Section 14 · PDF pages 837–842
The ray-family explicit formula with its exceptional zero
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
14 The ray-family explicit formula with its exceptional zero
We prove (NP.3) for the family of Definition 13.1. The coefficients and constants in that definition remain unchanged. For a character χ of its finite group, abbreviate
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑c_{χ}(n)c_{χ}(n) = χ(g)λ_{g}(n), D_{χ}(s) =_{s} , ℓ(t) = log(B(|t| + 2)).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
g n≥1^{n}Positivity of the λ_{g} and their sum bound give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|c_{χ}(n)| ≤∑λ_{g}(n) ≤2Λ(n). (361)
gIn particular the series for D_{χ} converges absolutely on ℜs > 1. Lemma 13.4 gives there
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{1F} ′_{(s)}
D_{χ}(s) =_{s −}^{χ=1}_{1}−_{F}^{χ}_{χ(s)}. (362)For a fixed 0 < c_{0} ≤1/20, let Z be a set of at most one real number such that each β ∈Z satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 −_{ℓ}^{c}_{(0)}^{0} ≤β < 1, F_{χ}(β) = 0, F_{χ}^{′}(β) ̸= 0,and every zero of F_{χ} in ℜs ≥ 1 −c_{0}/ℓ(ℑs) belongs to Z. This is the exact predicate ExcZ(χ, c_{0}, Z) in the source. In particular it asserts exhaustion of all zeros in the region, as well as simplicity. The preceding section supplies such sets with a common c_{0} for the family.
Lemma 14.1 (The exceptional logarithmic derivative is bounded). For every 0 < c_{0} ≤1/20, there is C > 0, depending only on c_{0}, such that for all the families, characters and sets just described,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||||||_{F}′_{(s)} ∑_{1} ||||||
^{χ} − ≤Cℓ(ℑs)^{2} (363)
^{Fχ(s)} β∈Z^{s −β}when
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 −_{2ℓ(}^{c}_{ℑ}^{0}_{s)} ≤ℜs ≤3, s /∈Z.Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/LogDerivSubExceptionalLe.lean:12--260.
Proof. Let C_{1} > 0 be the absolute constant of the local zero-subtraction formula in Lemma 13.8. At height t, it lists the zeros in the closed disk centered at 5/4 + it of radius 3/5, with their multiplicities m_{w}; their total is at most C_{1}ℓ(t). On the concentric disk of radius 1/2, away from zeros, the difference
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
F_{χ}^{′}(s) ∑_{mw}
F_{χ}(s)^{−}_{w} s −whas magnitude at most C_{1}ℓ(t). Write t = ℑs. The asserted narrower region is contained in ℜs ≥ 3/4, because ℓ(t) > 2 and c_{0} ≤1/20. It contains no zero outside Z.
If 3/4 ≤ℜs < 7/4, then |s −(5/4 + it)| ≤1/2, so the local formula applies. For a listed zero w /∈Z, exhaustion gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℜw < 1 −_{ℓ(ℑ}^{c0}_{w)}.The outer disk gives |ℑw −t| ≤3/5. Therefore
ℓ(ℑw) ≤ℓ(t) + log(13/10) ≤_{3}^{4}ℓ(t).
Indeed |ℑw| + 2 ≤(13/10)(|t| + 2), and log(13/10) ≤3/10, while ℓ(t) > 2. Subtracting the bounds on real parts yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℜ(s −w) ≥_{4ℓ}^{c}_{(}^{0}_{t)}, ||||_{s −}^{1}_{w}|||| ≤^{4ℓ}_{c}^{(}_{0}^{t)}.Thus the contribution of all these nonexceptional zeros has magnitude at most 4C_{1}ℓ(t)^{2}/c_{0}. If the exceptional zero is listed, its multiplicity is one and subtracting 1/(s −β) cancels it exactly. If it is not listed, its distance from the outer center exceeds 3/5, whereas the distance of s from that center is at most 1/2. Hence
|s −β| ≥1/10, and the extra subtracted term has magnitude at most 10. The empty exceptional set needs no such term. This proves a bound
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
C_{1}ℓ(t) + 4C_{1}ℓ(t)^{2}/c_{0} + 10on this part of the strip.
For 7/4 ≤ℜs ≤3, absolute convergence and (361) instead give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|D_{χ}(s)| ≤K, K = 2∑Λ(n)n^{−7/4}< ∞.
n≥1Both 1/(s −1) and 1/(s −β), when present, have magnitude at most 4/3, since β < 1. Use (362) and |Z| ≤1. As ℓ(t) > 2, both parts of the strip are covered by
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
C = C_{1} + 4C_{1}/c_{0} + 10 + K + 3.This constant is fixed before the family, χ, Z, s. The proof is the two-region argument, including the listed/unlisted exceptional-zero case, in the cited source.
Lemma 14.2 (The unsmoothed truncated Perron estimate). There is an absolute P > 0 such that, for every complex sequence c(n) with |c(n)| ≤2Λ(n), every 2 ≤T ≤u, and c_{u} = 1 + 1/ log u,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|||||| ∑ ∫ T (∑ ) |||||| )
1 c(n) u^{cu+it} (u(log u)^{2}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
c(n) − dt ≤P + log u . (364)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{1≤n≤u} 2π_{−Tn≥1}n^{cu+it} c_{u} + it TThe sum at the left includes an integer endpoint n = u. One may take P = 1440.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/TruncatedPerronKernel.lean:22--402; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/TruncatedPerronPsi.lean:7--434; Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/TruncatedPerronOfLeTwoVonMangoldt.lean:9--157.
Proof. For y > 0, c > 0, T ≥1, put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{1} ∫ T_{y}c+it
K_{T} (y, c) = _{2π−Tc + it }dt, E_{T} (y, c) = |K_{T} (y, c) −1_{y≥1}|.The source’s elementary kernel bounds, with absolute constant C_{K} = 3, are
E_{T} (y, c) ≤C_{K}y^{c}, E_{T} (y, c) T| log y| ≤C_{K}y^{c}. (365)
Here is their full contour calculation. Write L = log y. When L < 0, shift the finite vertical segment to ℜs = U and let U →+∞. The integrand e^{Ls}/s has no pole in this rectangle. Each horizontal integral is at most e^{Lc}/(T|L|); the new vertical integral tends to zero, being at most 2Te^{LU}/U. When L > 0, shift instead to ℜs = −U. The residue of e^{Ls}/s at zero is 1; the horizontal estimates are the same, and the new vertical integral is at most 2T/U. Thus for L ̸= 0,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{y}c
|K_{T} (y, c) −1_{y>1}| ≤_{πT|L|}.For the complementary small-T|L| bound, use
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{e}L(c+it)_{Lc}{_{e}iLt_{ −11} }
c + it^{= e} c + it^{+}c + it^{.}The first quotient has magnitude at most |L| because |e^{iLt}−1| ≤|Lt| ≤|L||c+it|. The second has integral 2 arctan(T/c), of magnitude less than π. Combining this with the indicator term gives E_{T} (y, c) ≤ 3y^{c} whenever T|L| ≤1. Together with the preceding far bound it proves (365) for y ̸= 1. For y = 1, the exact formula K_{T} (1, c) = arctan(T/c)/π gives E_{T} ≤1; the second inequality has zero on its left. This treats the included endpoint without silently assigning it half weight.
Put L = log u ≥1/2, c = c_{u}, N = ⌊u⌋ and b = 2u/T. Absolute convergence permits interchanging the series and finite integral: the summand is dominated on [−T, T] by |c(n)|n^{−c}u^{c}/c, a summable majorant. The left side of (364) is therefore at most ∑_{n≥1}2 log n E_{T} (u/n, c).
Split these terms at n = u/2, 2u. In the far ranges, | log(u/n)| ≥ log 2 > 1/2, u^{c} = eu < 3u, and log n ≤2Ln^{1/(2L)}. The latter follows from v ≤e^{v}, applied to v = (log n)/(2L). Consequently
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
12uL
log n E_{T} (u/n, c) ≤C_{K} n^{−1−1/(2L)}.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
T
For u/2 < n < 2u, we have log n ≤2L and (u/n)^{c}≤2e < 6. Define the nonnegative weight
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w_{N}(b; n) = 1_{n=N} + 1_{n=N+1} + b{^{ 1}_{N}^{n<N}_{ −n}+_{n}^{1}_{ −}^{n>N}_{N −}^{+1}_{1}},with the fractions omitted when their indicators vanish. At n = N, N + 1 the first kernel bound applies. For n < N, | log(u/n)| ≥(N −n)/(2u); for n > N + 1 it is at least (n −N −1)/(2u). These inequalities follow by integrating 1/t between u, n, using n < 2u in the latter case. The second kernel bound now gives in all the near cases
log n E_{T} (u/n, c) ≤16C_{K}L w_{N}(b; n).
All such n are less than 2(N + 1). The two reciprocal tails of this weight are harmonic sums, so
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
w_{N}(b; n) ≤2 + 2b(1 + log N) ≤2 + 2b(1 + L).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
0≤n<2(N+1)
Also, by comparison with the decreasing integral of t^{−1−1/(2L)},
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑n^{−1−1/(2L)}≤1 + 2L.
n≥1Summing the two bounds, retaining their harmless overcount in the respective complementary ranges, gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2C_{K}{^{12}_{T}^{uL}(1 + 2L) + 16L[2 + 4(u/T)(1 + L)]}.For L ≥1/2, its expression in braces, multiplied by 2, is at most 480((u/T)L^{2}+ L). Expansion verifies this directly: the coefficient of (u/T)L is absorbed using L ≤2L^{2}. Thus P = 480C_{K} = 1440 proves (364). The two exceptional integers in w_{N} are why the estimate is uniform even when u is an integer or arbitrarily close to one.
Lemma 14.3 (The rectangle after subtracting the exceptional pole). Let C be as in (363), u ≥2, T ≥1, and put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{0}d = , M_{T} = Cℓ(T)^{2}+ 2/d, c = 1 + 1/ log u.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
8ℓ(T)
Writing
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{1} ∫ T_{u}c+it
I(u, T) = _{2π−T}D_{χ}(c + it)_{c + it }dt,one has ||||||
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑_{u}β||||||
I(u, T) −1_{χ=1}u + ≤18M_{T} u/T + 4TM_{T} u^{1−2d}+ 2u^{1−2d}. (366)
β∈Z^{β}Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassFamilyPsiWithExceptionalZero.lean:14--355.
Proof. Choose σ ∈[1−4d, 1−2d] at distance at least d from every β ∈Z. This is possible because |Z| ≤1: if its point is at most 1 −3d, use σ = 1 −2d; otherwise use 1 −4d. For an empty set use the first choice. Since ℓ(T) ≥1, d ≤1/160; hence σ ≥1/2. Also 1 < c ≤3 and u^{c}= eu < 3u.
On the rectangle σ ≤ℜs ≤c, |ℑs| ≤T, the left-edge bound gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℜs ≥1 −_{2ℓ(}^{c}_{ℑ}^{0}_{s)},because 4d = c_{0}/(2ℓ(T)) and ℓ(ℑs) ≤ℓ(T). Thus the only possible poles of
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{F} ′_{(s)1}
P_{χ}(s) =_{Fχ}^{χ}_{(s)}−_{s −}^{χ=1}_{1}there are the exceptional real zeros and s = 1. At an exceptional zero, analyticity and the nonzero derivative give F_{χ}(s) = (s −β)H(s), with H holomorphic and nonzero locally. Consequently F_{χ}^{′}/F_{χ}= 1/(s −β) + H^{′}/H. The residue of P_{χ} there is 1. At 1, F_{χ} ̸= 0 by exhaustion and β < 1; the residue is −1_{χ=1}. This includes a removable singularity when χ ̸= 1.
On the left and horizontal edges, |s −β| ≥d, by the choice of σ on the first edge and by T ≥1 ≥d on the others. The same bound holds for |s −1|: on the left 1 −σ ≥ 2d, and on the horizontal edges its imaginary part has magnitude T. Since there is at most one exceptional term, (363) gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|P_{χ}(s)| ≤Cℓ(T)^{2}+ 2/d = M_{T}on all three edges. Shift the right integral, using D_{χ} = −P_{χ} on ℜs = c, to the left edge. The residue theorem for −P_{χ}(s)u^{s}/s gives the crossed terms
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1_{χ=1}u −∑u^{β}/β.
β_{β>σ}∈ZThe origin is outside the rectangle, since σ ≥1/2. Each horizontal integral has length at most 3, numerator at most 3M_{T} u, and denominator at least T, so contributes at most 9M_{T} u/T. The left integral has length 2T, denominator at least 1/2, and numerator at most M_{T} u^{σ}, so contributes at most 4TM_{T} u^{σ}. The normalization 1/(2π) ≤ 1 preserves these bounds. Finally any exceptional zero not crossed has β ≤ σ ≤ 1 −2d and β ≥1 −c_{0}/ℓ(0) > 1/2, whence
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|u^{β}/β| ≤2u^{1−2d}.There is at most one such point. Add this omitted term and use u^{σ} ≤u^{1−2d} to obtain (366), with the full exceptional set Z rather than only the crossed part.
Proposition 14.4 (The full exceptional-zero explicit formula). For every fixed 0 < c_{0} ≤ 1/20, there are positive c_{7}, C_{7}, depending only on c_{0}, such that every family, character and exceptional set described above satisfies ||||||
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑_{u}β|||||| √
ψ_{χ}(u) −1_{χ=1}u + ≤C_{7}ue^{−c7log u} (367)
β∈Z^{β}Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
√
for all u ≥2 with log B ≤ log u. One may take c_{7} = c_{0}/64. Thus this is exactly (NP.3), with constants uniform over the family, the group, the character and its possible exceptional zero.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassFamilyPsiWithExceptionalZero.lean:357--502.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
√
Proof. Put W = log u, δ = c_{0}/32, and let C be the subtracted logarithmic-derivative constant. Set
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
K = 9C + 48/c_{0}, C_{7} = 14 + (2P + 22K + 2) 24(2/δ)^{4}, c_{7} = δ/2.All are positive and fixed before the family.
If δW ≤1, the coefficient bound and ψ(u) ≤2u give |ψ_{χ}(u)| ≤4u. The principal term has magnitude at most u; the single possible exceptional term at most 2u. Thus the left side is at most 7u. But e^{−δW/2}≥ 1−δW/2 ≥1/2, and C_{7} ≥14, so the asserted bound follows. This handles the entire initial range uniformly.
Otherwise δW > 1. Then W ≥1, and take T = e^{δW} > 2. As δ ≤1 and W ≥1, T ≤e^{W 2} = u. The conductor range gives
1 ≤ℓ(T) = log B + log(T + 2) ≤W + log 2 + δW ≤3W.
For d = c_{0}/(8ℓ(T)), this implies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
M_{T} = Cℓ(T)^{2}+ 2/d ≤9CW^{2}+ 48W/c_{0} ≤KW^{4}.Also
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{c0W} 2_{c0W}
2dW^{2}=_{4ℓ(T)} ≥_{12} ≥2δW, u^{1−2d}≤u/T^{2}.Apply Lemma 14.2 using (361), and add Lemma 14.3. Their combined error is at most
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P(uW^{4}/T + W^{2}) + 18M_{T} u/T
+ 4TM_{T} u^{1−2d}+ 2u^{1−2d}
≤(2P + 22K + 2)W^{4}u/T.Here u/T ≥1 absorbs W^{2}, the estimate u^{1−2d} ≤u/T^{2} handles the left edge, and T ≥1, W ≥1 handle the omitted zero. The elementary exponential-series inequality
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
W^{4}e^{−δW} ≤24(2/δ)^{4}e^{−δW/2}follows from e^{δW/2} ≥(δW/2)^{4}/4!. Substitution proves (367) with precisely the constants chosen above. No limiting height or family-dependent contour has been introduced: T is this explicit function of u, c_{0}, and the selected left line only avoids the at most one zero already present in Z.