Section 15.3.4 · PDF pages 922–933
Normalized local class and harmonic valuation estimates
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
15.3.4 Normalized local class and harmonic valuation estimates
We now prove the uniform harmonic valuation lower bound chBound_host across all finite places of the host field, the ℓ-primary isotropic class-sum estimate ell_part and its translated-product companion bound_of_trivAt assembled in class_bound, and the resulting unconditional verification of inequality (SS.5) and exists_smul_short_nonneg.
Lemma 15.73 (Host-field Galois, discriminant, conjugation, and vdH bounds). Let D : D7 and let H : Host D.host.E be a host datum for the CM field E := D.host.E, with conductor N_{host} := D.host.condN and normalized discriminant ramification function
v_{p}(| disc E|) vdH(p) := (p ∈ℕ).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
[E : ℚ]
(a) (hostField_galois_degree_discr_conj_moves_primes) E/ℚ is Galois of degree [E : ℚ] = 4 D.R.ord;
every rational prime p | disc E divides N_{host}; and for every prime p | N_{host} and every prime ideal 𝔭 ⊂𝒪_{E} with p ∈𝔭, there exists x ∈𝔭 such that H.bar(x) /∈𝔭.
(b) (vdH_le_natAbs) For every p ∈ℕ, 0 ≤ vdH(p) ≤| disc E|.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HostFieldGaloisDegreeDiscrConjMovesPrimes.lean:18--56; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HostFieldGaloisDegreeDiscrConjMovesPrimesStatement.lean:12--13; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/PrimeDiscriminants/SlopeTestRemainingChoices.lean:28--33; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/CyclotomicBounds/RamifiedDiscriminants/VdHLeNatAbs.lean:4--11.
Proof. For (a), the Galois property, [E : ℚ] = 4 D.R.ord, and the divisibility of N_{host} by every prime divisor of disc E are directly supplied by the host-field construction (D.host.galois, D.host.der.finrank_{E}, and D.host.der.discr_{p}rimes.1). Evaluating at any complex embedding φ : E ↪→ℂ identifies H.bar(x) = D.host.conj · x for every x ∈𝒪_{E} (host_bar_eq_smul), and H.bar is an involution. Let p | N_{host} be prime and let 𝔭 ⊂𝒪_{E} be a prime ideal containing p. Since (p) ⊂ℤ is maximal and (p) ⊆𝔭 ∩ℤ ⊊ℤ, 𝔭 lies over (p). If H.bar(x) ∈𝔭 held for all x ∈𝔭, then involutivity of H.bar would give D.host.conj · 𝔭 = 𝔭, placing D.host.conj in the decomposition group of 𝔭 and contradicting D.host.der.decompConj.
For (b), nonnegativity is immediate from the definition. Since [E : ℚ] ≥1 and v_{p}(m) ≤⌊log_{p} m⌋≤m for every m ∈ℕ (with v_{p}(m) = 0 when p ≤1 or m = 0), dividing v_{p}(| disc E|) ≤| disc E| by [E : ℚ] ≥1 gives vdH(p) ≤| disc E|.
Proposition 15.74 (Integral harmonic values when the discriminant is a unit). Assume ⋆= H.bar on 𝒪_{E}. Let T : CDVR, io : c.F →T.Fr, y : IntFr Xo c T io, and C : IntegralChartA3 Xo c T io y. If the field discriminant disc E is a unit in T.V , then for every e, n ∈ℕ and every weight w,
ChBound C e 0 w n.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueBoundOfColumnProducts.lean:18--23; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/JetHarmonics/TotalDegreeLeOfMemFFV.lean:24--122; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/IntegralChartFormalBiextensionGaugeBound.lean:19--108; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/BiextCoeffSecondLinear.lean:154--239; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/EigenLiftsOfDirectionsBiext.lean:56--74; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/ChartValJ.lean:31--162; Reciprocity
Theory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/TaylorDiscriminants/WickVanishing/Closed.lean:22--63; Reci-procityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/TaylorDiscriminants/WickVanishing/SCMain.lean:28--84; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueIntegralOfUnitDiscriminant.lean:27--234; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueIntegralOfUnitDiscriminantStatement.lean:13--14.
Proof. We first reduce ChBound to products of 1-variable integral series (chBound_of_columns, bound_all_iff_bound_prod). By definition, ChBound C e ρ w n asserts that for every level k ∈ ℕ, every P ∈ FFV T w n, and every n-variable integral power series f ∈ PS(T.Fr, n, d) with coefficients in T.V , ν_{e}(chartVal C k f P) ≥−ρ. Because the differential operator chartVal C k (·) P depends only on a finite jet of degree deg P (nabJet), f can be replaced by a finite T.V -linear combination of monomials, each of which factors as a box product of 1-variable integral series f_{b} (b ∈ Fin n); by the nonarchimedean triangle inequality (le_nval_int_comb) and chartVal_boxSer, it suffices to bound the column-product sum
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∏n ( )
Σ(P, f) := P_{m} B.nabVal_{T.Fr} h, H.w_{0}, k, f_{b}, u, X^{colb(m)}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m∈supp(P) b=1
for f_{b} integral over T.V , where B is the integral formal biextension over T.V associated to C with canonical gauge h = gaugeOf C (h(0, 0) = 0) and integral chart directions u_{ℓ}∈(T.V )^{d} satisfying the eigen-equation (dAct_{T.Fr}(B, a))u_{ℓ} = σ_{ℓ.1}(a) u_{ℓ} with σ_{τ} := io ∘ embK c τ (integralBiext_gauge_eig_bound). Note that σ_{τ̄}(a) = σ_{τ}(⋆a) and distinct embeddings τ ̸= τ^{′} differ on some a ∈𝒪_{E}.
Split into two cases according to isRQ_or_rat:
(i) Residue characteristic zero (ℚ ↪→T.V ). Because T.V is a ℚ-algebra, B admits a canonical gauge h_{0} already defined over T.V (canonGauge_exists), whose base change to T.Fr is a canonical gauge computing the same T.V -integral column values (canonGauge_nabVal_baseChange). Since P is harmonic, canonical-gauge independence on harmonic polynomials (canonGauge_independence_harmonic) equates Σ(P, f) computed in gauge h with the same sum computed in gauge h_{0}, which lies in T.V ⊂T.Fr term by term (value_mem_rat).
(ii) Mixed characteristic (T.Fr = T.V [N^{−1}] for some nonunit N ∈ℕ_{>0}, i.e., TB.IsRQ). Write ϖ for a uni-
formizer of T.V ; since N is a nonunit, ϖ | N, so every s ∈T.V \{0} divides a power of N, giving TB.IsRQ. Because disc E ∈T.V^{×}, | disc E| is invertible in T.V . Using an integral basis of 𝒪_{E} and its trace-dual basis (scaled by | disc E| ∈T.V^{×}), EigA.idem_data produces for each embedding τ a finite family (b_{i}, c_{i}) ∈𝒪_{E} × T.V with ∑_{i}c_{i}σ_{τ}(b_{i}) = 1 and integral representation matrices ab_{i} = ∑_{j}m_{ij}b_{j} sat-isfying ∑_{i}m_{ij}c_{i} = σ_{τ}(a)c_{j}. Starting from ξ_{0,ℓ}:= (u_{ℓ}, −sg_{1}(h)u_{ℓ}) in the 𝒪_{E}-stable integral gauge space Hset (gauge_stable) and applying the idempotent operator ∑_{i}c_{i} OactH_{B}(b_{i}) produces integral vectors φ_{ℓ}∈(T.V )^{d} such that ξ_{1,ℓ}= (u_{ℓ}, φ_{ℓ}−sg_{1}(h)u_{ℓ}) ∈ Hset is a σ_{ℓ.1}-eigenvector; sesquilinearity of the symplectic form betaH then forces cross-type orthogonality ∑_{i}(φ_{ℓ}′_{,i} −(sg_{1}(h)u_{ℓ}′)_{i})u_{ℓ,i} = 0 whenever ℓ^{′}.1 ̸= ℓ.1 (EigA.eigLift_core).
Partition the embeddings into conjugate pairs (c(τ), s(τ)) using the CM type InPsi H (s(τ) = 1_{τ∈Ψ}). Harmonicity of P implies that the second-order contraction operator annihilates P (harmSecond_holds), so lemma_H_columns rewrites Σ(P, f) as a sum of ordered covariant derivatives ordNabla. Applying scaled_connection_columns (SCPf.sc_of, with ψ = 0 and J = T.V · 1) places Σ(P, f) in J^{e}= T.V (value_mem_idem).
In both cases Σ(P, f) ∈T.V , so ν_{e}(Σ(P, f)) ≥0.
Proposition 15.75 (Ramified eigenlifts and harmonic valuation loss). Assume ⋆= H.bar on 𝒪_{E}. Let T : CDVR, io : c.F →T.Fr, y : IntFr Xo c T io, and C : IntegralChartA3 Xo c T io y. Assume that E/ℚ is Galois, p is a rational prime with p /∈T.V^{×}, | disc E| = p^{a}m with p ∤m, and for every prime ideal 𝔭 ⊂𝒪_{E} with p ∈𝔭 there exists x ∈𝔭 with H.bar(x) /∈𝔭. Then for every e > 0, every weight w, and every n ∈ℕ,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
)
v_{T.V} (p) a DF(Dw, w) ChBound C e · · w n.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
e [E : ℚ] 2
Source: ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/PadicValNatAbsNormEqZero.lean:15--268; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsRingOfIntegersLift.lean:12--151; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/EigRamData.lean:14--150; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/EigRamCore.lean:15--235; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/EigRamLift.lean:15--233; ReciprocityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/ChartValJ.lean:31--162; Reci-procityTheory/ReductiveGroups/ArithmeticGeometry/PullbackSections/HolomorphicFamilies/ChartValueRamifiedOfLifts.lean:18--127; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsRamifiedEigenLiftsOfChartDirections.lean:19--300; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsRamifiedEigenLiftsOfChartDirectionsStatement.lean:13--14; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueBoundIntegralChartRamified.lean:19--90; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueBoundIntegralChartRamifiedStatement.lean:13--14.
Proof. Set c_{J} :=^{vT.V}_{e}^{ (p)} ·_{[E}^{a}_{:ℚ]} ≥ 0. Since p /∈ T.V^{ ×} is nonzero, T.Fr = T.V [p^{−1}] (isRQ_of_not_isUnit). As in Proposition 15.74, chBound_of_columns and integralBiext_gauge_eig_bound reduce the claim to bounding the column-product sum Σ(P, f) for P ∈ FFV T w n and integral 1-variable series f_{b}.
Step 1 (Galois different exponent and local denominators δ_{τ}). Let 𝔇 := 𝔇_{E/ℚ} ⊂𝒪_{E} be the different ideal; its absolute norm is | disc E| = p^{a}m. Because E/ℚ is Galois, Gal(E/ℚ) preserves both 𝔇 and (p) (smul_differentIdeal, smul_span_nat) and acts transitively on the set S_{p} of prime ideals of 𝒪_{E} above p. Evaluating v_{p}(Nm(·)) by summing over S_{p} (padicValNat_absNorm_eq_sum) gives, for any 𝔓 ∈S_{p},
a = v_{p}(Nm(𝔇)) = |S_{p}| · v_{𝔓}(𝔇) v_{p}(Nm(𝔓)), [E : ℚ] = v_{p}(Nm((p))) = |S_{p}| · v_{𝔓}(p) v_{p}(Nm(𝔓)),
whence v_{𝔓}(𝔇) [E : ℚ] = a v_{𝔓}(p) (diffExp).
For each embedding τ : E ↪→ℂ, put ψ_{τ} := io ∘ embF c τ : E →T.Fr. Because T.V is integrally closed, ψ_{τ}(𝒪_{E}) ⊆ T.V , defining a ring homomorphism σ_{τ} : 𝒪_{E} → T.V (exists_ringOfIntegers_lift) and a nonzero prime ideal 𝔓_{τ} := σ_{τ}^{−1}(𝔪_{T.V}) ∈S_{p}. Factor 𝔇 = 𝔓^{d}_{τ}^{τ}𝔔 with 𝔓_{τ} ∤𝔔; then σ_{τ}(𝔔)T.V = T.V , so σ_{τ}(𝔇)T.V = σ_{τ}(𝔓^{d}_{τ}^{τ})T.V . Choosing δ_{τ} ∈ 𝔇 minimizing the DVR valuation of σ_{τ}(δ_{τ}) generates
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d [E:ℚ]
σ_{τ}(𝔇)T.V , while (p) ⊆ 𝔓^{e}_{τ}^{τ} with e_{τ} = v_{𝔓τ} (p) gives p^{a} ∈ 𝔓^{ae}_{τ}^{τ} = 𝔓_{τ}^{τ}. Mapping via σ_{τ} yields σ_{τ}(δ_{τ})^{[E:ℚ]} | p^{a} in T.V (exists_delta). Consequently, any x ∈ T.Fr satisfying σ_{τ}(δ_{τ})x ∈ T.V obeys [E : ℚ] v_{T.V} (x) ≥−a v_{T.V} (p), hence ν_{e}(x) ≥−c_{J} (bound_of_den).
Step 2 (Integral place idempotents and ramified eigenlifts). For each prime 𝔓 ∈ S_{p}, we construct an integral place idempotent (b_{𝔓,i}, a_{𝔓,i}) ∈𝒪_{E} × T.V satisfying ∑_{i}a_{𝔓,i}ψ_{τ}(b_{𝔓,i}) = 1_{𝔓τ=𝔓} (placeIdem). Pick c_{τ} /∈𝔓 with c_{τ} ∈𝔓_{τ} whenever 𝔓_{τ} ̸= 𝔓, invert ∏_{τ}c_{τ} mod 𝔓 to form b := y ∏_{τ}c_{τ} ∈𝒪_{E} with σ_{τ}(b) ≡1 (mod 𝔪_{T.V} ) if 𝔓_{τ} = 𝔓 and σ_{τ}(b) ∈𝔪_{T.V} otherwise. Then the polynomials p_{0}(X) :=∏_{𝔓τ̸=𝔓}(X −σ_{τ}(b)) and p_{1}(X) :=∏_{𝔓τ=𝔓}(X −σ_{τ}(b)) in T.V [X] are coprime (every difference σ_{τ}(b) −σ_{φ}(b) across the two sets is congruent to −1 mod 𝔪_{T.V} , hence a unit in T.V ). Choosing u, v ∈T.V [X] with up_{0} + vp_{1} = 1, the polynomial g := up_{0} ∈T.V [X] satisfies g(σ_{τ}(b)) = 1_{𝔓τ=𝔓}, giving the desired expansion in powers of b.
By the prime-movement hypothesis on H.bar, 𝔓_{τ} := 𝔓_{τ̄} ̸= 𝔓_{τ} for every τ. Choosing any linear order on the finite set of prime ideals yields a pairing map c(τ) := {τ^{′} : 𝔓_{τ} ′ ∈{𝔓_{τ}, 𝔓_{τ}}} and a sign
s(τ) := 1_{𝔓τ<𝔓τ} such that c(̄τ) = c(τ) and s(̄τ) ̸= s(τ) (exists_pairs_sides). Now apply ERam.eigLiftRam_core to the initial integral vectors ξ_{0,ℓ}:= (u_{ℓ}, −sg_{1}(h)u_{ℓ}) ∈ Hset:
• Applying the integral place idempotent at 𝔓_{ℓ.1} preserves Hset (actP_mem) and fixes the first coordinate u_{ℓ}, producing an integral lift φ_{ℓ}∈(T.V )^{d} such that ξ_{h,ℓ}:= (u_{ℓ}, φ_{ℓ}− sg_{1}(h)u_{ℓ}) ∈ Hset.
• Fix a ℤ-basis {ω_{i}} of 𝒪_{E} with trace-dual basis {ω_{i}^{∗}} ⊂ E. Because δ_{τ} ∈ 𝔇, each δ_{τ}ω_{i}^{∗} lies in 𝒪_{E} (isIntegral_mul_dual). Defining b_{E,τ,i} := δ_{τ}ω_{i}^{∗} ∈𝒪_{E} and c_{E,τ,i} := ψ_{τ}(ω_{i})/ψ_{τ}(δ_{τ}) ∈ T.Fr gives an equivariant σ_{τ}-projector (eqv_D, ev_D) with σ_{τ}(δ_{τ})c_{E,τ,i} = σ_{τ}(ω_{i}) ∈ T.V . Applying this projector to ξ_{h,ℓ} yields the exact σ_{ℓ.1}-eigenvector ξ_{ℓ}= ξ_{h,ℓ}+ (0, ψ_{ℓ}) with σ_{ℓ.1}(δ_{ℓ.1})ψ_{ℓ,i} ∈T.V (hset_snd_int), hence ν_{e}(ψ_{ℓ,i}) ≥−c_{J} by Step 1.
• Because | disc E| ∈𝔇, the corresponding global trace-dual projectors sum to the identity on both dActH and dActS (comp_D). Since the place idempotent at 𝔓_{τ} is supported on embeddings inducing 𝔓_{τ} and conju-gation sends 𝔓_{τ} to 𝔓_{τ} with opposite sign s, beta_vanish establishes OppositePairVanishing for (ξ_{h}, ξ_{h}), ((0, ψ), ξ_{h}), and (ξ_{h}, (0, ψ)), while eigen_orthogonality gives cross-type orthogonality for ξ_{ℓ} (exists_ramified_eigenLifts).
Step 3 (Wick contraction and pair-minimum estimate). Consider the T.V -submodule J_{v}(c_{J}) := {x ∈ T.Fr : ν_{e}(x) ≥−c_{J}} of T.Fr (Jv); since c_{J} ≥0, 1 ∈J_{v}(c_{J}) (one_mem_Jv), and by induction on m every x ∈J_{v}(c_{J})^{m} satisfies ν_{e}(x) ≥−m c_{J} (mem_Jv_pow). For any monomial m ∈ supp(P) of P ∈ FFV T w n, the row-degree condition ∑^{n}_{b=1}m(τ, i, b) = w(τ, i) implies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n ( ) ∑n ∑ ∑
2 pairMin c, s, col_{b}(m) ≤ col_{b}(m)(ℓ) = w(τ, i) = DF(Dw, w), (391)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
b=1 b=1 ℓ τ,i
because∑ 2 min(A_{q}, B_{q}) ≤ A_{q} + B_{q} at each pair class q (two_pairMin_le, sum_pairMin_le). Thus
_{b} pairMin(c, s, col_{b}(m)) ≤M_{w} := ⌊DF(Dw, w)/2⌋. Applying chartValJ (which combines harmSecond_holds, lemma_H_columns, and scaled_connection_columns via the Wick expansion ordNabla_wick and divided-power integrality divided_power_integrality: each contraction between ξ_{h} and (0, ψ) contributes one factor in J_{v}(c_{J}), and contractions of order exceeding pairMin vanish) shows Σ(P, f) ∈ J_{v}(c_{J})^{Mw}. Therefore
DF(Dw, w) v_{T.V} (p) a DF(Dw, w)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{e}(Σ(P, f)) ≥−M_{w} c_{J} ≥−_{2} c_{J} = −_{e} ·_{[E : ℚ]}·_{2} ,proving chBound_ramified.
Theorem 15.76 (Uniform host-field harmonic lower bound at all finite places). Let D : D7, H : Host D.host.E, Dw : Datum H, l : Level H, Xo : Moduli Dw l, c : Coeff l, with ⋆= H.bar on 𝒪_{E}. Let T : CDVR, io : c.F →T.Fr, y : IntFr Xo c T io, C : IntegralChartA3 Xo c T io y, e > 0, w a weight, n ∈ℕ, and DF_{w} ∈ℕ with DF(Dw, w) ≤DF_{w}. Then (GlobalTheory.PlaceInt.HostChart.chBound_host)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ v_{T.V} (p) )ChBound C e vdH(p)^{DFw} w n. (392)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p|D.host.condN^{e2}Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValuationLowerBoundHostFieldAllPlaces.lean:19--71.
Proof. Every summand in (392) is nonnegative because v_{T.V} (p) ≥0 (vV_nat_nonneg) and vdH(p) ≥0. Let N := D.host.condN. host
• If every prime p | N_{host} is a unit in T.V , then by Lemma 15.73(a) every prime factor of | disc E| is a unit in T.V , so disc E ∈T.V^{×}. Proposition 15.74 gives ChBound C e 0 w n, and monotonicity in the bound parameter (chBound_mono) yields (392).
• Otherwise, choose a prime p | N_{host} with p /∈T.V^{×}, and factor | disc E| = p^{a}m with a := v_{p}(| disc E|) and p ∤ m. By Lemma 15.73(a), E/ℚ is Galois and H.bar moves every prime ideal of 𝒪_{E} above p. v (p) DF(Dw,w)
Proposition 15.75 therefore supplies ChBound C e (^{T.V}_{e} vdH(p)_{2} ) w n. Since DF(Dw, w) ≤ DF_{w} and all terms in the sum are nonnegative, chBound_mono upgrades this single-p bound to (392).
We next build the adapted similitude machinery and formal-kernel trace formula needed for the ℓ-primary isotropic sum bound ell_part.
Lemma 15.77 (Adapted similitude data, primary kernels, and lattice indices at ℓ). Let Λ : GenLat E n satisfy Λ.Unimod and Λ.LevOK N M, and let ℓ be a rational prime.
(a) (exists_adapted_similitude_data_at_prime) There exists A : Adapt Λ N ℓ consisting of odd positive
integers k, k_{1} coprime to ℓ, a unitary matrix γ ∈M_{n}(E) (γ̄^{T}γ = I_{n}), and integral matrices p, q, g ∈ M_{n}(𝒪_{E}) such that kγ(Λ.La) ⊆𝒪_{E}^{n}, k𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆ γ(Λ.La), g(𝒪_{E}^{n}) ⊆ Λ.Ln, k_{1}Λ.Ln ⊆ g(𝒪_{E}^{n}), gq = (k_{1}N)I_{n}, pq = (kN)γ, and IsSim H (pq) ((kN)^{2}) (that is, pq^{T}(pq) = (kN)^{2}I_{n}).
(b) (inZh_iff_kills_adapted) Over any Xo.X-scheme T, an ℓ-primary n-tuple u : Fin n → (T →
Xo.univ.t.G) satisfies
InZh Xo Λ N u ⇐⇒ Kills Xo (A.p · A.q) u ⇐⇒ InZh Xo Λ (A.k N) u.
(c) (map_pushL_mem_FFV) For any P ∈ harmL c Λ w, any T : CDVR with ℓ∈/T.V^{×}, and any io : c.F →T.Fr,
MvPolynomial.map(io)(pushL c A.γ P) ∈ FFV T w n, pushL c I_{n} P = P, and pushL c ((m · A.γ)) P = m^{deg P}pushL c A.γ P for every m ∈ℕ.
(d) (latidx, card_primaryTorsionTuples_killed_by_matrix) Set r := Dw.p+Dw.q. Then Λ.mIdx(N, r) ̸=
0 and ( ( ) v_{ℓ} | Nm_{𝒪E/ℤ}(det A.q)|^{r})= v_{ℓ} Λ.mIdx(N, r) .
Moreover, for any field K and point x : Spec K →Xo.X satisfying AllRat Xo x (N^{2}),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||
||{u : Fin n →(ptO Xo x →Xo.univ.t.G) : Kills Xo A.q u and u is ℓ-primary} = ℓ^{vℓ(Λ.mIdx(N,r))}.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsUnitaryOfSelfDual.lean:20--163; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/IsPrincipalIdealRingLoc.lean:11--187; Devel-opment/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsAdaptedSimilitudeDataAtPrime.lean:34--106; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsAdaptedSimilitudeDataAtPrimeStatement.lean:11--12; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/InZhIffKillsAdapted.lean:19--232; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/MemRangeOfIsIntegral.lean:21--123; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/IndexRangeMatrix.lean:9--195, 410--415; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/CardPrimaryTorsionTuplesKilledByMatrix.lean:11--240; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/CardPrimaryTorsionTuplesKilledByMatrixStatement.lean:11--12.
Proof. For (a), because E/E^{+} is unramified and Λ.La is self-dual for the standard Hermitian form, local orthonormal frames at all places dividing 2ℓ can be approximated by a global unitary matrix γ ∈M_{n}(E) (ex-ists_unitary_of_selfDual); uniform clearing of denominators on finitely many generators gives k_{2} coprime to 2ℓ with k_{2}γ(Λ.La) ⊆𝒪_{E}^{n} and k_{2}𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆ γ(Λ.La) (exists_unitary_adapted). Independently, localizing
𝒪_{E} at integers coprime to 2ℓ gives a Dedekind domain with finitely many prime ideals, hence a PID (isPrincipalIdealRing_loc), so the lattice Λ.Ln = Λ.La ∩𝒪_{E}^{n} admits g ∈M_{n}(𝒪_{E}) and k_{1} coprime to 2ℓ with g(𝒪_{E}^{n}) ⊆Λ.Ln and k_{1}Λ.Ln ⊆g(𝒪_{E}^{n}) (LocBasis.exists_matrix_primeTo). Since N𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆Λ.Ln, solving gq = (k_{1}N)I_{n} in M_{n}(𝒪_{E}) and setting p := k_{2}γg (integral since g(𝒪_{E}^{n}) ⊆Λ.La) gives k := k_{1}k_{2} coprime to 2ℓ, pq = (kN)γ, and pq^{T}(pq) = (kN)^{2}γ̄^{T}γ = (kN)^{2}I_{n}.
For (b), the 𝒪_{E}-action makes Hom_{Xo.X}(T, Xo.univ.t.G) an 𝒪_{E}-module on which any integer coprime to ℓ is invertible on ℓ-primary elements (Kl.cancel). If InZh Xo Λ (cN) u with gcd(c, ℓ) = 1, applying the defining InZh equation to µ = kγ gives Kills Xo (c · pq) u, and cancelling c yields Kills Xo (pq) u. Conversely, if Kills Xo (pq) u, multiplying on the left by pq^{T} gives (k^{2}N^{2})u = 0 (hence N^{2}u = 0 and (cN)^{2}u = 0), and for any µ with µ(Λ.La) ⊆𝒪_{E}^{n} and cm = (cN)µ ∈ M_{n}(𝒪_{E}), using k𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆ γ(Λ.La) constructs r ∈ M_{n}(𝒪_{E}) with r(pq) = k^{2}cm (exists_factor), so cancelling k^{2} yields Kills Xo cm u. Taking c = 1 and c = A.k gives both equivalences.
For (c), because γ is unitary, pushL c γ preserves harmonicity, row-invariance, and row-degree (push_mem_harmK, push_rows), which transfer along io. Since A.k is coprime to ℓ ∈/ T.V^{×}, A.k ∈ T.V^{×}. For every generator letB c σ i v (v ∈ Λ.La) of symO c Λ, pushL(c, γ, letB(v)) = letB(γv) has coefficients in A.k^{−1}𝒪_{E} ⊆ T.V , while 𝒪_{c.F} -constants map into T.V (coeff_mem); hence MvPolynomial.map(io)(pushL c γ P) ∈ FFV T w n. Homogeneity follows from the constant total degree of every monomial in P (degree_eq_totalDegree, aeval_smul_of_degree).
For (d), inside 𝒪_{E}^{n} consider the finite-index subgroups Y^{ ′} := gq(𝒪_{E}^{n}), X^{′} := N𝒪_{E}^{n}, Z^{′} := g(𝒪_{E}^{n}), and L^{′}:= Λ.Ln. Since Y^{′}⊆X^{′}⊆L^{′} and Y^{′}⊆Z^{′}⊆L^{′}, [L^{′}: X^{′}][X^{′}: Y^{′}] = [L^{′}: Z^{′}][Z^{′}: Y^{′}]. Both X^{′}/Y^{′} (as gq = k_{1}NI_{n}) and L^{′}/Z^{′} (as k_{1}Λ.Ln ⊆g(𝒪_{E}^{n})) are killed by k_{1}, which is coprime to ℓ, so ℓ divides neither [X^{′} : Y^{′}] nor [L^{′} : Z^{′}] (not_dvd_relIndex). Meanwhile [Z^{′} : Y^{′}] = [𝒪_{E}^{n} : q𝒪_{E}^{n}] = | Nm_{𝒪E/ℤ}(det q)| (index_range_matrix), proving v_{ℓ}(| Nm(det q)|^{r}) = v_{ℓ}([L^{′} : X^{′}]^{r}) = v_{ℓ}(Λ.mIdx(N, r)). Finally, under AllRat Xo x (N^{2}), Xo.univ yields an 𝒪_{E}-linear map ev : Dw.La → A(K) with kernel N^{2}Dw.La and image A(K)[N^{2}]. Using (Ng) · q = (k_{1}N^{2})I_{n} with gcd(k_{1}, ℓ) = 1, the lifted map w →→ ev(Ngw) induces a bijection between the ℓ-primary subgroup of (Dw.La)^{n}/q(Dw.La)^{n} and the ℓ-primary tuples in A(K)^{n} killed by q (TorsCount.card_ker_eq), whose order is ℓ^{vℓ(| detℤ(q|(Dw.La)n)|)}= ℓ^{vℓ(| Nm(det q)|r)} by det_mact and Sylow’s theorem (card_primary).
Proposition 15.78 (Primary-kernel harmonic trace bound via formal similitude descent). Assume ⋆= H.bar on 𝒪_{E}, let T : CDVR, io : c.F → T.Fr, y : IntFr Xo c T io, C : IntegralChartA3 Xo c T io y with Good3 C, IsNab Xo c nab, e > 0, and ChBound C e ρ w n. Let ℓ be a prime with ℓ ∈/ T.V^{×}, let N, k, M, k_{1} ∈ ℕ with N odd, N^{2} = kM, gcd(k, ℓ) = gcd(k_{1}, ℓ) = 1, and AllRat Xo (xOf y) M. Let p, q, g ∈M_{n}(𝒪_{E}) satisfy IsSim H (pq) (N^{2}) and gq = (k_{1}N)I_{n}. Let a : J ↪→(Fin n →A(T.Fr)) be a finite injective enumeration of all ℓ-primary tuples killed by pq, and assume a is isotropic for the N^{2}-Weil pairing: whenever WeilIs_{N}2(a_{i,b}, a_{i}′_{,b}, ε_{b}) holds for all b, ∏_{b}ε_{b} = 1. Let F_{b}, G_{i,b} ∈ SecN Xo (xOf y) (N^{2}) satisfy Reach Xo (sOf1 y) (N^{2}) (F_{b}), Moves Xo u (F_{b}) (F_{b}) for every ℓ-primary N-torsion point u, and Moves Xo (a_{i,b}) (F_{b}) (G_{i,b}). Finally, let P ∈ HH c w n and s ∈ c.F satisfy MvPolynomial.map(io)(s · pushL c (pq) P) ∈ FFV T w n. Then (GlobalTheory.T.sum_hv_primary_kernel_alt) there exists z ∈T.Fr with ν_{e}(z) ≥−ρ such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ || ∏ )
io(s) hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) (G_{i}) P =||{i ∈J : Kills Xo q (a_{i})}·io embK c τ (det p)^{Dw.mult(τ)} ·z.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈J τ:E↪→ℂ (393)
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ExistsIntegralExponentialSimilitudeGauge.lean:21--107, 253--351; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ProdSymmetricTranslationUnitsEqKappaRatio.lean:21--128; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/FormalSeries
DescendsOfSplitKernelInvariant.lean:20--92; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ConstantDvdTraceOfJacobianFiniteColength.lean:11--276; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/JacobianNonzeroSplittingOfProduct.lean:38--241; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ConnectionValueLevelKappaMulPullback.lean:18--93; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueIntegralPointEqValueOnBiextensionCo.lean:25--94; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/SumHarmonicValuesFormalKernelSimilitude.lean:42--364; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ReachedSectionRegularOnIntegralModel.lean:30--100; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/SumHvPrimaryKernel.lean:27--304; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/SumHvPrimaryKernelStatement.lean:11--12.
Proof. Let B be the integral formal biextension over T.V of C with canonical gauge h = gaugeOf C (integralBiext_gauge_eig_bound).
Step 1 (Formal-kernel similitude trace formula, sum_hv_formal_kernel). Suppose first that a enumerates the formal-kernel subgroup {u : Kills Xo (pq) u, ∀b ∃α, FormPt C (u_{b}) α}, that each F_{b} is Regular on the integral model of C, and that for every i with Kills Xo q (a_{i}) the sections G_{i,b} differ from F_{b} by scalars r_{b} ∈T.V with ∏_{b}r_{b} = 1.
(i) Integral germs, translation units, and similitude gauge κ. Each F_{b} admits an integral germ f_{b} ∈ PS(T.V, 1, d) (regular_section_integral_germ_unique_scale). Put f_{box} := ∏_{b} ev_{b}(f_{b}) ∈ PS(T.V, n, d). Under the formal-group identification (formal_group_points_of_integral_chart_spec, kills_formalPoints_iff_mem_coordinateKernel), a_{i} corresponds bijectively to α_{i} ∈ ker_{M}(B, pq) ⊂ (𝔪^{d}_{T.V})^{n}. By gauge_thirdDifference_symmetry_integral_exponentials and exists_translateUnit_symmetric_formalGroup_point, each a_{i,b} has a formal translation unit u_{i,b} ∈ PS∏(T.V, 1, d)^{×} satisfying TrUnit such that G_{i,b} has germ u_{i,b} · shift_{αi,b}(f_{b}). Writ-ing U_{i} :=_{b} ev_{b}(u_{i,b}), the box germ of G_{i} is U_{i} · shift_{αi}(f_{box}) (box_shift). Moreover, because pq^{T}(pq) = N^{2}I_{n}, working modulo the subgroup intLog of series whose exponen-tials lie in PS(∑(T.V, n, d) (hq_sum) produces a unit ∑ ) κ ∈ PS(T.V, n, d) with κ(0) = 1 and κ = exp _{b}h_{L}((pq)_{b}(X)) − N^{2}_{b}h_{L}(X_{b}) (exists_integral_exponential_similitude_gauge).
(ii) Cocycle cancellation U_{i} · shift_{αi}(κ) = κ. Put χ := U_{i} · shift_{αi}(κ) · κ^{−1} and let ψ := shift_{αi}. The
cube identity for κ, the multiplicative cocycle of TrUnit, and the N^{2}-periodicity of κ and U_{i} imply ψ(χ)E_{0}(χ) = χE_{αi}(χ) and ∏^{N}_{r=0}^{2−1}ψ^{r}(χ) = 1; taking E_{0} forces χ^{N2}= E_{0}(χ)^{N2}, hence χ = E_{0}(χ) (as char(T.V ) = 0 and N^{2} ̸= 0), so ψ(χ) = χ and χ^{N2} = 1. Meanwhile the [−1]-symmetry of TrUnit yields χ^{2}= 1; since N^{2} is odd, χ = 1 (prod_symmetricTranslationUnits_eq_kappa_ratio).
(iii) Twisted power-series descent and Scheja–Storch Jacobian trace. For α_{i} ∈ ker_{M}(B, q), the hypothesis
on G_{i} and ∏_{b}r_{b} = 1 give U_{i} · shift_{αi}(f_{box}) = f_{box} (box_smul); substituting U_{i} · shift_{αi}(κ) = κ shows that κ^{−1}f_{box} is invariant under ker_{M}(B, q). By Good3 C and AllRat, B has finite height (finiteHeight_formalGroup_uniformisedModel) and satisfies SplitKer B (pq) (splitKernel_formalGroup_of_rational_torsion), hence also SplitKer B q (splitKer_right). Therefore pullM_{B}(p), pullM_{B}(q), and pullM_{B}(pq) define finite free extensions of R := PS(T.V, n, d) of ranks r, r^{′}, r^{′′} with r^{′} = | ker_{M}(B, q)| and r^{′′} = | ker_{M}(B, pq)| (exists_finite_basis_powerSeries_subst_finite_colength, formalMatrixKernel_finite_ncard_eq_rank). Invariant descent (formalSeries_descends_of_splitKernel_invariant) writes κ^{−1}f_{box} = pullM_{B}(q)(f^{′}). In the finite free tower pull_{p} pull_{q} R−−−→R−−−→R, summing the r^{′′} distinct R-automorphisms shift_{α} (α ∈ ker_{M}(B, pq)) computes the tower trace (sum_tower):
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ( ) ( )
shift_{α} pullM_{B}(q)(f^{′}) = r^{′}· pullM_{B}(pq) Tr_{pullp}(f^{′}) .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
α∈ker_{M}(B,pq)Since the Jacobian determinant of pull_{p} is jacM_{B}(p)·U_{p} with U_{p} ∈R^{×} (det_jacobian_formal_module_matrix_eq_const_mul_unit) and jacM_{B}(p) ̸= 0, the Scheja–Storch trace-Jacobian theorem (C_dvd_trace_of_jacobian, constructed via the diagonal annihilator det P ∈R ⊗_{R0} R whose multiplication image is the Jacobian determinant and whose mod-𝔪 reduction lies outside the ideal of coordinates by det_notMem_span) yields g ∈ PS(T.V, n, d) with Tr_{pullp}(f^{′}) = jacM_{B}(p) g. Multiplying back by κ (sum_twisted) yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ( )
U_{i} · shift_{αi}(f_{box}) = | ker_{M}(B, q)| · jacM_{B}(p) · κ · pullM_{B}(pq, g) .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i
(iv) Connection chain rule and ChBound. By hv_eq_nabValN, linearity of nabValN, and the similitude con-
nection chain rule (( ∑ ) nabValN_kappa_mul_pullM( ), using the exponential cancellation κ · pullM_{B}(pq, g) · exp N^{2}_{b}h_{L} = ev_{pq}g ·exp(∑_{b}h_{L}) and constantCoeff_invariant_operator_along_matrix), we obtain ∑ io(s) hv(G_{i}, P) = | ker_{M}(B, q)| · jacM_{B}(p) · z,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i
where∏ z := nabValN^{(1)}_{B} (g, MvPolynomial.map(io)(s · pushL c (pq) P)). Identifying jacM_{B}(p) = _{τ} io(embK c τ (det p))^{Dw.mult(τ)} (jacM_eq_prod), | ker_{M}(B, q)| = |{i : Kills Xo q (a_{i})}|, and ν_{e}(z) ≥−ρ from ChBound C e ρ w n (integralBiext_gauge_eig_bound) proves (393) in the formal-kernel case.
Step 2 (Coset reduction from all ℓ-primary points to the formal kernel). Let W := {u : Kills Xo (pq) u and u is ℓ-primary} ≃ J, W_{0} := {u ∈ W : Kills Xo q u}, and W_{1} := {u ∈ W : ∀b ∃α, FormPt C (u_{b}) α}. For any u, u^{′} ∈ W, composing symmetric translates by u^{′} then u agrees with the symmetric translate by uu^{′} up to N^{2}-th roots of unity r_{b} ∈ T.V satisfying r_{b}^{2} = ε_{b}, where
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
WeilIs_{N}2(u_{b}, u^{′}_{b}, ε_{b}) (moves_mul). By isotropy, (∏_{b}r_{b})^{2} =_{b}ε_{b} = 1; since also (∏_{b}r_{b})^{N2} = 1 and N^{2} is odd, ∏_{b}r_{b} = 1 (rel_of_moves), which preserves hv (hv_linear). For u ∈ W_{0}, gq = (k_{1}N)I_{n} implies u_{b}^{k1N} = 1; since u_{b} is ℓ-primary and gcd(k_{1}, ℓ) = 1, u^{N}_{b} = 1, so u_{b} fixes F_{b} by hypothesis, making x →→ hv(G_{x}, P) invariant under W_{0}-shifts.
For every x ∈W, each G_{x,b} is Reach (by Reach.move), hence Regular on the integral model of C (reachedSection_regular_on_integralModel, proved by induction on Reach via nonnegativity of Mumford–Raynaud uniformization valuations). Moreover, by splitKernel_formalGroup_of_rational_torsion.2, every formal kernel point of pq is automatically ℓ-primary, so W_{1} bijects with the full formal kernel of pq. Applying Step 1 to each base section G_{x} gives z_{x} ∈T.Fr with ν_{e}(z_{x}) ≥−ρ and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∏ )
io(s) hv(G_{αx}, P) = |W_{1} ∩W_{0}| · δ · z_{x}, δ := io embK c τ (det p)^{Dw.mult(τ)} .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
α∈W_{1} τLet φ : W_{1} → W/W_{0} be the canonical homomorphism; its kernel has order |W_{1} ∩W_{0}|. Dividing by |W_{1} ∩∑W_{0}| ̸= 0 and summing over coset representatives of (W/W_{0})/ im(φ) (sum_cosets) yields (393) with z :=_{c∈(W/W0)/ im(φ)}z_{c.out} satisfying ν_{e}(z) ≥−ρ by the nonarchimedean triangle inequality.
Theorem 15.79 (The ℓ-primary isotropic sum bound and coprime-to-ℓ class estimate). Assume ⋆= H.bar on 𝒪_{E}, let T : CDVR, io : c.F → T.Fr, y : IntFr Xo c T io, C : IntegralChartA3 Xo c T io y with Good3 C, IsNab Xo c nab, e > 0, ChBound C e ρ w n, and let ℓ be a rational prime with ℓ∈/ T.V^{×}. Let Λ : GenLat E n and N, M ∈ℕ satisfy Λ.Unimod and Λ.LevOK N M, let P ∈ harmL c Λ w, and assume AllRat Xo (xOf y) (N^{2}).
(a) (GlobalTheory.SupFull.ell_part) Let a : J ↪→(Fin n →A(T.Fr)) be a finite injective enumeration
of {u : InZh Xo Λ N u and u is ℓ-primary}, and let F_{0}, F_{i} : Fin n → SecN Xo (xOf y) (N^{2}) satisfy Reach Xo (sOf1 y) (N^{2}) (F_{0,b}), Moves Xo u (F_{0,b}) (F_{0,b}) for every ℓ-primary N-torsion point u, and Moves Xo (a_{i,b}) (F_{0,b}) (F_{i,b}). Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
−ρ ≤ ν_{e} io Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P} ) ∑ hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) (F_{i}) P . (394)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈J
(b) (GlobalTheory.SupFull.bound_of_coprime) Let z : Fin(Λ.zCard(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)) → Fin n →
A(T.Fr), tp : Fin n →A(T.Fr), and F satisfy InZh Xo Λ N (z_{i}), GeoInj Xo (xOf y) z, tp^{N}_{b}^{2} = 1, and IsUUOver N (sOf1 y) (z_{i,b}) (tp_{b}) (F_{i,b}). If there exists m^{′}∈ℕ coprime to ℓ with tp^{m}_{b}^{′} = 1 for all b, then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ( ) )
−ρ ≤ ν_{e} io Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P} ) ∑ hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) b →→ sqN_{N}(F_{i,b}) P .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ShortValueBoundOfCoprime.lean:34--208; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/CuspFormEvaluations/TorsionIsotropicCommutatorPairing.lean:23--155; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueChainRuleNormalizedPullback.lean:15--55; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/IsotropicGroupPrimaryDecomposition.lean:23--148; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/IsotropicGroupPrimaryDecompositionStatement.lean:13--14; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ExistsSmulShortNonneg.lean:20--124.
Proof. For (a), apply Lemma 15.77(a) to obtain A : Adapt Λ N ℓ with IsSim H (A.pA.q) ((A.kN)^{2}), A.k odd and coprime to ℓ, and A.kN odd (as N is odd from Λ.LevOK). By Lemma 15.77(b), a enumerates the ℓ-primary kernel of A.pA.q and every a_{i} satisfies InZh Xo Λ (A.kN) (a_{i}). Because gcd(A.k, ℓ) = 1, the power map u →→u^{A.k} restricts to a bijection on ℓ-primary torsion killed by A.pA.q, yielding a permutation π : J ≃J with a_{π(i),b} = a^{A.k}_{i,b} (exists_perm).
For any section G of level N^{2}, let pl(G) denote its unique normalized pullback along A.k : 𝒪_{E} to level (A.kN)^{2} (existsUnique_pulls). By moves_of_pulls (using u ∘ act(A.k) = u^{A.k}), pl(F_{0,b}) is Reach (via Reach.pull, as N^{2} = 1 or N^{2} ≥ 4), is fixed by every ℓ-primary (A.kN)-torsion point, and satisfies Moves Xo (a_{i,b}) (pl(F_{0,b})) (pl(F_{π(i),b})). Moreover, (A.kN)𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆ N𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆ Λ.La, so zh_isotropic_and_half_isotropic (instantiated with the axiom-free theorem GlobalTheory.firstFiveLaws.1) guarantees that the tuples a_{i} are isotropic for the (A.kN)^{2}-Weil pairing. By Lemma 15.77(c) and A.pA.q = (A.kN)A.γ,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ( )
MvPolynomial.map(io) (A.kN)^{−deg P}pushL c (A.pA.q) P = MvPolynomial.map(io) pushL c A.γ P ∈ FFV T w n.
Applying Proposition 15.78 at level (A.kN)^{2} = (A.k)^{2}· N^{2} with matrices A.p, A.q, (A.k)A.g and scalar s = (A.kN)^{−deg P} produces z ∈T.Fr with ν_{e}(z) ≥−ρ such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ( ) ||
(A.kN)^{−deg P} hv (A.kN)^{2}, pl(F_{π(i)}), P =||{i ∈J : Kills Xo A.q (a_{i})} · δ · z,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i∈J
where δ := io(∏_{τ} embK c τ (det A.p)^{Dw.mult(τ)}). By the normalized pullback chain rule (harmonic_value_chain_rule_normalized_pullback), hv((A.kN)^{2}, pl(F_{π(i)}), P) = io(nrm(A.k))·hv(N^{2}, F_{π(i)}, P), and rein-dexing by π replaces F_{π(i)} by F_{i}. By card_kills and Lemma 15.77(d), |{i ∈J : Kills Xo A.q (a_{i})}| =
v(Λ.mIdx(N,Dw.p+Dw.q)) ℓ^{ℓ}. Because det A.p ∈𝒪_{E}, δ is integral over ℤ, so ν_{e}(δ) ≥0 (nval_nonneg) and hence ν_{e}(δz) ≥−ρ. Finally, writing S :=∑_{i∈J} hv(N^{2}, F_{i}, P), the identity above rearranges to
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(_{ℓ}v_{ℓ}(Λ.mIdx(N,Dw.p+Dw.q)) )io Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p+Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P} )S = · io(nrm(A.k))^{−1} · (A.k)^{deg P} ·(δz).
Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)
Since A.k and Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p+Dw.q)/ℓ^{vℓ(Λ.mIdx)} are positive integers coprime to ℓ∈/T.V^{×}, every factor in parentheses is a T.V -unit (un_ordProj, un_nrm, un_of_coprime). Multiplying δz by a T.V -unit preserves ν_{e} ≥−ρ, proving (394).
For (b), by isotropic_group_primary_decomposition (combining geometric surjectivity of the enumera-tion z over T.Fr with the Sylow ℓ-subgroup and Hall ℓ^{′}-complement of the finite abelian group Z_{h}), there exist finite sets J, J^{′}, enumerations a : J ↪→Z_{h}[ℓ^{∞}] and a^{′}: J^{′}→Z_{h}, a bijection σ : J × J^{′}≃ Fin(Λ.zCard), and m ∈ℕ coprime to ℓ such that z_{σ(i,i}′_{),b} = a_{i,b} a^{′}_{i′,b} and (a^{′}_{i′,b})^{m} = (a_{i}^{′}_{′,b})^{N2} = 1. Reindexing the sum over J ×J^{′} and applying the triangle inequality over i^{′}∈J^{′} (le_nval_sum) reduces the estimate to each fixed i^{′}∈J^{′}. For fixed i^{′}, since gcd(m, ℓ) = gcd(m^{′}, ℓ) = 1, exists_base pulls back sOf1 y along N, translates first by a^{′}_{i′,b} and then by tp_{b} (using uu_through_moves and symmetricTranslate_mul_of_coprime_orders), pro-ducing F_{0,b} that is Reach, fixed by every ℓ-primary N-torsion point, and moved by a_{i,b} to sqN_{N}(F_{σ(i,i}′_{),b}). Applying (a) yields the bound −ρ for each i^{′}∈J^{′}.
Proposition 15.80 (Translated-product torsion cancellation and unified local class bound). Retain the am-bient hypotheses of Theorem 15.79, with M = l.M, Λ.TrivAt l.M, and ℓ^{2} ∤ l.M. Let z, tp, F satisfy InZh Xo Λ N (z_{i}), GeoInj Xo (xOf y) z, IsUUOver N (sOf1 y) (z_{i,b}) (tp_{b}) (F_{i,b}), and suppose there exists a_{0} : Fin n →Dw.La such that for every b, tp^{N}_{b} = levPt Xo (xOf y) (a_{0,b}) and KilledBy Xo (l.Mb^{jb}) (tp_{b}) for some j_{b} ∈ℕ.
(a) (GlobalTheory.SupFull.bound_of_trivAt) Suppose Λ.TrivAt ℓ and N = β_{0}αn^{′} in 𝒪_{E} with
gcd(n^{′}, ℓ) = 1, αᾱ = A, β_{0}β^{̄}_{0} = B_{n}, AB_{n} = ℓ^{j}, tp^{N}_{b}^{2}= 1, and (β_{0} · tp_{b})^{n′2A}= 1 for all b. Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ( ) )
−ρ ≤ ν_{e} io nrm(Dw, c, w, α) Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P} ) ∑ hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) b →→ sqN_{N}(F_{i,b}) P .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i
(b) (GlobalTheory.SupFull.class_bound) Let α ∈𝒪_{E} satisfy one of the three cases: (i) ℓ∤l.M and α = 1;
(ii) ℓ| l.M, αᾱ = ℓ, and l.Mb ≤(̄α); or (iii) ℓ| l.M and α = ℓ. Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ) ( ( ) )
−ρ ≤ ν_{e} io nrm(Dw, c, w, α) io Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P} ) ∑ hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) b →→ sqN_{N}(F_{i,b}) P .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{i} (395)Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/MixedTranslatePullbackEqReachedSection.lean:17--65; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueTranslatedProductValuationBound.lean:20--124; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/HarmonicValueTranslatedProductValuationBoundStatement.lean:11--12; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/LatticeTrivialAtPrimeIndicesAndUnits.lean:19--217; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/LatticeTrivialAtPrimeIndicesAndUnitsStatement.lean:13--14; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ShortBoundOfTrivAt.lean:29--162; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/DvdOfCastDvd.lean:19--172; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ExistsSmulShortNonneg.lean:129--250.
Proof. We first establish the single-term translated-product bound (harmonicValue_translated_product_valuation_bound / TermBound.term_bound): given N = β_{0}αn^{′} (N odd, αᾱ = A, β_{0}β^{̄}_{0} = B_{n}, n^{′}∈T.V^{×}), points x_{1,b}, x_{2,b} of order dividing N^{2} with ((αβ_{0})·x_{1,b})^{n′2}= 1 and (β_{0}·x_{2,b})^{n′2A}= 1, sections F_{b} satisfying IsUUOver N (sOf1 y) (x_{1,b}) (x_{2,b}) (F_{b}), and P ∈ HH c w n with MvPolynomial.map(io)(P) ∈ FFV T w n, we claim
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ( ( ) )
−ρ ≤ ν_{e} io nrm(Dw, c, w, α) N^{−deg P} ) hv Xo c nab y.1 (N^{2}) b →→ sqN_{N}(F_{b}) P . (396)
If P = 0 the right-hand side is +∞. For P ̸= 0, note that N^{2}= n^{′2}AB_{n}. By mixed_translate_pullback_eq_reached_section (factoring the multiplication-N pullback through n^{′}, α, and β_{0} and commuting pull-backs with symmetric translates via normalisedPullback_commutes_symmetric_translations), there exists a section h_{b} of level n^{′2}A that is Reach from sOf1 y and satisfies Pulls Xo β_{0} (h_{b}) (sqN_{N}(F_{b})). Thus h_{b} is Regular (reachedSection_regular_on_integralModel) and has an integral germ f_{b} ∈ PS(T.V, 1, d) (regu-lar_section_integral_germ_unique_scale). By the normalized pullback chain rule (harmonic_value_chain_rule_normalized_pullback) and the multiplicativity identity N^{deg P} = nrm(N) = nrm(β_{0})nrm(α)(n^{′})^{deg P} (using totalDegree_of_rowDeg),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(
io nrm(α) N^{−deg P} ) hv(N^{2}, sqN_{N}(F), P) = (n^{′})^{−deg P} hv(n^{′2}A, h, P).
Because n^{′}∈T.V^{×}, (n^{′})^{−deg P} is a T.V -unit (nval_inv_pow_mul). Rewriting hv(n^{′2}A, h, P) via hv_eq_nabValN and applying ChBound C e ρ w n (integralBiext_gauge_eig_bound) yields (396).
Now prove (a). Since Λ.TrivAt ℓ, there is k ∈ℕ coprime to ℓ with kΛ.La ⊆𝒪_{E}^{n} and k𝒪_{E}^{n} ⊆Λ.La. By lattice_trivial_at_prime_indices_and_units, v_{ℓ}(Λ.zCard(N, r)) = v_{ℓ}(Λ.mIdx(N, r)) (with r = Dw.p+ Dw.q), Λ.mIdx(N, r) ̸= 0, and MvPolynomial.map(io)(P) ∈ FFV T w n (by Lemma 15.77(c) with γ = I_{n}). Decompose Z_{h} ≃J × J^{′} by isotropic_group_primary_decomposition, with |J| = ℓ^{vℓ(Λ.zCard)}= v(Λ.mIdx) ′ m ′ N ℓ^{ℓ} > 0 and (a_{i′,b}) = (a_{i′,b})^{2} = 1 for some m coprime to ℓ. For every i ∈ J and b, ap-plying InZh to kI_{n} gives a^{kN}_{i,b} = 1; since a_{i,b} is ℓ-primary and gcd(k, ℓ) = 1, a^{N}_{i,b} = 1 (pow_eq_one_of_trivAt). Hence a_{i,b} fixes the N-pullback of sOf1 y (moves_self), so isUUOver_of_mul cancels a_{i,b} from IsUUOver(N, sOf1 y, a_{i,b}a^{′}_{i′,b}, tp_{b}, F_{σ(i,i}′_{),b}) to give IsUUOver(N, sOf1 y, a^{′}_{i′,b}, tp_{b}, F_{σ(i,i}′_{),b}). By uniqueness of sqN_{N} (sqN_eq_of_isUUOver), the summand is independent of i ∈J; picking any i_{0} ∈J extracts the exact factor |J|: ∑
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
hv(N^{2}, sqN_{N}(F_{i}), P) = |J| hv(N^{2}, sqN_{N}(F_{σ(i0,i}′_{)}), P).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i i^{′}∈J^{′}Factor Λ.mIdx(N, r) = |J| · m^{′} with gcd(m^{′}, ℓ) = 1, so m^{′} ∈T.V^{×}; then |J| cancels the ℓ-primary part of Λ.mIdx(N, r)^{−1}, leaving the T.V -unit (m^{′})^{−1}. Furthermore, since N^{2} = n^{′2}ℓ^{j} and gcd(m, ℓ^{j}) = 1, (a^{′}_{i′,b})^{m} = (a_{i}^{′}_{′,b})^{N2} = 1 forces (a^{′}_{i′,b})^{n′2} = 1, hence ((αβ_{0}) · a^{′}_{i′,b})^{n′2} = 1. Applying (396) to each i^{′} ∈J^{′} and summing via the triangle inequality (le_nval_sum) proves (a).
For (b), every level point is killed by l.Mb (levPt_killed), so KilledBy Xo l.Mb (tp^{N}_{b} ). Apply the torsion-factorization lemma GlobalTheory.TorsFac.factorisation:
• In case (i) (ℓ ∤ l.M, α = 1): since l.M ∈ l.Mb and l.M | N, factorisation.1 yields tp^{N}_{b}^{2} = 1 and tp^{l.M}_{b}^{ib} = 1, so setting I := ∑_{b}i_{b} gives tp^{l.M}_{b}^{I} = 1 with gcd(l.M^{I}, ℓ) = 1. Since nrm(1) = 1,
• In cases (ii) and (iii) (ℓ| l.M): because l.M | N and ℓ^{2}∤l.M, writing N = ℓ^{e+1}n^{′} with gcd(n^{′}, ℓ) = 1 forces l.M | ℓn^{′}, hence ℓn^{′} ∈l.Mb. In case (ii) (A = ℓ, l.Mb ≤(̄α)), factorisation.2 sets β_{0} := ℓ^{e}ᾱ (B_{n} = ℓ^{2e+1}, j = 2e + 2) and uses l.Mb + l.Mb = (1) to verify n^{′}ᾱ ∈l.Mb, whence (β_{0} · tp_{b})^{n′2ℓ} =
tp_{b}^{N(n′ ̄α)} = 1. In case (iii) (α = ℓ, A = ℓ^{2}), factorisation.2 sets β_{0} := ℓ^{e} (B_{n} = ℓ^{2e}, j = 2e + 2),
giving (β_{0} · tp_{b})^{n′2ℓ2} = tp^{N}_{b}^{(ℓn′)} = 1. In both cases Λ.TrivAt l.M and ℓ| l.M imply Λ.TrivAt ℓ, so (a) establishes (395).
Corollary 15.81 (Unconditional verification of (SS.5), exists_smul_short_nonneg, and fullness of cusp-form lattices). Under the hypotheses of GlobalTheory.SupFull.exists_smul_short_nonneg (in particular D : D7, d.IsLev, IsNab d.Xo_{2} d.c_{2} d.nab_{2}, d.c_{δ} = 1, d.l_{2}.M squarefree, d.PhiPin, and g ∈ shortGen Xo c nab bad n_{V} w n d with witness (Λ, N, x_{0}, P)):
(a) Realization of (SS.5). At every place λ and integral framed point (T, io, y, e) with T.FinRes, let
(T^{′}, i_{T} , r, io_{2}, y_{2}, C, ζ, z, tp, F) be the finite-cover witness of Theorem 15.72 (short_value_on_cover) and let ℓ be the residue characteristic of T^{′}.V (exists_resChar). Setting α := 1 if ℓ ∤ d.l_{2}.M and α := ℓ if ℓ| d.l_{2}.M, and writing d_{w} := DF(Dw, w), b := io_{2}(Λ.mIdx(N, Dw.p + Dw.q)^{−1}N^{−deg P}), and X_{q} := ∑_{i} hv(d.Xo_{2}, d.c_{2}, d.nab_{2}, y_{2}.1, N^{ 2}, b^{′} →→ sqN_{N}(F(q, i, b^{′})), P^{ eF} ), inequality (SS.5) of
Proposition 15.16 holds for every q : Fin n → LevQ Dw d.l_{2}:
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ v_{T} ′_{.V} (p)ν_{re}(α^{dw}b X_{q}) ≥− vdH(p)^{dw}, (397)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
p|D.host.condN^{re2}together with vdH(p) ≤| disc E|.
(b) (GlobalTheory.SupFull.exists_smul_short_nonneg) With P_{0} := ∏_{p|D.host.condN}p, C_{lev} := |Fin n →
LevQ Dw d.l_{2}|, and K := P_{0}^{| disc E| dw}(d.l_{2}.M)^{dw}C_{lev}, the scalar s := K β_{H}(c, Λ) ∈ c.F^{×} satisfies 0 ≤v(s · g) for every finite place λ and every v ∈ valSet Xo c (algCls Xo c) λ.
(c) (fullAt_of_pins, fullLat, latFull) Combining (b) with Corollary 15.65 (exists_datum_span) and the
power-lifting lemma (exists_smul_nonneg_of_pow) establishes the fullness clause FullLat.span_eq_top of FullAt (and hence of GoodW) unconditionally.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/RingsOfIntegers/ShortGeneratorPlaceValuationBoundProof.lean:32--138; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ExistsSmulShortNonneg.lean:256--375; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ExistsSmulNonnegOfPow.lean:28--60, 135--177; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/IntegralCuspFormsFullLattice.lean:17--51.
Proof. For (a), since T^{′}.FinRes holds, the residue characteristic ℓ of T^{′}.V is a prime with ℓ∈/ T^{′}.V^{×} (ex-ists_resChar). Because d.l_{2}.M is squarefree, ℓ^{2}∤d.l_{2}.M. Apply Theorem 15.76 (chBound_host) to C with ramification index re > 0 and DF_{w} := d_{w} = DF(Dw, w) to obtain ChBound C (re) ρ w n, where ρ is the sum on the right-hand side of (397). By Lemma 15.67(d) (eF_transfer), P^{eF} ∈ harmL d.c_{2} Λ w and deg(P^{eF}) = deg P. By nrm_nat, nrm(Dw, d.c_{2}, w, α) = α^{dw} for α ∈{1, ℓ} ⊂ ℕ. Applying Proposi-tion 15.80(b) (class_bound, in case (i) if ℓ∤d.l_{2}.M and case (iii) if ℓ| d.l_{2}.M) for each q yields (397), while
Lemma 15.73(b) supplies vdH(p) ≤| disc E|.
For (b), Theorem 15.72(b) supplies (SS.4) and (390), Lemma 15.14 (datum_isIntegral) gives integrality of the coefficients w_{q}, and part (a) supplies (SS.5) and vdH(p) ≤| disc E|. Proposition 15.16 (using le_nval_avg and vV_prod_nat in ExistsSmulShortNonneg.lean:320--372) then yields s ̸= 0 and 0 ≤ v(s · g) simultaneously for every v ∈ valSet.
For (c), let f ∈ cuspW T j w and set k_{0} := 4([E : ℚ] D.R.r) + 3. By pow_mem_cusp, f^{k0+1} is a bounded algebraic cusp form of rank (k_{0} + 1)w.n ≥4([E : ℚ] D.R.r) + 4, so Corollary 15.65 (exists_datum_span) places f^{k0+1} in the c.F-span of shortGen for a cover datum d with squarefree level d.l_{2}.M = D.host.g_{0} D.host.g_{1}. By part (b), every g ∈ shortGen has a nonzero scalar s_{g} ∈ c.F^{×} with v(s_{g}g) ≥ 0 at all v ∈ valSet. Clearing the finitely many denominators in the linear combination for f^{k0+1} yields a nonzero integer t ∈𝒪_{c.F} \ {0} with v(t · f^{k0+1}) ≥0 for all v ∈ valSet. For each such v, v(t) ≥0 and v(t) + (k_{0} + 1)v(f) ≥ 0; hence if v(f) ≥ 0 then v(tf) = v(t) + v(f) ≥ 0, while if v(f) < 0 then v(tf) = v(t) + v(f) ≥v(t) + (k_{0} + 1)v(f) ≥0 (exists_smul_nonneg_of_pow). Therefore tf lies in the integral cusp lattice latIn, so f = t^{−1}(tf) ∈ span_{c.F} (latIn), proving FullLat.span_eq_top (fullAt_of_pins, fullLat, latFull).