Section 6.7 · PDF pages 328–337
Simultaneous arithmetic realization on the selected family
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
6.7 Simultaneous arithmetic realization on the selected family
We now complete the arithmetic comparison stream by proving all six clauses of Input 6.78 simultaneously on every compatible setup GlobalTheory.NLink.SetupAlt and deducing the pointwise split-case bound Up-perTheory.N.conclusion_split_alt and the uniform two-prime family bound UpperTheory.N.at23_family_alt. The argument combines four ingredients: (1) construction of the canonical integral block-ring objects (RingDef, RingTop) from primitive matrix data; (2) unramified residue-field enlargement and determinant-comparison descent removing the residue-field cardinality restriction in Proposition 6.7; (3) simultaneous realization of the column lifts, strict Selmer/Sha/class-group identifications, and Tate-dual row quotients on the integrally normalized family; and (4) assembly on the selected family from the already-proved local crystalline lifting, invariant-annihilator, and trivial-block theorems (Proposition 6.62 and Corollaries 6.69 and 6.76) together with the conjugate row–column declarations at ℓ= 2 and split odd primes.
Proposition 6.97 (Canonical block-ring data from primitive matrix inputs). Let O be a discrete valuation ring with fraction field K, residue field k_{O}, and divisible quotient D = K/O. Let X be finite, T ⊂ O^{X} a local O-subalgebra separating points of X, d a finite index set equipped with a block partition bl : d →
{0, 1, . . . , t} (t ≥ 1) whose fibers over c ≥ 1 each have cardinality 1, and r_{0} : G → M_{d}(O)^{X} a group homomorphism satisfying:
(a) for every g ∈G and k ≥0, the k-th coefficient function of det(1 −zr_{0}(g, x)) belongs to T;
(b) at a selected point π ∈ X, r_{0}(g, π) is block diagonal for bl, its 0-th block reduction modulo 𝔪_{O} is absolutely irreducible over k_{O}, and for every a ∈ d with c = bl(a) ≥ 1 one has r_{0}(g, π)_{a,a} = χ_{1}(g)ε(g)^{−(c−1)} for characters χ_{1}, ε : G →O^{×};
(c) e_{B}, e_{1} ∈ span_{T} (r_{0}(G)) are orthogonal idempotents of constant K-ranks t and 1 respectively, with e_{B}(π) the standard projection onto {a : bl(a) ≥1} and e_{1}(π) supported on the 0-th block;
(d) there exist g_{0} ∈ G and s ∈ span_{T} (r_{0}(G)) with e_{B}s = se_{B} = s and s(π) = 0 such that for every x ∈X, the corner polynomial
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
P_{x}(z) = det ze_{B}(x) −(e_{B}(x)r_{0}(g_{0}, x)e_{B}(x) + s(x)) + 1 −e_{B}(x)
splits over K into t pairwise distinct roots.
Then there exists an integral block-ring package D_{0} = (X^{′}, T^{′}, p, q, (b_{k}), A, r, χ, e^{′}_{B}, e^{′}_{1}, X_{0}^{′}, E, (r_{i}), π^{′}, ρ_{π}, (ρ_{c}), s_{E}, t_{E}) satisfying all defining, scalar-tower, and top-level axioms of RingDef, RingInst, and RingTop (ring_objects_of_matrix_data). In particular:
(i) X^{′} is the finite set of pairs (x, (α_{0}, . . . , α_{t−1})) with P_{x}(z) =∏^{t}_{i=0}^{−1}(z −α_{i}) in O[z], p : X^{′} →X is the first projection, T^{′}⊂O^{X′} is free of rank q = t! over T on a basis (b_{k}) whose restrictions to every fiber p^{−1}(x) are O-linearly independent, and π^{′}= (π, (γ_{i})_{0≤i<t}) ∈X^{′} has γ_{i} = χ_{1}(g_{0})ε(g_{0})^{−i};
(ii) A = span_{T} ′(r(G)) ⊂M_{d}(K)^{X′} (where r(g, x^{′}) = r_{0}(g, p(x^{′}))) is left Noetherian, has integral evalu-
ations everywhere, satisfies the block-determinant property of Lemma 6.11 into T^{′}, and its evaluation ρ_{π} : A →M_{d}(O) at π^{′} is block diagonal with surjective block homomorphisms ρ_{c} : A ↠M_{dc}(O) for 0 ≤c ≤t;
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
(iii) writing X_{0}^{′} = e^{′}_{B}r(g_{0})e^{′}_{B}+s^{′}, E = e^{′}_{B}^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(X_{0}^{′}−r_{i}e_{B}^{′} ) ∈A, and δ = ∏^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(r_{0} −r_{i}) ∈T^{ ′}, one has
E^{2}= δE, (e^{′}_{1})^{2} = e_{1}^{′}, and at every x^{′} ∈X^{′} both E(x^{′}) and e^{′}_{1}(x^{′}) have K-rank 1 while δ(x^{′}) ̸= 0;
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
(iv) writing∑ E =_{g∈sE}t_{E}(g)r(g) with t_{E}(g) ∈ T^{ ′} and setting δ_{O} = δ(π^{′}) ∈ O and τ =
_{g∈sE}t_{E}(g)χ(g) ∈T^{ ′} (where χ(g) is the constant function χ_{1}(g)), one has
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏t−1( )
δ_{O} = χ_{1}(g_{0}) −χ_{1}(g_{0})ε(g_{0})^{−i} , τ(π^{′}) = δ_{O}, (168)
i=1and on the block A-modules M_{c} = D_{ρ}^{d}_{c}^{c}: E kills M_{0} and M_{c} (c ≥2) and acts by δ_{O} on M_{1}; δ acts by δ_{O} on every M_{c}; τ acts by δ_{O} on M_{0} and M_{c} (c ≥ 2); u_{g} = χ(g)^{−1}r(g) acts trivially on M_{1}; e_{1}^{′}M_{c} = 0 for c ≥1; and e^{′}_{1}M_{0} ≃_{O} D.
Proof. Set X_{0} = e_{B}r_{0}(g_{0})e_{B} + s ∈ span_{T} (r_{0}(G)). By Lemma 6.11 applied over T, every coefficient function of P_{x}(z) = det(ze_{B}(x) −X_{0}(x) + 1 −e_{B}(x)) lies in T (blockPolyT). Since P_{x} is monic in O[z] and splits into distinct roots in K, integral closure of the DVR O places all roots of P_{x} in O (rootsInt).
Lemma 6.9 (splitPts) immediately yields X^{′}, p, T^{′}, and the T-basis (b_{k})_{1≤k≤t!} with O-linearly independent fiber restrictions. At π, block diagonality of r_{0}(g_{0}, π), s(π) = 0, and the character formula in (b) give X∏_{0}(π) = diag(β_{a}) with β_{a} = 0 for bl(a) = 0 and β_{a} = γ_{c−1} for c = bl(a) ≥ 1. Hence P_{π}(z) = _{i}^{t}_{=0}^{−1}(z −γ_{i}), so π^{′} = (π, (γ_{i})_{0≤i<t}) lies in X^{′}, proving (i).
Pulling back coefficients along p maps span_{T} (r_{0}(G)) into A = span_{T} ′(r(G)), so e^{′}_{B}, e^{′}_{1}, X_{0}^{′}, E ∈ A. Every element of A is a finite T^{′}-combination of matrices in M_{d}(O), hence evaluates integrally at every x^{′}∈X^{′} and is block diagonal at π^{′}. By Lemma 6.10, A is finite over O and left Noetherian, and because the residual 0-th block is absolutely irreducible over k_{O}, Lemma 6.17 plus Nakayama’s lemma give surjectivity of ρ_{0} : A ↠ M_{d0}(O); for c ≥ 1 we have d_{c} = 1 and ρ_{c} contains all scalars in O, so every ρ_{c} is surjec-tive. Pullback preserves condition (a) into T^{′}, so Lemma 6.11 gives the block-determinant property into T^{′}, proving (ii).
For (iii) (eMat in IdemFactor.lean:123), fix x^{′}∈X^{′} and write e = e^{′}_{B}(x^{′}), x = X_{0}^{′}(x^{′}), and α_{i} = r_{i}(x^{′}) in M_{d}(K). Since e^{2} = e, splitting K^{d} = im(e) ⊕ ker(e) produces matrices U ∈ M_{d×t}(K) and W ∈ M_{t×d}(K) with UW = e and WU = I_{t}. Setting B = WxU ∈M_{t}(K), the corner relations(∏ ex = xe =) x give x = UBW, e = UI_{t}W, and inductively E(x^{′}) = e∏^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(x −α_{i}e) = U^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(B −α_{i}I_{t}) W. Moreover, ze−x+1−e = I_{d} +U((zI_{t} −B −I_{t})W), so Sylvester’s determinant identity det(I_{d} +MN) = det(I_{t} + NM) gives P_{p(x}′_{)}(z) = det(I_{t} + (zI_{t} −B −I_{t})WU) = det(zI_{t} −B). Since α_{0}, . . . , α_{t−1} are pairwise distinct eigenvalues of B ∈M_{t}(K), B is diagonalizable over K with one-dimensional eigenspaces, so E_{B} = ∏^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(B −α_{i}I_{t}) has rank 1 and satisfies E_{B}^{2} = δ(x^{′})E_{B} with δ(x^{′}) = ∏^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(α_{0} −α_{i}) ̸= 0. Multiplying on the left by U and on the right by W (using WU = I_{t}) gives E(x^{′})^{2} = δ(x^{′})E(x^{′}) and rank_{K} E(x^{′}) = rank_{K} E_{B} = 1. Since x^{′} is arbitrary, E^{2} = δE holds in A, and rank_{K} e^{′}_{1}(x^{′}) = 1 is assumption (c).
For (iv), evaluating δ at π^{′} using r_{i}(π^{′}) = γ_{i} yields the first identity in (168). At π^{′}, both e^{′}_{B}(π^{′}) and X_{0}^{′}(π^{′}∏) are diagonal, so a direct diagonal product (eDiag') gives E(π^{′}) = diag(v_{a}) where v_{a} = 0 if bl(a) = 0, v_{a} =_{i}^{t}_{=1}^{−1}(γ_{0} −γ_{i}) = δ_{O} if bl(a) = 1, and v_{a} = ∏^{t}_{i=1}^{−1}(γ_{c−1} −γ_{i}) = 0 (the i = c −1 factor vanishes) if c = bl(a) ≥2. Hence E acts by 0 on M_{0} and M_{c} (c ≥2) and by δ_{O} on M_{1}. Since T^{′} acts on M_{c} through evaluation at π^{′}, δ acts by δ_{O} on every M_{c}, and the scalar towers of RingInst hold pointwise. Let a_{1} ∈d be the unique index with bl(a_{1}) = 1. Evaluating the (a_{1}, a_{1})-entry of E =∑_{g∈sE}t_{E}(g)r(g) at π^{′} and using r_{0}(g, π)_{a1,a1} = χ_{1}(g) gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
δ_{O} = E(π^{′})_{a1,a1} = ∑t_{E}(g)(π^{′})χ_{1}(g) = τ(π^{′}),
g∈s_{E}which proves the second identity in (168) and shows that τ acts by δ_{O} on every M_{c}. On M_{1}, u_{g} = χ(g)^{−1}r(g) acts by χ_{1}(g)^{−1}r_{0}(g, π)_{a1,a1} = 1. Finally, since e_{1}(π) is supported on the 0-th block, e^{′}_{1}M_{c} = 0 for c ≥1, and the 0-th block e_{0} = ρ_{0}(e^{′}_{1}) ∈M_{d0}(O) is an idempotent of K-rank 1 (rank_block). Writing e_{0} = U_{0}W_{0} over K with W_{0}U_{0} = 1 gives ∑_{j}(e_{0})_{j,j} = 1, so in the local ring O some diagonal entry c = (e_{0})_{i0,i0} is a unit. Since e_{0} has rank 1, all 2 × 2 minors vanish, giving (e_{0})_{i,j} = (e_{0})_{i,i0}(c^{−1}(e_{0})_{i0,j}) for all i, j. Thus the endomorphism e_{0} of D^{d0} factors as ψ ∘η with ψ(m) = ((e_{0})_{i,i0}m)_{i} and η(v) = ∑_{j}c^{−1}(e_{0})_{i0,j}v_{j},
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
)
satisfying η(ψ(m)) = c^{−1}(∑_{j}(e_{0})_{i0,j}(e_{0})_{j,i0} m = c^{−1}(e_{0})_{i0,i0}m = m (idemKO). Hence η is surjective and ψ is injective, giving e^{′}_{1}M_{0} = im(ψ ∘η) ≃_{O} D.
Proposition 6.98 (Unramified residue-field enlargement and determinant descent). Under the hypotheses of Proposition 6.97, let D_{0} be the resulting block-ring package over O, let Z ⊂X, and let 𝒩 be a finitely generated left A-module such that Hom_{A}(𝒩, K_{x}^{d}_{′}) ̸= 0 for every x^{′} ∈X^{′} with p(x^{′}) /∈Z. Then, with no assumption on |k_{O}|,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑t
length_{O}(O/I_{π}) ≤ length_{O} Hom_{A}(𝒩, M_{c}). (169)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c=0
Consequently, for every choice of column-module data (ι, colIdx, (D_{w}), (j_{w}), (e^{′}_{w}), (K_{c}), (k_{0})) satisfying the hypotheses of Lemmas 6.2–6.6, the full length inequality of LocalToDisplayFree holds over O without any cardinality bound on k_{O} (lemma_five_three_any_residue_field, displayFree, composite_of_chain_holds).
Proof. Since A is left Noetherian and 𝒩 is finitely generated, choose g generators and a finite presentation
A^{h} −→^{P} A^{g} →𝒩 → 0 with P ∈ M_{h×g}(A). We first construct a finite free unramified DVR extension O ↪→ O^{′} (ramification index e = 1, so v_{O}′(y) = v_{O}(y) for all y ∈ O) whose residue field satisfies |k_{O}′| > g|d| (bigResidueExt). If k_{O} is infinite, take O^{′} = O. If k_{O} is finite, pick a finite subset S of an algebraic closure of k_{O} of cardinality g|d| + 1; the finite extension k_{O}(S)/k_{O} is simple, generated by some α with monic irreducible minimal polynomial f^{̄} ∈ k_{O}[z]. Lift f^{̄} to a monic polynomial f ∈ O[z] and set O^{′}= O[z]/(f) (unram_ext). Then f is irreducible over O, O^{′} is a finite free O-domain, the kernel of the surjection O^{′} ↠ k_{O}[z]/( f^{̄}) is generated by a uniformizer ϖ of O, every maximal ideal of O^{′} lies over (ϖ) by integrality and hence equals ϖO^{′}, so O^{′} is a DVR with uniformizer ϖ, v_{O}′(y) = v_{O}(y), and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|k_{O}′| = |k_{O}(S)| > g|d|.For any finite free DVR extension O ↪→O^{′} with ramification index e ≥1 (meaning v_{O}′(y) = e v_{O}(y) for all y ∈O), let T_{O}′ = span_{O}′(T) ⊂(O^{′})^{X} and base-change r_{0}, χ_{1}, ε, e_{B}, e_{1}, s along O ↪→O^{′} (stageC). Because T is local, every f ∈T has constant residue class on X, hence so does every element of T_{O}′; by integrality of (O^{′})^{X} over T_{O}′, an element of T_{O}′ is a unit if and only if its value at π is a unit, so T_{O}′ is local (bcLocal). Separation of points and membership of characteristic-polynomial coefficients are preserved by injectivity of O ↪→O^{′}. Residual absolute irreducibility of the 0-th block over k_{O}′ holds because Burnside’s theorem (Lemma 6.17) places every matrix unit E_{ij} in the k_{O}-span of the 0-th block image, hence in its k_{O}′-span (absIrrExt). The idempotent ranks are unchanged under O ↪→O^{′} (bcRank), and the corner polynomials remain monic, separable, and split with distinct roots in O^{′} (bcSplit, sep_ext). Moreover, since O^{′}/O is finite free of ramification index e, the congruence ideal scales by length_{O}′(O^{′}/I_{π,O}′) = e · length_{O}(O/I_{π}) (vccBaseChange).
Applying Proposition 6.97 over O^{′} produces a package D_{0}^{′} = (X_{O}^{′}_{′}, T^{ ′}_{O′}, p^{′}, A^{′}, . . . ) satisfying RingDef and RingTop. Because every P_{x} already splits over O, each root in O^{′} of P_{p}′_{(y}′_{)} lies in the image of O (by injectivity of O^{′}→K^{′} and the already known factorization in O[z]). Uniqueness of ordered-root lifts in RingDef therefore defines a map σ : X_{O}^{′}_{′} →X^{′} with p(σ(y^{′})) = p^{′}(y^{′}), r_{i}^{′}(y^{′}) = r_{i}(σ(y^{′})), and σ(π_{O}^{′}_{′}) = π^{′} (exists_sigma). Composing with σ and the field embedding κ : K ↪→K^{′} induces a ring homomorphism bc : A →A^{′} commuting with every block projection: ρ^{′}_{c}(bc(a)) = ρ_{c}(a) ⊗_{O}O^{′} (bcHom).
Let P^{′} = bc(P) ∈ M_{h×g}(A^{′}) and 𝒩^{′} = (A^{′})^{g}/P^{′T}(A^{′})^{h} (moduleBc in SpanSingle.lean:62). For y^{′} ∈ X_{O}^{′}_{′} with p^{′}(y^{′}) /∈ Z, we have p(σ(y^{′})) /∈ Z, so there exists a nonzero ϕ ∈ Hom_{A}(𝒩, K_{σ}^{d}_{(y′)}),
corresponding to a nonzero vector v ∈ ker(P(σ(y^{′}))) in (K^{d})^{g}; then κ(v) ∈((K^{′})^{d})^{g} is nonzero and lies in ker(P^{′}(y^{′})), giving a nonzero element of Hom_{A}′(𝒩^{′}, (K^{′})^{d}_{y′}). For each block 0 ≤ c ≤ t, applying ρ_{c} gives a rectangular matrix P_{c} ∈M_{hdc×gdc}(O) whose kernel on D^{gdc} is Hom_{A}(𝒩, M_{c}), and P_{c}^{′}= P_{c}⊗_{O}O^{′} has kernel Hom_{A}′(𝒩^{′}, M_{c}^{′}) on (D^{′})^{gdc}. Because O is a PID, the row submodule of P_{c} in O^{gdc} is free of rank at most gd_{c}; padding a basis of that row space by zero rows gives a square matrix B ∈ M_{gdc}(O) together with C, C^{′} such that P_{c} = CB and B = C^{′}P_{c} (exists_square in KerEqOfFactor.lean:43). Hence ker(P_{c} on D^{gdc}) = ker(B on D^{gdc}) and similarly ker(P_{c}^{′} on (D^{′})^{gdc}) = ker(B ⊗_{O}O^{′} on (D^{′})^{gdc}). By Smith normal form over a DVR (lenKer), length_{O} ker(B on D^{gdc}) = v_{O}(det B) (interpreted as ∞ if det B = 0), and therefore
length_{O}′ Hom_{A}′(𝒩^{′}, M_{c}^{′}) = v_{O}′(det(B ⊗_{O}O^{′})) = e v_{O}(det B) = e · length_{O} Hom_{A}(𝒩, M_{c})
(kerBc). Applying Proposition 6.7 over O^{′} (with e = 1 and |k_{O}′| > g|d| = g∑_{c}d_{c}) yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑t ∑t
e · length_{O}(O/I_{π}) = length_{O}′(O^{′}/I_{π,O}′) ≤ length_{O}′ Hom_{A}′(𝒩^{′}, M_{c}^{′}) = e length_{O} Hom_{A}(𝒩, M_{c}),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c=0 c=0
and cancelling e = 1 proves (169). For any column module 𝒩 as in Lemmas 6.2–6.6, 𝒩 is finitely generated over the Noetherian ring A, Lemma 6.6 supplies the off-spectrum nonzero homomorphisms, and combin-ing (169) with Lemmas 6.2–6.5 yields LocalToDisplayFree.
Proposition 6.99 (Pointwise integral realization and split-case bound from admitted data). Assume the published global Artin reciprocity, local Tate duality, and local Euler characteristic hypotheses (GlobalArtinReciprocity, LocalTateDualityK, LocalEulerCharK). Fix a host D, local index a, good eigencharac-ter π ∈ Z_{a}, row–column declaration dc = (R_{a}, C_{a}) with R_{a} = C^{̄}_{a} and sign ep ∈{±1}, and inte-gers e^{′} ≥ 0, c_{0}(u) ≥ 0 (u ∈ C_{a}), and b_{0} ≥ 0. Suppose all 36 admitted local, residual, crystalline, jump-shape, duality, lifting, invariant, and trivial-block conditions of EmbeddingTypes.admitted hold at (a, r, ρ, π, dc, ep, e^{′}, c_{0}, b_{0}), together with the local-index conditions hypL and hypDecl. Then:
(i) for every column place u ∈C_{a}, the rational finite-cohomology rank of W^{′}= ρ_{π} ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1} at u satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j_{W} (u) ≤d_{u}m;(ii) for every column place u ∈C_{a} and its conjugate row place w = ̄u ∈R_{a}, the enlarged row quotient
for T_{2} = (W^{′})^{∗}(1) at w satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
λ_{a} H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, T_{2})/ im_{row}(w) ≤d_{u}me^{′}+ rc_{0}(u); (170)
(iii) if Sel_{a,π} and every Sha_{ℓ}(j) (1 ≤j < t) have finite length and ζ_{a,v} ̸= 1 for all v ∈Q_{a}, then the integral
congruence–Selmer comparison (137) holds with exponents (e^{′}, c_{0}, b_{0}) (splitCase_bound_at_point_of_admitted_items_alt).
Proof. For (i) and (ii) (jump_and_length_of_admitted in JumpAndLengthOfAdmitted.lean:930--1012), fix a column place u ∈ C_{a}. By hypDecl, every ℚ_{ℓ}-embedding τ : E_{u} ↪→ L lies in the CM half selected by ep, so admG2 gives a signed ShapeJumps decomposition C_{τ} ⊔L_{τ} ⊔{0, . . . , t −1} of the Hodge–Tate jumps of r_{π} ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1} at τ with every a ∈ C_{τ} strictly positive and |L_{τ}| = m. Subtracting the t character jumps {0, . . . , t −1} (ambBlock, multW_eq) leaves C_{τ} ⊔L_{τ} as the multiplicity-1 jump set of W^{′} at τ. Hence at most |L_{τ}| = m jumps of W^{′} at τ are negative. Since W^{′} is crystalline (ambW) with H^{0}(E_{u}, W^{′}) = 0 (ColumnH0Vanishing), the Bloch–Kato dimension formula and ambFil give j_{W} (u) =∑_{τ:Eu↪→L} #{a ∈C_{τ} ⊔L_{τ} : a < 0} ≤[E_{u} : ℚ_{ℓ}]m = d_{u}m (rank_le_col), proving (i).
Now let w = ̄u ∈R_{a} be conjugate to u. By ambTypeD, no embedding τ : E_{w} ↪→L lies in the ep-half, so the sign in ShapeJumps flips to −1: every a ∈C_{τ} is strictly negative, while |L_{τ}| = m. Under Tate duality T_{2} = (W^{′})^{∗}(1), jump multiplicities reflect by a →→−a −1 (ambDual); therefore every a ∈ C_{τ} becomes −a −1 ≥0, and again at most |L_{τ}| = m jumps of T_{2} at τ are negative. By ambT2 (T_{2} is crystalline with H^{0}(E_{w}, T_{2}) = 0) and [E_{w} : ℚ_{ℓ}] = [E_{u} : ℚ_{ℓ}] = d_{u} (locDeg_conj), the same Bloch–Kato rank count gives rk_{L}H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, T_{2}) ≤ d_{u}m (rank_le_row). On the standard O-lattice L_{2} of T_{2}, the finitely generated module H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2}) = Z_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2})/B^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2}) has O-rank at most d_{u}m and torsion submodule bounded by (T_{2}/L_{2})^{GEw} (H1fFiniteRankTorsion, lenModPow_le_of_fg), whose O-length is at most rc_{0}(u)e_{O} by H0ColumnLengthBound. Since multiplication by ℓ^{e′} on H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2}) factors through the row lattice map (Lift
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
′
ExponentDualPlaces), its cokernel is a quotient of H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2})/ℓ^{e}H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, L_{2}) (rowAt_of_lift), whose O-length is at most (d_{u}me^{′}+ rc_{0}(u))e_{O}. Dividing by e_{O} proves (170).
For (iii) (theorem_n5_from_inputs in StatementOneBFromUnramified.lean:142--176 and StatementOneBChangedOfOpen.lean:271--364), replace r(·, π) by the block-diagonal integral direct sum ρ_{π} ⊕⊕^{t}_{c=1}χ_{c} using Lemma 6.12 (this preserves all polynomial identities, ranks, characteristic-polynomial membership in T, local lifting exponents, row bounds, and trivial-block conditions). The admitted reference-object datum adm51 supplies a wild-cyclotomic element g_{0} ∈ G_{E} with ε(g_{0}) = 1 + ℓ^{s0}u_{0} (u_{0} ∈ ℤ^{×}_{ℓ}, s_{0} ≥ 2 if ℓ = 2) together with orthogonal idempotents e_{B}, e_{1} and a separable split corner perturbation s on the normalized family (design_normalized_of_admitted). By admG1 and admG3, the hypotheses of Propositions 6.97 and 6.98 hold, yielding the block-ring package D_{d} with RingDef, RingTop, LocalToDisplayFree, and vcc(T_{a}, Z_{a}, π) = length_{Oa}(O_{a}/I_{a,π}) (normalized_ring_data).
We now verify all five local-to-global clauses required by realDisplayAllK_of (open_inputs_at_normalized and plugOpen3_B):
• Column lifts and off-spectrum dimension bound. At each column place u ∈ C_{a}, the left ideals Ae_{1} and AE are finite free O_{a}-lattices in subquotients of sums of r^{n}⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1}, mapping surjectively onto the 0-th block lattice L_{0} and the rank-one ideal δ_{O}O_{a} respectively. Applying LiftExponentColumn (with exponent e^{′}) lifts a basis of H_{f}^{1}(E_{u}, L_{0}) (of cardinality j_{u} = j_{W} (u)) and the unramified column homomorphism u_{l} : G_{Eu} →O_{a} (vanishing on inertia I_{u} and taking value 1 on a Frobenius element, whose image lies in H_{f}^{1} by UnramifiedTrivialH1f, unrFin_of) after multiplying by ℓ^{e′}, producing the exact matrix cocycles K_{la} and k_{0l} (colK, colk, liftCol_eve_Dd, liftCol_evE_Dd) with k_{0l}(g) · m = ℓ^{e′}δ_{O}u_{l}(g) · m on M_{1}. For every x^{′}∈X^{′} above X_{a} \ Z_{a}, the crystalline representation K_{x}^{d}_{′} has the same negative Hodge–Tate jump count as W^{′} at u (admG2, colLx), so taking L_{l} to be the preimage of H_{f}^{1}(E_{u}, K_{x}^{d}_{′}) in Map(G_{Eu}, K_{x}^{d}_{′}) yields dim_{K}(L_{l}/ im d_{l}) ≤j_{u}+dim_{K} ker d_{l}, discharging Lemma 6.6.
• Main block c = 0 and row Tate duality. By hRho_rN and selFS_of_normAt, the strict global cohomol-ogy group for M_{0} equals the Selmer module Sel_{a,π} defining s_{a,π} (with finite conditions at places over ℓ and unramified conditions outside S_{a} ∪Q_{a}, using admG4 and tateH1FinitenessAtPlacesOver). At every row place w ∈R_{a}, the dual lattice map T_{w}^{′} attached to Ae_{1} is equivariantly isomorphic to the standard lattice of T_{2}(ρ_{π}) (phiW_rhoT', rowMat_at), its propagated finite condition is the exact annihi-lator of H_{f}^{1}(E_{w}, M_{0}) under local Tate duality by BlochKatoAnnihilators and Background fact 6.14 (bKa_clause), and its enlarged row quotient length is therefore bounded by (170) (rowTieIn_of, tie_clause).
• Higher character blocks c ≥ 2. On M_{c} ≃ D(ε^{1−c}), chi_of matches the strict global cohomology group with the specified Tate-twist Selmer group defining Sha_{ℓ}(c−1) (ShaT.tieSel2_full). At every prime v ∈ S_{a} ∪Q_{a} not dividing ℓ, the wild inertia subgroup P_{v} is a pro-p group for the residual characteristic p ̸= ℓ, so every continuous homomorphism from P_{v} into a torsion ℓ-power group is trivial (wildTriv_holds, qPow_rec); combined with the tame inertia decomposition admG5 and TameGeneratorConditions, this forces unramifiedness at S_{a} and bounds the local quotient at each v ∈Q_{a} by v_{Oa}(ζ_{a,v}−1) (locPos). At row places w ∈R_{a}, admTB (with exponent b_{0}) supplies the annihilator ℓ^{b0} on Y -induced cocycles and the quotient bound (d_{w} +1)b_{0}e_{O} (tbTarget_row, tb_of_target), contributing (d_{w} + 2)b_{0}e_{O} in Lemma 6.5.
• First character block c = 1. Here u_{g} acts trivially on M_{1} ≃D. The same tame/wild inertia verifica-tion (first_local_clause_of) together with hCover ensures that every strict global class is unramified at every finite place of E. By Lemma 6.77 (vhEInChi), the strict global group has O_{a}-length at most
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
e_{O}v_{ℓ}(h_{E}).Plugging all five clauses into LocalToDisplayFree (Proposition 6.98), applying Lemma 6.8 to δ_{O} ((168)), dividing by e_{O} > 0, and substituting (i) and (ii) yields (137) (length_bound_of_theorem).
Proposition 6.100 (Conjugate row–column declarations at two and split odd primes)_{√}. Let D be a host with CM field E = F( −d), where d ≡_{√} 7 (mod 8) is a distinguished odd prime and the CM type Φ of E is determined by the chosen sign of −d( at each complex embedding. Let) a be a local index with prime ℓ satisfying either ℓ = 2, or ℓ odd with ^{ −}_{ℓ}^{d} = 1. Then for each sign ep ∈{±1} there exists a disjoint partition dc = (R_{a}, C_{a}) of the places of E above ℓ satisfying hypDecl and ambTypeD: every place in C_{a} has all its local embeddings in the ep-half of Φ, every place in R_{a} has all its local embeddings in the opposite half, and R_{a} is precisely the set of complex conjugates of C_{a} (UpperTheory.N.Two.decl_split, UpperTheory.N.decl_split).
Proof. Suppose first that ℓ = 2. Write d + 1 = 8k (k ∈ ℤ_{≥1}). Since 1^{2}+ d = 8k has 2-adic norm at most 1/8 < ‖2 · 1‖^{2}_{2} = 1/4, Hensel’s lemma gives s ∈ ℤ_{2} with s^{2} = −d (Two.exists_sqrt). In ℤ_{2}, (1 + s)(1 −s) = 8k, so one of 1 ± s is divisible by 2; since their sum is 2, both are divisible by 2 and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
√
u = (1 + s)/2 ∈ℤ_{2} satisfies u(1 −u) = 2k (Two.exists_half). In 𝒪_{E}, the element ω = (1 + −d)/2 is integral (_{√} ω^{2}−ω + 2k = 0) and satisfies ̄ω = 1 −ω. For any place w | 2 of E, its local embedding of −d equals either s or −s in ℤ_{2}, which forces all ℚ_{2}-embeddings of E_{w} to lie in a single CM-type half (determined by the sign of s). If a conjugate pair w, w^{′}= ̄w had the same sign s, then ω ∈w ⇐⇒‖u‖_{2} < 1 and 1 −ω ∈ w^{′} ⇐⇒ ‖1 −u‖_{2} < 1, while conjugacy gives ω ∈ w ⇐⇒ 1 −ω ∈ w^{′}; hence ‖u‖_{2} < 1 ⇐⇒ ‖1 −u‖_{2} < 1. Yet ‖u‖_{2}‖1 −u‖_{2} = ‖2k‖_{2} ≤ 1/2 < 1, forcing both ‖u‖_{2} < 1 and ‖1 −u‖_{2} < 1, contradicting u + (1( −u)) = 1 (Two.root_ne).
Suppose next that ℓ is odd and_{√}^{ −}_{ℓ}^{d} = 1. Hensel’s lemma gives s_{0} ∈ℤ_{ℓ} with s^{2}_{0}= −d and ‖2s_{0}‖_{ℓ}= 1. Again each place w | ℓ maps _{√}−d to either s_{0} or −s_{0}, fixing a single CM-type half for all embeddings of_{√} E_{w}. If w and w^{′}= ̄w mapped_{√} −d to the same root t ∈{±s_{0}}, then the integral element −d −t would lie in w while its conjugate − −d−t would lie in w^{′} and simultaneously evaluate to −2t with ‖−2t‖_{ℓ}= 1, a contradiction (place_type_conj).
In both cases, complex conjugation acts without fixed points on the places above ℓ and swaps the two CM-type halves (columns_xor). Defining C_{a} to be the set of places above ℓ lying in the ep-half and R_{a} to be its complement immediately gives R_{a} = C^{̄}_{a}, hypDecl, and ambTypeD.
Theorem 6.101 (Simultaneous arithmetic realization on the selected family). Assume the published local and global Galois-cohomology and p-adic Hodge hypotheses of Hypotheses_{2} (FontaineBcris, GlobalArtinReciprocity, BlochKatoLocal, LocalTateDualityK, LocalEulerCharK, LocalFinitenessK, and BhattScholzeIntegral). Let D be a host, L size data, P a parameter choice, (HW, F, Cm) a compatible Wach–Fontaine– prismatic comparison package (supplied from BhattScholzeIntegral via Lemma 6.16), X hub data, and S a compatible setup GlobalTheory.NLink.SetupAlt.
(i) Local cyclotomic package. At every rational prime ℓ, the three local cyclotomic lifting, invariant-annihilator, and trivial-block predicates LiftK, InvariantsKilledOverCyclotomic, and TBK hold with the exact exponents e_{L}, c_{0L}, and c_{BL} of Lemma 6.81 (UpperTheory.N.locAll).
(ii) Simultaneous realization at a non-twisted local index. Let a be a local index with prime ℓ∈{/ g_{0}, g_{1}}
satisfying hypL, let N satisfy the cyclotomic level condition CycAt at a, and assume a conjugate decla-ration exists for every sign ep (hdecl). Then there exists a conjugate declaration dc = (R_{a}, C_{a}) such that all six clauses of Input 6.78 hold for every π ∈Z_{a}^{good}, and consequently
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
c_{a,π} satisfies (137) with e_{L}(ℓ, N, h_{1}), c_{0L}(ℓ, N, h_{2}, 4nV ), c_{BL}(ℓ, N, h_{3}, 4nV, t) , (171)
where h_{1} = ⌊H_{lift}⌋, h_{2} = ⌊2b⌋+ 1, h_{3} = ⌊2b⌋, together with h_{u} ≤ r c_{0L}(ℓ, N, h_{2}, 4nV ) for all u ∈C_{a} and ζ_{a,v} ̸= 1 for all v ∈Q_{a} (UpperTheory.N.conclusion_split_alt).
(iii) Two-prime family bound and closed transport. In particular, at ℓ = 2 and at ℓ = 3 /∈ small(D)
(with 3 ̸= q, d), every compatible setup S satisfies the local comparison with constants A = 6000, B = 30000 (onAt_eq_two_bounds_of_setup, rowThreeAt_of_setup_alt), and every admissible family ℱ satisfies the uniform two-prime family bound (160) of Proposition 6.85 (at23_family_alt) as well as its closed linked transport (boundAtTwoThree_linked_of_recT).
Proof. Proof of (i). Fix a prime ℓ. For any finite extension K ⊂K^{′}= ℚ_{ℓ}(µ_{lcm(ℓ,N)}) (4 | N if ℓ= 2) and any finite coefficient extension L splitting K^{′}, the cyclotomic Wach-lattice comparison (HW, F, Cm) satisfies WAll (crystallineLatticeWachModuleExists_proof) and preserves crystallinity and Hodge–Tate jumps un-der restriction K ⊂K^{′}. Combining Proposition 6.62 with Lemma 6.82 (using v_{ℓ}([K^{′}: K]) ≤⌊log_{ℓ}N⌋+1) proves LiftK with exponent e_{L}(ℓ, N, h) = 32(2hs + 1) + L_{1} (liftK_of). Corollary 6.69 directly gives In-variantsKilledOverCyclotomic with exponent c_{0L}(ℓ, N, h, n) = 20(n + 1)L_{1} (invariants_killed_over_
cyclotomic_subfield_of_admissible). Corollary 6.76 (using BlochKatoLocal, LocalTateDualityK, and Lo-calEulerCharK) directly gives TBK with exponent c_{BL}(ℓ, N, h, n, t) = 40(t + 1)(n + 1)L_{1} (tbK_of, TwistK.tbe_all). This proves UpperTheory.N.locAll.
Proof of (ii). We assemble all 36 clauses of EmbeddingTypes.admitted on the selected setup S (Con-clusionSplitOfHub.lean:33--82). From S.facts (NormChoiceFacts) and S.par we obtain AdmJAlt, whence holds_all_alt produces JumpConditions, fixing a global sign ep together with the cloud-centre, low-jump, absolute-bound, and dual-cloud estimates. Evaluating hdecl at ep yields the conjugate declaration dc = (R_{a}, C_{a}) with hypDecl and ambTypeD. Fix π ∈Z_{a}^{good}⊂Z_{a}.
(1) Point setup and ambient subquotients. From S.facts and S.canon (via split_bound_of_params_alt), set_pt_of_setup_not_twisted yields all 17 fields of SetPt: admG1, admG2, admG3, admG4, admG5, TameGeneratorConditions (including ζ_{a,v} ̸= 1 for v ∈ Q_{a}), admG6, admBK, FamilyContinuous, admSS, SemisimpleDecomposition, CyclotomicInertiaImage, LocalCoefficientCompatibility, CyclotomicCompletionAdmissible, FontaineAtPlacesOverL, admH2, and UnramifiedClassFieldBound. Then amb_of_setPt extracts ambSub (subquotients of sums of r ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1} remain crystalline with the same jump set), ambCont, and ColumnH0Vanishing.
(2) Signed jump shape and tame inertia. admG2_of_setup_jumps combines DeRhamFamilyAwayAlt and the jump-set dictionary with FontaineBcris to prove crystallinity of r and r ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1} and the signed ShapeJumps formula at every place above ℓ. admG5_of_setup uses S.facts to verify the two-block tame inertia decomposition at Q_{a} and the cohomology vanishing of residual twists ̄ρ_{π}(ε^{a}) at S_{a}.
(3) Crystallinity and nonzero jumps of W^{′} and T_{2}. decomposition_fontaine_at_places_over_l deduces from the semisimple decomposition at π and Fontaine admissibility that χ^{−}_{1}^{1}, the twisted dual family r^{du}, W^{′}, and T_{2} are all crystalline at every place above ℓ. decomposition_local_above verifies from the jump conditions that for both W^{′} and T_{2}, every τ-jump multiset has at most r elements, lies in [−h_{2}, h_{2}] (h_{2} = ⌊2b⌋+ 1), and excludes 0, yielding JumpsNoZero for both W^{′} and T_{2}.
(4) Quantitative lifting, invariant, and trivial-block bounds from (i). Because each E_{w} has [E_{w} : ℚ_{ℓ}] ≤ [E : ℚ] = 2f = 4n, the union of the jump sets over all embeddings τ : E_{w} ↪→L has cardinality at most 4nV = 2fV . Applying part (i):
• LiftK gives both LiftExponentColumn (for r ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1}) and LiftExponentDualPlaces (for r^{du}) with exponent e_{L}(ℓ, N, h_{1}) (lift_exponent_admissible_cols_rows_of_crystalline);
• InvariantsKilledOverCyclotomic applied to JumpsNoZero for T_{2} and W^{′} gives H0ColumnLengthBound for T_{2} and the column bound h_{u} ≤ r c_{0L}(ℓ, N, h_{2}, 4nV ) for W^{′} (invariants_length_admissible_of_nonzero_jumps, length_invariants_Wprime_divisible_le_of_nonzero_jumps);
• hodgeTateJumpWindow_of_jumpSets places all jumps of r_{π} ⊗χ^{−}_{1}^{1} in [−h_{3}, h_{3}] (t ≤h_{3} = ⌊2b⌋), so TBK yields admTB with exponent c_{BL}(ℓ, N, h_{3}, 4nV, t) (block_condition_at_places_of_jump_window).
(5) Remaining ambient, reference, and local-cohomology clauses. charpoly_span_and_hom_relations_of_admissible supplies the span and relation clauses from admG1. ambT2_of_deRham_family supplies ambT2, ambW, ambFil, and ambBlock. closingFamilyX_alt_alt (using FontaineBcris and LocalFinitenessK) supplies ambDual and H1fFiniteRankTorsion. admissibleAtGoodPoints_of_coefRing_taken_at_live combines the Chebotarev density theorem (cheb_holds), the reference-family enlargement TakenAll (Proposition 6.31), residual absolute irreducibility from S.facts.rhoBar (resid-ualAbsIrredGoodPoint_of_residualIrred), rational Frobenius conjugacy, character cancellation (Lemma 6.13), and reference transport (Proposition 6.25) to produce adm51 (exists_globalObjects_
every_family_wild). Finally, blochKatoAnnihilator_all_of_tateDuality_eulerChar and tateFinitenessAll_of_localTateDuality supply BlochKatoAnnihilators and tateH1FinitenessAtPlacesOver from Hypotheses_{2}; and unramifiedTrivialH1f_of_decl shows Z_{unr}^{1} (G_{Eu}, L) = Z_{f}^{1}(G_{Eu}, L) on the trivial representation at every u ∈ C_{a} because unramified homomorphisms are crystalline (Z_{unr}^{1} ⊂Z_{f}^{1}) and nonzero while dim_{L} H_{f}^{1}(G_{Eu}, L) = 1 (UnramifiedTrivial.unrTriv).
Proposition 6.99 now yields (171), and the remaining two assertions of (ii) were established in steps (4) and (1) above.
Proof of (iii). For every column place u ∈C_{a} and every 1 ≤j < t, the inertia group at u contains an element g with ε(g) = 1 + ℓ^{s0} (s_{0} ≥1, and s_{0} ≥2 when ℓ= 2). Every G_{Eu}-invariant element of D(ε^{−j}) is killed by ε(g)^{j}−1, whose O_{a}-valuation is e_{O}(s_{0} + v_{ℓ}(j)) by Lemma 6.8; hence the normalized column invariant exponent satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
h_{0} ≤ max s_{0} + v_{ℓ}(j) ≤s_{0} + ⌊log_{ℓ}t⌋ (172)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1≤j<t
(UpperTheory.N.h0_le in LenUnitInvariantsLe.lean:55--71).
Now let ℓ= 2 (onAt_eq_two_bounds_of_setup). By the host conditions, 2 ∈ small(D) is disjoint from {g_{0}, g_{1}}, 4 | Q_{S} | N supplies CycAt and s_{0} = v_{2}(Q_{S}) = v_{2}(N) ≥ 2, and Proposition 6.100 supplies hdecl. Part (ii), (172), and the finiteness/killing hypotheses S.kill and S.sha discharge all hypotheses of
Lemma 6.81, yielding the local bound with A = 6000 and B = 30000. Likewise, at ℓ= 3 /∈ small(D) (rowThreeAt_of_setup_alt( )), the host conditions 3 ̸= q, d, 3 /∈{g_{0}, g_{1}}, and 60 ≤ splitBound(D) imply 3 ∤N,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
−d
_{3} = 1, s_{0} = 1, and unramifiedness at 3; Proposition 6.100 again supplies hdecl, so part (ii), (172), and Lemma 6.81 yield the same constants A = 6000 and B = 30000. Proposition 6.85 (boundAtTwoThree_of_local_bounds_at_two_three, at23_family_alt) converts these two pointwise estimates into the uniform two-prime family bound (160) for every admissible family ℱ, and Lemma 6.89 (boundAtTwoThree_linked_of_recT) transports it to every selected row and admissible extension.
Remark 6.102 (Audit of interfaces and acyclic dependency order). Propositions 6.97–6.100 and Theo-rem 6.101 completely close AR14-SIMULTANEOUS-REALIZATION, discharging Input 6.78 and Input 6.1 on every compatible setup SetupAlt. The upstream inputs and downstream consumption fall into a strictly acyclic order:
(a) Standard published arithmetic theorems (Hypotheses_{2}): Fontaine’s B_{cris} exact sequence and regularity (FontaineBcris), global Artin reciprocity (GlobalArtinReciprocity, Lemma 6.77), Bloch–Kato local finite-condition duality and dimension formula (BlochKatoLocal, Background fact 6.14), local Tate duality, local Euler characteristic, and local finiteness (LocalTateDualityK, LocalEulerCharK, LocalFinitenessK), and Bhatt–Scholze integral prismatic F-crystals (BhattScholzeIntegral, Background fact 6.15, which constructs (HW, F, Cm) via Lemma 6.16), together with degree-one Chebotarev density (cheb_holds, proved internally from primes in cyclotomic ray classes).
(b) Upstream AbelianDeRham input and strictly downstream host/family consumption: Theorem 6.101 (UpperTheory.N.at23_family_alt and UpperTheory.N.boundAtTwoThree_linked_of_recT in At23OfAll.lean:19--26) is universally quantified over all families ℱ and all supplied setups SetupAlt (BoundAtTwoThreeFamilyFon.lean:25--28); it uses only Hypotheses_{2} and does not require constructing any SetupAlt, host, or HypsAlt bundle. The upstream AbelianDeRham input feeding TwistedTransport in Proposition 6.95 is discharged in Proposition 10.32 and Theorems 10.37 and 10.43 (Section 10). Downstream in Proposition 17.4 (Section 17), UpperTheory.GalC.final_alt_alt (CFinal.lean:19--23) constructs the SetupAlt witnesses on candidate member families from SerN and UpperTheory.GalS.galois_preconditions_at_mem to upgrade the universal bound BoundAtTwoThreeFamilyFonAlt to S0.NL, while large_unramified_exponent_bundles_exist_alt independently supplies nonempty linked bundles before nonempty_hyps_of_allRows_alt extracts HypsAlt.
Branch closure status. Every arithmetic comparison, local cyclotomic lifting, invariant-annihilator, trivial-block, prescribed definite automorphic realization, and simultaneous family-realization obligation in Sec-tion 6 is now proved (including AR-invariant, AR-trivial-block, AR7-PRESCRIBED-AUTOMORPHIC-LATTICE in Subsection 6.6, and AR14-SIMULTANEOUS-REALIZATION discharging Inputs 6.78 and 6.1 universally over every supplied compatible setup SetupAlt in Subsection 6.7, using only Hypotheses_{2}). Outside this section, the upstream AbelianDeRham input to TwistedTransport in Proposition 6.95 is discharged in Proposition 10.32 and Theorems 10.37 and 10.43 (Section 10); downstream consumption of BoundAtTwoThreeFamilyFonAlt on candidate SetupAlt data (via final_alt_alt) and independent existence of nonempty linked bundles feeding HypsAlt are assembled in Proposition 17.4 and Theorem 17.5 (Section 17).