Section 6 · PDF pages 241–242
The uniform arithmetic estimate at two and three
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
6 The uniform arithmetic estimate at two and three
The arithmetic estimate needed here compares a congruence ideal with a Selmer module. Its constants must be chosen before the host, the local representation and its good eigencharacter are chosen. An estimate for one fixed representation would not suffice. We first specify the quantities, then prove the numerical and uniformity arguments, and finally identify the comparison assertion used in the source.
Fix a CM field E with [E : ℚ] = 2f. The host supplies positive integers m, r, t, n, V satisfying
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 ≤m ≤f ≤r ≤t, t ≤V ≤2t, f = 2n. (133)
There are two distinguished odd primes q, d, a positive integer Q_{S} coprime to qd, and a conductor
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
N = Q_{S}qd, Q_{S} ≤n^{2}. (134)The small primes of the host are the prime divisors of Q_{S}. In particular 2 is small and 4 | Q_{S}. The hosts used at the third prime satisfy 3 ̸= q, d. A local index a specifies a rational prime ℓ, a coefficient ring O_{a}, and a finite set X_{a} of eigencharacters. The ring O_{a} is the ring of integers of a finite extension of ℚ_{ℓ}; the associated
integral Hecke algebra is a separating subalgebra T_{a} ⊂ O_{a}^{Xa}. There are subsets Z_{a}^{good} ⊂ Z_{a} ⊂ X_{a}. The representations below are the compatible integral Galois representations attached to these data, rather than arbitrary representations with the same dimension.
This description of O_{a} follows from the actual coefficient-ring hypotheses. They make it a discrete valuation domain, finite over ℤ_{ℓ}. The map from ℤ_{ℓ} is injective: a nonzero prime kernel would be (ℓ), making O_{a} finite over the finite field 𝔽_{ℓ}, hence a field, contrary to the discrete valuation ring hypothesis. Its fraction field is therefore finite over ℚ_{ℓ}. Every element of O_{a} is integral over ℤ_{ℓ}; conversely an element of its fraction field integral over ℤ_{ℓ} is integral over O_{a} and lies in O_{a}, since a discrete valuation ring is integrally closed. Thus it is exactly the integral closure of ℤ_{ℓ} in that finite extension.
For π ∈Z_{a} let I_{a,π} ⊂O_{a} be the ideal consisting of the values u(π) of elements u ∈T_{a} which vanish on X_{a} \ Z_{a}. For a finite-length O_{a}-module put
length_{Oa} M
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
λ_{a}(M) = c_{a,π} = λ_{a}(O_{a}/I_{a,π}).length_{Oa}(O_{a}/ℓO_{a})^{,}
The denominator is the positive ramification index of O_{a}/ℤ_{ℓ}. The Selmer quantity s_{a,π} is λ_{a}(Sel_{a,π}), where the divisible representation is the lattice quotient of the source’s W^{′} representation and the local conditions are its specified finite conditions at the places over ℓ and its unramified conditions outside the selected sets S_{a} ∪Q_{a}. The chosen finite conditions, and not unrestricted H^{1}, are essential in this definition. Write
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
W_{ℓ}= λ_{a}(Sha_{ℓ}(j)), H_{ℓ}= v_{ℓ}(h_{E}), ϵ_{ℓ}= ℓ^{−2},
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1≤j<t
with the source’s fixed Tate twists in Sha_{ℓ}(j), and with h_{E} = # Cl(E). The compatible setup requires these Selmer and Sha modules to have finite length. No infinite length is interpreted as an ordinary finite length in this section.
The congruence colength is finite as well. For each x ∈ X_{a} \ Z_{a}, separation gives u_{x} ∈ T_{a} with u_{x}(π) ̸= u_{x}(x). The product of u_{x} −u_{x}(x) 1 over this finite complement vanishes off Z_{a} and has nonzero value at π. Thus I_{a,π} ̸= 0. A nonzero ideal in the discrete valuation ring O_{a} is a positive or zero power of its maximal ideal, and its quotient has finite length. This also covers an empty complement, when the product is 1 and I_{a,π} = O_{a}.