subtracted term is a coboundary, hence lies in Z_{f}^{1}(id, W ∘ι_{A}) via the period vector z(g^{−1}) ⊗1 ∈
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
ℚ_{ℓ}⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr}. Thus σ →→z(ι_{A}(σ)) belongs to Z_{f}^{1}(id, W ∘ι_{A}).
Because W(s)_{1,0} = 0 on Dec(A), projection onto the second coordinate f(v) = v_{1} is a continu-ous ℚ_{ℓ}-linear equivariant map from W ∘ι_{A} to the one-dimensional character representation Loc.chRep of κ(σ) = W(ι_{A}(σ))_{1,1}. Applying Loc.z1fCoef again shows that c(σ) = z(ι_{A}(σ))_{1} lies in Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ). For σ ∈ I_{ℚℓ}, upper triangularity gives det W(ι_{A}(σ)) = W(ι_{A}(σ))_{0,0} κ(σ), so W(ι_{A}(σ))^{m}_{0,0} = χ_{ℓ}(ι_{A}(σ))^{em} and (det W)^{2}= 1 yield
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )2m ( )2 (
κ(σ) χ_{ℓ}(ι_{A}(σ))^{e} = κ(σ)^{2m} W(ι_{A}(σ))^{m}_{0,0} = det W(ι_{A}(σ))^{2})^{m}= 1.
Continuity of κ therefore places κ in Loc.HasWeight id of negative Hodge–Tate weight w = −e < 0 (hasWeight_neg_of_cyclotomic_pow_on_inertia): on an open subgroup U ⊂G_{ℚℓ}, κ(σ) = χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{−e} for all
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
σ ∈U ∩I_{ℚℓ}.We now descend the algebraic-closure finite cocycle c to a finite extension of ℚ_{ℓ} (NegVan.desc, coef_finext). Since c.O is finitely generated over ℤ_{ℓ}, adjoining a finite ℤ_{ℓ}-generating set of c.O yields a finite extension K_{0}/ℚ_{ℓ} inside ℚ_{ℓ} containing all values of κ. Write a witnessing period tensor x ∈ℚ_{ℓ}⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr} for c ∈Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ) as a finite sum x = ∑_{p∈Sx}a_{p} ⊗b_{p}, and set E = K_{0}(a_{p} : p ∈S_{x}) ⊂ℚ_{ℓ}, which is still finite over ℚ_{ℓ}. Choose an E-linear retraction π : ℚ_{ℓ}→E of the inclusion i : E ↪→ℚ_{ℓ}. Then π is ℚ_{ℓ}-linear and commutes with multiplication by κ^{′}(g) ∈E^{×}, and (π ⊗ id)(x) = x (viewing x in E ⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr} via i ⊗ id). Applying π ⊗ id to c(g) ⊗1 = actC(g)(x) −x yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
π(c(g)) ⊗1 = actC(id, κ^{′}, g) (π ⊗ id)(x) −(π ⊗ id)(x)
in E ⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr}. Applying i ⊗ id recovers i(π(c(g))) ⊗1 = c(g) ⊗1 in ℚ_{ℓ}⊗_{ℚℓ}B_{cr}. Because the tied period ring B_{cr} is an integral domain (isDomain_of_tied), the structure map ℚ_{ℓ} ↪→ B_{cr} is injective, so tensoring
on the right by 1 ∈B_{cr} is injective on ℚ_{ℓ} (includeLeft_injective). Consequently c(g) = i(π(c(g))) ∈E for every g ∈G_{ℚℓ}, and c^{′}= π ∘c is a continuous finite cocycle in Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ^{′}) with coefficients in the finite extension E/ℚ_{ℓ}.
Finally, we compute Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ^{′}) over E (charFil, z1fChar). On the open subgroup U = G_{K} ⊂ G_{ℚℓ} where κ^{′}|_{IK} = χ^{w}_{ℓ} (w = −e < 0), the twisted character µ = κ^{′}χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{w} is unramified and takes integral values in E, so it admits an invertible period matrix W_{0} over the Witt ring inside A_{inf} ⊂ Fil^{0}B_{dR} (exists_witt_matrix). Multiplying W_{0} by t^{−w} (where t is the cyclotomic period in Fil^{1}B_{dR} \ Fil^{2}) shows that E(κ^{′}) is de Rham with filtration jumping solely at −w = e:
Fil^{i}D_{dR}(κ^{′}) = D_{dR}(κ^{′}) (i ≤e), Fil^{i}D_{dR}(κ^{′}) = 0 (i > e).
In particular, since 0 < e, we have Fil^{0}D_{dR}(κ^{′}) = D_{dR}(κ^{′}). Moreover, χ_{ℓ}(U ∩I_{ℚℓ}) contains elements of infinite order (cycInertia), so κ^{′}̸= 1 and H^{0}(G_{ℚℓ}, E(κ^{′})) = 0. The Bloch–Kato dimension formula (BlochKato.DimFormula from LocalPublishedTheorems.bk) then gives
dim_{E} H_{f}^{1}(G_{ℚℓ}, E(κ^{′})) = dim_{E}H^{0}(G_{ℚℓ}, E(κ^{′})) + dim_{E}D_{dR}(κ^{′}) − dim_{E} Fil^{0} D_{dR}(κ^{′}) = 0.
Since B^{1}(G_{ℚℓ}, E(κ^{′})) ≤ Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ^{′}), equality of finite E-dimensions forces Z_{f}^{1}(id, κ^{′}) = B^{1}(κ^{′}). Hence there exists x ∈E ⊂ℚ_{ℓ} with c^{′}(σ) = κ^{′}(σ)x −x for all σ ∈G_{ℚℓ}. Because ι_{A} surjects onto Dec(A), this says z(s)_{1} = W(s)_{1,1}x −x for all s ∈ Dec(A), establishing Gr W A z.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PadicHodgeTheory/FiniteCohomology.lean:78--130; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/AutomorphicForms/BlochKatoSelmerVanishes.lean:119--145; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/CrystallineClassRestrictDecompositionGroup.lean:12--80; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/CrystallineCocycleCoboundaryOfNegativeWeight.lean:23--128; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PadicHodgeTheory/CharFil.lean:28--232; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PadicHodgeTheory/ExistsNeOne.lean:8--106; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/BlochKatoCocycleUnramifiedAndGreenbergOrdinary.lean:13--68.
Next we pass from the input hypotheses Used for (ℓ, Ω, K, e, N, θ, ψ, W), the attached weight-(2e + 1) newform f, and the quadratic-CM window witness WitAQ for (ι, W) to an unramified-at-ℓ ordinary source newform and an integral upper-triangular normal form for both W and W ⊗θ. Recall that WitAQ for (ι, W) as-serts that for every imaginary quadratic CM field K^{′}/ℚ on which W|_{GK′} remains irreducible, the restriction W|_{GK′} satisfies WitA: locally at places above ℓ, Unl1 implies PotUnl, and every regular algebraic cuspidal GL_{2}(𝔸_{K}′) representation attached to W|_{GK′} satisfies WinAt at all places away from ℓ and all potentially unlinked places above ℓ.
Proposition 4.14 (Spherical decomposition, Frobenius unit roots, and unramified ordinary normal form). Assume P : HypothesesH', and let h_{R} = rowOf' P.toClassicalTheorems.litN.aut.gal : RowT and h_{Q} = quadBC2 : QuadBC2.
(i) (locQ_of_alt, sphOfWit) Let V : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ GL_{2}(ℚ_{ℓ}) be continuous and irreducible with det V factoring through ℚ(µ_{M}) for some M ≥ 1, and let π be a regular algebraic rank-2 cuspidal representation over ℚ (TR.CuspSub) with AttR for (ι, V, π). Suppose V is ordinary of weights (e, −e) at a valuation ring A over v | ℓ (Exact for (e, V, A, κ)), and either WitAQ holds for (ι, V ) or π is spherical at v. Then π admits a Satake multiset B at v, and for every Frobenius element σ ∈ Dec(A) at ℓ there exists b ∈ algSat(2, ℓ, B) with ℓ^{e}ι(κ_{0}(σ)χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{−e})b = 1 (FrobIn for (ι, e, ℓ, A, κ, B)). In particular, if WitAQ holds for (ι, W), then SphAt holds for (ι, e, W) and for (ι, e, W ⊗ det W).
(ii) (srcS_alt, Used.adm, admissible_twist_by_det) Suppose Used holds for (ℓ, Ω, K, e, N, θ, ψ, W) and
f ∈ Af.Newform (2*e+1) is attached to W ⊗χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e} under ι. Then det W = θ and both W and W ⊗θ satisfy admitted for (ι, e). If moreover SphAt holds for (ι, e, V ) with V ∈{W, W ⊗θ}, then SrcL holds for (ι, e, V ): there exist a weight-(2e + 1) newform g with ℓ ∤ g.M and ‖ι^{−1}(g.a_{ℓ})‖ = 1, a character χ killing µ_{ℓ}, and a flag (A, κ) for V at ℓ such that g is attached to V ⊗χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e}(det V )^{−1}χ, κ_{1}(s)χ_{ℓ}(s)^{e}(det V (s))^{−1}χ(s) = 1 on Ine(A), and for every flag (A^{′}, κ^{′}) of V above ℓ there exists s ∈ Dec(A^{′}) with κ^{′}_{0}(s) ̸= χ_{ℓ}(s).
(iii) (exists_nf_srcUr) From admitted and SrcL for (ι, e, V ), there exist a finite set S ⊂ Pl(ℚ) containing
the place above ℓ, a valuation ring A over ℓ, a conjugate representation V^{′} with RepIso V V', and a weight-(2e + 1) newform g satisfying Nf e S A V' and SrcUr for (ι, e, A, V^{′}, g).
Proof. For (i), base_change_split_of_printed_quad_bc uses exQuad and quadBC2 to choose an imaginary quadratic CM field K^{′}/ℚ in which the place v | ℓ splits (so Dec_{ℚ}(A) fixes K^{′} and N(w) = ℓ for the place w of K^{′} under A), such that V |_{GK′} remains irreducible (range_of_sign) and the quadratic base change P ∈ CuspSub K' 2 of π is regular algebraic, attached to V |_{GK′}, polarized (polar_of_lift, using det V and dualTw_det), and satisfies π.HasSat(v, B) ⇐⇒ P.HasSat(w, B) (sat_iff). Because Exact fixes the inertia weights of V to be (e, −e) with e ≥ 1, every integer m ≥ 1 satisfies m(m_{i} −m_{j} −1) ̸= 0 for m_{0} = e, m_{1} = −e, so cycIne rules out κ^{m}_{i} = (κ_{j}χ_{ℓ})^{m} on inertia at every valuation ring over w, giving PotUnl (potOf). Consequently, either WitAQ for (ι, V ) (via guard_of) or π.HasSat(v, B) (via plainOf) yields PlainAt P w. Now local_k_of_printed_rec_compat_sph_frob combines local-global compatibility CompatT (supplied by compatTOf h_R plainRec) with weil_deligne_above_of_printed_results to deduce IsLevelWD 1 2 for rc(algNorm σ) at the local component σ of P at w. Then recSph forces σ to have a nonzero GL_{2}(𝒪_{Kw}′)-fixed vector, so P (hence π) admits a Satake multiset B at w (hence v). Finally, weilDeligne_frobenius_eigenvalue_of_full_flag shows that ℓ^{e}ι(κ_{0}(σ)χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{−e}) is a root of the Weil–Deligne Frobenius characteristic polynomial, and recFrob matches every root with b^{−1} for some b ∈ algSat(2, ℓ, B), proving locQ_of_alt. Since twisting by any finite-order character φ killing µ_{M} preserves continuity, irreducibility, finite-order determinant, and WitAQ (twWit_alt via aIsoTwOf_alt), applying locQ_of_alt to W ⊗φ gives SphAt for (ι, e, W) (sphOfWit), and sphAt_tw transports it to W ⊗ det W since det W has finite abelian kernel (kwAbs).
For (ii), Used.adm reads det W = θ directly from Used.det, deduces θ(c) = −1 on complex conjugations from Used.imag and ker θ = G_{K,Ω}, transfers irreducibility from G_{K,Ω}∩ ker χ_{ℓ} to H_{0}(W) = ker χ_{ℓ}∩ ker(det W), and assembles admitted for (ι, e, W). Because (det W)^{2} = 1, twisting by det W preserves det, H_{0}, and the flag inertia weights, giving admitted for (ι, e, W ⊗ det W) (admissible_twist_by_det). Given admitted and SphAt for (ι, e, V ), let (A, χ, κ) be the flag data at ℓ and set φ = (det V )^{−1}χ^{−1}, which kills µ_{Nℓ} where det V kills µ_{N}. Then exists_newform_attached_twist_of_kills_mu (twNew_alt) twists the attached weight-(2e + 1) newform by φ to obtain g ∈ Newform (2*e+1) attached to V ⊗χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e}φ. Let π be the cuspidal GL_{2}(𝔸_{ℚ}) representation attached to V ⊗φ (exists_rep_alt). On Ine(A), det V = 1 cancels, so V ⊗φ has exact inertia weights (e, −e); hence SphAt for (ι, e, V ) shows π is spherical at ℓ, and not_dvd_level_of_satake_hecke_poly_cofinite forces ℓ∤g.M (otherwise a spherical vector at ℓ would yield a nonzero cusp form of level g.M/ℓ with the same prime-to-g.M Hecke eigenvalues, contradicting newform minimality g.new). Applying frobRoot_alt (built from locQ_of_alt and exists_cuspidal_satake_prod_eq_hecke_poly_of_not_dvd_level) at a Frobenius element σ ∈ Dec(A) yields a root α ∈ℂ of g.heckePoly(ℓ) = X^{2}−g.a_{ℓ}X + g.χ(ℓ)ℓ^{2e} satisfying α = ι(u) or α^{−1} = ι(u), where u = (κ_{0}φ)(σ)χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{−e} has ‖u‖ = 1 by compactness of G_{ℚ,Ω} (norm_flag). Hence ‖ι^{−1}(α)‖ = 1. Writing g.a_{ℓ} = α + g.χ(ℓ)ℓ^{2e}/α with ‖ι^{−1}(g.χ(ℓ))‖ = 1 and ‖ℓ^{2e}‖ < 1, the ultrametric triangle inequality yields_{√} ‖ι^{−1}(g.a_{ℓ})‖ = 1. Moreover, for any odd prime ℓ≥3 and e ≥1, setting s = ℓ< ℓ−1 and L = ℓ^{e}≥ℓ gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℓ^{(2e+1)/2}+ ℓ^{(2e−1)/2}=^{Ls(ℓ}_{ℓ}^{+ 1)} < L^{2}−1 = ℓ^{2e}−1. (81)If α^{m}= 1 for some m ≥1, then |α| = 1 would force |g.a_{ℓ}| ≥|g.χ(ℓ)ℓ^{2e}/α| −|α| = ℓ^{2e}−1, contradicting the Hecke bound |g.a_{ℓ}| ≤ℓ^{(2e+1)/2}+ ℓ^{(2e−1)/2} (newform_norm_coeff_prime_le_of_not_dvd_level) via (81). Thus α is not a root of unity (newform_unit_root_not_root_of_unity_odd_weight). Finally, if some flag (A^{′}, κ^{′}) of V above ℓ satisfied κ^{′}_{0}= χ_{ℓ} on Dec(A^{′}), then comparing the two character multisets on Dec(A) (eps_mem) forces either κ_{0} = χ_{ℓ} or κ_{1} = χ_{ℓ}. In the second case χ^{e}_{ℓ}^{+1} = χ on Ine(A), impossible since χ has finite order and χ_{ℓ}(Ine(A)) is infinite; in the first case e ≥ 2 gives χ^{e}_{ℓ}^{−1}χ = 1 on Ine(A) (same contradiction), while e = 1 gives u = φ(σ), a root of unity, contradicting α^{m} ̸= 1. This proves SrcL for
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(ι, e, V ).
For (iii), let g_{1} ∈ GL_{2}(ℚ_{ℓ}) conjugate V |_{Dec(A)} into upper-triangular form with diagonal (κ_{0}, κ_{1}). Since G_{ℚ,Ω} is compact, the matrix entries of r = g_{1}V g_{1}^{−1} lie in a finite extension E/ℚ_{ℓ} (exists_finiteDimensional_entries_mem), and a further upper-triangular conjugation B makes all entries of V^{′}= BrB^{−1} integral in a finite free ℤ_{ℓ}-subalgebra c.O (exists_upperTriangular_conj_integral_compact) while preserving upper triangularity and both diagonal characters κ_{0}, κ_{1} on Dec(A) (upper_triangular_conj_lower_right_entry_eq). The away-from-ℓ level condition LevelAway yields a finite ramification set S containing the place above ℓ (unramified_of_levelAway_inertia_characters), and χ^{ℓ−1} = 1 gives V^{′}(s)^{ℓ}_{0}^{−}_{,0}^{1}= χ_{ℓ}(s)^{e(ℓ−1)} on Ine(A). Hence V^{ ′} satisfies Nf e S A V' and SrcUr for (ι, e, A, V^{ ′}, g).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/KatoTwoOfUseN.lean:11--48; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/KatoTwoOfVanishOrd.lean:8--38; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/AdmissibleTwistByDet.lean:484--522; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/SphOfWit.lean:18--95; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/SphOfWitAlt.lean:5--21; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/DecConj.lean:30--69; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/IsFrobOfRs.lean:71--91; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/RecSph.lean:76--113; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/RecFrob.lean:64--68; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/PolarOfLift.lean:113--144; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/LocK.lean:20--70; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/IrrOfTw.lean:43--56; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/TAIsoTwOf.lean:52--75; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/MemOfNormVDvd.lean:89--143; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/FrobRoot.lean:13--27; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/UnramifiedAlgebraicWeights.lean:59--136; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/ExistsCuspidalSatakeAtPrimeToLevelOfNewform.lean:78--150; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/TwistNewform.lean:17--118; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/NewformTwistNorms/NewformUnitRootNotRootOfUnityOddWeight.lean:23--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/NewformTwistNorms/WeilDeligneFrobeniusEigenvalueOfFullFlag.lean:39--120; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/ExistsOrdinaryNormalFormUnramifiedSource.lean:23--140.
We next record the unconditional Lean construction of Kato’s Euler system GlobalTheory.Ord2.ES W
A. By definition (FinalTheorems.lean:88-102), ES W A supplies a coefficient ring c : Coef l, a finite set S^{′} ⊂ Pl(ℚ), and an integral global cocycle y ∈ Z^{1}(Loc.colRep W) such that: (a) W and y have entries in c.O; (b) y is unramified away from ℓ (Unr W y); (c) y is not Greenberg-ordinary at A (¬Gr W A y); and (d) for every n ≥ 1, every prime w /∈ S^{′} with ℓ^{n} | q_{w} −1, and every surjective homomorphism ψ : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ Multiplicative(ℤ/ℓ^{n}ℤ) killing µ_{qw}, there exist a continuous integral shifted cocycle Y : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ (ℤ/ℓ^{n}ℤ) → c.O^{2}, elements∑ P, u ∈ c.O with ‖u‖ = 1, and b ∈ c.O^{2} such that Y (st, x) = Y (s, x) + W(s)Y (t, x−ψ(s)), _{x∈ℤ/ℓ}n_{ℤ}Y (s, x) = P y(s)+(W(s)b−b), P ≡u det(W(σ)−1) (mod ℓ^{n}) for every Frobenius σ at w, and Y is integrally unramified at every finite place q /∈{w, ℓ} (Tame for (c, W, y, n, w, ψ)).
Proposition 4.15 (Unconditional Kato Euler system and non-Greenberg-triviality). The predicate GlobalTheory.Ord2.ZetaUr holds unconditionally (with no external hypothesis parameters): whenever Nf e S A W and SrcUr for (ι, e, A, W, g) hold for an odd prime ℓ, e ≥1, and g ∈ Newform (2*e+1), there exists a Kato Euler system ES W A.
Proof. In ZetaUr.lean:9-12, UpperTheory.V.Z.Kato.Final.zetaUr applies zetaUr_of_halves2 Pin7 to two unconditional theorems, producing an integral Euler system with a cyclotomic Iwasawa tower pinned to a nonvanishing p-adic L-measure and then deducing ¬Gr W A y.
Step 1: Global Iwasawa system and explicit reciprocity law (kato_global_unit_law_of_smoothed_classes). Fix an embedding ε : Ω↪→ℂ and construct the algebraic modular function tower X of type Tower over (Ω, ε) (towerEx via tower_exists). Using the unramifiedness ℓ∤g.M and ordinarity ‖ι^{−1}(g.a_{ℓ})‖= 1 of g, ordinaryEisensteinEigenfunctional_exists (chapterM_holds) selects an auxiliary prime r ≥ 7 coprime to ℓ, a level N ≥5 divisible by g.M and r with ℓ∤N, a unit root α of X^{2}−g.a_{ℓ}X + χ(ℓ)ℓ^{2e}= 0 (unitRoot_split), a Dirichlet character θ mod N of parity (−1)^{e}ψ(−1) with θχ^{±1}̸= 1, smoothing integers c_{1}, d_{1} > 1 coprime to 6Nℓ, and a finitely supported Hecke eigenfunctional λ_{0} on level-N modular forms whose depleted Eisenstein-product evaluation v ̸= 0 (muModelProduct_value_ne_zero_of_depleted, using nonvanishing of the twisted edge L-value odd_chi_and_tendsto_twisted_LSeries_ne_zero_of_prim) yields a nonvanishing p-adic measure power series L ∈c.O[[T]] (exists_muModel_measure_of_eigenfunctional).
Next, untwisted_representation_ordinary_triangular_shape realizes the twisted representation ρ_{K}(W, e, ψ) (which is upper triangular on Dec(A) with inertia diagonal (χ^{2}_{ℓ}^{e}, 1)), heckeProjector_newform_galoisImage produces an admissible Hecke projector P cutting out ρ_{K}(W, e, ψ)-isotypic summands in the tower cohomology X.VB(N, ℓ, 2e − 1), and exists_admissible_hecke_projection_nonvanishing (admissibleFunctional_of_projection, kato_global_admissibility_of_admissible) constructs an integral
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
Galois- and Hecke-equivariant projection pr : X.Fn(ℓ) →ℚ_{ℓ} matching a scaled eigenfunctional ℓ^{a}λ (IsLamFR2).
Using symmetric-power Siegel-unit symbols (symEx) on the modular tower, K4.g3 and K4.top (kato_eulerSystem_integrality) build a norm-compatible integral cyclotomic tower of shifted cocycles Y_{r} : G_{ℚ,Ω} × (ℤ/ℓ^{r}ℤ)^{×} → c.O^{2} (satisfying Y_{r} = push(Y_{r+1})) together with its specialized limit y ∈ Z^{1}(Loc.colRep W) satisfying SpLink (y(s) ≡ ∑_{u∈(ℤ/ℓ}r_{ℤ)}× u^{−e}χ_{K}(u) Y_{r}(s, u) (mod ℓ^{r})). For every auxiliary tame prime w /∈ S^{′} with ℓ^{n} | q_{w} −1, the projected tame norm relation kato_tame_relation_projected (combining kato_norm_relation_tame_prime, kato_normRelation_twistTower, and kato_normRelation_levelTower) produces the tame classes Y_{w} satisfying Tame, and middle_glue2 assembles the Euler system Sys and the bottom-coordinate Iwasawa system Z_{r}(s, u) = ℓ^{m}Y_{r}(s, u)_{1} (IwSys2). Smoothing Z_{r} by an integer d_{0} ≥2 with d_{0} ≡1 (mod ℓ) multiplies y by 1 −d^{e}_{0}^{+1} while preserving Sys, IwSys2, and SpLink (sm_sys, sm_iw, sm_sp). Finally, the smoothed Hodge–Tate / explicit reciprocity theorem smoothedZetaClass_hodgeTateLaw (K5.hco, K5.top) relates the primitive character sums of the smoothed Z_{r} modulo ℓ^{m−c1} to the λ-evaluations of the Eisenstein-product q-expansions, hence to the character sums of the nonvanishing measure power series L up to the unit smoothing factor (1 −d_{0}ψ^{−1}(d_{0}))v_{m}^{′} κ(a^{′})^{m}, establishing ExistsZetaEulerSystemIwasawaData Pin7.
Step 2: Non-Greenberg-triviality (pLocu). Given Sys, IwSys2, SpLink, and Pin7, suppose for contradiction that y(s)_{1} = 0 for all s ∈ Ine(A) ∩ ker χ_{ℓ}. By SpLink, the twisted character sums of Z_{r} vanish on Ine(A) ∩ ker χ_{ℓ} to arbitrarily high ℓ-adic precision (SpZero). Using a Frobenius element σ_{0} ∈ Dec(A) ∩ ker χ_{ℓ} (pFrobEx), the unramifiedness of ν on Ine(A) yields the Frobenius conjugation identity Z_{m}(σsσ^{−1}, 1) = a Z_{m}(s, 1) (conj_law), where ‖a‖ = 1. Applying Coleman-series interpolation pCore produces a power series G_{s} ∈ c.O[[T]] whose twisted character sums match those of the smoothed Z_{m} modulo ℓ^{m−c1} and hence, via Pin7, match those of the nonvanishing measure L up to unit factors. On the one hand, nonvanishing_transfer_characterSums_powerSeries transfers the uniform nonvanishing lower bound of L (mod ℓ^{n0+r}) to G_{s} (mod ℓ^{n1+r} for all sufficiently large r). On the other hand, SpZero forces the same character sums of G_{s} to vanish modulo ℓ^{n1+r} for large r, a contradiction. Therefore there exists s ∈ Ine(A) ∩ ker χ_{ℓ} with y(s)_{1} ̸= 0, while quotient_char_trivial_inertia_cyclotomic_tower shows W(s)_{1,1} = 1 for such s. This yields NzAt W Ay, which immediately implies ¬Gr W A y (for any x ∈ℚ_{ℓ}, W(s)_{1,1}x −x = 0 ̸= y(s)_{1}), completing ES WA.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/UnramifiedZeta/ZetaUr.lean:9--13; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Definitions/Foundations/ZetaElementsUnramifiedOrdinaryOfEulerSystemInert.lean:13--48; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/FrobeniusHodgeTateLaws/KatoGlobalUnitLawOfSmoothedClasses.lean:8--11; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/FrobeniusHodgeTateLaws/KatoGlobalAdmissibilityOfAdmissible.lean:35--39; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/FrobeniusHodgeTateLaws/AdmissibleFunctionalOfProjection.lean:36--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/FrobeniusHodgeTateLaws/SmNormNat.lean:12--137; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/FrobeniusHodgeTateLaws/TowerEx.lean:6--10; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/OrdinaryEisensteinEigenfunctionalExists.lean:39--145; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/ExistsAdmissibleHeckeProjectionNonvanishingStatement.lean:13--49; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/HeckeProjectorNewformGaloisImageStatement.lean:9--10; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/UntwistedRepresentationOrdinaryTriangularShapeStatement.lean:8--20; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SymmetricPowerSymbols/SymEx.lean:12; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/EulerFactorBounds/KatoNormRelationTamePrime.lean:78--230; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/EulerFactorBounds/KatoTameRelationProjected.lean:50--200; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/IwahoriReduction/NormProducts/AdmissibleWeightedDataMonoCoef.lean:15--208; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SmoothedZetaClasses/Hco.lean:34--322; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SmoothedZetaClasses/Imports.lean:11--31; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/IwahoriReduction/LangPolynomials/NormFactorLeOne.lean:13--164; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/IwahoriReduction/LangPolynomials/FrobEx.lean:23--39.
We now carry out the complete Euler-system descent from ES W A to BlochKatoSelmerVanishes l ( Loc.colRep W) using only LitCoh. Write ω(u, v) = u_{0}v_{1} −u_{1}v_{0} for the standard symplectic pairing on
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
ℚ_{ℓ}, which is G_{ℚ,Ω}-equivariant from W × W^{ ∗}(1) to ℚ_{ℓ}(1): ω(W(s)u, W^{ ∗}(1)(s)v) = χ_{ℓ}(s) ω(u, v). For
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2
global 1-cochains a, b : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ℚ_{ℓ}, let cup_{W}(a, b)(s, t) = ω(a(s), W^{ ∗}(1)(s)b(t)). Define the subgroups H_{0}(W) = ker χ_{ℓ}∩ ker(det W) and N_{0}(W) = ker χ_{ℓ}∩ ker W. Let StrZero (resp. GrZero) denote the vanishing of all global cocycles z ∈Z^{1} that are unramified away from ℓ and satisfy Triv (coboundary on Dec(A)) (resp. Gr, coboundary in the lower coordinate on Dec(A)).
Proposition 4.16 (Euler-system Kolyvagin descent and dual-to-primal Greenberg vanishing). Assume hLit : LitCoh, and let W : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ GL_{2}(ℚ_{ℓ}) satisfy Nf e S A W and ES W A. Then:
(i) (StrictKill.main) StrZero (dual1 W) A holds;
(ii) (Upgrade.upgrade) GrZero (dual1 W) A holds;
(iii) (grZero_of_grZero_dual1) GrZero W A holds; and
(iv) (es_vanish) Af.BlochKatoSelmerVanishes l (Loc.colRep W) holds.
Proof. Proof of (i). Suppose for contradiction that z ∈ Z^{1}(W^{∗}(1)) satisfies Unr (dual1 W) z and Triv (dual1 W) A z, yet z /∈B^{1}(W^{∗}(1)). Let (c, y, S^{′}) witness ES W A. Scaling y and z by powers ℓ^{k1}, ℓ^{k2} and enlarging c to c_{2} (galois_cocycle_integral_after_scaling) gives integral cocycles y^{′}= ℓ^{k1}y and z^{′}= ℓ^{k2}z with entries in c_{2}.O that are integrally unramified at every q ∤ℓ, while z^{′} is an integral coboundary on Dec(A) (z^{′}(s) = W^{∗}(1)(s)x_{A} −x_{A} with x_{A} ∈ c_{2}.O^{2}) and y^{′} still satisfies the tame Euler-system axiom over c_{2} (eulerSystemTameClass_scale_enlarge_coefficients).
For every n ≥1, the cup product cup_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}) is a continuous integral 2-cocycle unramified outside S (cupProductDualTwist_isTwoCocycle_unramified). At each v ∈ S with v ∤ ℓ, unramifiedness of y^{′} and z^{′} implies via local unramified orthogonality (cupProduct_unramifiedClasses_vanishes, from LitCoh) that cup_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}) is a local 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n}; at v | ℓ, strict triviality of z^{′} on Dec(A) likewise makes cup_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}) a local 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n} (cup_product_coboundary_mod). Since Sha^{2} vanishes for the cyclotomic twist mod ℓ^{n} (local_cochains_glue_global, using LitCoh), there exists a continuous c_{2}.O-valued 1-cochain u : G_{ℚ,Ω}→c_{2}.O, invariant under ker(G_{ℚ,Ω}→G_{ℚ,S}) modulo ℓ^{n}, such that
cup_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′})(s, t) ≡χ_{ℓ}(s) u(t) −u(st) + u(s) (mod ℓ^{n}) (∀s, t ∈G_{ℚ,Ω}).
Associated to (y^{′}, z^{′}, u) is the height function
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(s) = det(W(s) −1) u(s) −ω adj(W(s) −1) y^{′}(s), z^{′}(s) . (82)
We claim that for every commutator σ ∈[H_{0}(W), H_{0}(W)] and every n ≥1,
det(W(σ) −1) ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(σ) ≡0 (mod ℓ^{n})
(ht_vanish_commutator). Set F(s) = det(W(s) −1) ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(s), which is continuous on G_{ℚ,Ω}. Because σ ∈ [ker χ_{ℓ}, ker χ_{ℓ}], Chebotarev’s density theorem (exists_auxiliary_prime_frobenius_near_commutator) yields an auxiliary prime w /∈ S ∪S^{′} with a Frobenius element τ at w arbitrarily close to σ (so ‖F(τ) −F(σ)‖ < ‖ℓ^{n}‖ and det W(τ) = det W(σ) = 1) such that ℓ^{n} | q_{w} −1 and every place v ∈S splits completely in the degree-ℓ^{n} tame subfield of ℚ(µ_{qw}). Let ψ : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ Multiplicative(ℤ/ℓ^{n}ℤ) be a surjective character of conductor w (exists_character_primeConductor_degree_prime_pow); then ψ vanishes on Dec(B^{′}) for every v ∈ S. Applying Tame for (n, w, ψ) and taking Kolyvagin’s derivative cochain d (unramified_cocycle_kills_roots) gives an integral continuous 1-cochain d unramified outside S_{2} = S ∪{w} with P ≡u_{w} det(W(τ) −1) (mod ℓ^{n}) (‖u_{w}‖= 1), such that
ξ(s, t) = cup_{W} (d, z^{′})(s, t) −ψ(s) P χ_{ℓ}(s) u(t)
is an integral 2-cocycle modulo ℓ^{n} unramified outside S_{2} (cocycle_pairing_locally_constant). At every v ∈S_{2} \ {w} = S, ψ vanishes on Dec(B^{′}), so ξ = cup_{W} (d, z^{′}) is a local 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n} (at v | ℓ by strict triviality of z^{′}; at v ∤ℓ by unramified orthogonality of d and z^{′}). Global reciprocity (integralTwoCocycle_reciprocity_trivial_at_last_place, from LitCoh) therefore forces ξ to be a local 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n} at the remaining place w. Evaluating the local invariant of ξ at w (local_height_frobenius_
place) gives P ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(τ) ≡0 (mod ℓ^{n}). Since P ≡u_{w} det(W(τ) −1) (mod ℓ^{n}) with ‖u_{w}‖= 1, we obtain F(τ) ≡0 (mod ℓ^{n}) and hence F(σ) ≡0 (mod ℓ^{n}), proving the claim.
On the other hand, because ¬Gr W A y and z ∈/ B^{1}(W^{∗}(1)), neither y^{′} nor z^{′} can vanish identi-cally on N_{0}(W) (greenbergOrdinary_of_vanishing_on_cycloKernel, tateDual_cocycle_coboundary_of_vanish_on_fixing). Irreducibility of W|_{H0(W)} (Nf.irr) then produces g, h ∈ N_{0}(W) with de^{′} = ω(y^{′}(h), z^{′}(g)) − ω(y^{′}(g), z^{′}(h)) ̸= 0 (cocycle_pair_alternating_ne_on_cycloKernel) and a commutator φ ∈[H_{0}(W), H_{0}(W)] with de = det(W(φ) −1) ̸= 0 (exists_commutator_det_nonzero). Put φ_{1} = φ[g, h] ∈[H_{0}(W), H_{0}(W)]. Since g, h ∈ ker W, we have W(φ_{1}) = W(φ), and a direct coboundary calculation (height_commutator_invariance) gives for every n ≥1 the commutator shift identity
ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(φ_{1}) − ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(φ) ≡de · de^{′} (mod ℓ^{n}). (83)
Multiplying (83) by de (which satisfies ‖de‖≤1) and combining with F(φ) ≡F(φ_{1}) ≡0 (mod ℓ^{n}) yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
‖de^{2}· de^{′}‖=‖‖de(de · de^{′}−(t_{1} −t_{0}))+ de · t_{1} −de · t_{0}‖‖ ≤‖ℓ^{n}‖for every n ≥ 1, where t_{0} = ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(φ) and t_{1} = ht_{W} (y^{′}, z^{′}, u)(φ_{1}). Letting n →∞ forces de^{2}· de^{′}= 0, contradicting de ̸= 0 and de^{′}̸= 0. Thus StrZero (dual1 W) A holds.
Proof of (ii). Let z ∈ Z^{1}(W^{∗}(1)) satisfy Unr (dual1 W) z and Gr (dual1 W) A z. Scale y and z into a common integral ring c_{2}.O so that y_{1} = ℓ^{j}y and ℓ^{k}z are integrally unramified away from ℓ and (ℓ^{k}z)(s)_{1} = W^{∗}(1)(s)_{1,1}x−x on Dec(A) for some x ∈c_{2}.O. Let v_{0} ∈c_{2}.O^{2} be the column vector (0, x)^{T} and set z_{1} = ℓ^{k}z −d^{0}(v_{0}). Then z_{1} is still integral and integrally unramified away from ℓ, and satisfies z_{1}(s)_{1} = 0 identically on Dec(A). For every n ≥1, cup_{W} (y_{1}, z_{1}) is locally a 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n} at every v ∈S with v ∤ℓ by unramified orthogonality, so global reciprocity (integralTwoCocycle_reciprocity_trivial_at_last_place) forces cup_{W} (y_{1}, z_{1}) to be a 2-coboundary modulo ℓ^{n} on Dec(A). Since z_{1}(·)_{1} = 0 and W, W^{∗}(1) are upper triangular on Dec(A), we have
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
cup_{W} (y_{1}, z_{1})(s, t) = −y_{1}(s)_{1} W^{∗}(1)(s)_{0,0} z_{1}(t)_{0} (s, t ∈ Dec(A)),
where k(s) = W(s)_{1,1} and k^{′}(s) = W^{∗}(1)(s)_{0,0} satisfy k(s)k^{′}(s) = χ_{ℓ}(s) on Dec(A). Choosing t ∈ Ine(A) with χ_{ℓ}(t) = 1 + ℓ (cycZ_Ine_surjective) and putting T = t^{2m} gives W(T)_{0,0} = (1 + ℓ)^{2em}> 1 and det W(T) = 1, whence k(T) ̸= 1 and k^{′}(T) ̸= 1 (nontriv). Local Tate duality for nontrivial dual characters on Dec(A) (local_duality_character_orthogonal_classes, from LitCoh) therefore implies that either y_{1}(·)_{1} is a coboundary for k or z_{1}(·)_{0} is a coboundary for k^{′} on Dec(A). The first case contradicts ¬Gr W A y; the second gives x^{′}∈ℚ_{ℓ} with z_{1}(s) = W^{∗}(1)(s)(x^{′}, 0)^{T}−(x^{′}, 0)^{T} on Dec(A), i.e. Triv (dual1W) A z_1. Part (i) then yields z_{1} ∈B^{1}(W^{∗}(1)), and hence z = ℓ^{−k}(z_{1} + d^{0}(v_{0})) ∈B^{1}(W^{∗}(1)).
Proof of (iii). Suppose for contradiction that ¬GrZero W A, and pick an integral cocycle Y ∈ Z^{1}(W) over c.O witnessing Unr W Y, Gr W A Y, and Y /∈B^{1}(W). Because Y /∈B^{1}(W), there is a bounded torsion exponent k_{0} such that no nonzero integer multiple aY with |a| < ℓ^{t} is a coboundary modulo ℓ^{t+k0} (nonzero_class_bounded_torsion), producing ℓ^{t} distinct mod-ℓ^{t+k0} Greenberg Selmer classes for every t ≥ 1. By the Greenberg–Wiles Euler-characteristic inequality (greenbergWiles_dualSelmer_lower_bound_mod_prime_pow, from LitCoh), there exists a constant C ≥ 1 independent of n such that the dual mod-ℓ^{n} Greenberg Selmer group has at least ℓ^{t}/C distinct classes. On the other hand, for any fixed m ≥ 0, the number of dual mod-ℓ^{n} Greenberg classes killed by ℓ^{m} is bounded by a constant B(m) independent of n (card_primePowTorsion_selmerClassesModPrimePow_bounded, via global finiteness LitCoh). Choosing t = CB(m) + 1 gives ℓ^{t}> CB(m), producing for every m a dual mod-ℓ^{n} Greenberg class not killed by ℓ^{m} (dual_classes_unbounded). Since the ℓ-torsion of the discrete dual Greenberg Selmer group is finite (finite_lTorsion_selmer_rank_two_adjoint), these classes of unbounded order yield a compatible divisible chain (exists_divisible_chain_primary_torsion_group), whose integral inverse-limit representatives (divisibleOrdinary
SelmerChain_exists_integral_representatives) produce a nonzero rational class in Z^{1}(W^{∗}(1)) satisfying Unr (dual1 W) and Gr (dual1 W) A (nonzero_ordinary_class_of_compatible_cocycles_mod_pow), contra-dicting (ii).
Proof of (iv). Given z ∈Z^{1}(Loc.colRep W) satisfying IsBK l (Loc.colRep W) z, Proposition 4.13 (bk_unr_gr, using localGaloisCohomology_of_galoisCohomology hLit) gives Unr W z and Gr W A z, and part (iii) concludes z ∈B^{1}(Loc.colRep W).
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Definitions/Foundations/FinalTheorems.lean:53--128; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/StrictVanishingDualOfLiterature.lean:162--282; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/CohomologyUnramifiedLift.lean:119--278; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/LocalCochainsGlueGlobal.lean:315--374; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/OrdinarySelmerDualVanishesOfStrict.lean:47--277; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/OrdinarySelmerVanishesOfDualVanishes.lean:10--17; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/ExistsDualSelmerClassesUnboundedOrder.lean:16--100; De-velopment/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/DualSelmerUnboundedOrderNonzeroOrdinaryClass.lean:22--34; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/LocPublishedOfLitCoh.lean:13--24.
Theorem 4.17 (Discharge of the Kato two-character predicate and wiring into case I). (i) (vanishOrdL_
of_zetaUr) Assuming hC: LitCoh, GlobalTheory.Ord2.VanishOrdL holds: for every odd prime ℓ, every e ≥1, and every V : G_{ℚ,Ω}→ GL_{2}(ℚ_{ℓ}) satisfying admitted and SrcL for (ι, e, V ), one has Af.BlochKatoSelmerVanishes l (Loc.colRep V).
(ii) (twoS, katoTwoW_of_printsH_of_rT_of_quadBC2, katoTwoW_of_printsH) For every P : HypothesesH',
the full source predicate KatoTwoW holds: whenever Used holds for (ℓ, Ω, K, e, N, θ, ψ, W), f ∈ Af.Newform (2*e+1) is attached to W ⊗χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e} under ι, and WitAQ holds for (ι, W), both W ⊗1 and W ⊗θ satisfy Af.BlochKatoSelmerVanishes on Loc.colRep.
Proof. For (i), given admitted and SrcL for (ι, e, V ), Proposition 4.14(iii) (exists_nf_srcUr) produces (S, A, V^{′}, g) with RepIso V V', Nf e S A V', and SrcUr for (ι, e, A, V^{′}, g). Proposition 4.15 (Final.zetaUr) supplies ES V' A, and Proposition 4.16(iv) (es_vanish) yields BlochKatoSelmerVanishes l (Loc.colRep V'). Conjugation invariance of BlochKatoSelmerVanishes (UpperTheory.V.X.Kato.conj, transporting cocycles and IsBK via the ℚ_{ℓ}-linear automorphism v →→P^{−1}v and Kato.bkMap) transfers vanishing back to Loc.colRep V.
For (ii), set h_{R} = rowOf' P.toClassicalTheorems.litN.aut.gal : RowT and h_{Q} = quadBC2 : QuadBC2. Given Used for (ℓ, Ω, K, e, N, θ, ψ, W), f attached to W ⊗χ^{−}_{ℓ}^{e}, and WitAQ for (ι, W), Proposition 4.14(i)–(ii) yields det W = θ, admitted, SphAt, and SrcL for both W and W ⊗θ. Since Af.tw W 1 = W, applying part (i) with h_{C} = P.toClassicalTheorems.litN.coh to both W and W ⊗θ proves twoS, katoTwoW_of_printsH_of_rT_of_quadBC2, and katoTwoW_of_printsH.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/FoundationProofs/VanishOrdLOfZetaUr.lean:20--25; De-velopment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LevelCohomology/KatoConj.lean:7--41; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/SphAtTw.lean:16--34; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/KatoTwoW.lean:10--32; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/KatoTwoWOfPublishedH.lean:35--50.
Remark 4.18 (External-interface accounting, audit, and downstream wiring). Theorem 4.17 discharges the entire source-model gap F8-Kato-model without appealing to Kato’s Theorem 14.2(1) (Fact 4.10) or to any external period-ring dictionary. Specifically:
(1) External interfaces: Final.zetaUr is proved completely unconditionally. The only inputs of katoTwoW_of_printsH P are the standard fields of P : HypothesesH', namely LitCoh (local and global Galois cohomology and the local Bloch–Kato dimension formula), RowT (already proved unconditionally in
Theorem 7.116), and the standard GL_{2} newform, Artin-reciprocity, and quadratic base-change com-ponents of HypothesesH' (itself assembled in published_hypotheses_from_patching_alt from Liter-atureRankNHypothesis and the already-proved DescWeak of Subsection 4.9).
(2) Transitive verification: auditing the transitive local import graph verifies zero axioms, zero sorries, and zero missing modules across all 761 modules under FiniteCohomology.lean, 1,668 under BlochKatoSelmerVanishes.lean, 2,104 under KatoTwoOfUseN.lean, 22,864 under VanishOrdLOfZetaUr.lean, 24,417 under ZetaUr.lean, 25,167 under KatoTwoW.lean, 26,419 under SphOfWitAlt.lean, 28,068 un-der SphAtTw.lean, and 36,168 under KatoTwoWOfPublishedH.lean.
(3) Downstream callers: kUse' packages KatoTwoW for a modular datum D with witness WitAQ, feed-ing typeII_of_blochKato_localPoint, oneCharU_of_katoTwoW_rig_admI_automorphy, and count_i_of_printed_bound_k_kato_automorphy inside vwin_of_hypotheses_H_E_alt.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/KatoTwoW.lean:21--30; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/KatoQuadraticCharacters/SphericalDecomposition/TypeIIOfBlochKatoLocalPoint.lean:12--117; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/PublishedHypothesesFromPatching.lean:98--103; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean:25--34.