Section 10.2 · PDF pages 760–762
The prismatic normalization and its Hodge quotient
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
10.2 The prismatic normalization and its Hodge quotient
The separate prismatic input in the Hodge-bundle package requires a functor, not merely the existence of individual modules. We record the part whose precise normalization is already checked against the published construction.
Lemma 10.8 (The perfectoid base hypotheses). The ring O in Lemma 10.1 is an integral perfectoid ring. It is therefore among the quasisyntomic bases of prismatic Dieudonne theory.
Proof. It is p-complete by assumption and has no p-torsion, being a subring of a characteristic-zero field. Choose ϖ ∈C with ϖ^{p} = p. Its valuation is v(p)^{1/p} < 1, so ϖ ∈O and ϖ^{p} = p. Frobenius on O/p is surjective: given a lift x ∈O, choose y ∈C with y^{p} = x. Then v(y)^{p} = v(x) ≤1, so y ∈O. Its kernel on O/p consists of the classes of z with v(z)^{p} ≤v(p), equivalently v(z) ≤v(ϖ), equivalently z ∈ϖO. Thus Frobenius gives the required isomorphism O/ϖ ≃ O/p. These are the integral perfectoid criterion for a p-torsion-free complete ring, with ϖ^{p}= p. Equivalently, C is complete and uniform, with surjective Frobenius on O/p and nondiscrete valuation: the elements p^{1/pa} have valuations tending to one from below. The implication from integral perfectoid to quasisyntomic is the precise established base-ring fact in [10,
Example 3.17(2)].
Put A = W(O^{♭}) and let φ be its Witt Frobenius. Fix a compatible primitive cyclotomic system ϵ = (1, ζ_{p}, ζ_{p}2, . . .) and put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
µ = [ϵ] −1, ξ =_{[ϵ}^{[}_{1/}^{ϵ]}_{p}^{ −}_{] −}^{1}_{1}, ξ̃ = φ(ξ).The quotient notation denotes the finite geometric sum, so it is an element of A. The untilt map is θ : A →O with kernel (ξ). The initial prism used by the cited prismatic Dieudonne functor is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(A, (ξ̃)), θ̃ = θφ^{−1}.In particular its prismatic ideal is generated by φ(ξ), whereas the Hodge quotient used below is by ξ. These two generators must not be identified. The choice of this prism and the distinction of the two quotient maps are [10, Example 1.10(1) and the beginning of §4.3, pp. 43–44].
Background fact 10.9 (The precise prismatic functor used here). On a perfectoid base the published func-tor is a contravariant additive functor G →→ (M_{G}, φ_{G}) to finite projective A-modules of rank ht G. The
linearized Frobenius is injective with cokernel killed by ξ̃, and the functor is fully faithful. Its constant and multiplicative objects are
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(M_{ℚp/ℤp}, φ) ≃(A, φ), (M_{µp∞}, φ) ≃(A,ξφ̃ ).The exact references are [10, Proposition 4.69, Theorems 4.71 and 4.74, Lemma 4.75 and Proposition 4.77]. For the filtration Fil M_{G} = φ^{−}_{G}^{1}(ξM̃_{G}), the natural quotient is M_{G}/ Fil M_{G} ≃ Lie(G^{∨}) [10, Remark 1.14].
Proposition 10.10 (The source’s Frobenius and reduction clauses). With the published functor in Fact 10.9, put D_{G} = M_{G}/ξM_{G}. Then D is a contravariant additive O-linear functor. The quotient r_{G} : M_{G} →D_{G} is θ-semilinear, surjective, and has kernel ξM_{G}. The modules M_{G} and D_{G} are finite free of rank ht G over A and O, respectively. Moreover
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ξM̃_{G} ⊆φ_{G}(M_{G}),and every A-linear Frobenius-compatible map M_{µp∞} →M_{ℚp/ℤp} comes from one unique map ℚ_{p}/ℤ_{p} →
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
µ_{p}∞.Proof. The tilt O^{♭} is a valuation ring, hence local. A Witt vector is a unit precisely when its zeroth component is a unit of O^{♭}. Thus A is local. A finite projective module over a local ring is free: lift a basis modulo the maximal ideal to a minimal generating set, split its surjection from a finite free module by projectivity, and reduce the kernel modulo that ideal. Its reduction is zero; Nakayama’s lemma gives zero kernel. Apply this to M_{G}. Reducing a basis modulo ξ gives a basis of D_{G} over A/(ξ) = O, of the same rank.
Every functorial map M_{H} →M_{G} carries ξM_{H} into ξM_{G}, so it descends to D_{H} →D_{G}. Composition, identities and addition descend as well. Scalar reduction is through θ, which proves the semilinearity of r_{G}; its surjectivity and kernel are the defining quotient identities.
Because O^{♭} is perfect, φ is an automorphism of A. The underlying abelian group of φ^{∗}M_{G} = A⊗_{φ,A}M_{G} is identified with that of M_{G} by a ⊗m →→φ^{−1}(a)m. Under this identification, the image of the linearized Frobenius is the image of the semilinear φ_{G}. Its cokernel being killed by ξ̃ therefore says exactly that, for every m, some n satisfies φ_{G}(n) =ξm̃. This is the source’s elementwise image condition, not just a rank assertion.
Finally the source asks only for the particular full faithfulness assertion between the constant and multi-plicative objects. Both of the displayed rank-one Frobenius modules are the objects of the published functor. Its full faithfulness provides one unique group homomorphism with any given Frobenius-compatible module map between them, with the direction reversed because the functor is contravariant. This is exactly the stated direction of the group homomorphism.
Proposition 10.11 (The natural Hodge submodule). There is a natural identification
F_{G} := Fil M_{G}/ξM_{G} ≃ω_{G}. (G.3)
Consequently the published functor, with D_{G} = M_{G}/ξM_{G}, has a natural exact sequence
0 −→ω_{G} −→D_{G} −→ Lie(G^{∨}) −→0. (G.4)
Together with Proposition 10.10, this supplies all the clauses of the separate prismatic input used in the Hodge-bundle package.
Proof. First ξM_{G} ⊆ Fil M_{G}, since φ_{G}(ξm) =ξφ̃_{G}(m). The quotient assertion of Fact 10.9 therefore gives the exact sequence
0 −→F_{G} −→D_{G} −→ Lie(G^{∨}) −→0.
Its last module is finite free by Lemma 10.7 and duality. Lifting a basis of that quotient splits the sequence, so F_{G} is a direct summand of D_{G}.
Use prismatic Cartier duality, in its exact form [10, Proposition 4.73 and the Frobenius formula following it]. After the chosen rank-one trivialization of M_{µp∞}, it gives a perfect pairing ⟨, ⟩: M_{G} × M_{G}∨→A with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
⟨φ_{G}(x), φ_{G}∨(y)⟩=ξ φ̃ (⟨x, y⟩). (G.5)This follows from the published dual Frobenius being ξ̃ times the transpose inverse of the linearized Frobe-nius; thus it uses the multiplicative rank-one object, not an unmodified dual Frobenius.
If x ∈ Fil M_{G} and y ∈ Fil M_{G}∨, the left side of (G.5) lies in ξ̃^{2}A. Cancel one ξ̃ to conclude that φ(⟨x, y⟩) ∈ ξÃ, and apply φ^{−1} to obtain ⟨x, y⟩∈ ξA. The cancellation is legitimate: O^{♭} is a domain, and so is W(O^{♭}). Explicitly, the first nonzero Witt digits of two nonzero elements, after extracting their finite powers of p, have nonzero product modulo p; hence their product is nonzero. In particular ξ̃ ̸= 0 is a nonzerodivisor.
Reducing the perfect pairing modulo ξ gives a perfect O-pairing D_{G}×D_{G}∨→O. What we have proved says
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
F_{G} ⊆F_{G}^{⊥}∨.The inclusion is equality. To verify this integrally, write h = ht G, d = rk ω_{G} and d^{∨} = rk ω_{G}∨. The rational Hodge–Tate exact sequence gives h = d + d^{∨}. The quotient descriptions give rk F_{G} = h −d^{∨}= d and rk F_{G}∨ = h −d. Thus both sides of the inclusion have rank d. After passage to C they agree. If z belongs to the right side, some nonzero c ∈O consequently satisfies cz ∈F_{G}, by clearing its finitely many coordinates. But D_{G}/F_{G} is free, so has no nonzero element killed by c. Hence z ∈F_{G}, proving equality without identifying equal ranks with equal lattices.(
The perfect pairing now identifies F_{G} with D_{G}∨/F_{G}∨)^{∨}. Indeed a functional on that quotient composes with the quotient map to a functional on D_{G}∨. Perfectness gives one unique representing vector of D_{G}; its vanishing on F_{G}∨ puts it in F_{G}. The quotient is naturally Lie G, by Fact 10.9 applied to G^{∨} and biduality. We obtain F_{G} ≃(Lie G)^{∨}≃ω_{G}. The last map is the evaluation biduality map for a finite free module; in a basis and its dual it is the identity coordinate matrix.
All these maps are natural. For a homomorphism f : G →H, prismatic Cartier duality states
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
⟨M(f)x, y⟩_{G} = ⟨x, M(f^{∨})y⟩_{H}.Passing to the quotients shows that the map F_{H} →F_{G} just constructed is dual to Lie(f) : Lie G → Lie H; hence it is the usual cotangent pullback ω_{H} → ω_{G}. The natural quotient map to Lie(G^{∨}) already has the required dual-Lie functoriality. Its inclusion kernel is therefore exactly the natural ω_{G} in (G.4). This proves the two functoriality squares as well as injectivity, exactness and surjectivity.