Skip to content

Section 6.2 · PDF pages 275–297

The reference-family construction from result 6.45

The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.

Lemma 6.45 (The period intersection and lattice sandwich). For the cyclotomic prism lattice, put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
A = O ⊗_{ℤℓ}W(k)[[u]], E = (A[1/u])^{∧}_{ℓ},
B = O ⊗_{ℤℓ}A_{inf}, C = O ⊗_{ℤℓ}W(C^{♭}),

using the embeddings in Lemma 6.16. Then E ∩B = A inside C. Let D be a free E-module embedded in C ⊗_{O} T, with scalar extension equal to that tensor product and with the compatible Frobenius. If N ⊂D is free over A, spans D and is Frobenius-commensurable by powers of Q_{s}, then there is h such that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X_{s}^{h}N ⊂B ⊗_{O}T, X_{s}^{h}(D ∩(B ⊗_{O}T)) ⊂N.

In particular any two such lattices are commensurable by powers of X_{s}.

Proof. First take O = ℤ_{ℓ}. Modulo ℓ, the intersection in question is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
k((̄u)) ∩O_{C}^{♭} = k[[̄u]].

Indeed ̄u has strictly positive valuation and every nonzero coefficient from k has valuation zero. The valua-tion of a Laurent series is therefore its lowest exponent times the valuation of ̄u, so it is integral exactly when that exponent is nonnegative. An element in the characteristic zero intersection can accordingly be reduced modulo ℓ and lifted to W(k)[[u]]. Subtract that lift and divide by ℓ. The quotient is again in both rings: each ambient inclusion is saturated for ℓ, as its reduction modulo ℓ is injective. Repeating gives compatible ap-proximations by elements of W(k)[[u]] modulo every ℓ^{n}. Completeness and separatedness give the asserted equality. For general O, expand in a finite ℤ_{ℓ}-basis of O. The intersection is taken coordinate by coordinate in that basis, reducing it to the case just proved.

Choose an A-basis of N and an O-basis of T. Write Z for the square matrix of the former in the latter inside C ⊗_{O} T. It is invertible over C by the scalar-extension premise. Common Frobenius denominators give integral matrices F, P and exponents h, e with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Q^{h}_{s}φ(Z) = ZF, φ(Z)P = Q^{e}_{s}Z.

Since φ(X_{s}) = X_{s}Q_{s}, the first equation says

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
φ(X_{s}^{h}Z) = (X_{s}^{h}Z)F.

Apply Lemma 6.44 with R = O_{C}^{♭}, a perfect valuation ring, to conclude that X_{s}^{h}Z has entries in B. This is the first inclusion. The second matrix equality, multiplied by the two inverses, gives Q^{e}_{s}φ(Z^{−1}) = PZ^{−1}. Hence

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
φ(X_{s}^{e}Z^{−1}) = P(X_{s}^{e}Z^{−1}).

The same lemma makes this matrix integral over B too. For y ∈D with image in B ⊗T, its N-coordinates after multiplication by X_{s}^{e} therefore belong to B. They also belong to E, because y ∈ D = EN. The intersection equality puts those coordinates in A, giving the second inclusion. Increase the two exponents to their maximum. For two lattices, apply the first inclusion to one and the second to the other; their sum of exponents gives the claimed power commensurability in each direction.

For completeness the etale modules in this construction have the exactness used above. Before adding O-coefficients, E_{0} = (W(k)[[u]][1/u])^{∧}_{ℓ} is a complete DVR with uniformizer ℓ and residue field k((̄u)): an element with nonzero residue is invertible by completeness, and every nonzero element is an ℓ-power times such a unit. The ring W(C^{♭}) is torsion-free over E_{0} and has nonzero reduction modulo ℓ. A torsion-free module over a DVR is flat, as follows by testing the principal ideals; the nonzero residue test makes this extension faithfully flat. Tensoring by the finite free coefficient algebra O identifies the resulting rings with E and C, and preserves faithful flatness. Thus exactness can be checked after extending to C. There the prism comparison identifies the maps with the given maps of O-lattices tensored with C, which preserve their exactness. The latter tensor is exact since C is obtained from the torsion-free ℤ_{ℓ}-module W(C^{♭}) by base change to O. A short exact sequence of crystalline lattices therefore gives the surjective etale map required in Lemma 6.41.

Together with the period sandwich, this verifies the extra power-commensurability premise in

Lemma 6.43 for these realized period modules. The initial common u- and ℓ-power cokernel control used in the height argument is consequently proved for this construction.

Lemma 6.46 (The filtered Laurent lattice criterion). Let D be a finite-dimensional K-space over a char-acteristic zero field, and let Λ be a full finite free K[[t]]-lattice in D((t)). Suppose Λ is stable under the automorphism (∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Γ t^{j}d_{j})=∑η^{j}t^{j}d_{j},
j j

where η ∈ K^{×} has infinite order. Let B^{+} be a complete DVR containing K[[t]] such that t maps to a uniformizer times a unit and K embeds in its residue field. Suppose a period identification carries B^{+}Λ onto a specified lattice L^{+}, and endow D with the filtration

Fil^{i}D = {d ∈D : d ∈t^{i}L^{+}}

under that same identification. Then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{{∑ }}

Λ = t^{j}d_{j} : d_{j} ∈ Fil^{−j}D .

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{j≥c }

For crystalline periods B^{+} = B_{dR}^{+} and L^{+} = V ⊗B_{dR}^{+}, this is the ordinary Hodge filtration with the displayed sign convention.

Proof. Choose a basis of D. Since Λ is a full lattice, there are integers c < m with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
t^{m}D[[t]] ⊂Λ ⊂t^{c}D[[t]].

These follow by bounding the Laurent orders of the finitely many entries in a basis matrix of Λ and its inverse. For c ≤j < m, the distinct numbers η^{c}, . . . , η^{m−1} admit the Lagrange projector

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏_{z −η}h
P_{j}(z) =_{jh} ∈K[z].
c≤_{h}h<m_{̸=j}^{η−η}

If f =∑_{h}t^{h}d_{h} ∈Λ, stability gives P_{j}(Γ)f ∈Λ. Modulo t^{m}D[[t]] this is exactly t^{j}d_{j}. The error belongs to Λ, so t^{j}d_{j} ∈Λ. For j ≥m the same assertion follows from the first inclusion, and for j < c the coefficient is zero. Conversely, if every monomial of a bounded-below series belongs to Λ, all its finite partial sums do. The lattice Λ is t-adically closed: its inverse basis matrix carries it to the closed module K[[t]]^{a}. Taking the limit puts the full series in Λ. Thus membership is coefficientwise membership of monomials.

Membership in Λ is detected after extension to B^{+}. Indeed, in a Λ-basis its coordinates lie in K((t)); such a coordinate lies in B^{+} exactly when its Laurent order is nonnegative, which is exactly membership in K[[t]]. Consequently

t^{j}d ∈Λ ⇐⇒ t^{j}d ∈L^{+} ⇐⇒ d ∈ Fil^{−j}D.

Combine this with the coefficientwise assertion just proved.

At a primitive cyclotomic point the formal parameter can be taken proportional to log((1 + u)/ζ). The cyclotomic action fixes the coefficients and rescales this parameter by η, as in the proof of Lemma 6.42. Also X_{s}(ζ −1) = ζ^{ℓs−1}−1 ̸= 0. Thus the period sandwich identifies the completed lattice there with V ⊗B_{dR}^{+}, once its formal expansion is identified with the crystalline coefficient space and the specified de Rham embedding. The lemma then proves precisely the filtered coefficient description used in Lemma 6.40. The coefficientwise filtration conclusion has thus been reduced to that actual period identification. It is verified below in Lemma 6.50.

Background fact 6.47 (The natural integral Herr comparison). Let K/ℚ_{ℓ} be finite and suppose Γ_{K} = Gal(K(µ_{ℓ}∞)/K) is procyclic and torsion-free, with generator γ. For a finite free ℤ_{ℓ}-lattice T with continu-ous G_{K}-action, let D_{K}(T) be its etale cyclotomic (φ, Γ)-module. The complex

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
D_{K}(T) −−→^{d0} D_{K}(T)^{2} −−→^{d1} D_{K}(T),
d_{0}(m) = ((φ −1)m, (γ −1)m),
d_{1}(y, z) = (γ −1)y −(φ −1)z

computes continuous H^{i}(G_{K}, T), naturally in T. Its H^{1} comparison is linear over every finite coefficient ring acting equivariantly on T.

The finite-torsion assertion is L. Herr, Sur la cohomologie galoisienne des corps p-adiques, Bulletin de la Societe mathematique de France 126 (1998), 563–600, Theorem 2.1, printed p. 572; the etale equivalence is recalled as Theorem 1.2 there. The inverse-limit passage is also explained on printed p. 565.^{8} Here K = K_{0}(ζ_{ℓ}s), with s ≥1 for odd ℓ and s ≥2 for ℓ= 2, so its cyclotomic quotient is 1+ℓ^{s}ℤ_{ℓ}, a torsion-free copy of ℤ_{ℓ}. No finite torsion factor is being omitted from this complex.

For clarity, the passage from torsion to the displayed lattice statement introduces no bound on a torsion exponent. Apply the torsion theorem to T/ℓ^{n}T. Reduction on the terms of its etale complex is surjective, be-cause the etale-module functor is exact. Its degree-zero cohomology is the finite group (T/ℓ^{n}T)^{GK}. These finite groups satisfy the Mittag–Leffler condition: for each fixed n their descending transition images stabi-lize. The inverse-limit exact sequence for complexes therefore has zero first derived-limit term in degree one. Its H^{1} is the inverse limit of the torsion H^{1} groups. The same argument for continuous cochains computes H^{1}(G_{K}, T): continuous maps to each finite quotient lift to locally constant maps to T, and T = lim T/ℓ^{n}T.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
←−

Naturality of the torsion comparisons passes to the limit. Applying it to multiplication by each coefficient proves the asserted coefficient linearity.

The prism lattice above gives this etale module: Q_{s} is a unit in E, so its linearized Frobenius is invertible there; after extension to the Witt period ring its realization is T, by the stated prism comparison. Fontaine’s equivalence therefore identifies it with D_{K}(T), including its maps. This verifies the ordinary cohomology comparison used in Lemma 6.60. Identifying which integral pairs represent the finite crystalline condition requires a further argument. It is proved in Lemma 6.49, and the bounded converse needed for lifting is proved in Lemma 6.55.

^{8}Publisher primary text: https://smf.emath.fr/system/files/2017-08/smf_bull_126_563-600.pdf.

Lemma 6.48 (A convergent solution of the cyclotomic difference equation). Work over a finite extension L/ℚ_{ℓ} with integers O. Set γ(u) = (1 + u)^{η}−1, where v_{ℓ}(η −1) = s ≥ 1 and s ≥ 2 if ℓ = 2. Let N_{i} = O[[u]]^{a} be cyclic coefficient components with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
γ_{N}(v) = G_{i}γ(v), φ_{N}(v) = F_{i}φ(v), F_{i} = Q^{−}_{s}^{m}P_{i},

where G_{i} ≡1 (mod u) is integral, P_{i} is integral, F_{i} is invertible over L[[u]], and the two actions commute. Let J be a finite multiset and Λ =∏_{j∈J}φ^{j}Q_{s}. Suppose y_{i} ∈Λ^{−1}N_{i}, z_{i} ∈uN_{i} and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
G_{i}γ(y_{i}) −y_{i} = F_{i}φ(z_{i−1}) −z_{i}.

There are w_{i} ∈L[[u]]^{a}, with w_{i}(0) = 0, such that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
G_{i}γ(w_{i}) −w_{i} = z_{i},

and every entry of log(1 + u)^{m+|J|}w_{i} converges on the whole open unit disc.

Proof. First, any integral matrix H(u) with H(0) = 1 has a unique formal matrix U(0) = 1 satisfying Hγ(U) = U. Use t = log(1 + u) near zero. At degree n ≥ 1 the equation determines U_{n} from earlier coefficients by division by η^{n}−1, which is nonzero. This proves existence and uniqueness coefficient by coefficient. It also gives a positive convergence radius. Indeed the coefficients of H(e^{t}−1) have norm at most c^{n}, where c = ℓ^{1/(ℓ−1)}, by v_{ℓ}(n!) ≤ n/(ℓ−1) and the integral coefficients of H. The lifting-the-exponent formula gives |η^{n}−1|^{−}_{ℓ}^{1}= ℓ^{s+vℓ(n)}. Induction in the coefficient equation therefore gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
‖U_{n}‖≤c^{n}ℓ^{ns+vℓ(n!)}.

For the term involving the coefficient of H of degree k, use (n −k + 1)s ≤ns and v_{ℓ}((n −k)!) + v_{ℓ}(n) ≤ v_{ℓ}(n!). This exponential bound gives a positive radius, and the convergent inverse change t = log(1 + u) gives a positive radius in u. The inverse matrix exists formally and also converges on a sufficiently small disc, since U(0) = 1. The identical coefficient recursion shows that every column fixed by Hγ equals U times its constant column.

Apply this construction to the block matrices

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
H_{i} =(^{G}_{0}^{iz}_{1}^{i}), A^{0}_{i} =(^{F}_{0}^{iy}_{1}^{i}).

The cocycle identity and the commuting actions say exactly H_{i}γ(A^{0}_{i}) = A_{i}^{0}φ(H_{i−1}). Let H_{i}γ(U_{i}) = U_{i}, U_{i}(0) = 1. Every column of A^{0}_{i}φ(U_{i−1}) is consequently fixed by H_{i}γ, so

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
A^{0}_{i}φ(U_{i−1}) = U_{i}C_{i}

for a constant invertible matrix C_{i} over L. Invertibility follows by taking constant terms, since A^{0}_{i} and U_{i} are invertible as formal matrices. The last row of U_{i} is (0, 1): its entries are fixed by the scalar action t →→ηt and hence are constant, with these prescribed constant values. If v_{i} is the upper part of its last column, the last-column equation gives G_{i}γ(v_{i})+z_{i} = v_{i}. Thus w_{i} = −v_{i} has the required difference equation and zero constant term.

It remains to continue this small-disc solution. Put X_{s} = (1 + u)^{ℓs−1}−1 and

_{τ =} log(1 + u)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{Xs} , b = m + |J|.

The function τ converges on the open unit disc, because

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{τ = ℓ1−s} ∑(−1)^{n}X_{s}^{n}
_{n≥0} n + 1

and ‖X_{s}‖_{r} < 1 for every 0 < r < 1. The identity φ(X_{s}) = X_{s}Q_{s} gives τ = ℓ^{−1}Q_{s}φ(τ). Iterating it shows, for every j ≥0, that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{j}^{τ} = ℓ^{−j−1}((∏φ^{h}Q_{s}))φ^{j+1}(τ)
^{φQs} h<j

also converges throughout that disc. In particular τ^{|J|}/Λ does.

Multiply the top a rows of U_{i} by τ^{b}, leaving the last row unchanged, and call the resulting matrix V_{i}. Its Frobenius relation becomes

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{−b} |J|_{b} )
V_{i} = A_{i}φ(V_{i−1})C_{i}^{−1}, A_{i} =^{ℓQ}_{0}^{sPi(τ/Λ)(Λ}_{1}^{yi)} .

This follows by conjugating A^{0}_{i} with diag(τ^{ b}1, 1) and its Frobenius image; the scalar identity is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|J|

τ^{b}/(Q^{m}_{s}φ(τ^{ b})) = ℓ^{−b}Q_{s}. All entries of A_{i} converge on the open unit disc, by the preceding identities and the integrality of P_{i}, Λy_{i}.

For any 0 < r < 1, substitution by φ(u) contracts the Gauss radius to at most

h(r) = max(ℓ^{−1}r, r^{ℓ}) < r.

The iterates h^{n}(r) tend to zero: their decreasing limit would otherwise be a positive fixed point below 1, which the displayed formula excludes. Iterate the relation for V_{i} until the radius h^{n}(r) is inside the common small convergence disc of the finitely many V_{i}. It expresses V_{i} on the radius-r disc as a finite product of the convergent matrices A_{i}, φ(A_{i−1}), . . ., one convergent substituted V_{i−n} and constant matrices. Therefore V_{i} converges on that disc. Since r < 1 was arbitrary, τ^{b}w_{i} converges everywhere on the open unit disc. Multiplication by the polynomial X_{s}^{b} gives the asserted convergence of log(1 + u)^{b}w_{i}.

Lemma 6.49 (Integral Wach pairs give finite crystalline classes). Use the actual cyclotomic prism and its Witt and crystalline period embeddings as above. Let T be crystalline and N its integral lattice. If a Herr cocycle satisfies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
y ∈Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N, z ∈uN, (γ −1)y = (φ −1)z,

then its class in H^{1}(G_{K}, T) maps to zero in H^{1}(G_{K}, V ⊗B_{cris}). It therefore belongs to the integral finite crystalline condition, defined as the preimage of the rational finite condition in H^{1}(G_{K}, T).

Proof. Write y, z in an N-basis. A common Frobenius denominator gives the matrices in the preceding lemma, with J consisting of M copies of 0. It gives formal coefficients w with (γ −1)w = z after the semilinear basis action, and a power of log(1+u) makes these coefficients convergent on the open unit disc.

These convergent series have a crystalline period evaluation. Indeed u maps to π_{s} = [ϵ^{1/ℓs}] −1 in A_{inf}. In its divided-power envelope A_{cris}, a fixed power of π_{s} belongs to ℓA_{cris}: modulo ℓ its ℓ^{s}th power is µ = [ϵ] −1, and µ^{ℓ} is divisible by ℓ because µ is a multiple of the divided-power ideal generator. For a series converging at every radius below 1, its coefficient denominators grow more slowly than any fixed exponential. Substitution of this topologically nilpotent π_{s} therefore converges in A_{cris}[1/ℓ]: if π_{s}^{d}∈ℓA_{cris}, choose a coefficient growth rate smaller than ℓ^{1/d}. The series log(1+π_{s}) is t/ℓ^{s}, invertible in B_{cris}. Dividing by its indicated power gives an evaluation w^{′} of w in V ⊗B_{cris}. The construction commutes with the Galois action on convergent series and with the integral period embedding.

We give explicitly the cohomology representative and its period coboundary. Extend z from the generator to a continuous cyclotomic cocycle by

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
z_{γ}a =∑(^{a} )(γ −1)^{n}z (a ∈ℤ_{ℓ}).
n≥0^{n + 1}

This converges in the (ℓ, u)-adic topology of N. In fact (γ −1) raises that topology by one: on u^{j}N its leading scalar is η^{j}−1, divisible by ℓ^{s}, and the remaining terms have one higher u-order. The binomial coefficients are integral. The cocycle law and (φ −1)z_{g} = (g −1)y hold for integer powers and then for all a by continuity. Inflate this cocycle along G_{K} →Γ_{K}; in particular z_{g} = 0 on its kernel. This defines a cocycle for G_{K} with values in its etale period module. The evaluated w^{′} is fixed by that kernel, since its coefficients and the integral lattice basis are fixed there. The difference equation, first on the generator and then on its dense integer powers, gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(g −1)w^{′}= z_{g}^{cris}.

Over the Witt ring W(C^{♭}), Frobenius minus the identity is surjective. Reduce first modulo ℓ, solve the Artin–Schreier equation in the algebraically closed field C^{♭}, and successively correct modulo ℓ^{n}; com-pleteness gives a solution. Apply this coordinatewise in a ℤ_{ℓ}-basis of T to choose b with (φ −1)b = y. Then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{g} = z_{g} −(g −1)b

is Frobenius-fixed, hence belongs to T. It is continuous and satisfies the cocycle law. This is the Herr class of (y, z); changing b changes it by a T-coboundary.

To evaluate b in crystalline periods, choose h such that X_{s}^{h}N has integral A_{inf}-coordinates, using

Lemma 6.45. Put d = h + M and Z = X_{s}^{d}b. Its Frobenius equation is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
φZ = Q^{d}_{s}Z + φ(X_{s}^{d})y.

The last term has integral A_{inf}-coordinates, since y ∈Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N and φ(X_{s}^{d}) = X_{s}^{d}Q_{s}^{d}. Lemma 6.44 puts Z itself in those integral coordinates. The crystalline image of X_{s} is [ϵ^{1/ℓ}]−1, a unit in B_{cris}; indeed its product with the ideal generator is µ, which is inverted there. Evaluate Z and divide by that unit’s dth power to obtain b^{′}. Galois equivariance and the representative formula now give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{g} ⊗1 = (g −1)(w^{′}−b^{′}) (g ∈G_{K}).

This is the required crystalline period coboundary.

Lemma 6.50 (The actual crystalline formal expansion). For the realized cyclotomic prism lattice N(T), let ζ be a primitive ℓ^{s}th root of unity in a finite coefficient extension and put t_{ζ} = log((1 + u)/ζ). The formal expansion of N(T) at u = ζ −1, expressed in its crystalline coefficient space, is a full lattice in D (V )((t )) whose extension to B^{+} is V ⊗B_{dR}^{+}. Its elements are precisely the bounded-below series ∑cris ζ

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
dR

_{j}t_{ζ}^{j}d_{j} with d_{j} ∈ Fil^{−j} D_{dR}(V ), in the specified coefficient and de Rham component. Moreover

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(γ −1)N(T) ⊂X_{s}N(T).

Proof. Enlarge coefficients to split the finite unramified coefficient algebra. All assertions can be checked on its cyclic components; integral divisibility will be descended at the end. In an integral basis let G_{i} be the matrix of γ and let F_{i} be that of Frobenius. We know G_{i}(0) = 1, and there are nonnegative integers m, h with Q^{m}_{s}F_{i} and Q^{h}_{s}F^{ −}_{i}^{1} integral. These are the two commensurability bounds of the prism lattice, without yet using a Hodge bound.

The coefficient recursion in the proof of Lemma 6.48 gives the unique matrix U_{i}(0) = 1 satisfying G_{i}γ(U_{i}) = U_{i}. It and its inverse have a positive convergence radius. Commutativity with Frobenius gives

F_{i}φ(U_{i−1}) = U_{i}C_{i}, C_{i} ∈ GL_{a}(L).

Indeed the columns on the left are γ-invariant, so the same uniqueness calculation expresses them as U_{i} times constant columns; the constant matrix is invertible by evaluation at zero. Put τ = log(1 + u)/X_{s} as above. Since τ/φτ = Q_{s}/ℓ, these identities imply

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
τ^{m}U_{i} = ℓ^{−m}(Q^{m}_{s}F_{i})φ(τ^{ m}U_{i−1})C_{i}^{−1},
τ^{h}U_{i}^{−1}= ℓ^{−h}C_{i}φ(τ^{h}U_{i}^{−}_{−}^{1}_{1})(Q^{h}_{s}F^{ −}_{i}^{1}).

Both coefficient matrices on the right are analytic on the open unit disc. Iterating the strict radius contraction r →→ max(ℓ^{−1}r, r^{ℓ}), exactly as in the preceding continuation proof, proves that τ^{m}U_{i} and τ^{h}U_{i}^{−1} converge throughout that disc. Thus U_{i} and its inverse are meromorphic there, with poles of finite order only at zeros of τ.

Let Z_{i} be the period matrix of the chosen N(T)-basis in a T-basis. The two period-sandwich inclusions show that Z_{i} and its inverse have entries in B_{cris}: a power of X_{s} makes them integral, and X_{s} is a unit there. The series just obtained also evaluate in B_{cris}, by the divided-power convergence argument in Lemma 6.49. The evaluated columns of Z_{i}U_{i} are fixed by the cyclotomic kernel, since the integral basis and its scalar coef-ficients are fixed there. They are fixed by γ by G_{i}γ(U_{i}) = U_{i}, and hence by G_{K} by continuity and density of the integer powers of γ in the cyclotomic quotient. The evaluated inverse matrix proves their independence and that they give a full period basis. They therefore form the actual D_{cris}-basis, in its chosen coefficient component. This identifies the constant space in the formal construction with crystalline invariants, rather than with an abstract space of the same dimension.

At u = ζ −1 the function τ has a zero of finite order. Consequently U_{i} and U_{i}^{−1} have Laurent expansions with bounded-below support in t_{ζ}. The N(T)-basis, written in the invariant basis Z_{i}U_{i}, has matrix U_{i}^{−1}. Its formal span is thus a full finite free L[[t_{ζ}]]-lattice, stable under t_{ζ} →→ ηt_{ζ} with constant coefficient space D. Here γ fixes ζ because η ≡1 (mod ℓ^{s}). cris We check that this formal span has the stated de Rham scalar extension. Analytic evaluation and Taylor expansion at a = ζ −1 are compatible with the period embedding. For an analytic scalar function f and every integer q, Taylor division gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
f(u) −∑f_{j}(u −a)^{j}= (u −a)^{q}f_{q}^{∗}(u),
j<q

where f_{q}^{∗} is again analytic on the open unit disc. Evaluate this identity in crystalline periods and then in de Rham periods. The image of u −a is a de Rham uniformizer times a unit: Q_{s} generates the period ideal and its root at a is simple in characteristic zero. Thus the evaluated Taylor remainder has de Rham order at least q. Applying this for every q, and then to the finitely many meromorphic entries after clearing their poles, identifies the formal expansion with the actual de Rham expansion. The logarithmic parameter maps to t/ℓ^{s} and hence is also a uniformizer times a unit. Finally X_{s}(a) = ζ^{ℓs−1}−1 ̸= 0, so X_{s} is a unit in this de Rham completion. The period sandwich then says exactly that the B_{dR}^{+} -span of the expanded basis is V ⊗B_{dR}^{+}.

Lemma 6.46 now gives the asserted coefficientwise filtration. This verifies the comparison premise in the earlier height proof.

It remains to verify the stronger integral γ divisibility. At every root a of X_{s}, the zero of log(1 + u) cancels the simple zero of X_{s}; their derivatives have nonzero quotient. Thus τ(a) ̸= 0, and the analytic continuation shows that U_{i} and its inverse are regular and invertible at a. Since γ(a) = a, evaluation of G_{i}γ(U_{i}) = U_{i} gives G_{i}(a) = 1. Also every integral scalar series satisfies γ(f)(a) = f(a). Therefore all

coordinates of (γ −1)x, x ∈ N(T), vanish at every root of X_{s}. The integral root-divisibility argument of Lemma 6.39, applied to the monic distinguished polynomial X_{s}, gives divisibility by X_{s} in the original integral coefficient ring. One can first divide after a finite coefficient extension: the unique monic-division remainder was already over the original ring, so its vanishing after the injective extension implies its original vanishing. This proves the last assertion without a coefficient-extension denominator.

Lemma 6.51 (The integral kernel and the finite cokernel). For a short exact sequence of crystalline lattices 0 →T_{0} →T_{1} →T_{2} →0, the realized map on Wach lattices is injective at the first term and its kernel at N(T_{1}) is exactly N(T_{0}). The cokernel at N(T_{2}) has finite O-length.

Proof. Write D_{j} = D_{K}(T_{j}) and identify D_{0} with the kernel of D_{1} →D_{2}, using the exact etale comparison. Put K = N(T_{1}) ∩D_{0}. It is finite over A =∏_{i}O[[u]], since it is a submodule of a finite module over this Noetherian ring. We explain why it is free, component by component. Multiplication by u is injective. If ℓx = uy with x, y ∈K, freeness of N(T_{1}) gives x = uz, y = ℓz in N(T_{1}), because reduction modulo u is torsion-free over O. Since u is a unit in the etale ring and x ∈D_{0}, we have z ∈D_{0} and hence z ∈K. Thus K/uK is torsion-free over O (a uniformizer can replace ℓ in the same argument). It is finite and therefore free over that DVR. Lift an O-basis to K. Nakayama gives a surjection A^{d} → K; reducing a relation modulo∩ u shows it is divisible by u, and injectivity of u on K repeats this indefinitely. Completeness and _{q}u^{q}A^{d} = 0 kill the relation. These lifts are an A-basis of K. The image of N(T_{0}) is contained in K and etale-spans D_{0}. Thus K also spans D_{0}. Its basis is indepen-dent over the etale ring: an A-basis has a nonzero maximal minor over each component fraction field, while all minors of order greater than rank D_{0} vanish already in the injective extension to the etale ring. Together with the spanning assertion this fixes its rank and makes that basis an etale basis of D_{0}.

The module K is Γ-stable. Moreover (γ−1)x = uz in N(T_{1}) implies z ∈D_{0}, again by cancellation of u, so the action is trivial on K/uK. Forward Frobenius commensurability follows by clearing the denominator for N(T_{1}) and using stability of D_{0}. For the reverse inclusion we need

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
AφN(T_{1}) ∩D_{0} = AφK.

Use the free scalar Frobenius decomposition with basis (1 + u)^{j}, 0 ≤j < ℓ. Express a vector on the left as ∑_{j}(1 + u)^{j}φ(x_{j}), x_{j} ∈ N(T_{1}). Its image in D_{2} vanishes. The Frobenius images of an N(T_{2})-basis are etale independent; comparing those coordinates and the free scalar Frobenius decomposition therefore gives that every image of x_{j} is zero. Hence every x_{j} belongs to K. This proves the equality. The inverse Frobenius bound of N(T_{1}) now gives the inverse bound for K.

Thus K is another free, etale-spanning, Frobenius commensurable lattice with trivial Γ action modulo u in the same crystalline module D_{0}. The period sandwich makes it power-commensurable with N(T_{0}), and

Lemma 6.43 identifies them. Exactness at the first two terms follows.

The already proved double-saturation and uniqueness argument gives an integer c killing the cokernel by both u^{c} and ℓ^{c}. A finite set of A-generators, multiplied by the finitely many component idempotents and by 1, u, . . . , u^{c−1}, generates that cokernel over O: truncate every scalar series modulo u^{c}. It is therefore a finite O-module killed by ℓ^{c}. It is a quotient of a finite direct sum of O/ℓ^{c}O, which has finite length. This proves the final assertion, including the finiteness needed before taking lengths.

Lemma 6.52 (The height bounds give the required annihilator recurrence). Let f : N_{1} →N_{2} be the integral period-module map of a crystalline surjection, with cyclic coefficient components over R = O[[x]]. Suppose the source and target have Frobenius bases and, in component i,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Q^{M}_{s}^{i}φ(N_{2,i−1}) ⊂N_{2,i}, Q^{h}_{s}^{i}N_{1,i}⊂Rφ(N_{1,i−1}).

Suppose the Frobenius images of a basis of N_{2,i−1} are linearly independent. If the cokernel is killed by some x^{c}, then it is killed by X_{s}^{H} for H = max_{i}(M_{i}+ h_{i}).

Proof. Let ∑ I_{i} = f(N_{1,i}) and let 𝔞_{i} = {g ∈R : gN_{2,i} ⊂I_{i}}. These ideals contain x^{c}. For g ∈𝔞_{i}, expand Q^{H}_{s}g =_{j}e_{j}φ(z_{j}) in Frobenius coordinates. For any y ∈N_{2,i−1}, the first height inclusion and g ∈𝔞_{i} put gQ_{s}^{Mi}φ(y) in I_{i}. The second inclusion, multiplied by the remaining nonnegative power of Q_{s}, puts Q^{H}_{s}gφ(y) in Rφ(I_{i−1}). On the other hand this vector equals ∑_{j}e_{j}φ(z_{j}y).

Uniqueness of this vector coordinate decomposition follows from the scalar coordinate decomposition and independence of the Frobenius images of a basis of N_{2,i−1}: expand each vector in that basis and compare its scalar Frobenius coordinates. Expressing the same vector in Rφ(I_{i−1}) gives coordinates in I_{i−1}. There-fore z_{j}y ∈I_{i−1} for every j and every y. This proves z_{j} ∈𝔞_{i−1}, and hence Q^{H}_{s}𝔞_{i}⊂Rφ(𝔞_{i−1}). Lemma 6.38 now gives X_{s}^{H}∈𝔞_{i}, exactly the asserted cokernel bound.

The independence used here can also be checked integrally. The original basis and its Frobenius images span lattices commensurable after inverting Q_{s}. Writing both inclusions with one common power of Q_{s} gives transition matrices whose product is that power times the identity. Their determinants are nonzero, so the Frobenius images are linearly independent over the fraction field and hence over R. This is the commensurable-basis argument used by the source, rather than an assumption that the integral Frobenius matrix is invertible.

Lemma 6.53 (Integral interpolation for the Wach quotient). Let a ≥ 0 and v_{ℓ}(u −1) = s with the same restrictions on s as above. Put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a∏−1 2∏a−1
A_{0}(z) = (z −u^{j}), A_{1}(z) = (z −u^{j}), b = 2as + v_{ℓ}((2a)!).
j=0 j=a

Then ℓ^{b}∈(A_{0}, A_{1}) in ℤ_{ℓ}[z]. If a morphism f : (D_{1}, N_{1}) →(D_{2}, N_{2}) of the period modules above satisfies X^{a}N_{2} ⊂f(N_{1}), then ℓ^{b}N_{2} ⊂f(N_{1}).

Proof. For a = 0, both polynomials are one and both assertions hold. Suppose a > 0. The 2a numbers u^{j} are distinct by the lifting-the-exponent calculation. The Lagrange interpolation polynomials

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{Lj(z) =} ∏∏0≤i<2a, i̸=j^{(z −ui)}
0≤i<2a, i̸=j^{(uj −ui)}

sum to one: their sum minus one has degree less than 2a and vanishes at the 2a distinct points. The denom-inator has valuation

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(2a −1)s + v_{ℓ}(j!) + v_{ℓ}((2a −1 −j)!) ≤b.

The inequality follows because the two factorials divide (2a −1)! jointly, their quotient being a binomial coefficient. Thus ℓ^{b}L_{j} has integral coefficients. Its numerator is divisible by A_{1} if j < a and by A_{0} if j ≥a. Summing proves ℓ^{b}= R_{0}A_{0} + R_{1}A_{1} for integral polynomials R_{0}, R_{1}.

The graded γ identity proved below implies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d∏−1
(γ −u^{i})(X^{c}n) ∈X^{d}N (0 ≤c ≤d).
i=c

It follows by induction, raising the X-degree one at each factor. Let S = f(X^{a}N_{1}). It is stable under γ, since γ(X) = X(u + Xt) and γ(N_{1}) ⊂N_{1}. Given n ∈N_{2}, choose m ∈N_{1} with f(m) = X^{a}n. Then A_{0}(γ)(X^{a}n) = f(A_{0}(γ)m) ∈ S by the degree-zero-to-a graded identity. Also A_{1}(γ)(X^{a}n) ∈ X^{2a}N_{2}. Every element of this last module belongs to S: first lift its X^{a}N_{2} factor to N_{1} by the hypothesis and then multiply by X^{a}. Since S is stable under integral polynomials in γ, the Bezout identity gives ℓ^{b}X^{a}n ∈ S. Write this as X^{a}f(m^{′}) = ℓ^{b}X^{a}n with m^{′}∈N_{1}. Injectivity of X on D_{2} permits cancellation of X^{a}, giving f(m^{′}) = ℓ^{b}n. This proves the second assertion.

In particular the height bound X^{H}N_{2} ⊂f(N_{1}) gives the exact exponent e_{W} = 2Hs + v_{ℓ}((2H)!) used in the full cyclotomic case. The height bound is an assertion about the realized integral Wach modules; the interpolation proof derives its integral ℓ-power consequence without assuming that consequence.

Lemma 6.54 (Hodge jumps in the crystalline extension). Let 0 →V →Y →L →0 be an exact sequence of crystalline representations, where the last term is trivial of rank one. In every coefficient embedding the multiset of Hodge jumps of Y is the multiset for V , together with one additional zero. In particular a jump interval [−M, h] for V , with M, h ≥0, is also such an interval for Y .

Proof. The period functors on crystalline representations are exact, and the de Rham sequence is strictly exact as a sequence of filtered spaces. The exact primary statements used here are Fontaine, Representations p-adiques semi-stables, Asterisque 223 (1994), Theorem 3.8(i),(ii), printed p. 142, and the unnumbered theorem immediately following 5.1.7, printed p. 158. The latter applies because the middle representation is crystalline; the former gives strict compatibility with the de Rham filtrations.^{9} These statements remain exact on each coefficient component, by applying its idempotent.

For clarity, strictness gives 0 → Fil^{j}D(V ) → Fil^{j}D(Y ) → Fil^{j}D(L) → 0 for every j. Pass to successive quotients. If a class in gr^{j}D(Y ) has zero image, choose a lift of its image in Fil^{j+1}D(L) to Fil^{j+1}D(Y ) and subtract it. What remains belongs to Fil^{j}D(V ). The kernel at the first graded term is zero by the induced filtration on D(V ); surjectivity at the last term follows from surjectivity on Fil^{j}. Thus the graded sequence is exact and its dimensions add. For the trivial line only the grade zero has dimension one. This proves the assertion, including multiplicities.

Lemma 6.55 (A uniformly bounded integral representative of a finite class). Let T be a crystalline O-lattice whose Hodge jumps in every component lie in [−M, h], with M, h ≥0. Put e_{0} = 2hs + v_{ℓ}((2h)!). Every κ ∈H_{f}^{1}(G_{K}, T) has a Herr representative of ℓ^{e0}κ of the form

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
y ∈Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N(T), z ∈X_{s}N(T), (γ −1)y = (φ −1)z.

Here H_{f}^{1}(G_{K}, T) is the integral preimage of the rational crystalline finite condition.

Proof. Represent κ by a continuous integral cocycle c_{g} ∈T. On Y = T ⊕Oe put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
g(v + ae) = g(v) + ac_{g} + ae.

The cocycle identity verifies the group law for this action, and its continuity follows from that of c and the action on T. The inclusion and projection give a short exact sequence of integral lattices with trivial quotient O. Since κ is finite, there is b ∈V ⊗B_{cris} with c_{g} = (g −1)b. The vector e −b is invariant in the crystalline period realization of Y . Together with a crystalline invariant basis of V it is a full basis there. Thus Y is crystalline. By the preceding lemma its jumps lie in [−M, h].

For the trivial representation, the Wach lattice is A · 1: this lattice has the trivial coefficient action, Frobenius fixes 1, and the uniqueness argument identifies it with the realized one. In the map N(Y ) → N(O), the target lower height is zero and the source upper height is at most h, by Lemma 6.50 and the height calculation. The initial u-power bound is supplied by double saturation. The annihilator recurrence therefore gives X_{s}^{h}N(O) ⊂ im N(Y ). Lemma 6.53 gives ℓ^{e0}N(O) ⊂ im N(Y ). Choose x ∈ N(Y ) mapping to ℓ^{e0}· 1.

The elements (φ −1)x and (γ −1)x lie in the etale kernel D_{K}(T). The lower height of Y gives Q_{s}^{M}(φ −1)x ∈N(Y ). By the saturated-kernel lemma, its preimage is Q^{M}_{s} y for a unique y ∈Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N(T). Also (γ −1)x = X_{s}w for w ∈N(Y ), by the last assertion of Lemma 6.50. Its image in the trivial etale

^{9}Original primary text: https://www.numdam.org/item/AST_1994__223__113_0.pdf, PDF pp. 30 and 46. The theorem at printed p. 158 is not 5.2.1, which begins the next paragraph.

module vanishes, and X_{s} is a unit in that module. Consequently w lies in its kernel and hence in N(T). Put z = X_{s}w in that identified kernel. Commutativity of Frobenius and γ, and injectivity of the kernel inclusion, give the required Herr cocycle identity.

The class is the stated multiple, including its sign. In the Witt period realization set b_{0} = x −ℓ^{e0}e. It has zero image in the quotient and hence lies in the period realization of T. Frobenius fixes the original integral vector e, so (φ −1)b_{0} = y. The cyclotomic cocycle of x is (g −1)x. Subtracting (g −1)b_{0} leaves ℓ^{e0}(g −1)e = ℓ^{e0}c_{g}. This is exactly the cocycle formula for the natural Herr comparison, so its class is ℓ^{e0}κ. All choices in this proof concern a representative; the exponent depends only on h, s, not on κ.

Lemma 6.56 (The obstruction hypotheses hold for the realized lattice). Let N = N(T) have jumps in [−M, h] and put L_{0} = Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N. With U the set of actual jumps and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
J = ((U + {1, . . . , M}) \ {0}) ∪{1, . . . , M}, P(z) =∏(z −η^{−j}),
j∈J

all four hypotheses of the following obstruction lemma hold, with its module L equal to L_{0} and its X equal to X_{s}.

Proof. For the first assertion, the lower height gives φ(X_{s}^{M+1}N) ⊂ X_{s}^{M+1}Q_{s}N. Every φ^{j}Q_{s} belongs to the maximal ideal (ϖ, u) of each coefficient component, where ϖ is a uniformizer of O. Successive Frobenius iterates therefore send X_{s}^{M+1}N into X_{s}^{M+1}(ϖ, u)^{q}N after q steps. These lattices are complete and separated. For w ∈X_{s}^{M+1}N the convergent sum ∑_{q≥0}φ^{q}w belongs to the same module and has image w under 1 −φ. This proves surjectivity (and the same decay proves uniqueness).

For the two saturation assertions write y = Q^{−}_{s}^{M}a in an N-basis, a ∈A^{r}. If either X_{s}y or ℓy belongs to N, its numerator is divisible by Q^{M}_{s}. At every primitive ℓ^{s}th root, both X_{s} and ℓ are nonzero, hence units in the local Laurent coefficient field. Thus every coordinate of a vanishes to order at least M at each root of Q_{s}. Integral monic division, as in Lemma 6.39, gives Q^{M}_{s} | a over the original coefficient ring. This proves y ∈N in both cases. Notice that ℓ is used as a local-field unit only to detect the orders of these zeros; the monic-division remainder is integral, which is what gives the integral conclusion.

Finally, L_{0}/N is finite free over O: in an N-basis it is a direct sum of copies of A/(Q^{M}_{s} ), and the latter is finite free by monic division. We may therefore check that an operator vanishes on it after passing to its fraction field and splitting the roots of Q_{s}. The formal filtered description just proved admits a filtered basis d_{a} with jumps u_{a} ∈U. At each primitive root its lattice has basis t^{−}_{ζ}^{ua}d_{a}. Consequently L_{0}/N has there the basis of classes

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
t^{−}_{ζ}^{ua−j}d_{a}, 1 ≤j ≤M.

The operator γ is diagonal on this basis, with eigenvalues η^{−(ua+j)}. If u_{a} + j = 0, the factor γ −1 kills that vector; otherwise u_{a} + j ∈J and the corresponding factor of P(γ) kills it. Thus (γ −1)P(γ) vanishes on every component of the fraction-field quotient, and hence on L_{0}/N itself by its torsion-freeness. This is exactly the third obstruction assertion. The extra factors indexed by {1, . . . , M} are harmless and retain the source’s chosen polynomial.

Lemma 6.57 (The local obstruction is killed by an explicit product). Let s ≥1, with s ≥2 if ℓ= 2, and v_{ℓ}(u −1) = s. Let J ⊂ℤ \ {0} be finite and put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏ ∏M
P(z) = (z −u^{−j}), c_{G} = (u^{i}−1), c = P(1)c_{G}.
j∈J i=1

Assume the following four properties:

(i) 1 −φ maps X^{M+1}N onto X^{M+1}N;

(ii) if y ∈L and Xy ∈N, then y ∈N;

(iii) (γ −1)P(γ)L ⊂N;

(iv) if y ∈L and ℓy ∈N, then y ∈N.

If ω ∈C^{2} and some ℓ^{k}ω belongs to d(C^{1}), then cω ∈d(C^{1}). Furthermore

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v_{ℓ}(c) = e_{U} :=∑(s + v_{ℓ}(j)) + Ms + v_{ℓ}(M!). (142)
j∈J

Proof. The graded action of γ is multiplication by u^{i} on X^{i}N/X^{i+1}N. In fact γ(X^{i}n) = X^{i}(u+Xt)^{i}(n+ Xn^{′}) for an n^{′}∈N, and subtracting u^{i}X^{i}n leaves X^{i+1}N. It follows inductively that, for every n ∈N,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{G}Xn = (γ −1)Xx + X^{M+1}n^{′}, x, n^{′}∈N. (143)

For completeness, at stage K = 0 take x = 0, n^{′} = n. If the formula holds with product through K and remainder X^{K+1}n^{′}, the graded identity at degree K + 1 replaces x by (u^{K+1}−1)x + X^{K}n^{′} and the remainder by the negative of its new degree-K + 2 term. This gives the formula through K + 1.

Write ℓ^{k}ω = d(y, Xn) with y ∈ L, n ∈ N. Apply (143) to n and set Y = c_{G}y −(φ −1)Xx ∈ L. Commutativity of the two operators gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{G}ℓ^{k}ω = (γ −1)Y −(φ −1)X^{M+1}n^{′}.

Apply P(γ). The first term lies in N by (iii). The second lies in N because φ(X^{M+1}n^{′}) = X^{M+1}Q^{M+1}φ(n^{′}) ∈N, and P(γ) preserves N. Hence c_{G}ℓ^{k}P(γ)ω ∈N. The scalar c_{G} is nonzero by the lifting-the-exponent calculation, and P(γ)ω ∈L. Repeated use of (iv), followed by cancellation of the unit part of c_{G}, proves P(γ)ω ∈N. Since P(γ) preserves XL, write it as Xy_{0} with y_{0} ∈L. Property (ii) gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
y_{0} ∈N.

Apply (143) to y_{0}: c_{G}Xy_{0} = (γ−1)Xx_{0}+X^{M+1}n_{0}. Choose z_{0} ∈N with X^{M+1}n_{0} = (1−φ)X^{M+1}z_{0} by (i). Polynomial division gives P(z) −P(1) = (z −1)S(z) with integral coefficients. The pair

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(−c_{G}S(γ)ω + Xx_{0}, X^{M+1}z_{0})∈C^{1}

has differential c_{G}P(1)ω: substitute the last two identities and cancel the X^{M+1}n_{0} terms. Its first coordinate is in L by γ-stability and its second is in XN. This proves the obstruction assertion.

Finally v_{ℓ}(u^{i}−1) = s + v_{ℓ}(i) for i > 0 and v_{ℓ}(1 −u^{−j}) = s + v_{ℓ}(j) for j ̸= 0, by the same binomial lifting-the-exponent proof as in Lemma 6.8; inverse powers have unit denominators. Summing these valuations gives (142). Thus c is a unit times ℓ^{eU}, with no extra denominator.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i

Proposition 6.58 (Integral cocycle lifting). Let 0 → D_{0} →→ D_{1} →→^{p} D_{2} → 0 be an exact sequence of the preceding modules, respecting their operators, and suppose i^{−1}(N_{1}) = N_{0}. Assume ℓ^{e}N_{2} ⊂p(N_{1}) and that every integral cocycle in C_{2}^{1} has, after multiplication by some power of ℓ, a cocycle lift modulo a boundary of an element of N_{2}. If the kernel module satisfies Lemma 6.57, then every integral cocycle has an actual integral cocycle lift after multiplication by ℓ^{e+eU}.

Proof. Let (y, Xn) ∈C_{2}^{1} be a cocycle. Put a = ℓ^{e}. Lift Q^{M}y and n to N_{1} after multiplication by a. Division by the bijection Q^{M} gives y_{1} ∈L_{1}, and the other lift gives n_{1} ∈N_{1}, with p(y_{1}) = ay and p(Xn_{1}) = aXn. The differential of this pair is Xw with w ∈ L_{1}, by the displayed differential properties. It maps to zero.

Injectivity of X on D_{2} shows p(w) = 0, so exactness and the saturation i^{−1}(N_{1}) = N_{0} write w = i(w_{0}) with w_{0} ∈L_{0}. Thus the obstruction is i(ω) with ω = Xw_{0} ∈C_{0}^{2}.

The rational-lift assumption makes this obstruction torsion modulo d(C_{0}^{1}). We verify the assertion, in-cluding the integral boundary. Choose an integral cocycle (y^{′}, Xn^{′}), an x ∈N_{2}, and b = ℓ^{k} such that its image is b(y, Xn) + ((φ −1)x, (γ −1)x). Choose x_{1} ∈N_{1} with p(x_{1}) = ax. The pair

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(Y, Z) = b(y_{1}, Xn_{1}) −a(y^{′}, Xn^{′}) + ((φ −1)x_{1}, (γ −1)x_{1})

lies in C_{1}^{1} and maps to zero. Its first coordinate belongs to L_{1} and its second to XN_{1} by the defining operator conditions. Exactness pulls the first coordinate back to L_{0} using saturation. Write the second as Xm; injectivity of X in the quotient gives p(m) = 0, and saturation pulls m back to N_{0}. Consequently (Y, Z) = i(Y_{0}, Z_{0}) for an integral pair in the kernel. Commutativity of φ and γ makes the boundary term have zero differential, so ( )

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i d(Y_{0}, Z_{0}) = b i(ω).

Injectivity of i proves bω = d(Y_{0}, Z_{0}).

The obstruction lemma now supplies an integral kernel pair (y_{0}, z_{0}) with d(y_{0}, z_{0}) = cω. Subtract its image from c(y_{1}, Xn_{1}). The result is an integral cocycle, and its image in D_{2} is ac(y, Xn). Since c is a unit times ℓ^{eU}, divide this cocycle by that scalar unit. Its image is precisely ℓ^{e+eU}(y, Xn), as asserted.

Lemma 6.59 (An integral boundary has an integral primitive). If m ∈D_{K}(T) satisfies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(φ −1)m ∈Q^{−}_{s}^{M}N(T), (γ −1)m ∈uN(T),

then m ∈N(T). Consequently the rational-lift premise in Proposition 6.58 holds for every crystalline short exact sequence considered here.

Proof. In D_{K}(T) ⊕Ee with trivial last representation, consider the free lattice generated by N(T) and e + m. It etale-spans this direct sum, is Γ-stable, and has trivial Γ action modulo u, by the second displayed condition. Its Frobenius matrix and its inverse are

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(_{Fy}) (_{F} −1_{−F}−1_{y})
_{01} ,_{01} , y = (φ −1)m.

A sufficiently large power of Q_{s} clears both matrices. This lattice therefore satisfies all the integral Frobenius and cyclotomic conditions used in the period sandwich and uniqueness proofs. Applying those proofs in the crystalline representation V ⊕L identifies it with N(T)⊕Ae. In particular e+m belongs to this last lattice, and comparison of its first coordinate gives m ∈ N(T). In matrix terms this is the bordered transition-matrix argument: its off-diagonal column is m, and the already proved matrix divisibility removes its entire X_{s} denominator. No assertion about a rational primitive being integral is being assumed.

We verify the consequence. The rational finite-condition functor is right exact on crystalline short exact sequences. The precise published input is Bloch–Kato, cited above, Corollary 3.8.4, printed pp. 355–356: it presents H_{f}^{1}(K, V ) as the cokernel of

D_{cris}(V ) −→D_{cris}(V ) ⊕D_{dR}(V )/ Fil^{0}, x −−→((1 −φ)x, x).

Exactness of crystalline periods and strict de Rham exactness make the map on the displayed right-hand spaces surjective. Lift a representative there and use naturality of this cokernel presentation to obtain the claimed surjection on rational H_{f}^{1}.

An integral target Herr cocycle is finite by Lemma 6.49. Lift its rational class as just explained. A continuous source cocycle has compact image in the finite-dimensional coefficient space; its coordinates

have bounded denominators, so some ℓ-power makes it integral. Apply Lemma 6.55 to that integral finite class to obtain an integral source period pair. Its image and the corresponding power of the original target pair have the same Herr class. Their difference is ((φ −1)m, (γ −1)m) for some m ∈ D_{K}(T_{2}), by the natural Herr comparison. The difference pair satisfies the two displayed integrality conditions, so the first part of this lemma puts m in N(T_{2}). This is the integral boundary required in the rational-lift premise. The auxiliary power used here need not be uniform; it only proves that the obstruction is torsion, whose uniform annihilator was calculated separately.

Lemma 6.60 (Passage from period cocycles to finite Galois cohomology). Suppose a surjective map of crystalline lattices has compatible period-cocycle class maps to its finite Galois cohomology groups. Assume every target finite class, after multiplication by ℓ^{eW}, has an integral period-cocycle representative, and every integral target cocycle has an integral source lift after multiplication by ℓ^{eW +eU}. Then multiplication by ℓ^{2eW +eU} on target finite cohomology factors through the source finite cohomology.

Proof. For a target class κ, choose a cocycle z whose class is ℓ^{eW}κ. Lift ℓ^{eW +eU}z to an integral source cocycle z_{1}. Its class is finite by the stipulated finite-condition identification. Naturality of the class maps gives its image as ℓ^{eW +eU}ℓ^{eW}κ = ℓ^{2eW +eU}κ. This proves the factorization for every class, with the same exponent.

Lemma 6.61 (The uniform crystalline lifting constant). Suppose the realized crystalline lattices satisfy the height and period-cocycle hypotheses of the preceding three results, with M ≤h, H ≤2h and actual jump set U ⊂[−M, h]. Use ( )

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
J = (U + {1, . . . , M}) \ {0} ∪{1, . . . , M}.

Then the lifting exponent is at most 32(2hs + 1).

Proof. If h = 0, the sets and exponents are zero. Otherwise h, s ≥1. Every member of J is nonzero and lies between −M + 1 and h + M. Thus |J| ≤h + 2M ≤3h, and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑v_{ℓ}(j) ≤v_{ℓ}((M −1)!) + v_{ℓ}((h + M)!) ≤3h.
j∈J

The last inequality uses v_{ℓ}(b!) ≤b/(ℓ−1) ≤b, which follows by counting multiples of each power of ℓ in the factorial. Consequently

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
e_{U} ≤3hs + 3h + hs + h ≤8hs, e_{W} = 2Hs + v_{ℓ}((2H)!) ≤4hs + 4h ≤8hs.

The cohomology lifting exponent is 2e_{W} + e_{U} ≤24hs. This is at most 32(2hs + 1), giving the deliberately loose uniform constant used in the arithmetic estimate.

Proposition 6.62 (The realized local crystalline lift). Let K = K_{0}(ζ_{ℓ}s) with K_{0}/ℚ_{ℓ} unramified, s ≥ 1 and s ≥ 2 if ℓ = 2. Let T_{1} → T_{2} be a surjection of finite free O-lattices in crystalline representations. Suppose all Hodge jumps of its source and target, in every coefficient embedding, lie in [−h, h], h ≥ 0. Then multiplication by ℓ^{32(2hs+1)} on H_{f}^{1}(K, T_{2}) factors through H_{f}^{1}(K, T_{1}). This exponent is independent of the ranks, the individual representations and the class being lifted.

Proof. The kernel is crystalline and has jumps in the same interval. This follows from the strict filtered exactness used in Lemma 6.54; its graded-dimension proof applies to a general quotient as well, giving the union of the kernel and quotient jump multisets. The realized lattice kernel is saturated by Lemma 6.51. The actual formal expansion supplies the lower and upper height bounds, so the annihilator recurrence uses M ≤h and H ≤2h. Integral interpolation gives the cokernel exponent e_{W} .

All four obstruction properties have been verified in Lemma 6.56, and the rational-lift premise has just been proved with an integral boundary. Integral cocycle lifting therefore uses the exponent e_{W} + e_{U}. The target finite-class representative is supplied by Lemma 6.55. Its exponent 2hs + v_{ℓ}((2h)!) is at most the e_{W} chosen with H = 2h; multiply a representative by the remaining nonnegative power if necessary. Every resulting integral source pair is finite by Lemma 6.49, and the Herr class maps commute with the given surjection. Thus Lemma 6.60 gives 2e_{W} +e_{U}, bounded by 32(2hs+1) in the preceding uniform calculation. Multiplication by the additional nonnegative power of ℓ preserves the image. This proves the displayed statement and its uniformity.

We next establish the quantitative local invariant annihilator for a crystalline lattice whose Hodge–Tate jumps avoid zero. Fix a prime ℓ, an algebraic closure ℚ_{ℓ} with completed algebraic closure ℂ_{ℓ}, valuation ring O_{ℂℓ} = {z ∈ℂ_{ℓ}: |z| ≤1} (normalized by |ℓ| = ℓ^{−1}), and continuous Galois action of G_{ℚℓ} = Gal(ℚ_{ℓ}/ℚ_{ℓ}) by isometries on ℂ_{ℓ}, together with the ℓ-adic cyclotomic character χ_{ℓ}: G_{ℚℓ} →ℤ^{×}_{ℓ}. For a finite extension K/ℚ_{ℓ} inside ℚ_{ℓ} with maximal unramified subextension K_{0} = K ∩ℚ^{nr}_{ℓ}, write K_{j} = K_{0}(µ_{ℓ}j), K_{∞} =

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∪

_{j≥0}K_{j}, G_{j} = Gal(ℚ_{ℓ}/K_{j}), H_{∞}= Gal(ℚ_{ℓ}/K_{∞}), and ̂O_{K∞}= O_{K∞}⊂O_{ℂℓ}. Set ρ_{1}(ℓ) = ℓ^{−1/(ℓ−1)}, and for integers s ≥1 and H_{0} ≥0 put

n_{0}(ℓ, H_{0}) = min{n ∈ℕ : H_{0} ≤ℓ^{n}(ℓ−1)}, m_{N}(ℓ, s, H_{0}) = 2s + n_{0}(ℓ, H_{0}) + 1. (144)

Call a level j ∈ ℕ admissible if j ≥ 1 and j ≥ 2 when ℓ = 2. A good triple (K, s, L) consists of finite extensions K, L ⊂ℚ_{ℓ} and an admissible level s such that K ⊂K_{s} and every ℚ_{ℓ}-embedding K_{s} ↪→ℚ_{ℓ} has image inside L. Write O = O_{L} for the ring of integers of L and f = [L : ℚ_{ℓ}].

Lemma 6.63 (Cyclotomic ring basis, trace almost-surjectivity, and completed invariants). Let K/ℚ_{ℓ} be finite.

(i) For every i ≥2 and every primitive ℓ^{i}th root of unity ζ ∈K_{i}, one has O_{Ki} =⊕^{ℓ}_{a}^{−}_{=0}^{1}ζ^{a}O_{Ki−1}.

(ii) For every finite Galois extension E/K_{∞} inside ℚ_{ℓ} and every a ∈ K_{∞} with |a| < 1, there exists

b ∈O_{E} with Tr_{E/K∞}(b) = a.

(iii) An element y ∈O_{ℂℓ} is fixed by H_{∞} if and only if y ∈Ô_{K∞}.

(iv) For every a ∈K_{∞} with |a| < 1, every r ≥0, and every continuous 1-cocycle c : H_{∞}→O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} for the

coordinatewise Galois action, there exists x ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} such that a c(h) = h(x) −x for all h ∈H_{∞}.

Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/IntegersEqSumZetaPow.lean:207--272; ExistsTraceNormGe.lean:339--508; TraceAlmostOntoOfLevels.lean:111--201; CyclotomicTowerTraceAlmostSurjective.lean:11--17; CyclotomicTowerFixedIffMemCompletedIntegers.lean:88--154; CyclotomicTateMaximalIdealKillsFirstCohomology.lean:80--169.

Proof. For (i), since ζ^{ℓ}∈K_{i−1} and K_{i} = K_{i−1}(ζ), every x ∈K_{i} can be written as p(ζ) with p ∈K_{i−1}[X] of degree less than ℓ. Expand at 1: q(T) = p(T +1) =∑^{ℓ}_{a}^{−}_{=0}^{1}z_{a}T^{ a} with z_{a} ∈K_{i−1}, so x = ∑^{ℓ}_{a}^{−}_{=0}^{1}z_{a}(ζ−1)^{a}. Since |ζ −1| = ℓ^{−1/(ℓi−1(ℓ−1))} and every nonzero z ∈K_{i−1} has norm a power of ℓ^{1/(ℓi−2(ℓ−1))}, the nonzero summands z_{a}(ζ −1)^{a} (0 ≤ a < ℓ) have pairwise distinct norms: their exponents of ℓ^{1/(ℓi−1(ℓ−1))} are congruent to −a (mod ℓ). The ultrametric equality therefore yields |z_{a}(ζ −1)^{a}| ≤|x| for every a. If x = 0, every z_{a} = 0, so q = 0 and p = 0, proving K_{i−1}-linear independence of 1, ζ, . . . , ζ^{ℓ−1}. If |x| ≤1, then for each a with z_{a} ̸= 0 writing |z_{a}| = ℓ^{nℓ/(ℓi−1(ℓ−1))} gives nℓ−a ≤0, hence n ≤0 (as a < ℓ), i.e. |z_{a}| ≤1. Shifting back via p(X) = q(X −1) preserves integrality of all coefficients, giving p ∈ O_{Ki−1}[X] and proving (i).

For (ii), suppose first that L^{′}/ℚ_{ℓ} is finite and ε > 0. Choose a primitive element y ∈O_{L}′ with G_{L}′ = Stab_{Gℚℓ}(y), let n be the cardinality of its G_{ℚℓ}-orbit, and set c = ∏_{r̸=y}|y −r| > 0 over the remaining conjugates r of y. Choose a = min(1, ε/(n + 1)) so (1 −a)^{n} ≥1 −ε, put δ = 1 −a, choose N_{0} ∈ℕ with δ^{N0} < ℓ^{−1}, set N = N_{0} + n, and choose j_{0} ∈ℕ with ℓ^{−j0} < c^{N}. Take any i = j + 1 ≥j_{0} + 1, put E_{i} = L^{′}K_{i}, and let S ⊂G_{i} be a left transversal of G_{i}/G_{Ei}; then |S| ≤n since s →→s(y) is injective on S. Because the residue field of ℤ_{ℓ} is finite, O_{Ei} = ℤ_{ℓ}[x] for some x ∈O_{Ei}. We claim that |x −σ(x)| ≥δ for every σ ∈G_{i} with σ(y) ̸= y. Assume to the contrary that |x −σ(x)| < δ for such a σ. Let ζ be a primitive ℓ^{j+1}th root of unity and ω = ζ^{ℓ}. For each 0 ≤k < ℓ^{j}−1, surjectivity of χ_{ℓ}: G_{K0} →ℤ^{×}_{ℓ} yields τ_{k} ∈G_{1} with τ_{k}(ζ) = ζ^{1+ℓ(k+1)}= ζω^{k+1}. By induction on i ≥1 using (i), every z ∈O_{Ki} satisfies |τ_{k}(z) −z| ≤ |τ_{k}(ζ) −ζ| = |1 −ω^{k+1}|. Applying τ_{k} to the monic polynomial f(X) = ∏_{s∈S}(X −s(x)) ∈ O_{Ki}[X], which vanishes at x, gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏|x −τ_{k}(s(x))| =||(τ_{k}(f) −f)(x)|| ≤|1 −ω^{k+1}|.
s∈S

Choosing s_{k} ∈S attaining the minimum factor yields |x −τ_{k}(s_{k}(x))|^{N} ≤|x −τ_{k}(s_{k}(x))|^{|S|}≤|1 −ω^{k+1}|. Put g_{k} = τ_{k}s_{k} if τ_{k}(s_{k}(y)) ̸= y and g_{k} = στ_{k}s_{k} otherwise. In both cases g_{k}(y) ̸= y and g_{k}(ζ) = ζω^{k+1} (since σ, s_{k} ∈G_{i} fix ζ). Because ω^{k+1}̸= 1 is an ℓ^{j}th root of unity, |ℓ| ≤|1−ω^{k+1}|, so |x−σ(x)|^{N} < δ^{N} ≤ |ℓ| ≤|1 −ω^{k+1}|; by the ultrametric triangle inequality for x −στ_{k}s_{k}(x) = (x −σ(x)) + σ(x −τ_{k}s_{k}(x)), both cases satisfy |x −g_{k}(x)|^{N} ≤|1 −ω^{k+1}|. Write y = p(x) and ζ = q(x) with p, q ∈ ℤ_{ℓ}[X]. The elements g_{k}(x) (0 ≤k < ℓ^{j}−1) are pairwise distinct because q(g_{k}(x)) = ζω^{k+1} are distinct. Every g_{k}(x) is a root of Q(X) =∏_{r̸=y}(p(X) −r) ∈O_{ℚℓ}[X], so dividing out the monic factors X −g_{k}(x) over O_{ℚℓ}

gives c = |Q(x)| ≤∏^{ℓ}_{k}^{j}_{=0}^{−2}|x −g_{k}(x)|. Raising to the Nth power gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℓ∏^{j}−2
c^{N} ≤ |1 −ω^{k+1}| = |ℓ^{j}| = ℓ^{−j}≤ℓ^{−j0}< c^{N},
k=0

a contradiction. Hence |x −σ(x)| ≥ δ for all σ ∈G_{i} moving y. Choose s_{0} ∏ ∈S in G_{Ei}. For the monic integral polynomial P(X) =∏_{t∈S\{s0}}(X −t(x)), one has ∑_{s∈S}P(s(x)) =_{t̸=s0}(s_{0}(x)−t(x)), whose

||∑norm is at least|| δ^{|S|−1} ≥ (1 −a)^{n} ≥ 1 −ε. Expanding P in powers of X, some k ≤ deg P satisfies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{s∈S}s(x^{k}) ≥1 −ε.

To deduce (ii) for a general finite Galois extension E/K_{∞} and a ∈ K_{∞} with 0 < |a| < 1 (the case a = 0 is trivial), let S ⊂H_{∞} be a transversal of H_{∞}/G_{E}. For each pair s ̸= t in S pick an element of E moved by∩ s^{−1}t, and let L^{′} ⊂ E be the finite extension of ℚ_{ℓ} they generate. By compactness of G_{ℚℓ} and _{i}G_{i} = H_{∞}, the open cover ∪_{s∈S}sG_{L}′ of H_{∞} contains G_{i} for all sufficiently large i, so S is a transversal of G∑_{i}/G_{L}′_{Ki}. Applying the preceding paragraph with ε = 1 −|a| > 0 yields b_{0} ∈ O_{L}′_{Ki} ⊂ O_{E} with t =_{s∈S}s(b_{0}) ∈K_{∞} satisfying |t| ≥|a|. Then b = (a/t)b_{0} ∈O_{E} satisfies Tr_{E/K∞}(b) = a.

For (iii), the reverse implication holds by continuity of each h ∈ H_{∞}. Conversely, if y ∈ O_{ℂ}^{H}_{ℓ}^{∞} and ε > 0, put δ = min(ε/2, 1) and pick x ∈ ℚ_{ℓ} with |y −x| < δ/ℓ. Choose a finite Galois extension E/K∑_{∞} containing x with transversal S ⊂ H_{∞}, and by (ii) choose b ∈ O_{E} with ∑_{s∈S}s(b) = ℓ. Then w =_{s∈S}s(bx) ∈K_{∞}, and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|||∑ (

|ℓy −w| = s b(y −x))||| ≤ max |b||y −x| < δ.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
s∈S^{s∈Sℓ}

Hence |y −w/ℓ| ≤δ < ε, and |w/ℓ| ≤ max(|y|, |y −w/ℓ|) ≤1, so w/ℓ∈O_{K∞}. Thus y ∈Ô_{K∞}.

For (iv), work coordinatewise (r = 1) and assume a ̸= 0. Given any continuous 1-cocycle c^{′}: H_{∞}→ℂ_{ℓ} with sup_{H∞}|c^{′}| ≤t and any ε > 0, continuity at 1 gives a finite Galois extension E/K_{∞} with transversal

S ⊂∑ H_{∞} such that |c^{′}(g)| ≤ ε on G_{E}. By (ii) choose b ∈ O_{E} with ∑_{s∈S}s(b) = a, and set x^{′} = −_{s∈S}s(b) c^{′}(s). Then |x^{′}| ≤ t. For any h ∈ H_{∞}, writing hs = π_{h}(s)v_{s} with a permutation π_{h} of S and v_{s} ∈G_{E}, the cocycle identity gives h(s(b)c^{′}(s)) = π_{h}(s)(b)(c^{′}(hs) −c^{′}(h)) = π_{h}(s)(b)(c^{′}(π_{h}(s)) + π_{h}(s)(c^{′}(v_{s})) −c^{′}(h)), so

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a c^{′}(h) −(h(x^{′}) −x^{′})=∑π_{h}(s)(b c^{′}(v_{s})),
s∈S

which has norm at most ε. Starting at y_{0} = 0 and applying this step inductively to c_{n}(g) = c(g)−a^{−1}(g(y_{n})− y_{n}) with t = 2^{−n} and ε = |a|2^{−(n+1)} yields a Cauchy sequence (y_{n}) in O_{ℂℓ} with |y_{n+1} −y_{n}| ≤2^{−n} and |a c(h) −(h(y_{n}) −y_{n})| ≤|a|2^{−n}. Its limit x ∈O_{ℂℓ} satisfies a c(h) = h(x) −x for all h ∈H_{∞}.

Lemma 6.64 (Tate decomposition, perturbation operator, and twisted invariants). Let K/ℚ_{ℓ} be finite, let j ∈ ℕ be admissible, and let g ∈ G_{j} satisfy |χ_{ℓ}(g) −1| = ℓ^{−j}. For i ≥ 1 let X_{lev}(i) be the additive subgroup of O_{Ki} generated by products ζy with ζ a primitive ℓ^{i}th root of unity and y ∈ O_{Ki−1}, and set

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X_{j} =∑_{i>j}X_{lev}(i) ⊂Ô_{K∞}.

(i) One has Ô_{K∞}= O_{Kj} + X_{j} and K_{j} ∩X_{j} = {0}. Moreover X_{j} is an O_{Kj}-submodule of Ô_{K∞} stable under G_{K0}.

(ii) For any primitive ℓth root of unity ζ_{ℓ}, there exists a unique O_{Kj}-linear map S : X_{j} →X_{j} such that

(g −1)S(x) = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)x = S(g(x) −x) for every x ∈X_{j}.

(iii) Let r ≥ 0, let U_{g} ∈ Mat_{r}(O_{Kj}) satisfy max_{a,b} |(U_{g} −I_{r})_{a,b}| < ρ_{1}(ℓ), and fix i ∈ ℤ. Write

tw_{i}(U_{g})(y) = χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}U_{g}g(y) on ℂ^{r}_{ℓ}. Then tw_{i}(U_{g}) −1 is injective on X_{j}^{r}, and its image on X_{j}^{r} contains (ζ_{ℓ}−1)X_{j}^{r}.

(iv) If y ∈ℂ_{ℓ} and i ∈ℤ satisfy χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{i}σ(y) = y for all σ ∈G_{j}, then y = 0 when i ̸= 0 and y ∈K_{j} when

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i = 0.

Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/TateDecompositionCompletedCyclotomicIntegers.lean:359--387; ExistsTateOperatorLevelComplement.lean:216--447; CyclotomicTowerGeneratorMatrixPerturbation.lean:31--133,302--334; TateInvariantsCyclotomicTwist.lean:54--115.

Proof. For (i), O_{Kj}-stability and G_{K0}-stability of X_{j} are immediate from the definition of X_{lev}(i) and con-tinuity. By Lemma 6.63(i), for i ≥ 2 every z ∈ O_{Ki} splits uniquely as y_{0} + w with y_{0} ∈ O_{Ki−1} and w ∈ X_{lev}(i) (since for 1 ≤ a < ℓ, ζ^{a} is primitive of order ℓ^{i}); furthermore K_{i−1} ∩X_{lev}(i) = {0}. It-erating downward from any layer∑ K_{j+n} shows O_{K∞} ⊂ O_{Kj} + X_{alg}(j) and K_{j} ∩X_{alg}(j) = {0}, where X_{alg}(j) =_{i>j}X_{lev}(i). Since O_{Kj} is compact and X_{j} is closed, O_{Kj}+ X_{j} is closed and therefore equals

Ô_{K∞}. If y ∈ K_{j} and w ∈ X_{alg}(j) satisfy |y −w| ≤ ℓ^{−n}, then (y −w)/ℓ^{n} ∈ O_{K∞} decomposes as y^{′}+ w^{′} with y^{′} ∈O_{Kj} and w^{′} ∈X_{alg}(j), forcing y −ℓ^{n}y^{′} = w + ℓ^{n}w^{′} ∈K_{j} ∩X_{alg}(j) = {0} and thus |y| = |ℓ^{n}y^{′}| ≤ℓ^{−n}. Taking n →∞ proves K_{j} ∩X_{j} = {0}.

For (ii), first solve on a generator zy ∈ X_{lev}(j + b + 1) (b ≥ 0, z primitive of order ℓ^{j+b+1}, y ∈ O_{Kj+b}). Because j is admissible, lifting the exponent (as in Lemma 6.8) gives |χ_{ℓ}(g^{ℓb}) −1| = ℓ^{−(j+b)},

so g^{ℓb} ∈ G_{j+b} fixes y and z^{ℓ}, while g^{ℓb}(z) ̸= z. Hence η = g^{ℓb}(z)/z is a primitive ℓth root of unity, |η −1| = ρ_{1}(ℓ) = |ζ_{ℓ}−1|, and w =^{ζ}_{η}^{ℓ}_{−}^{−}_{1}^{1}y ∈O_{Kj+b}. Then u = zw ∈X_{alg}(j) and the telescoping sum

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑b

v =_{k}^{ℓ}_{=0}^{−1}g^{k}(u) ∈ X_{j} ∩K_{∞} satisfies g(v) −v = (g^{ℓb} −1)(zw) = (η −1)zw = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)zy. Next, if d ∈X_{alg}(j) satisfies |g(d) −d| ≤ℓ^{−n}, then (g(d) −d)/ℓ^{n} ∈O_{K∞} splits as o + d^{′} with o ∈O_{Kj} and d^{′}∈X_{alg}(j), and ℓ^{n}o = (g(d) −d) −ℓ^{n}d^{′}∈K_{j} ∩X_{j} = {0} gives o = 0. Choosing y ∈X_{j} ∩K_{∞} with

g(y) −y = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)d^{′}, the element (ζ_{ℓ}−1)d −ℓ^{n}y ∈X_{j} ∩K_{∞} is fixed by g; since g generates G_{j}/G_{m} on every finite layer K_{m}, this element lies in K_{j} ∩X_{j} = {0}. Thus |(ζ_{ℓ}−1)d| = |ℓ^{n}y| ≤ℓ^{−n}. Choosing n with ℓ^{−(n+1)}< |g(d) −d| ≤ℓ^{−n} (or letting n →∞ when g(d) = d) gives |ζ_{ℓ}−1||d| ≤ℓ|g(d) −d| on X_{alg}(j), and by continuity on all of X_{j}. Therefore g−1 : X_{j} →X_{j} is injective with closed image containing (ζ_{ℓ}−1)X_{alg}(j), hence containing (ζ_{ℓ}−1)X_{j}. This defines the unique O_{Kj}-linear map S : X_{j} →X_{j} with (g −1)S(x) = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)x; uniqueness gives S(g(x) −x) = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)x.

For (iii), admissibility of j gives ℓ^{−j} < ρ_{1}(ℓ) (for ℓ≥3, j ≥1 > 1/(ℓ−1); for ℓ= 2, j ≥2 > 1). Hence |χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}−1| ≤|χ_{ℓ}(g) −1| = ℓ^{−j} < ρ_{1}(ℓ) = |ζ_{ℓ}−1|. Since ‖U_{g} −I_{r}‖_{∞} < ρ_{1}(ℓ), the matrix B = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)^{−1}(χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}U_{g} −I_{r}) has entries in O_{Kj} of norm strictly less than 1. Choosing an entry π ∈O_{Kj} of B of maximal norm (or π = 0 if B = 0) writes χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}U_{g} = I_{r} + (ζ_{ℓ}−1)πB^{′} with |π| < 1 and B^{′}∈ Mat_{r}(O_{Kj}). For y ∈X_{j}^{r},

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
tw_{i}(U_{g})(y) −y =(g(y) −y)+ (ζ_{ℓ}−1)πB^{′}g(y).

If tw_{i}(U_{g})(y) = y, applying S coordinatewise and using O_{Kj}-linearity of S yields (ζ_{ℓ}−1)y = −(ζ_{ℓ}− 1)πS(B^{′}g(y)), so y = −πS(B^{′}g(y)) ∈πX_{j}^{r}. Inductively y ∈π^{k}X_{j}^{r} for all k ≥0, hence |y_{a}| ≤|π|^{k} →0 and y = 0. For surjectivity onto (ζ_{ℓ}−1)X_{j}^{r}, define T : X_{j}^{r}→X_{j}^{r} by T(v) = B^{′}g(S(v)). Given w ∈X_{j}^{r}, the series y =∑^{∞}_{k=0}(−π)^{k}S(T^{ k}w) converges in the closed group X_{j}^{r} since |π| < 1, and the partial sums

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑

P_{n} =_{k}^{n}_{=0}^{−1}(−π)^{k}S(T^{ k}w) satisfy inductively

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
tw_{i}(U_{g})(P_{n}) −P_{n} = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)w −(ζ_{ℓ}−1)(−π)^{n}T^{n}w.

Letting n →∞ gives tw_{i}(U_{g})(y) −y = (ζ_{ℓ}−1)w.

For (iv), choose n ∈ ℕ so z = ℓ^{n}y ∈ O_{ℂℓ}. Since χ_{ℓ}|_{H∞} = 1, z is fixed by H_{∞}, so z ∈ Ô_{K∞} by

Lemma 6.63(iii). Split z = a + x with a ∈ O_{Kj} and x ∈ X_{j} via (i). Applying χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}g(z) = z yields (χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}−1)a = x −χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}g(x) ∈K_{j} ∩X_{j} = {0}. Hence χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}g(x) = x, which forces x = 0 by (iii) with r = 1 and U_{g} = I_{1}. If i ̸= 0, lifting the exponent gives |χ_{ℓ}(g)^{i}−1| = ℓ^{−(j+vℓ(i))}> 0, so a = 0 and y = 0. If i = 0, then z = a ∈O_{Kj}, so y = ℓ^{−n}a ∈K_{j}.

We call a continuous map U : G_{m} → Mat_{r}(O_{Km}) together with a generator g ∈G_{m} a cyclotomic frame of level m if |χ_{ℓ}(g) −1| = ℓ^{−m}, U is a group homomorphism on G_{m} trivial on H_{∞}, and max_{a,b} |(U(g) − I_{r})_{a,b}| < ρ_{1}(ℓ). A Hodge–Tate basis for U with weights in J ⊂ℤ is a ℂ_{ℓ}-basis e_{1}, . . . , e_{r} of ℂ^{r}_{ℓ} together with u_{1}, . . . , u_{r} ∈J such that χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{uk}U(σ)σ(e_{k}) = e_{k} for all σ ∈G_{m} and all k.

Lemma 6.65 (The realized Wach lattice supplies a cyclotomic decompletion frame). Let (K, s, L) be a good triple and let T be a G_{K}-stable finite free O-lattice in a continuous L-linear representation (V, ρ) of G_{K}, with ℤ_{ℓ}-rank d = f rank_{O} T. Fix a ℤ_{ℓ}-basis b_{1}, . . . , b_{d} of T, and let M : G_{K} → GL_{d}(ℤ_{ℓ}) ⊂ Mat_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) and A : O → Mat_{d}(ℤ_{ℓ}) ⊂ Mat_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) be the matrices of the G_{K}-action and O-multiplication in this basis. Suppose T admits an integral Wach module N ⊂D(T) over A_{W} = O⊗_{ℤℓ}W(k)[[u]] ≃∏_{ℤ/nℤ}O[[u]] whose

A_{W}-basis becomes an (O ⊗_{ℤℓ} W(C^{♭}))-basis under the etale comparison j_{D}, with heights M_{0}, h_{0} ≥ 0 satisfying Q^{M}_{s}^{0}φ(N) ⊂ N, Q_{s}^{h0}N ⊂ A_{W}φ(N), and (γ −1)N ⊂ uN for all γ ∈ Gal(K_{∞}/K_{s}). Set m = m_{N}(ℓ, s, M_{0} + h_{0}). Then there exist D ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}) ∩ GL_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) with ℓD^{−1} ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}), a cyclotomic frame (U_{0}, g) of level m and size d such that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
DU_{0}(σ) = M(σ)σ(D) (σ ∈G_{m}),

and D^{−1}A(a)D ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{Km}) for all a ∈O.

Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/ExistsContinuousGaloisLatticeMatrixIntegral.lean:188--228; WachLatticeSandwichAinf.lean:39--126,168--268; ExistsFontaineThetaFrobenius

InverseShift.lean:49--78; ExistsAinfTensorLatticeSpecialisation.lean:184--218; KapIdemMemInC.lean:71--103; OcTensorCoeffBasisCoordsMemCyclotomicLevelOfPowe.lean:69--112; OneAddXPowPrimePowSubOneMemSpan.lean:5--50; GammaActionSubMemSpanPowSucc.lean:7--125; SemilinearIteratePrimePowSubMemFiltration.lean:40--64; NormLtRho1OfMemIdealPower.lean:35--110; ExistsPrimeEqMulPrimitiveRootSubOnePow.lean:13--43; DecompletionFrameOfMatrixForm.lean:23--91; ExistsDecompletionFrameOfLattice.lean:151--258,329--470.

Proof. Continuity of M on G_{K} follows because each ℤ_{ℓ}-coordinate functional on T extends to a ℚ_{ℓ}-linear form on the finite-dimensional space V , which is continuous in the module topology. Write R_{A} = O⊗_{ℤℓ}A_{inf} and R_{W} = O⊗_{ℤℓ}W(C^{♭}). Since φ(X_{s}) = X_{s}Q_{s} in R_{W} , the proof of Lemma 6.45 (applying Lemma 6.44 to the transition matrix Z of an A_{W}-basis of N in an O-basis of T, and to Z^{−1}) shows that X_{s}^{M0}Z and X_{s}^{h0}Z^{−1} both have entries in R_{A}. Equivalently, since R_{A} ⊗_{O} T →R_{W} ⊗_{O} T is injective, there is a unique A_{W}-linear lift z : N →R_{A} ⊗_{O} T of X_{s}^{M0}j_{D} satisfying

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X_{s}^{M0}· σ(z(y)) = σ(X_{s})^{M0}· z(γ_{σ}(y)) (σ ∈G_{Ks}, y ∈N), X_{s}^{M0+h0}(1 ⊗T) ⊂R_{A} · z(N). (145)

Put n = n_{0}(ℓ, M_{0} +h_{0}), so m = 2s+n+1 = s+(s+n+1), and let θ_{n} = θ∘φ^{−n}: A_{inf} →O_{ℂℓ} be the shifted Fontaine specialization. It is G_{ℚℓ}-equivariant and sends [ε^{(j)}] to ζ_{ℓ}j+n, where (ζ_{ℓ}r) is the compatible

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
id ⊗θn

system of primitive ℓ^{r}th roots of unity underlying ε. Under the composite φ_{sp} : A_{W} → R_{A} −−−−→^{O} O_{ℂℓ}⊗_{ℤℓ}O, the variable u maps to (ζ_{ℓ}s+n −1) ⊗1 and X_{s} = (1 + u)^{ℓs−1}−1 maps to (ζ_{ℓ}1+n −1) ⊗1. Put c = ζ_{ℓ}1+n −1 ∈ O_{K1+n} ⊂ O_{Km}. Since M_{0} + h_{0} ≤ ℓ^{n}(ℓ−1) and |c| = ℓ^{−1/(ℓn(ℓ−1))}, we have |c^{M0+h0}| ≥ℓ^{−1}= |ℓ|, so ℓ= u_{0}c^{M0+h0} with u_{0} ∈O_{ℂℓ}.

Choose a ℤ_{ℓ}-basis o_{1}, . . . , o_{f} of O. Every w ∈ O_{ℂℓ} ⊗_{ℤℓ} O writes uniquely as ∑^{f}_{k=1}κ_{k}(w) ⊗o_{k} with κ_{k}(w) ∈ O_{ℂℓ}; the map Λ(w) = ∑^{f}_{k=1}κ_{k}(w)A(o_{k}) is a ring homomorphism into Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}) with Λ(1 ⊗a) = A(a). Specializing R_{A} ⊗_{O} T via θ_{n} on R_{A} and ℤ_{ℓ}-coordinates on T gives an additive map Φ : R_{A} ⊗_{O} T →O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ} such that Φ(r ·w) = Λ((id_{O} ⊗θ_{n})(r))Φ(w), Φ(σ(w)) = M(σ)σ(Φ(w)) for σ ∈G_{K}, and Φ(1 ⊗b_{j}) is the jth standard basis vector e_{j}. Set Ψ = Φ ∘z : N →O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}. For σ ∈G_{m}, σ fixes ζ_{ℓ}1+n (as 1 + n ≤m), so θ_{n}(σ(X_{s})) = c = θ_{n}(X_{s}). Applying Φ to the first relation in (145) and canceling the nonzero scalar c^{M0} yields

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Ψ(γ_{σ}(y)) = M(σ)σ(Ψ(y)) (σ ∈G_{m}, y ∈N).

Let (b^{′}_{j})_{j}^{ρ}_{=1} be an A_{W}-basis of N (comparing R_{W} -ranks gives ρ = rank_{O} T, so fρ = d), and let D ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}) be the square matrix whose columns are the d vectors Ψ(o_{k}b^{′}_{j}). Expanding any y ∈ N in (b^{′}_{j}) and taking κ_{k}(φ_{sp}(·)) expresses Ψ(y) as D · co(y) with co(y) ∈ O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}. The same holds for every element of the additive closure of Λ(O_{ℂℓ}⊗_{ℤℓ}O)Ψ(N). Applying Φ to the second inclusion in (145) puts c^{M0+h0}e_{j} in that closure; multiplying by u_{0} yields Y ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}) with DY = ℓI_{d}. Thus D ∈ GL_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) and ℓD^{−1}= Y ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{ℂℓ}). ∏ We verify that every coordinate κ_{k}(φ_{sp}(a)) (a ∈A_{W}) lies in O_{Km}. Each factor idempotent e_{i} of A_{W} = _{ℤ/nℤ}O[[u]] is G_{K}-invariant and idempotent; evaluating φ_{sp}(e_{i}) at all f embeddings η_{1}, . . . , η_{f} : L ↪→ℚ_{ℓ} gives values in {0, 1}. Since the embedding matrix (η_{r}(o_{k})) has nonzero discriminant, inverting it shows each κ_{k}(φ_{sp}(e_{i})) lies in ℚ_{ℓ} and is fixed by G_{K}, hence lies in K ⊂K_{m}. Any a ∈A_{W} expands modulo u^{q} as a polynomial in u with coefficients in ∑_{i}e_{i}O. Since φ_{sp}(u) = (ζ_{ℓ}s+n −1) ⊗1 with ζ_{ℓ}s+n −1 ∈O_{Km} and |ζ_{ℓ}s+n −1| < 1, truncation modulo u^{q} approximates κ_{k}(φ_{sp}(a)) arbitrarily closely by elements of O_{Km}, which is compact and hence closed. Thus κ_{k}(φ_{sp}(a)) ∈O_{Km} for all a ∈A_{W}.

Set U_{0}(σ) = D^{−1}M(σ)σ(D) for σ ∈G_{m}. Its columns are co(γ_{σ}(o_{k}b^{′}_{j})), hence lie in O_{K}^{d}_{m}. Since M is continuous on G_{m} and G_{m} fixes O_{Km} and M(τ) pointwise, U_{0} is continuous and multiplicative on G_{m}. For σ ∈H_{∞}, γ_{σ} = 1, so U_{0}(σ) = I_{d}. Similarly, for any a ∈O, the columns of A(a)D are Ψ(a · o_{k}b^{′}_{j}), so D^{−1}A(a)D has entries in O_{Km}.

Finally, pick a generator g_{0} ∈G_{s} with |χ_{ℓ}(g_{0}) −1| = ℓ^{−s} and put g = g_{0}^{ℓs+n+1}. Since s is admissible, lifting the exponent gives g ∈G_{m} and |χ_{ℓ}(g) −1| = ℓ^{−m}. Write 𝔫 = (ℓ, u) ⊂A_{W}. Because χ_{ℓ}(g_{0}) ≡1 (mod ℓ^{s}) with s ≥ 1, the power series γ_{g0}(u) = (1 + u)^{χℓ(g0)}−1 satisfies γ_{g0}(u) −u ∈ u(ℓ, u) = 𝔫^{2}, while γ_{g0}(a) −a ∈uA_{W} ⊂𝔫 for all a ∈A_{W}. By the twisted Leibniz rule, (γ_{g0} −1)(𝔫^{k}) ⊂𝔫^{k+1} and hence (γ_{g0} −1)^{k}(N) ⊂𝔫^{k}N for all k ≥0. For any integer b ≥1 and 1 ≤k < ℓ^{b−1}, one has v_{ℓ}(k) ≤b −2, so

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(b) (b ) (b)

k^{ℓ}_{k} = ℓ^{bℓ}_{k−}^{−}_{1}^{1} implies ℓ^{2}|^{ℓ}_{k} ; hence (1+X)^{ℓb}−1 ∈(ℓ^{2}, X^{ℓb−1}) ⊂ℤ[X]. Applying this to X = γ_{g0} −1 with b = s + n + 1 gives ( )

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(γ_{g} −1)(N) ⊂ ℓ^{2}A_{W} + 𝔫^{ℓs+n} N.

Put j = s + n ≥1 and z = ζ_{ℓ}j −1. Since |ℓ| = ℓ^{−1} ≤ℓ^{−1/(ℓj−1(ℓ−1))} = |z|, we have ℓ∈zO_{ℂℓ}, so φ_{sp} maps ℓ^{2}A_{W} + 𝔫^{ℓj} into (ℓ^{2}⊗1, z^{ℓj}⊗1). Therefore every entry of U_{0}(g) −I_{d} has norm at most

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( j ) ( )

max |ℓ^{2}|, |z^{ℓ} | = max ℓ^{−2}, ℓ^{−ℓ/(ℓ−1)} < ℓ^{−1/(ℓ−1)}= ρ_{1}(ℓ).

Thus (U_{0}, g) is a cyclotomic frame of level m.

Lemma 6.66 (Isolating the τ-component frame, Hodge–Tate basis, and integrality test). Under the hypothe-ses of Lemma 6.65, suppose further that V is de Rham over K with dim_{K} D_{dR}(V ) = d and that Fontaine’s period ring B_{dR} carries its canonical G_{K}-equivariant surjective ring homomorphism θ_{dR} : Fil^{0}B_{dR} →ℂ_{ℓ} with kernel Fil^{1}B_{dR} = t Fil^{0}B_{dR} extending ℚ_{ℓ}↪→ℂ_{ℓ} and g(t) = χ_{ℓ}(g)t. Fix a ℚ_{ℓ}-embedding τ : K ↪→L, and let U_{τ} = {u ∈ ℤ : Fil^{u+1}D_{dR,τ}(V ) ̸= Fil^{u}D_{dR,τ}(V )} be the set of Hodge jumps of the τ-isotypic component D_{dR,τ}(V ). Then U_{τ} is finite, and there exist r ≥0, P_{m} ∈ Mat_{r×d}(ℂ_{ℓ}), and a cyclotomic frame (U, g) of level m = m_{N}(ℓ, s, M_{0} + h_{0}) and size r such that:

(i) U admits a Hodge–Tate basis with weights in U_{τ};

(ii) P_{m}M(σ) = U(σ)σ(P_{m}) for all σ ∈G_{m};

(iii) O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}⊂P_{m}(O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}) and ℓP_{m}(O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}) ⊂O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ};

(iv) for every y ∈ℚ^{d}_{ℓ}, if P_{m}y ∈P_{m}(O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}) then y ∈ℤ^{d}_{ℓ}.

Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/ExistsIntegralFactorOfIdempotentSubfield.lean:43--133; ExistsSubBasis.lean:85--218; SerreTateLinearIndependentOfWeightwise.lean:38--98; ExistsSymbolBasis.lean:118--169; TmulMemFilV.lean:94--111,183--207; NormCoeAutLeOneIff.lean:53--105; NonemptyThetaOnBdRPlusPeriodData.lean:147--206; ExistsTauComponentFrameOfLattice.lean:150--260.

Proof. Since D_{dR,τ}(V ) is a finite-dimensional L-subspace of D_{dR}(V ), the filtration Fil^{•}D_{dR,τ}(V ) can jump at most dim_{L} D_{dR,τ}(V ) times, so U_{τ} is finite. Let (D, U_{0}, g) be the decompletion data from Lemma 6.65, and extend A to the ℚ_{ℓ}-algebra map B : L → Mat_{d}(ℚ_{ℓ}) ⊂ Mat_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) of L-scalar multiplication in the ℚ_{ℓ}-basis b_{1}, . . . , b_{d} of V . ∑ Since K/ℚ_{ℓ} is finite separable, choose a separability idempotent ∑ ∑^{q}_{j=1}α_{j} ⊗β_{j} ∈K ⊗_{ℚℓ}K satisfying

_{j}(κα_{j}) ⊗β_{j} =_{j}α_{j} ⊗(κβ_{j}) for all κ ∈K and ∑_{j}α_{j}β_{j} = 1. Put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑q

E = β_{j}B(τ(α_{j})) ∈ Mat_{d}(ℂ_{ℓ}).

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j=1

Then B(τ(κ))E = κE for all κ ∈ K, whence E^{2} = (∑_{j}α_{j}β_{j})E = E. Because B(a) commutes with M(σ) and β_{j} ∈K ⊂K_{m}, E commutes with M(σ) and is fixed by G_{m}. Clearing ℤ_{ℓ}-denominators from

D^{−1}A(a)D ∈ Mat_{d}(O_{Km}) shows e^{′}= D^{−1}ED is an idempotent in Mat_{d}(K_{m}), and DU_{0}(σ) = M(σ)σ(D) yields e^{′}U_{0}(σ) = U_{0}(σ)e^{′} for all σ ∈G_{m}.

Let r = rank(e^{′}), and among all r × r submatrices of e^{′} choose row and column index tuples (τ_{0}, σ_{0}) maximizing | det(e^{′}_{τ0,σ0})| > 0. Define R = (e^{′}_{τ0,σ0})^{−1}e_{τ}^{′}_{0,•} ∈ Mat_{r×d}(K_{m}) and let S ∈ Mat_{d×r}({0, 1}) be the matrix selecting the columns σ_{0}. By Cramer’s rule, each entry of R is a ratio det(e^{′}_{τ0,σ0′})/ det(e^{′}_{τ0,σ0}) and hence has norm at most 1 by maximality; thus R ∈ Mat_{r×d}(O_{Km}) and S ∈ Mat_{d×r}(O_{Km}). Clearly RS = I_{r}, Re^{′} = R (from (e^{′})^{2} = e^{′}), and the vanishing of all (r + 1) × (r + 1) minors of e^{′} implies the Schur-complement identity e^{′}SR = e^{′}.

Now set P_{m} = RD^{−1}, U(σ) = RU_{0}(σ)S for σ ∈ G_{m}, and Q = De^{′}S. Using e^{′}U_{0}(σ) = U_{0}(σ)e^{′} and e^{′}SR = e^{′}, one gets RU_{0}(σ)SR = RU_{0}(σ)e^{′}SR = RU_{0}(σ)e^{′}= Re^{′}U_{0}(σ) = RU_{0}(σ). This directly implies that (U, g) is a cyclotomic frame of level m and size r (in particular U(g) −I_{r} = R(U_{0}(g) −I_{d})S has entry norms strictly below ρ_{1}(ℓ) because R, S are integral), that P_{m}M(σ) = U(σ)σ(P_{m}) for σ ∈G_{m}, and that QP_{m} = De^{′}SRD^{−1}= De^{′}D^{−1}= E. Since P_{m}(DS) = RS = I_{r} with DS ∈ Mat_{d×r}(O_{ℂℓ}), we have O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} ⊂P_{m}(O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}); since ℓP_{m} = R(ℓD^{−1}) is a product of integral matrices, ℓP_{m}(O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}) ⊂O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}. This proves (ii) and (iii).

To construct the Hodge–Tate basis in (i), choose a K-basis x_{1}, . . . , x_{d} of D_{dR}(V ) ⊂B_{dR}^{d} (in coordinates of (b_{i})) adapted to the exhaustive separated filtration Fil^{•}B_{dR}^{d}: there are integers u_{1}, . . . , u_{d} with x_{k} ∈ Fil^{uk}B_{dR}^{d} such that any K-linear combination ∑_{uk=a}c_{k}x_{k} lying in Fil^{a+1} B_{dR}^{d} has all c_{k} = 0. Set y_{k} = t^{−uk}x_{k} ∈(Fil^{0}B_{dR})^{d} and e_{k} = θ_{dR}(y_{k}) ∈ℂ^{d}_{ℓ}. Because M(σ)σ(x_{k}) = x_{k} and σ(t) = χ_{ℓ}(σ)t, applying θ_{dR} gives χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{uk}M(σ)σ(e_{k}) = e_{k} for all σ ∈G_{K}. If ∑_{uk=a}c_{k}e_{k} = 0 with c_{k} ∈K, then ∑_{uk=a}c_{k}y_{k} ∈ (ker θ_{dR})^{d} = (Fil^{1}B_{dR})^{d}, so multiplying by t^{a} puts ∑_{uk=a}c_{k}x_{k} ∈ Fil^{a+1} B_{dR}^{d}, forcing all c_{k} = 0. By induction on the support size of a putative ℂ_{ℓ}-linear dependence ∑_{k}c_{k}e_{k} = 0 (dividing by a nonzero coefficient c_{k0} and applying χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{uk0}M(σ)σ(·) forces χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{uk0−uk}σ(c_{k}/c_{k0}) = c_{k}/c_{k0} for all σ ∈ G_{K}, hence c_{k}/c_{k0} = 0 for u_{k} ̸= u_{k0} and c_{k}/c_{k0} ∈ K for u_{k} = u_{k0} by Lemma 6.64(iv) and Galois descent), e_{1}, . . . , e_{d} form a ℂ_{ℓ}-basis of ℂ^{d}_{ℓ}.

Moreover, if u_{k} /∈U_{τ}, then applying the projector ∑_{j}τ(α_{j}) ⊗β_{j} to X_{k} = ∑_{i}b_{i} ⊗x_{k,i} ∈D_{dR}(V ) ∩ Fil^{uk} produces an element of D_{dR,τ}(V ) ∩ Fil^{uk} = D_{dR,τ}(V ) ∩ Fil^{uk+1}. Multiplying by t^{−uk} lands in Fil^{1}B_{dR} in every (b_{i})-coordinate; applying θ_{dR} gives Ee_{k} = 0. Since P_{m} is surjective onto ℂ^{r}_{ℓ}, a subset P_{m}e_{κ(1)}, . . . , P_{m}e_{κ(r)} is a ℂ_{ℓ}-basis of ℂ^{r}_{ℓ}. As P_{m}E = RD^{−1}De^{′}D^{−1} = Re^{′}D^{−1} = P_{m}, we have Ee_{κ(j)} ̸= 0 and hence u_{κ(j)} ∈U_{τ} for every j. By (ii), each P_{m}e_{κ(j)} is fixed by χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{uκ(j)}U(σ)σ(·) on G_{m}, proving (i).

For (iv), extend τ : K ↪→L ⊂ℚ_{ℓ} to an automorphism ι^{−1}∈G_{ℚℓ}, so ι(τ(κ)) = κ for all κ ∈K, and let φ : L ↪→ℂ_{ℓ} be the restriction of ι. Choose an O-basis t_{1}, . . . , t_{ρ} of T (hence an L-basis of V ), and form Pr ∈ Mat_{ρ×d}(ℂ_{ℓ}) with entries Pr_{i,j} = φ(t^{∗}_{i}(b_{j})). Since b_{j} ∈T, each t^{∗}_{i}(b_{j}) ∈O, and ι preserves norms on ℚ_{ℓ}, so | Pr_{i,j} | ≤1. By construction Pr ·B(a) = φ(a) Pr for all a ∈L, whence

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑q (∑q )

Pr ·E = β_{j}φ(τ(α_{j})) Pr = α_{j}β_{j} Pr = Pr .

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j=1 j=1

For any y ∈ℚ^{d}_{ℓ}, writing v = ∑_{j}y_{j}b_{j} ∈V , we have (Pr ·y)_{i} = φ(t^{∗}_{i}(v)), so ‖ Pr ·y‖_{∞} ≤1 holds if and only if t^{∗}_{i}(v) ∈O for all i, i.e. v ∈T, i.e. y ∈ℤ^{d}_{ℓ}. If P_{m}y = P_{m}x with x ∈O_{ℂ}^{d}_{ℓ}, then

Pr ·y = Pr ·Ey = Pr ·QP_{m}y = Pr ·QP_{m}x = Pr ·Ex = Pr ·x ∈O_{ℂ}^{ρ}_{ℓ},

forcing y ∈ℤ^{d}_{ℓ}.

Lemma 6.67 (Twisted-invariant annihilator for a cyclotomic frame). Let K/ℚ_{ℓ} be finite, let m ∈ ℕ be admissible, and let (U, g) be a cyclotomic frame of level m and size r admitting a Hodge–Tate basis with

weights in a finite set J ⊂ℤ. Fix i ∈ℤ \ J, and set

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( ∑( ))

N = max 1, m + v_{ℓ}(u −i) ,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
u∈J

where v_{ℓ}(a) = v_{ℓ}(|a|) for a ∈ℤ \ {0}. Write tw_{i}(U; σ)(y) = χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{i}U(σ)σ(y).

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )

(i) The matrix U(g) satisfies ∏_{u∈J} U(g) −χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−u}I_{r} = 0.

(ii) If c : G_{m} →O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} is a continuous tw_{i}(U)-cocycle such that ℓ^{k}c is a tw_{i}(U)-coboundary on O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} for

some k ≥0, then ℓ^{1+N}c is a tw_{i}(U)-coboundary on O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}.

(iii) Let ℳ ⊂ ℂ^{r}_{ℓ} be an additive subgroup such that O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} ⊂ℳ and ℓℳ ⊂ O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}. If y ∈ ℂ^{r}_{ℓ} satisfies

tw_{i}(U; σ)(y) −y ∈ℳ for all σ ∈G_{m}, then ℓ^{2+N}y ∈ℳ.

Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/InertiaEigenvalues/AevalProdEqZeroHodgeTateCyclotomicFrame.lean:59--141; TorsionCoinvariantsTwistedCyclotomicGenerator.lean:14--61,175--260; CocycleVanishingOnFixingSubgroupDeterminedByGene.lean:367--386; CocycleTwistCoboundaryOnBall.lean:244--344; PrimePowSmulMemOfTwistedInvariantModLattice.lean:212--320.

Proof. For (i), let e_{1}, . . . , e_{r} be a Hodge–Tate basis with weights u_{k} ∈J. Scale e_{k} by ℓ^{a} so ̃e_{k} = ℓ^{a}e_{k} ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}.

Since U|_{H∞}= I_{r} and χ_{ℓ}|_{H∞}= 1, ̃e_{k} is H_{∞}-fixed, hence lies in Ô_{K}^{r}_{∞}= O_{K}^{r}_{m}⊕X_{m}^{r} by Lemmas 6.63(iii) and 6.64(i). Writing ̃e_{k} = y_{0} + x, the invariance tw_{uk}(U; g)(̃e_{k}) = ̃e_{k} separates into the two summands (as K_{m} ∩X_{m} = 0), giving tw_{uk}(U; g)(x) = x, hence x = 0 by Lemma 6.64(iii). Thus ̃e_{k} ∈O_{K}^{r}_{m} is fixed by g, so U(g)e_{k} = χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−uk}e_{k}. Because (e_{k}) is a ℂ_{ℓ}-basis and each u_{k} ∈J, the polynomial ∏_{u∈J}(X −χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−u}) annihilates U(g).

For (ii), since tw_{i}(U) coincides with the coordinatewise action on H_{∞}, applying Lemma 6.63(iv) with a = ℓ gives x_{1} ∈ O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} with ℓc(h) = h(x_{1}) −x_{1} for all h ∈ H_{∞}. The modified continuous cocycle c_{1}(σ) = ℓc(σ) −(tw_{i}(U; σ)(x_{1}) −x_{1}) maps G_{m} into O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} and vanishes on H_{∞}. Since H_{∞}◁G_{m}, for every h ∈H_{∞} we have g(g^{−1}hg) = hg with g^{−1}hg ∈H_{∞}; evaluating c_{1} on both sides gives h(c_{1}(g)) = c_{1}(g), so c_{1}(g) ∈Ô_{K}^{r}_{∞} by Lemma 6.63(iii). If ℓ^{k}c(σ) = tw_{i}(U; σ)(x_{0})−x_{0} with x_{0} ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}, then x_{2} = ℓx_{0} −ℓ^{k}x_{1} ∈

O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} satisfies ℓ^{k}c_{1}(σ) = tw_{i}(U; σ)(x_{2}) −x_{2} on G_{m}; evaluating on H_{∞} shows x_{2} ∈Ô_{K}^{r}_{∞}.

Now split c_{1}(g) = w_{0} +w_{X} and x_{2} = v_{0} +v_{X} in O_{K}^{r}_{m}⊕X_{m}^{r}. For the X_{m}-component, pick a primitive ℓth root of unity ζ_{ℓ}; since N ≥1 and |ℓ| = ℓ^{−1}≤ℓ^{−1/(ℓ−1)}= |ζ_{ℓ}−1|, we have ℓ^{N}/(ζ_{ℓ}−1) ∈O_{Km}, so (ℓ^{N}/(ζ_{ℓ}−1))w_{X} ∈X_{m}^{r}. By Lemma 6.64(iii) there exists y_{X} ∈X_{m}^{r} with tw_{i}(U; g)(y_{X}) −y_{X} = ℓ^{N}w_{X}. For the O_{Km}-component, separating summands gives U(g)v_{0} −χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i}v_{0} = (χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i}ℓ^{k})w_{0}. Put f(u) = χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−u}∈O_{Km} and b = f(i). By induction on any finite set F ⊂ℤ, writing P_{F} (X) =∏_{u∈F}(X −f(u)), polynomial division yields a vector y_{1} ∈O_{K}^{r}_{m} with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P_{F} (U(g))w_{0} =(∏(b −f(u)))w_{0} + (U(g) −bI_{r})y_{1}.
u∈F

Taking F = J (recall i /∈ J), multiplying the left-hand side by χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i}ℓ^{k} ̸= 0 gives P_{J}(U(g))(U(g) − bI_{r})v_{0}∏= 0 by (i), hence P_{J}(U(g))w_{0} = 0. Thus (U(g) − χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i}I_{r})(−y_{1}) = βw_{0}, where β =_{u∈J}(χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i} −χ_{ℓ}(g)^{−u}) ∈ ℤ_{ℓ}. By lifting the exponent for admissible m, each factor has norm |χ_{ℓ}(g)^{u−i}−1| = ℓ^{−(m+vℓ(u−i))}, so |β| = ℓ^{−}∑^{u∈J(m+vℓ(u−i))}≥ℓ^{−N}. Hence t = ℓ^{N}/β ∈ℤ_{ℓ}⊂O_{Km}, and setting y_{0} = −tχ_{ℓ}(g)^{−i}y_{1} ∈O_{K}^{r}_{m} gives tw_{i}(U; g)(y_{0}) −y_{0} = ℓ^{N}w_{0}. Putting y = y_{0} + y_{X} ∈Ô_{K}^{r}_{∞}⊂O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}, the continuous tw_{i}(U)-cocycle d(σ) = ℓ^{N}c_{1}(σ) −(tw_{i}(U; σ)(y) −y) vanishes on H_{∞} and at g, hence on all of H_{∞}· {g^{a} : a ∈ℕ}. Because G_{m}/H_{∞} ≃ℤ_{ℓ} is topologically generated by g, this subset is dense in

G_{m}, so d ≡0 on G_{m}. Therefore ℓ^{1+N}c(σ) = tw_{i}(U; σ)(y + ℓ^{N}x_{1}) −(y + ℓ^{N}x_{1}) with y + ℓ^{N}x_{1} ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}, proving (ii).

For (iii), the hypothesis ℓℳ ⊂O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} implies that c(σ) = ℓ(tw_{i}(U; σ)(y) −y) is a continuous tw_{i}(U)-cocycle on G_{m} valued in O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}. Choose k ∈ℕ with ℓ^{k+1}y ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}; then ℓ^{k}c(σ) = tw_{i}(U; σ)(ℓ^{k+1}y) −ℓ^{k+1}y, so (ii) gives z ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ} with ℓ^{2+N}(tw_{i}(U; σ)(y) −y) = ℓ^{1+N}c(σ) = tw_{i}(U; σ)(z) −z for all σ ∈G_{m}. Thus w = ℓ^{2+N}y −z ∈ℂ_{ℓ}^{r} is fixed by tw_{i}(U; G_{m}). Expanding w = ∑^{r}_{k=1}c_{k}e_{k} in the Hodge–Tate basis yields χ_{ℓ}(σ)^{i−uk}σ(c_{k}) = c_{k} for all σ ∈ G_{m}. Since i /∈ J, every i −u_{k} is nonzero, so Lemma 6.64(iv) forces c_{k} = 0 for all k, i.e. w = 0. Consequently ℓ^{2+N}y = z ∈O_{ℂ}^{r}_{ℓ}⊂ℳ.