Section 15 · PDF pages 842–846
Vanishing and the isolated non-klt divisor
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
15 Vanishing and the isolated non-klt divisor
The two vanishing fields in the geometric input have different quantifiers. The field q6 concerns smooth projective varieties over every algebraically closed field of characteristic zero. The field q15 has two parts, both over ℂ, and permits a normal singular variety. We check both parts before deriving the smooth van-ishing statement. This also identifies the numerical equivalence, rational denominators and discrepancy conventions used in the geometric construction.
Lemma 15.1 (The divisor and discrepancy conventions). Let X be a normal integral projective variety over ℂ, of dimension n, and let ∆ be the source’s effective rational Weil divisor. The source’s IsLogCanonicalMultiple for a positive integer m and a Cartier divisor G means that, for a nonzero rational top form η,
G = m(K_{η} + ∆). (VN.1)
Its KltAt and LcAt use, respectively, discrepancies strictly greater than −1 and at least −1, for every divi-sorial valuation whose centre contains the point in question. If KltAt holds everywhere, then K_{X} + ∆ is ℚ-Cartier, as required in the usual definition of a klt pair.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/PublishedTheorems/Divisors2/IsLogCanonicalMultipleCanonical.lean:23--56,305--328.
Proof. The finite support and codimension-one support in IsEffQDiv make ∆ a rational Weil divisor. At a codimension-one point z, the local ring is a discrete valuation ring. The equality IsLogEqn says
m{ord_{z}(η) + ∆_{z}} = ord_{z}(g)
for a local equation g of G. These are exactly the coefficients of (VN.1). Normality identifies a Weil divisor with these coefficients. The integer formOrd is the order of η relative to a generator of top differentials at the divisorial valuation ring. Consequently the source expression
a_{E} = ord_{E}(η) − ord_{E}(g)/m
is the coefficient of K_{Y} −f^{∗}(K_{X} + ∆) on a model carrying E. The valuation ring in DivOver is discrete, contains the constant field and is essentially of finite type over it; these are the divisorial valuations used in this discrepancy test. The condition Through x says that the valuation ring contains 𝒪_{X,x}, so its centre is a generalization of x. This gives precisely the local discrepancy test, including divisors already on X.
For the last assertion, the local witness in KltAt supplies a positive m and a rational function g with the stated coefficient identity at every codimension-one generalization of x. Choose a fixed rational top form. Changing from the local witness to this form changes the corresponding canonical divisor by a principal divisor. After this change, the difference between m(K_{X} + ∆) and div(g) has finite support and no com-ponent containing x. Remove those components. On the resulting neighborhood of x the difference is zero, so m(K_{X} + ∆) is principal there. A finite such cover exists because X is projective. Taking a common multiple of its positive denominators proves that K_{X} + ∆ is ℚ-Cartier. Thus the pointwise source condition does not omit the ℚ-Cartier hypothesis of the classical theorem.
Proposition 15.2 (The normal-pair Nadel input). The complete source statement NadelVanishingPair holds. Explicitly, let X, ∆ be as above, let N, M_{0} be line bundles, and let m, r be positive integers. Suppose G satisfies (VN.1), M_{0} is nef and big, and, for every integral complete curve C,
_{C} deg_{C} 𝒪_{X}(G) deg_{C} M_{0} deg N = + . (VN.2)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m r
There is a coherent ideal J ⊆𝒪_{X} with
Supp(𝒪_{X}/J) = {x : (X, ∆) is not klt at x}, H^{i}(X, N ⊗J) = 0 (i > 0). (VN.3)
All points, curves and positive cohomological degrees in this statement retain their source quantifiers.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/PublishedTheorems/Divisors2/IsLogCanonicalMultipleCanonical.lean:545--555; Development/WeilBound/CoreStatements/PublishedTheorems/NadelVanishingPairs/NadelVanishingLemmas/NadelVanishingPairsOfPrincipalisation.lean:16--63.
Proof. Use the normal-pair vanishing theorem in [51, Theorem 2.16, p. 13]. Its hypotheses use numerical equivalence, and its conclusions are the ideal cosupport and all positive-degree vanishings in (VN.3). Here the required numerical relation is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1
N ≡K_{X} + ∆+ M_{0}. (VN.4)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
r
Indeed, (VN.1) identifies K_{X} + ∆ with G/m, and (VN.2) tests exactly (VN.4) on all integral complete curves. The rational Cartier divisor M_{0}/r is nef and big because r > 0. Projectivity implies properness, and normality and effectivity are hypotheses. Thus every hypothesis of that theorem is satisfied; smoothness of X and a klt assumption on the initial pair are not required.
For clarity, the numerical adapter actually used in the source is the line bundle
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
T = N^{⊗mr}⊗𝒪_{X}(−rG) ⊗M_{0}^{⊗(−m)}.For every complete curve C, multiplication of (VN.2) by mr gives deg_{C} T = 0. Hence T is nef, and its Picard class is mr[N] −r[𝒪_{X}(G)] −m[M_{0}]. These are exactly the additional arguments supplied to the native nadelVanishing theorem. In particular, the argument requires no unwarranted equality in the Picard group in place of the given numerical equality.
There is also no discrepancy-convention change in passing to the ideal of the classical theorem. On a log resolution f : Y →X, write K_{Y} −f^{∗}(K_{X} + ∆) =∑_{E}a_{E}E. Its ideal is f_{∗}𝒪_{Y} (∑_{E}⌈a_{E}⌉E). A regular function u belongs precisely when ord_{E}(u)+a_{E} > −1 for the relevant divisors. Since ord_{E}(u) is an integer, this is equivalent to ord_{E}(u) + ⌈a_{E}⌉≥0. It is the source’s multiplier-ideal inequality. The source’s ideal support denotes the support of the quotient 𝒪_{X}/J, so it is exactly the cosupport in (VN.3).
Proposition 15.3 (The isolated non-klt divisor with the exact class). The complete source statement IsolatedNonKltDivisor holds. Let (X, ∆) be a projective klt pair over ℂ, with n = dim X ≥1, and let x be a closed point. Let N_{0} be a nef and big line bundle and r > 0 an integer. Suppose c(1), . . . , c(n) > 0 satisfy
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(N_{0})^{e} ∑^{n} e· Z > c(e)^{e} for every integral Z ∋x, dim Z = e ≥1, ≤1. (VN.5)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
r_{e=1}c(e)There exist a positive integer m, an effective Cartier divisor D_{0}, and an open neighborhood U of x such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
D_{0} N_{0}≡ , (U, ∆+ D_{0}/m) is lc, (U \ {x}, ∆+ D_{0}/m) is klt, (VN.6)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m r
and (X, ∆+ D_{0}/m) is not klt at x.
Source: \leanpath {Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/PublishedTheorems/Divisors2/IsLogCanonicalMultipleCanonical.lean},557--574; \leanpath {Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/IsolatedNonKltDivisorOfPrincipalisation.lean},17--26.
Proof. Set A = N_{0}/r in [51, Theorem 6.4, p. 35]. It supplies an effective rational divisor D ≡ A, with exactly the three asserted singularity properties. Lemma 15.1 checks the pair convention. The intersection adapter is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{N}e_{· Z}
A^{e}· Z =^{0}_{re} .The source uses the reduced intersection number on the irreducible closed subset Z, which is this intersection number on its reduced integral subvariety. Thus its hypothesis over every such closed subset is the hypothesis over every Z in (VN.5). Only 1 ≤e ≤n occur; the source’s positivity assumptions therefore supply every c(e) needed by the theorem. The sum bound is unchanged, including its permitted equality case.
The source requests D_{0}/m with D_{0} Cartier, rather than only a rational Weil divisor. The construction in the cited theorem has this property. Its reduction to an ample class writes A = A^{′}+ F, where F is an effective rational Cartier divisor and A^{′} is ample. The singular-divisor, centre-cutting and tie-breaking steps use members of |sH|, with sH Cartier, and rational coefficients; see its proof, §§6.6–6.10, pp. 35–39. The resulting D is consequently a finite rational linear combination of Cartier divisors, hence is ℚ-Cartier. Choose a positive common denominator m for these finitely many terms and put D_{0} = mD. This is Cartier. It is effective because D is effective. On a normal variety this last assertion also agrees with the effective-Cartier convention: a Cartier local equation with nonnegative orders at every codimension-one point belongs to the normal local ring, and is a non-zero-divisor.
Now D_{0}/m = D as rational Weil divisors, so the pair itself, the open neighborhood and all its lc and klt assertions are unchanged. Numerical equivalence D ≡N_{0}/r gives, on every complete integral curve C,
deg_{C} 𝒪_{X}(D_{0})_{=} deg_{C} N_{0}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m r^{,}which is the source’s full curve conclusion. Its function qWeil D0 m is the coefficient function of D_{0}/m, so the final pointwise statements are precisely (VN.6).
The native producer implements the same centre-cutting result: its Angehrn–Siu induction is specialized at terminal dimension 0, forcing the residual centre dimension to be 0; the sum bound in (VN.5) then supplies the isolated lc centre. The primary theorem is the isolated-divisor result itself, so no inference from a mere global-generation theorem is being used here. Combining this proposition with Proposition 15.2 proves both conjuncts of NadelVanishingAndNonKltDivisor, the field q15.
Proposition 15.4 (Kawamata–Viehweg over the source’s full base field). Let k be any algebraically closed field of characteristic zero. Let X be an integral smooth projective k-variety of pure dimension d, let K represent its canonical line bundle, and let N be a nef and big line bundle. Then
H^{q}(X, K ⊗N) = 0 (q > 0). (VN.7)
This proves KawamataViehweg, the field q6, including its structure-morphism and Picard-class transport rules.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/PublishedTheorems/Divisors2/KawamataViehweg.lean:16--41; De-velopment/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/KawamataViehwegVanishingOfNadelPairs.lean:37--49; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/KawamataViehwegOfNadelVanishingPair.lean:24--67.
Proof. First suppose k = ℂ. In Proposition 15.2 take the boundary to be zero, m = r = 1, G = K_{X}, M_{0} = N, and take its line bundle called N there to be K ⊗N here. Tensor-product additivity of degrees verifies (VN.2). The smooth pair (X, 0) is klt at every point, so the ideal J has empty cosupport. Thus 𝒪_{X}/J = 0, J = 𝒪_{X}, and (VN.3) becomes (VN.7). This is also the empty-boundary specialization of [51,
Theorem 2.3, p. 6].
For a general k we follow the source’s descent argument. Choose a finitely generated subfield F ⊆k over which the finite projective equations for X, the gluing maps for N and their inverse transition functions are defined. Enlarge F if needed for these finitely many relations. Let k_{1} be the algebraic closure of F inside k, and let (X_{1}, N_{1}) be the corresponding base change to k_{1}. Then k_{1} is countable and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(X, N) ≃(X_{1}, N_{1}) ×_{k1} k.Projectivity descends with the chosen projective model. Smoothness descends along the faithfully flat field extension. Geometric connectedness descends as well, since it holds for the integral proper variety over the algebraically closed field k. After base change to the algebraically closed k_{1}, smoothness and connectedness
imply integrality: distinct irreducible components of a regular scheme are disjoint open and closed subsets. The relative dimension remains d. These are the smoothness and geometric-connectedness fields used for the countable model in the native argument.
The positivity hypotheses also descend. For every integral curve on X_{1}, degree after field extension is the same degree, so nefness of N gives nefness of N_{1}. For each integer a ≥0, coherent cohomology under extension of the ground field gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
H^{0}(X_{1}, N_{1}^{⊗a}) ⊗_{k1}k ≃H^{0}(X, N^{ ⊗a}).Thus the dimensions of all these spaces are unchanged. The source’s section-growth definition of bigness therefore gives bigness of N_{1}, with the same dimension d.
There is an embedding k_{1} ↪→ ℂ: embed a finite transcendence basis of F/ℚ into an algebraically independent tuple in ℂ, and extend over its algebraic closure. Form X_{ℂ} = X_{1} ×_{k1} ℂ and N_{ℂ}. Bigness again follows from the displayed equality of dimensions. Nefness is preserved by field extension. Here is the numerical reason for this direction as well: an integral curve over the extension is defined over a finitely generated intermediate k_{1}-algebra; after shrinking its parameter scheme it is a flat projective family of curves. It has a closed k_{1}-point because k_{1} is algebraically closed. Degree of the restricted line bundle is constant in this family, and its special-fibre components have nonnegative degree by nefness on X_{1}. Hence the original curve has nonnegative degree. This checks the field-extension invariance of the nef condition used in the source.
The complex case gives vanishing on X_{ℂ}. The canonical bundle commutes with these field extensions, because for a smooth variety it is the determinant of the relative cotangent bundle. Coherent cohomology under field extension therefore gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
H^{q}(X_{1}, ω_{X1/k1} ⊗N_{1}) ⊗_{k1} ℂ = 0.Tensoring a vector space with the field ℂ is faithful, so the cohomology group over k_{1} is zero. Tensoring instead with k proves (VN.7). The cohomological base-change assertion used here can be seen directly on a finite affine cover of the projective, separated scheme: its finite intersections are affine, the Cech complex computes coherent cohomology, and a flat field tensor product commutes with its kernels and quotients.
Finally the source’s CanonLB is an identified representative of ω_{X/k}, so replacing that representative transports cohomology by an isomorphism. The rule of_hom identifies the prescribed scalar action on global functions with the structure morphism. The rule twist assumes equality of Picard classes [M] = [K] + [N], obtains an isomorphism M ≃K ⊗N, and transports (VN.7) along it. These steps add no cohomological or positivity hypothesis.