Section 4.9 · PDF pages 102–113
Weak base-change descent and split-place rigidity
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
4.9 Weak base-change descent and split-place rigidity
Subsections 4.7 and 4.8 (together with Proposition 4.22 and Lemma 4.23) handle base change from a definite unitary group to GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}). In the reverse direction, both the patching package feeding the threshold counts in Section 4 and the full descent DescOffT used in Proposition 7.110(b) require weak base-change descent from a regular algebraic conjugate-self-dual cuspidal representation π of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) to the definite unitary group U(n) over E^{+}. In this subsection we reconstruct the complete proof of has_of_split, descWeakAll, and descWeak. Every step below is proved unconditionally in the supplied Lean source with zero axioms and zero sorries across all 36,328 modules in its transitive dependency cone; we note explicitly where a lower Lean module discharges a classical automorphic or trace-formula interface (Jacquet–Shalika bounds and Rankin–Selberg poles, cuspidal finiteness and multiplicity one, the definite unitary trace formula, endoscopic stabilization, the unit fundamental lemma, and twisted trace-formula asymptotics).
Throughout this subsection, let E be a CM field with maximal totally real subfield E^{+} such that E/E^{+} is unramified at every finite place (GlobalTheory.BCT.Unr E), and write Pl(E) for the set of finite places of E, c(w) (cPl w) for the complex-conjugate place of w ∈ Pl(E), and q_{w} = N(w) > 1 for the residue cardinality of w. For a finite multiset B in ℂ^{×}, set inv(B) = {α^{−1} : α ∈ B}. An isobaric datum D ∈ CD(E, n) consists of a length c ≥0, positive ranks N_{1}, . . . , N_{c} ≥1 with ∑^{c}_{i=1}N_{i} = n, and cuspidal isomorphism classes P_{i} ∈ CG(E, N_{i}). We write D.Sat(w, B) if there exist Satake multisets b_{i} for P_{i} at w with ∑_{i}b_{i} = B, D.Has(π) if (N_{i}, P_{i}) = (n, [π]) for some i, and D.Reg if for every complex embedding τ : E ↪→ ℂ the summed infinitesimal character ∑_{i} infChar_{τ}(P_{i}) equals infOfWeight(λ_{τ}) for some dominant weight λ_{τ} ∈ DomWeight(n) (so every entry has the form k + (n −1)/2 with k ∈ℤ).
Proposition 4.38 (Unitarity and θ-stability of conjugate-self-dual cuspidal representations). Let E be a CM field, let n ≥1, and let π be a cuspidal automorphic representation of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) satisfying DualIsConj (a nondegenerate invariant bilinear pairing between π and its complex-conjugate twist under conjOp). Then π is conjugate self-dual (IsCsd), normalized on the real split center (IsNormalised), unitary (IsUnitary), and θ-stable as an automorphic subspace (ThetaFix).
Proof. We first produce a nondegenerate invariant bilinear pairing between π and its inverse-transpose twist (Paired for invTOp), using the Jacquet–Shalika strong multiplicity one theorem (jacquetShalikaRigidity, proved unconditionally in the source from Rankin–Selberg poles rsPole and the local bound jacquetShalikaBound). Write π = π_{0} ⊗χ where π_{0} is normalized on the real split center (cuspidal_eq_twist_normalised). Let dualSubC(π_{0}) denote the space of functions obtained from π_{0} by applying the conjugate-linear inverse-transpose map D. Because π_{0} is normalized and cuspidal, its space embeds into L^{2}(GL_{n}(E)\GL_{n}(𝔸_{E})^{1}) via an injective equivariant map u (memL2_normalised_cusp_form, using cuspFormsBoundedGL), and at cofinitely many finite places w the Satake multiset of dualSubC(π_{0}) coincides with that of π_{0} (hasSat_dual). By jacquetShalikaRigidity.strong_multiplicity_one, there is a (𝔤, K_{∞}) × GL_{n}(𝔸^{∞}_{E})-equivariant isomor-phism T : dualSubC(π_{0})−→^{∼} π_{0} (dualSubC_iso). The composite J = T ∘D : π_{0} →π_{0} is a conjugate-linear
bijection intertwining invTOp with the action on π_{0}. Therefore
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B_{0}(φ, ψ) = ⟨u(Jψ), u(φ)⟩_{L}2is a nondegenerate ℂ-bilinear pairing witnessing Paired for π_{0} and invTOp: invariance under finite adelic and maximal compact elements follows from right-invariance of Haar measure, while Lie-algebra skew-symmetry holds by inner_lie_skew' (paired_of_dualSubC_iso). Twisting back by χ yields a nondegenerate pairing B_{1} witnessing Paired for π and invTOp (gelfandKazhdanDual_of_rigidity).
We now combine B_{1} (for invTOp) with the given pairing B_{2} (for conjOp). By admissibility and finite-ness of cuspidal forms (formsFiniteGL, exists_idempotent_finiteRank_adjoint_cuspidal), there exists a nonzero finite-rank idempotent P ∈ End_{ℂ}(π) admitting formal adjoints P_{1}, P_{2} with respect to B_{1}, B_{2}. Choose v ∈ π with Pv ̸= 0 and a linear functional g ∈ π^{∗} with g(Pv) ̸= 0. Then f = g ∘P satis-fies f ∘P = f, so nondegeneracy on the finite-dimensional image of P supplies vectors ψ_{1}, ψ_{2} ∈π with B_{1}(φ, ψ_{1}) = f(φ) = B_{2}(φ, ψ_{2}) for all φ ∈ π, and ψ_{1} ̸= 0 since f(v) ̸= 0. Both invTOp and conjOp are involutive (invTOp_involutive, conjOp_involutive). By irreducibility of π and the common represented functional, there is a ℂ-linear isomorphism S : π−→^{∼} π intertwining invTOp with conjOp, which gives π.IsCsd (isCsd_of_paired).
Let ω be the central character of π (exists_hasCentral). Conjugate self-duality implies that the archimedean derivative dχ_{ω} satisfies dχ_{ω}(t) = −dχ_{ω}(t) for every real scalar t ∈ ℝ (CsdUnitary.dchi_theta), so dχ_{ω}(t) = 0 and hence ω(exp(t)) = 1. Thus π is trivial on the real split center, i.e. IsNormalised (isNormalised_of_isCsd). The same triviality shows that the 1-dimensional representation 1 ⊗ ω is normalized, hence unitary, so ω is a unitary Hecke character and π is unitary (isUnitary_of_isNormalised), proving unitOf. Finally, pulling back π along the global involution θ yields a cuspidal subspace isomorphic to π by IsCsd, which coincides with π itself by cuspidal multiplicity one (cuspMultOneGL), yielding thetaFixOf.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/UnitOf.lean:13--20; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/ThetaFixOf.lean:39--70; Development/WeilBound/CoreStatements/TemperedRepresentationTheory/MultiplicityOneRigidity/GelfandKazhdanDualOfRigidity.lean:14--79; Devel-opment/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/SatakeParameters/ConjOpInvolutive.lean:16--63; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/SpehShapeIffOfDiscreteSpectrum.lean:163--176; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/SpehDataUnique.lean:25--43.
Lemma 4.39 (Infinitesimal-character normalization of regular isobaric factors). Let E be a CM field, n ≥ 1, π a cuspidal representation of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) satisfying DualIsConj, and D ∈ CD(E, n) a regular isobaric datum (D.Reg) such that for cofinitely many split places w ∈ Pl(E) there exists a multiset B with D.Sat(w, B) and [π].HasSat(w, B). Then for every index i of D, the factor D.P(i) admits a representative ρ_{i} ∈ CuspSub(E, D.N(i)) that is normalized (IsNormalised) and unitary (IsUnitary).
Proof. First, the set of split places of E/E^{+} is infinite (thin): every non-split prime of E has norm a square or ramifies over a prime of E^{+}, so ∑ q < ∞ (inertThin_holds), while the sum ∑ q^{−1}
w non-split w^{−1} w∈Pl(E) w diverges (not_summable_all); thus the complement {w : IsSplitAt w} cannot be finite. Intersecting with the cofinite matching hypothesis gives a split place w and Satake multisets b_{j} for D.P(j) such that B =∑_{j}b_{j} is the Satake multiset of π at w.
Fix an index i, put a = D.N(i) ≥ 1, and pick a representative ρ of D.P(i). Choose s ∈ ℂ so that ρ_{0} = ρ⊗| det |^{s} is normalized on the real split center (exists_twist_isNormalised), and put z = −s, so that D.P(i) = [ρ_{0}] ⊗| det |^{z}. We show z = 0 (twist_zero). Twisting by | det |^{z} translates every infinitesimal character multiset by +z (absInf): infChar_{τ}(D.P(i)) = infChar_{τ}(ρ_{0}) + z.
Step 1: Im z = 0. By D.Reg, every entry y of infChar_{τ}(D.P(i)) lies in infOfWeight(λ_{τ}) for some λ_{τ} ∈ DomWeight(n), hence has the form y = k + (n −1)/2 for some k ∈ℤ, so Im y = 0. Consequently every x ∈ infChar_{τ}(ρ_{0}) satisfies Im x = − Im z. On the other hand, because ρ_{0} is normalized, the real split center exp(t∑ · 1) acts trivially on a nonzero vector∑ x_{0} ∈ρ_{0}, whereas the Lie-algebra central trace element acts by ∑_{τ0} x; therefore ∑_{τ0} x = 0 (sum_inf_zero). Taking imaginary parts
τ x∈infChar (ρ) τ x∈infChar (ρ) yields −[E : ℚ] · a · Im z = 0, and since [E : ℚ] ≥1 and a ≥1 we obtain Im z = 0.
Step 2: 2z ∈ ℤ. Fix an embedding τ_{0} : E ↪→ ℂ and an element x ∈ infChar_{τ0}(ρ_{0}) (which exists since a ≥ 1). From Step 1, Im x = − Im z = 0, so ̄x = x. Because ρ_{0} is normalized, its infinitesimal character obeys the conjugate symmetry infChar_{τ̄0}(ρ_{0}) = −infChar_{τ0}(ρ_{0}) (infChar_conj), whence −x ∈ infChar_{τ̄0}(ρ_{0}). Applying D.Reg at τ_{0} and ̄τ_{0} yields integers k_{1}, k_{2} ∈ℤ with x + z = k_{1} + (n −1)/2 and −x+z = k_{2}+(n−1)/2. Adding these equalities cancels x and gives 2z = M where M = k_{1}+k_{2}+n−1 ∈ ℤ. Write r = M/2 ∈ℝ, so z = r.
Step 3: M = 0. By Proposition 4.38, π is unitary. Applying the Jacquet–Shalika local bound (jacquet
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1/2
ShalikaBound) to π at the split place w (where q_{w} > 1), every α ∈b_{i} ⊆B satisfies q_{w}^{−1/2}< |α| < q_{w}, i.e., −_{2}^{1} log q_{w} < log |α| <^{ 1}_{2} log q_{w}. Summing over the a elements of b_{i} gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a |||∏ |||
−_{2} log q_{w} < log α < a_{2} log q_{w}. (91)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
α∈b_{i}On the other hand, untwisting D.P(i) by | det |^{−z} recovers the normalized unitary representation ρ_{0}, whose Satake multiset at w is {α · |ϖ_{w}|^{−}_{w}^{z}: α ∈b_{i}} with |ϖ_{w}|^{−}_{w}^{z}= q_{w}^{r} (satake_twist_holds, norm_absC_val). By the determinant-one condition for unitary cuspidal representations (determinant_one_condition_holds),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 =|||∏(α · |ϖ_{w}|^{−}_{w}^{z})||| =|||∏α||| · q_{w}^{ar}.
α∈b_{i} α∈b_{i}Taking logarithms gives log |∏_{α∈bi}α| = −ar log q_{w}. Substituting into (91) and dividing by a log q_{w} > 0 yields −1/2 < r < 1/2. Since r = M/2 with M ∈ℤ, we must have M = 0, hence z = 0 and s = 0. Thus ρ_{0} = ρ represents D.P(i) and is normalized and unitary (isUnitary_of_isNormalised).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/AbsInf.lean:11--18; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/Thin.lean:8--19; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/PartNorm.lean:24--197.
Proposition 4.40 (Split-place Jacquet–Shalika rigidity). Let E be a CM field with E/E^{+} unramified at all finite places, let n ≥1, and let π ∈ CG(E, n) be unitary. Let J be a finite index set, and for each j ∈J let a_{j} ≥1 and P_{j} ∈ CG(E, a_{j}) be unitary. Suppose that for cofinitely many split places w ∈ Pl(E) there exist Satake multisets b_{j} for P_{j} at w such that ∑_{j∈J}b_{j} is the Satake multiset of π at w. Then there exists j ∈J with (a_{j}, P_{j}) = (n, π).
Proof. We follow the exact four-stage argument of splitRigid.
Stage 1: Split-active twisting character (antiTw). Because E/E^{+} is unramified at all finite places, there exists a unitary Hecke character µ of 𝔸^{×}_{E}/E^{×} whose restriction to 𝔸^{×}_{E+} is the quadratic character η_{E/E}+ of E/E^{+}, which is unramified at every non-split place w with µ_{w}(ϖ_{w}) = −1, and whose archimedean infinity types are e(v)/2 with e(v) odd for every infinite place v of E (muExists, muInf). Set χ = µ^{2}. Then χ is unitary, unramified at cofinitely many places with |χ_{w}(ϖ_{w})| = 1, and satisfies χ_{w}(ϖ_{w}) = (−1)^{2} = 1 at every non-split place w. Moreover, for every i ∈ℕ, π ⊗χ^{i} is unitary, and at any infinite place v of E the
summed infinitesimal character shifts by
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ x = ∑ x + n · i · e(v).
x∈infCharv(π⊗χ^{i}) x∈infCharv(π)Since n ≥1 and e(v) ̸= 0 (as e(v) is odd), the map i →→π ⊗χ^{i} is injective.
Stage 2: The finite Rankin–Selberg system and analytic bounds. Put M = 16(|J| + 1)^{2} ≥ 1, and form the finite set X = im({π ⊗χ^{i} : 0 ≤ i < M} ⊔{P_{j} : j ∈ J}). Write z_{i} = [π ⊗χ^{i}] ∈ X, x_{0} = z_{0} = [π], and y_{j} = [P_{j}] ∈ X; by Stage 1, i →→ z_{i} is injective. Choose a finite set S ⊂ Pl(E) outside which the split-matching hypothesis holds, χ is unramified, every x ∈ X has a Satake multiset A_{x}(w) = (α_{x,w,1}, . . . , α_{x,w,dx}) (cg_sat_ev, list_of_multiset), and all pairwise Rankin–Selberg Euler prod-ucts L^{S}(s, x × ̄y) obey the pole/holomorphy theorem (rankin_selberg_unitary_of_pole from rsPole). Set W = Pl(E) \ S and I = {w ∈W : ¬IsSplitAt w}. For x, y ∈X, σ > 1, and p = (w, k) ∈W × ℕ, define the logarithmic Euler-product term
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 (∑ )(∑ )
lterm(x, y, σ, p) = A_{x}(w, a)^{k+1} A_{y}(w, b)^{k+1} q_{w}^{−(k+1)σ}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
k + 1_{ab}By jacquetShalikaBound (|A_{x}(w, a)| ≤q_{w}^{1/2}) and determinant_one_condition_holds (| ∏_{a}A_{x}(w, a)| = 1), the family∑ (W, q, X, d, A) forms a Rankin–Selberg system Sys. By convergence_of_landau_euler,
_{p} lterm(x, y, s, p) converges absolutely and defines a holomorphic function on {Re s > 1}. Since the Euler product equals exp(∑_{p} lterm(x, y, t, p)) for t > max(σ_{0}, 2) (euler_product_log_bound), the real-analytic identity theorem on (1, ∞) yields an analytic function F_{x,y} on {Re s > 0} with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∑ )
F_{x,y}(σ) = (δ_{xy}(σ −1) + (1 −δ_{xy})) exp lterm(x, y, σ, p) (σ > 1)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p
(extId). Three analytic bounds follow immediately:
(a) Diagonal asymptotics (logTwo): for x = y, we have F_{x,x}(1) ̸= 0, for otherwise the divided difference dslope(F_{x,x}, 1)(σ) = exp(∑_{p} lterm(x, x, σ, p)) would be continuous and hence bounded on [1, 2], contradicting Landau’s nonnegativity theorem (dirichlet_series_unbounded). Thus log |F_{x,x}(σ)| is continuous and bounded on [1, 2], giving a constant C_{x} such that | Re ∑_{p} lterm(x, x, σ, p) + log(σ − 1)| ≤C_{x} for all 1 < σ ≤2.
(b) Off-diagonal upper bound (crossUp): for x ̸= y, continuity of F_{x,y} on [1, 2] gives |F_{x,y}(σ)| ≤C_{x,y}, so Re ∑_{p} lterm(x, y, σ, p) ≤ exp(Re ∑_{p} lterm(x, y, σ, p)) = |F_{x,y}(σ)| ≤C_{x,y} for all 1 < σ ≤2.
(c) Partial Cauchy–Schwarz (partCS): pointwise, | lterm(x, y, σ, p)|^{2} = | lterm(x, x, σ, p)| · | lterm(y, y, σ, p)|, and every diagonal summand lterm(x, x, σ, p) is real and nonnegative. Ap-plying the triangle inequality and Cauchy–Schwarz on I × ℕ and enlarging the y-sum from I to all of W yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||| ∑ |||2 ( ∑ )( ∑ )
lterm(x, y, σ, p) ≤ Re lterm(x, x, σ, p) Re lterm(y, y, σ, p) .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p∈I×ℕ p∈I×ℕ p∈W×ℕ
Stage 3: Bounding the non-split share (shareBd). Put c_{w} = χ_{w}(ϖ_{w}) for w ∈W, so |c_{w}| = 1∑ and c_{w} = 1 for all w ∈ I. By sat_pow, the power sums of z_{i} = π ⊗χ^{i} satisfy ∑_{b}A_{zi}(w, b)^{k} = c^{ik}_{wa}A_{x0}(w, a)^{k}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i(k+1)
Writing t(p) = lterm(x_{0}, x_{0}, σ, p) ≥0 and s(p) =∑^{M}_{i=0}^{−1}c_{w}, we obtain pointwise
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
M∑−1M∑−1
lterm(z_{i}, z_{j}, σ, p) = |s(p)|^{2}t(p) ≥0.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i=0 j=0
For w ∈I, c_{w} = 1 forces s(p) = M and hence |s(p)|^{2}t(p) = M^{2}t(p). Dropping the nonnegative terms with w /∈ I, summing over p, and applying (a) to the M diagonal pairs i = j and (b) to the off-diagonal pairs i ̸= j (which have z_{i} ̸= z_{j} by injectivity of z) gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ M∑−1 ∑ M∑−1
M^{2} Re lterm(x_{0}, x_{0}, σ, p) ≤ Re lterm(z_{i}, z_{j}, σ, p) ≤M(− log(σ −1)) + D_{i,j}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p∈I×ℕ i,j=0 p i,j=0
Dividing by M^{2} yields a constant C such that for all 1 < σ ≤2,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
_{00} − log(σ −1) Re lterm(x , x , σ, p) ≤ + C. (92)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p∈I×ℕ^{M}Stage 4: Contradiction (absShare, splitRigid_of). Suppose for contradiction that x_{0} ̸= y_{j} for ev-ery∑ j ∈∑J. At every split place w ∈ W \ I, equality of Satake multisets implies ∑_{a}A_{x0}(w, a)^{k+1} =
_{j∈Jb}A_{yj}(w, b)^{k+1} for all k ≥0. Hence
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑ ∑(∑ ∑ )
lterm(x_{0}, x_{0}, σ, p)− lterm(x_{0}, x_{0}, σ, p) = lterm(x_{0}, y_{j}, σ, p)− lterm(x_{0}, y_{j}, σ, p) .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p p∈I×ℕ j∈J p p∈I×ℕ (93)
Write L(σ) = − log(σ −1) ≥0 for 1 < σ ≤2, and put N_{J} = |J| + 1 ≥1, so M = 16N_{J}^{2}≥16. For each j ∈J, let C_{2,j} and C_{3,j} be the constants from (a) for y_{j} and (b) for (x_{0}, y_{j}), and put T_{j} = L(σ)+|C_{2,j}| ≥0. Combining (c), (92), and (a) for y_{j} gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||| ∑ |||^{2} (^{ T}j )^{T}j^{2}lterm(x_{0}, y_{j}, σ, p) ≤_{2}+ |C| T_{j} =_{2}+ |C| T_{j}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{p∈I×ℕ} 16N_{J} 16N_{J}Since T_{j}^{2}/(16N_{J}^{2}) + |C| T_{j} ≤(T_{j}/(3N_{J}) + 3N_{J}|C|/2)^{2} (le_of_sq_le), we obtain
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∑ ∑ ) L(σ)
Re lterm(x_{0}, y_{j}, σ, p) − lterm(x_{0}, y_{j}, σ, p) ≤ + D_{j} (94)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p p∈I×ℕ^{3NJ}with D_{j} = C_{3,j} + |C_{2,j}|/(3N_{J}) + 3N_{J}|C|/2. Taking real parts in (93), the left-hand side is bounded below by L(σ) −|C_{x0}| −L(σ)/16 −|C| =^{15}_{16}L(σ) −|C_{x0}| −|C|, while summing (94) over j ∈J bounds the
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑
right-hand side above by _{3(|J}^{|J}_{|+1)}^{|} L(σ) +_{j∈J}|D_{j}| ≤_{3}^{1}L(σ) +_{j∈J}|D_{j}|. Since ^{ 15}_{16}−^{1}_{3} >^{ 1}_{2}, we deduce
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 ∑
_{2}(− log(σ −1)) ≤K_{0} := |C_{x0}| + |C| + |D_{j}|
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j∈J
for every σ ∈(1, 2]. Setting K = 2K_{0} + 1 > 0 and evaluating at σ = 1 + e^{−K} ∈(1, 2] gives K/2 ≤K_{0}, a contradiction. Therefore y_{j} = x_{0}, i.e. (a_{j}, P_{j}) = (n, π), for some j ∈J.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/SplitRigid.lean:12--13; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/ListOfMultiset.lean:10--156; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/ShareBd.lean:8--101; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/AbsShare.lean:7--143; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/AntiTw.lean:9--60; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/Modularity
Argument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/NormLterm.lean:7--52; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/LogTwo.lean:7--48; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/CrossUp.lean:7--17; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL1SpectralBounds/PartCS.lean:8--64; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/MuInf.lean:13--25; Development/WeilBound/RepresentationTheoryGL/ArchimedeanBaseChange/ArchimedeanBaseChangeProof/SatakeExponents/UniformizerValuations/QuadraticCharacterNorms/QuadCharNorm.lean:19--56.
We next assemble the twisted spectral blocks that control the geometric terms geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}, l_{2}, Φ) on GL_{a} × GL_{b}. For a section S ⊂ Pl(E) selecting one place from each conjugate pair of split places (and containing all non-split places), disjoint finite sets Z, T ⊂S, local compactly supported test functions φ_{w} (w ∈ Z), and formal spherical Hecke polynomials e_{1}, e_{2} : Pl(E) → Ex(Fin(a + 1) × Fin(b + 1)), the k-th test family fam(Z, T, φ, e_{1}, e_{2}, k) equals φ_{w} for w ∈Z, the spherical function of (e_{1}(w)^{k}e_{2}(w)^{k}) for w ∈T, and the unit indicator 1_{K2,w} outside Z ∪T. Its Satake evaluation on (B_{1}, B_{2}) is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
val(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{1}, B_{2}) = ev_{2}(w, e_{1}(w), B_{1}(w), B_{2}(w))·ev_{2}(w, e_{2}(w), inv(B_{1}(c(w))), inv(B_{2}(c(w)))).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w∈T
A sequence x : ℕ →ℂ is Small of rate ρ > 0 if there exist C ∈ℝ and N ∈ℕ with |x(k)| ≤C(1 + k)^{N}ρ^{k} for all k.
Proposition 4.41 (Spectral accumulation, C^{∗}-peaking, and inert θ-stabilization of twisted blocks). Assume E/E^{+} is unramified at all finite places.
(i) (CuspReadI) For every rank N ≥ 0, open compact level K ≤ GL_{N}(𝔸^{∞}_{E}) containing GL_{N}(𝒪_{Ew}) outside a finite bad set bad, finite-dimensional K_{∞}-type W, target infinitesimal character m_{0}, and subsingleton set X of normalized cuspidal representations, there exist a finite index set J and isobaric data (D_{j}, C_{j})_{j∈J} with D_{j} ∈ CD(E, N), D_{j}.Inf(m_{0}), ¬D_{j}.Has(π) for π ∈X, and D_{j}.Sat(w, C_{j}(w)) for w /∈ bad, such that every sequence of nonzero automorphic eigenforms φ_{k} of level K, type W, excluding determinant twists of X, with infinitesimal characters m_{k} →m_{0}, has a subsequence whose Satake Hecke eigenvalues outside bad converge to those of C_{j} for some j ∈J.
(ii) (EndoBlockS) For all a, b with a + b ≥ 1, dominant weights l_{1}, l_{2}, split finite set Z ⊂ S, and test
functions φ_{w} (w ∈Z) with at least one regular-elliptic support condition RegAt2, there exist a finite family (D_{1,j}, D_{2,j}, B_{1,j}, B_{2,j})_{j∈J} matching m_{W} (l_{1}), m_{W} (l_{2}) with inert self-duality inv(B_{1,j}(w)) = B_{1,j}(w) and inv(B_{2,j}(w)) = B_{2,j}(w) at every non-split place w, such that for any split finite T ⊂S disjoint from Z, any e_{1}, e_{2}, and any ρ > 0 with | val(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{1,j}, B_{2,j})| < ρ for all j ∈ J, the sequence k →→ geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}, l_{2}, fam(Z, T, φ, e_{1}, e_{2}, k)) is Small of rate ρ.
(iii) (StableBlockS) Let n ≥ 1 and let π be a regular algebraic cuspidal representation of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E})
satisfying DualIsConj, with associated dominant weight l_{1}, local components τ_{w} (w ∈ Z), and Satake multisets B(w) off Z. Then there exists a nonzero constant c ̸= 0 such that for any test functions φ_{w} (w ∈ Z) with a regular-elliptic place, there exists a finite family (D_{j}, B_{1,j})_{j∈J} with ¬D_{j}.Has(π), D_{j}.Inf(m_{W} (l_{1})), and inv(B_{1,j}(w)) = B_{1,j}(w) at every non-split place w where inv(B(w)) = B(w), such that for any split finite T ⊂S disjoint from Z, any e_{1}, e_{2}, and any ρ > 0 with | val(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{1,j}, 0)| < ρ for all j ∈J, the difference
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ∏ )
k −−→ geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}, l_{0}, fam(Z, T, φ, e_{1}, e_{2}, k)) −c trc(τ_{w}, φ_{w}(·, 1)) val(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B, 0)^{k}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w∈Z
is Small of rate ρ.
Proof. For (i), shrink K to an integral level subgroup K^{′} (levShrink) and induct strongly on N (readJ_all, cuspReadI_of). The case N = 0 is trivial with D = CD.nil. For N ≥1, every automorphic form φ_{k} is either cuspidal or has a nonzero constant term along some standard maximal parabolic of block sizes (r, s) with r + s = N and r, s ≥1; by pigeonhole on this finite partition (readJ_or), we treat the two cases separately:
• Cuspidal case (cuspCaseJ): each φ_{k} lies in a cuspidal representation π_{k} = π_{0,k} ⊗| det |^{zk} with π∑_{0,k} normalized (cuspMem, normTw). Summing the infinitesimal characters yields z_{k} → z_{0} := (_{τ}m_{0}(τ).sum)/(N[E : ℚ]). Hence the π_{0,k} eventually have uniformly bounded infinitesimal characters, level K^{′}, and K_{∞}-type W, so they range over a finite set (cuspFin). Extracting a constant subsequence π_{0,σ(k)} = π_{0} gives D = [π_{0}] ⊗| det |^{z0} with D.Inf(m_{0}), ¬D.Has(π) for π ∈ X (by normUniq and the exclusion hypothesis on φ_{k}), and Satake eigenvalue convergence (satComb, absInf, mtoLaws).
• Non-cuspidal constant-term case (ctCaseJ): taking the constant term along (r, s) produces eigenforms (φ_{1,k}, φ_{2,k}) on GL_{r} and GL_{s} whose shifted infinitesimal characters sum to m_{k} with shifts −s/2 and +r/2 (stepT). Because m_{0} has only finitely many multiset partitions (splitLim), passing to a subse-quence converges to a pair (p_{1}, p_{2}) of target infinitesimal characters. Applying the strong induction hypothesis to r < N and s < N yields finite families (D_{1,j1}) and (D_{2,j2}), whose twisted concate-nations (D_{1,j1} ⊗| det |^{−s/2}) ⊞(D_{2,j2} ⊗| det |^{r/2}) (cdAddG) have ranks ≤ max(r, s) < N (hence automatically avoid X), sum to m_{0}, and satisfy Satake convergence (satComb).
For the raw versions EndoBlockG and StableBlockG (before enforcing inert self-duality), apply CuspReadI to the commuting self-adjoint algebra of archimedean and spherical Hecke convolution operators acting on the L^{2}-block Hilbert space H_{b} (rSpec_of, peakRun, peakAlg). By Gelfand duality on a commutative C^{∗}-algebra (peak in ExistsGap.lean), if every character extending the archimedean infinitesimal character χ_{l1}, χ_{l2} evaluates the spherical operator x to modulus < ρ, then multiplying x by a suitable archimedean peaking element g · a_{0} with character value 1 contracts the operator norm strictly below ρ on the invariant subspace Q (either Q = H_{b} in rEndo_of, or Q = (piSp π)^{⊥} in rStable). In the endoscopic case rEndo_of, iterating the contracted operator U gives ‖U^{k}‖≤ρ^{k}, and the elliptic-kernel trace growth estimate growthJ_holds converts this directly into Small of rate ρ for geomSt_{2}. In the stable case rStable, π is normalized and θ-stable by Proposition 4.38 (thetaFixOf); the twisted trace on the finite-dimensional π-isotypic subspace (piAdm_pf, piFin_holds, twTrSum_pf) equals the main term c · (∏_{w∈Z} trc(τ_{w}, φ_{w}(·, 1))) val(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B, 0)^{k} with c ̸= 0 by the global Haar-average trace identity (piTerm_holds, global_haarAverage_trace_identity), while the truncated kernel estimate on the orthogonal complement (growthPiJ_holds, via uncutHalf, cutTail, and ellFormula2J) together with final_bd yields Small of rate ρ for the remainder.
Finally, to upgrade EndoBlockG and StableBlockG to EndoBlockS and StableBlockS (enlarge, endoS, sta-bleS), consider the multiplicative submonoid U1 of formal spherical Hecke expressions on GL_{a} × GL_{b} gen-erated by 1 and elements 1 + c · d_{p} (c ∈ℂ, p = (i, j) ∈ Fin(a + 1) × Fin(b + 1)), where
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d_{p} = T_{a,b} · T_{i,j} −T_{a−i,b−j}. (95)At any non-split place w:
(a) For every e ∈ U1, the stable twisted orbital integral satisfies stTw_{2}(w, Q_{1}, Q_{2}, fn_{2}(e)) = stTw_{2}(w, Q_{1}, Q_{2}, 1_{K2,w}) (stUnit, proved in stUnit_of by induction on U1 using Gelfand commuta-tivity cvComm2 and twisted-orbital invariance twSwap to show twOrb(θ_{2}, h ∗ fn_{2}(d_{p})) = 0).
(b) For any multisets B_{1}, B_{2} of cardinalities a, b with inv(B_{1}) = B_{1} and inv(B_{2}) = B_{2}, the identities T_{a}(B_{1})T_{i}(B_{1}) = T_{a−i}(B_{1}) and T_{b}(B_{2})T_{j}(B_{2}) = T_{b−j}(B_{2}) force ev_{2}(w, d_{p}, B_{1}, B_{2}) = 0 and hence ev_{2}(w, e, B_{1}, B_{2}) = 1 for every e ∈ U1 (hecke_eigenvalues_unitary_one_factor).
(c) Conversely, if ¬(inv(B_{1}) = B_{1} ∧ inv(B_{2}) = B_{2}), then ev_{2}(w, d_{p}, B_{1}, B_{2}) ̸= 0 for some p (taking j = 0 or i = 0 recovers the full symmetric polynomial identities determining inv(B_{r}) = B_{r}), so e = 1 − ev_{2}(w, d_{p}, B_{1}, B_{2})^{−1}d_{p} ∈ U1 satisfies ev_{2}(w, e, B_{1}, B_{2}) = 0 (unitary_one_characters_separated_by_eigenvalues).
For each finite set of candidates failing inert self-duality at some non-split witness place u_{i}, enlarging T to T^{′} = T ∪{u_{i}} and placing the product of the separating U1-elements at each u_{i} (with e^{′}_{2}(u_{i}) = 1) leaves geomSt_{2} completely unchanged by (a), leaves val unchanged on all inert-self-dual candidates (and on B when inv(B(u_{i})) = B(u_{i})) by (b), and annihilates every failing candidate by (c) (enlarge). Passing to the subset of inert-self-dual candidates yields (ii) (endoS) and (iii) (stableS).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/CuspReadIOf.lean:10--74; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/CuspCaseJ.lean:13--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/CtCaseJ.lean:9--52; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/CdAddG.lean:10--43; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/CuspidalContribution/SplitLim.lean:22--94; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/ExistsGap.lean:12--99; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/EndomorphismSlices/REndoOf.lean:24--101; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/EndomorphismSlices/FiniteAdelicEstimates/RStable.lean:39--133; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/EndomorphismSlices/StableBlockG.lean:22--39; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/AutomorphicRepresentations/GrowthPiJHolds.lean:36--56; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/AutomorphicRepresentations/PiTermEqTraceSumOfDegreeFourTest.lean:60--85; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GL4GeometricSide/GlobalHaarAverageTraceIdentity.lean:30--33; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/OrbitalCosetFiniteness/LocalFieldTopologyFacts.lean:14--98; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/OrbitalCosetFiniteness/StUnit.lean:12--13; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/HeckeEigenvaluesUnitaryOneFactor.lean:10--32; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/SeparatesUnitaryOne.lean:9--53; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/Enlarge.lean:33--121; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/EndoS.lean:10--44; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/StableS.lean:10--55.
Theorem 4.42 (Global twisted-vs-unitary trace comparison dichotomy). Let E be a CM field with E/E^{+} unramified at all finite places, let n ≥1, and let π be a regular algebraic cuspidal representation of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) satisfying DualIsConj that admits a Satake multiset at every non-split finite place w. Then at least one of the following holds (RunTh):
(a) There exists an automorphic representation σ of the definite unitary group U(n)(𝔸_{E}+) (IsAutRepU) that is unramified at every non-split finite place w (IsUnramU) and satisfies that for cofinitely many split places w there exist an irreducible smooth representation τ of GL_{n}(E_{w}) and a Satake multiset B with τ occurring as a local component of σ at w, HasSatGL(w, τ, B), and [π].HasSat(w, B).
(b) There exists a regular isobaric datum D ∈ CD(E, n) with ¬D.Has(π) that has an inert-self-dual Satake multiset (inv(B) = B) at cofinitely many non-split places and matches the Satake multiset of π at cofinitely many split places.
Proof. Choose a unitary Hecke character µ for E/E^{+} with odd archimedean exponents e(v) (muEx) and let λ = l_{1} be the dominant weight attached to π by Proposition 4.41(iii). Pick a section S ⊂ Pl(E) and a finite set Z ⊂S of split places containing all places where π or µ ramifies (using the hypothesis that π is spherical at every non-split place, while µ is unramified at every non-split place) together with a good split place w_{1} ∈Z (rChoice). At every w ∈Z, choose a local component τ_{w} of π and a compactly supported smooth function f_{w} on GL_{n}(E_{w}) with trc(τ_{w}, f_{w}) ̸= 0 (levelFn), and at w_{1} choose f_{w1} supported on matrices with separable characteristic polynomial (regFn); then every twisted constant term ct_{0}(µ, a, b, f) satisfies RegAt2 at w_{1} (regCt). Write B(w) for the Satake multiset of π off Z.
Unitary trace formula (uSide, rUEval). For any split finite set T ⊂ S disjoint from Z, any spherical Hecke expressions e_{1}, e_{2} on GL_{n}, and any k ∈ ℕ, define the test family famU(Z, T, f, e_{1}, e_{2}, k) on U(n) equal to f_{w} on Z, fn_{1}(e_{1}(w)^{k}e_{2}(w)^{k}) on T, and the unit indicator elsewhere. Because w_{1} ∈ Z imposes regular-elliptic support, the definite unitary trace formula (uSide) expands geomU(S, λ, famU(k)) over a finite set {σ_{i}}_{i∈ι} of automorphic representations of U(n) of fixed weight λ and level K^{′} (unramified outside Z, hence unramified at all non-split places). Using spherical line multiplicity one at split and inert places (splitLine, inertLine) and conjugate-place inversion (uConj), there exist constants A_{i} ∈ ℂ and Satake multisets B_{U}(i) (i ∈ι) off Z such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
geomU(S, λ, famU(Z, T, f, e_{1}, e_{2}, k)) = A_{i} val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{U}(i))^{k}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈ι
Geometric stabilization and local matching (g2s, rFamMatch). By endoscopic geometric stabilization (g2s, decomposing the κ-orbital sums of geomU via archimedean character identities realProdS and re-sultant phases kap_mul), there exist a finite index set κ, ranks 0 ≤ a(i) ≤ n, dominant weights l_{1}(i) ∈ DomWeight(a(i)), l_{2}(i) ∈ DomWeight(n −a(i)), and signs sg(i) ∈{±1} such that:
• for every i ∈κ and infinite place v, the shifted infinitesimal characters (infOfWeight(l_{1}(i, v)) + (n − a(i))e(v)/2) + (infOfWeight(l_{2}(i, v)) + a(i)e(v)/2) sum to infOfWeight(λ(v));
• there is a unique index i_{1} ∈ κ with a(i_{1}) = n and sg(i_{1}) = +1, and a unique index i_{0} ∈ κ with a(i_{0}) = 0 and sg(i_{0}) = +1;
• for matched test functions,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
geomU(S, λ, famU(k)) = sg(i) geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}(i), l_{2}(i), Φ_{a(i),n−a(i)}(k)). (96)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈κ
Local matching of famU(k) with the twisted constant-term families Φ_{a,b}(k) on GL_{a} × GL_{b} (a + b = n) is supplied by rFamMatch: at every non-split place, both functions are the unit indicators and match by the fundamental lemma for the unit element of unramified unitary groups (matchUnit, proved unconditionally in archimedean_base_change_first via unitLemma_unramified_product_unitary_groups); at every split place, matching holds by the twisted constant-term homomorphism (matchSplit, ctEx), which pulls back spherical expressions e_{1}, e_{2} along t_{a,b} so that val(T, e_{1} ∘t, e_{2} ∘t, B_{1}, B_{2}) = val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, un(µ, a, b, B_{1}, B_{2})), where un(µ, a, b, B_{1}, B_{2})_{w} = (B_{1}(w) · µ_{w}(ϖ_{w})^{b}) + (B_{2}(w) · µ_{w}(ϖ_{w})^{a}).
Asymptotic separation and contradiction (asmTh_of). Apply Proposition 4.41(iii) (stableS) to π on (n, 0), obtaining c ̸= 0 and a finite family of residual candidates (D_{s}(j), B_{s}(j))_{j∈Js} with ¬D_{s}(j).Has(π), and apply Proposition 4.41(ii) (endoS) to each proper endoscopic index i ∈ κ (1 ≤ a(i) ≤ n −1), obtaining finite families (D_{1}(i, j), D_{2}(i, j), B_{1}(i, j), B_{2}(i, j))_{j∈Ji}.
Suppose for contradiction that both (a) and (b) fail. Form the finite disjoint union
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
I = ι ⊔ J_{s} ⊔ ⊔ J_{i},
1≤a(^{i}i^{∈})≤^{κ}n−1carrying Satake families C_{m} off Z defined by B_{U}(m) on ι, B_{s}(m) on J_{s}, and un(µ, a(i), n − a(i), B_{1}(i, j), B_{2}(i, j)) on J_{i}. We claim every m ∈I differs from B at some split place w ∈ Off(Z):
• For m ∈ι, agreement of B_{U}(m) and B at all split places off Z would directly produce σ_{m} satisfying (a).
• For m ∈ J_{s}, D_{s}(m) has ¬D_{s}(m).Has(π), is regular by regOf, and inherits inv(B_{s}(m)(w)) = B_{s}(m)(w) at cofinitely many non-split places w from the conjugate self-duality of π (csdInert); thus split-place agreement off Z would yield (b).
• For (i, j) with 1 ≤a(i) ≤n −1, the twisted concatenation D = (D_{1}(i, j) ⊗µ^{n−a(i)}) ⊞(D_{2}(i, j) ⊗ µ^{a(i)}) (twDataT) has every factor of rank ≤ max(a(i), n−a(i)) < n (so ¬D.Has(π)), is regular by the archimedean shift compatibility from g2s, has Satake multiset un(µ, a(i), n −a(i), B_{1}(i, j), B_{2}(i, j)) off Z, and satisfies inv(C_{i,j}(w)) = C_{i,j}(w) at every non-split place w because µ_{w}(ϖ_{w}) = −1 (muInf, unStable); again split-place agreement off Z would yield (b).
By rSep (constructing an affine polynomial in a separating elementary symmetric function at each witness place and multiplying across the finite set I), there exist a split finite set T ⊂S disjoint from Z and expres-sions e_{1}, e_{2} such that val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B) = 1 and val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, C_{m}) = 0 for every m ∈I.
Now take the limit k →∞ in (96):
• On the left-hand side, val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{U}(m)) = 0 for every m ∈ι, so geomU(S, λ, famU(k)) = 0 for all k ≥1.
• On the right-hand side, for every proper endoscopic index i (1 ≤a(i) ≤n −1), every candidate in J_{i} has | val(T, e_{1}∘t, e_{2}∘t, B_{1}(i, j), B_{2}(i, j))| = | val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, C_{i,j})| = 0 < 1/2, so Proposition 4.41(ii) and small_tendsto yield geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}(i), l_{2}(i), Φ_{a(i),n−a(i)}(k)) →0.
• For the boundary indices i ∈ κ with a(i) ∈{0, n}, we have sg(i) = +1, and the (0, n) and (n, 0) geometric terms agree termwise (ends). Since every j ∈J_{s} has | val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B_{s}(j))| = 0 < 1/2 while val_{1}(T, e_{1}, e_{2}, B) = 1, Proposition 4.41(iii) and small_tendsto give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
_{k}lim_{→∞} geomSt_{2}(S, l_{1}(i), l_{2}(i), Φ_{a(i),n−a(i)}(k)) = P := c trc(τ_{w}, ct_{0}(µ, n, 0, f)_{w}(·, 1)). (97)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w∈Z
By trAvg, each local trace in (97) equals trc(τ_{w}, f_{w}) ̸= 0, and c ̸= 0, so P ̸= 0.
Passing to the limit in (96) yields 0 = #{i ∈κ : a(i) ∈{0, n}} · P. Since i_{0} belongs to this index set, the count is nonzero (in fact equal to 2 for n ≥1), contradicting P ̸= 0. This proves runTh.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/DescWeak.lean:9; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/DescWeakOfPi.lean:14--16; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/DescWeakOfGalStep.lean:55--67; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/AsmThOf.lean:10--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/Modularity
Argument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/TraceAsymptotics/RChoice.lean:13--74; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/TraceAsymptotics/RUEval.lean:220--332; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/TraceAsymptotics/RFamMatch.lean:71--179; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/TraceAsymptotics/ConstantTermParabolicAverage.lean:15--112; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GlobalTraceComparison/TraceAsymptotics/SmallTendsto.lean:13--38; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/WeightRankUnits/USide.lean:9--48; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/WeightRankUnits/NeZeroOfFinprod.lean:13--72; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/WeightRankUnits/MatchUnit.lean:4; Devel-opment/WeilBound/RepresentationTheoryGL/ArchimedeanBaseChange/ArchimedeanBaseChangeProof/IwahoriFactorisation/MultiplicityOneBase/ArchimedeanBaseChangeFirst.lean:29--64; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/Convolution/WeightRankUnits/MatchSplit.lean:12--21; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/TwDataT.lean:13--65; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/RegOf.lean:9--26; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/UnStable.lean:18--23; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/GaloisFromTraceFormula/CsdInert.lean:9--15.
Theorem 4.43 (Split-matching rigidity and weak base-change descent). Let E be a CM field with E/E^{+} unramified at all finite places, let n ≥1, and let π be a cuspidal automorphic representation of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) satisfying DualIsConj.
(i) (has_of_split) If D ∈ CD(E, n) is regular (D.Reg) and matches the Satake multiset of π at cofinitely many split places, then D.Has(π).
(ii) (descWeakAll) If π is regular algebraic and admits a Satake multiset at every non-split finite place,
then there exists an automorphic representation σ of the definite unitary group U(n)(𝔸_{E}+) that is unramified at every non-split finite place and matches the Satake multiset of π at cofinitely many split places.
(iii) (descWeak) In particular, UpperTheory.V.Z.Desc.DescWeak holds: for every prime p, every finite set S
of places of E^{+} containing all places above p such that every place of E over S is split, every rank 2 ≤ n ≤ 4, and every regular algebraic cuspidal representation π of GL_{n}(𝔸_{E}) satisfying DualIsConj that admits a Satake multiset at every place of E not lying over S, there exists a definite unitary automorphic representation σ as in (ii).
Proof. For (i), Proposition 4.38 (unitOf) shows that [π] is unitary, and Lemma 4.39 (partNorm absInf) shows that every factor D.P(i) of D is unitary. Applying Proposition 4.40 (splitRigid) to [π] and the finite family (D.N(i), D.P(i))_{i∈Fin(D.c)} yields an index i with (D.N(i), D.P(i)) = (n, [π]), which is precisely D.Has(π).
For (ii), apply Theorem 4.42 (runTh). If the second alternative held, it would supply a regular isobaric datum D ∈ CD(E, n) with ¬D.Has(π) matching π at cofinitely many split places, contradicting (i). Hence the first alternative holds, proving descWeakAll.
For (iii), since 2 ≤n implies 1 ≤n, and every non-split place w ∈ Pl(E) cannot lie over S (as every place over S is split by hypothesis), the off-S Satake hypothesis supplies a Satake multiset for π at every non-split place. Applying (ii) therefore yields UpperTheory.V.Z.Desc.DescWeak.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/TraceFormula/SplitRigidity/HasOfSplit.lean:11--30; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/CuspidalDescent/DescWeak.lean:10--21.
Remark 4.44 (Downstream wiring into patching, DescOffT, and multiplicity one). Theorem 4.43 feeds di-rectly into three downstream boundaries of the manuscript:
(1) Threshold patching package: v_window_of_automorphy_csd_ss_mono_odd passes UpperTheory.V.Z.Tf.SR.descWeak as the descU field of published_hypotheses_from_patching_alt, supplying weak descent to HypothesesH' for the counts in Section 4.
(2) Full geometric base-change descent (DescOffT): UpperTheory.Gal.Desc.weakAll invokes weakAll_of on the identical four producers (splitRigid, partNorm absInf, unitOf, runTh), which match_of and desc_of upgrade via Speh base change (BcSpeh), len_one, and splitRigid to full split and archimedean matching in Proposition 7.110(b) (Subsection 7.15).
(3) Unitary multiplicity one: noData_free and compOf_free use has_of_split, match_of, splitRigid, thin, and unitOf to eliminate spurious isobaric counterexamples in the multiplicity-one trace comparison on definite unitary groups.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/WindowBoundOfLiteratureLevel.lean:30--34; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ThresholdArguments/DenseThresholdCases/PublishedHypothesesFromPatching.lean:98--103; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/GaloisRepresentations/BaseChangeDescent/Strong.lean:18--33,54--139; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Foundations/GaloisRepresentations/BaseChangeDescent/BcBackOffT.lean:24--31; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/MultiplicityOne/CompOfFree.lean:9--19.