Skip to content

Section 10.3 · PDF pages 762–767

The arithmetic model and its normalizations

The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.

10.3 The arithmetic model and its normalizations

The next inputs concern an integral closed subscheme

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏ |ι |−1

X ⊂ P_{Z}^{k} , dim X = d = D + 1.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
k∈K

The relevant multihomogeneous prime P is horizontal: P ∩ Z = 0. Thus X is flat over Z, since its affine coordinate rings have no integer torsion. Relevance means that, in every factor, some coordinate is nonzero at the generic point. The dimension of the multicone is dim X + |K|: on each nonempty standard chart its localized coordinate ring is the chart ring with |K| independent invertible homogeneous coordinates adjoined.

Consequently the dimension condition in IsArithVar is precisely the one displayed above. These assertions also apply to integral closed subschemes defined by relevant primes containing P.

A source object A = (a, h) defines L = 𝒪_{X}(a) with hermitian norm

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|s(z)|

‖s(z)‖= . (AG.1)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
h(z)

The homogeneity law for h makes this expression independent of the representative z in the multicone. Pos-itivity, smoothness and conjugation invariance give a smooth hermitian line bundle L in the usual arithmetic convention. In a local frame its weight is ϕ = − log ‖e‖^{2}; equivalently, on the cone the curvature is dd^{c} log h, where dd^{c}= (i/π)∂∂^{̄}.

Lemma 10.12 (The chart lattices are spaces of sections). Let y be the generic coordinate tuple, and suppose that the source’s Birational y holds. Under the rational trivialization at y, for every m ≥0,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
chartLat(y, a, m) = H^{0}(X, L^{m}),

_{0ν∗m} (AG.2)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
chartLatNm(y, a, m) = H (X , ν L ).

Here ν : X^{ν}→X is the normalization. On either space the source predicate IsSmallH is exactly ‖s‖_{sup} ≤1, with the pulled-back metric in the second case.

Proof. For a coordinate choice c = (c_{k}) nonzero at y, put t_{c} =∏_{k}y_{k,c}^{ak}_{k}. The standard affine chart U_{c} has coordinate ring

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
R_{c} = Z[y_{k,i}/y_{k,ck} : k, i].

Indeed its homogeneous degree-zero fractions are polynomials in these ratios. The birational hypothesis says that their common fraction field is the field denoted by Ω in the source. The frame t^{m}_{c} identifies a rational section s with s/t^{m}_{c}. Regularity on U_{c} is therefore the condition s/t^{m}_{c} ∈R_{c}. These are exactly the conditions defining chartLat. They glue: on U_{c} ∩U_{c}′ both coefficients are the same rational section divided by the appropriate frame, and their ratio is the transition unit (t_{c}′/t_{c})^{m}. The charts cover X, so this proves the first identity, including both implications.

Normalization commutes with localization in a domain. To see the potentially needed implication, if b is integral over R_{c}[f^{−1}], multiply the finitely many coefficients of a monic equation by a common sufficiently high power of f; then f^{r}b satisfies a monic equation over R_{c}. Thus the inverse image of U_{c} has coordinate ring the integral closure of R_{c} in Ω. The same frame argument proves the second identity. These closures are finite over R_{c}, since they are finite type domains over the excellent ring Z; hence X^{ν} is again projective.

Write a rational section as a homogeneous fraction g/h of the indicated degree difference. Away from h = 0, the inequality in IsSmallH is precisely |g/h|/h^{m}_{A} ≤ 1 by (AG.1). For every point, such a fraction exists on a neighborhood on which the section is represented regularly. Conversely the sup-norm bound implies |g| ≤|h|h^{m}_{A} wherever h ̸= 0. It holds on h = 0 too: after restriction to any complex irreducible component, the relation g = sh holds as a relation of sections; since s is regular, both sides extend there. The same argument on the normalization applies to sections regular only on X^{ν}. Its complex points map onto those of X, and the metric is pulled back. This proves precisely the universal fraction inequalities used in the source.

Lemma 10.13 (The integral densities have the Chern normalization). For smooth cone metrics A_{1}, . . . , A_{e} and an integrable function g on X(C), the source’s ptsIntegral is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∫

g c_{1}(A_{1}) · · · c_{1}(A_{e}), dim_{C} X = e. (AG.3)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X(C)

The integral over a singular variety means integration over its smooth locus, or equivalently over a resolution with the pulled-back forms. For the separate Weight convention, chernInt is integration against c_{1}(L)^{e}.

Proof. For the multicone convention this is precisely Lemma 12.1, including its density calculation, holo-morphic sheets, projection independence, singular-cycle convention and zero-dimensional case. It applies in particular to the smooth and logarithmic functions used below.

Finally Weight uses ϕ = − log ‖e‖^{2}. Its source Hessian is the ordinary Wirtinger Hessian of ϕ. The density of ((i/2π)∂∂ϕ^{̄} )^{e} is e!π^{−e} det(H_{ϕ}), precisely chernDens. The positive and negative parts used in chernPart are the positive and negative parts of this signed density. Their difference therefore gives the same Chern integral. On a compact smooth complex variety both parts are finite, by a finite coordinate cover and bounded smooth densities.

Proposition 10.14 (The source intersection family is canonical). For every source intersection system I, every arithmetic variety X of dimension d presented as above, and smooth hermitian lines L_{1}, . . . , L_{d} in that presentation, ( )

I(P, d; L_{1}, . . . , L_{d}) = deĝ ̂c_{1}(L_{1}) · · · ̂c_{1}(L_{d}) | X . (AG.4)

The right side uses the usual, unnormalized arithmetic degree: a finite point contributes log #κ(x), and complex embeddings are all counted.

Proof. We specify the classical intersection used here. Smooth arithmetic line intersections have symmetry, tensor additivity, and the section formula

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(L_{1} · · · L_{d−1}A | X) =∑m_{W} (L_{1} · · · L_{d−1} | W)
W∫

(AAG.1) − log ‖s‖_{A} c_{1}(L_{1}) · · · c_{1}(L_{d−1}).

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X(C)

For a vertical W in characteristic p its term is the algebraic intersection on W multiplied by log p. These are the divisor product and degree conventions of [12, §§4.2–4.3]. For a possibly singular X, take a projective generic resolution and pull back the lines. Independence of that resolution and the degree-one projection formula are stated explicitly in [13, (1.2),p. 189]. One may polarize that self-intersection definition to obtain the mixed intersection. Formula (AAG.1) on the resolution descends: the localized-length calculation in

Proposition 12.2 gives the multiplicity m_{W} , and exceptional divisors over smaller-dimensional images have zero intersection against pulled-back lines. The same algebraic projection formula gives this last assertion on finite fibers. Thus (AAG.1) holds on the original X. This construction includes integral projective flat schemes with singular generic fiber; regularity of X itself is not being assumed.

Here the vertical algebraic intersection is exactly geoNum. A coordinate not in the prime cuts the coordi-nate hyperplane Cartier divisor; its cycle has the source localized lengths. Its class is the corresponding 𝒪(1) class, so tensor additivity gives precisely the recursion defining geoNum, for positive or negative integer de-grees. In dimension zero the chosen nonzero coordinate in each block trivializes the entire zero-dimensional projective scheme, and its coordinate algebra is the source quotient obtained by setting those coordinates equal to 1. Its Z-module length, for a cycle in characteristic p, is its degree over F_{p}: a field of p^{f} ele-ments has length f, and a composition series gives the general length statement. Multiplication by log p consequently gives the usual finite degree, including residue-field extensions and nonreduced multiplicities.

Lemma 12.1 identifies the archimedean term of (AAG.1) with∫ arInt. In the squared-norm convention the same term is −_{2}^{1} log ‖s‖^{2}; hence the displayed formula has exactly the source’s coefficient.

It remains to show that its three axioms determine I, rather than merely giving similar properties. Induct on d. There is no nonempty integral projective flat scheme over Z of dimension zero. If the last line has componentwise nonnegative degree a, choose for every block a coordinate not in P. Their product with exponents a_{k} is a multihomogeneous section not in P, since P is prime. Apply the section axiom with this section. Every horizontal divisor has dimension d−1, so its value is already determined by induction; every

vertical term and the integral are already fixed. This gives equality with (AAG.1), including d = 1, where no horizontal dimension-zero divisor occurs.

For a last line A of arbitrary integer degree, take a smooth standard positive line B of sufficiently large componentwise degree that both B and A⊗B have nonnegative degrees. The tensor axiom gives I(. . . , A) = I(. . . , A⊗B)−I(. . . , B). Both terms have just been determined, and the same identity holds for the classical intersection. Symmetry permits any last position. This proves (AG.4) for all the required lines and all d.

Lemma 10.15 (Small generators give arithmetic nefness). Suppose that L is smooth and semipositive and that L is generated by finitely many global sections of sup norm at most 1. Then its degree on every integral arithmetic curve is nonnegative, and its degree on every curve in a geometric fiber is nonnegative. Thus L is arithmetically nef. Both IsSmallGeneratedDatum and the nonnegative-degree hypothesis MonomialsBounded provide exactly such small generators.

Proof. On an integral horizontal arithmetic curve C, some generator s is nonzero at the generic point. Its divisor is effective. The dimension-one instance of (AAG.1) is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑

deĝ(L | C) = m_{x} log #κ(x) − log ‖s(σ)‖.

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
x∈div s σ

The finite terms are nonnegative. Every norm in the last sum is at most 1, so its negative logarithm is nonnegative too. On a projective curve over a field the same choice of a nonzero generator gives an effective divisor, so has nonnegative ordinary degree. Generation is preserved by every field extension; this also proves the geometric-fiber assertion.

The coefficients w_{j} in IsSmallGeneratedDatum are global sections by Lemma 10.12. On each standard affine chart the source’s GeneratesOn gives coefficients in its ring whose linear combination of their local frame coefficients is 1. This is precisely surjectivity of the evaluation map 𝒪_{X}^{q} →L on that chart, hence globally. Their smallness is the sup-norm assertion of the same lemma. Alternatively all coordinate mono-mials of a componentwise nonnegative degree a generate 𝒪(a): at any point choose one nonzero coordinate in each block; the monomial with exponents a_{k} does not vanish there. The source’s MonomialsBounded makes each of these finitely many generators small by (AG.1).

Background fact 10.16 (The two arithmetic volume theorems used here). Let X be an integral projective flat Z-scheme of dimension d ≥1, and let L be a smooth conjugation-invariant hermitian line. Write

log #{s ∈H^{0}(X, L^{m}) : ‖s‖_{sup} ≤1} vol̂(L) = lim sup _{d} .

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{m→∞} m /d!

Moriwaki proves the following. If L is arithmetically nef, then

log #{s ∈H^{0}(X, L^{m}) : ‖s‖_{sup} ≤1} =^{md}deĝ(̂c_{1}(L)^{d}| X) + o(m^{d}). (AAG.2)

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d!

If L is nef on every geometric fiber and its metric is semipositive, then

deĝ(̂c_{1}(L)^{d}| X) ≤ vol̂(L). (AAG.3)

These are respectively Corollaries 5.5 and 6.4 of [11], read in the author’s 5 January 2007 version, pp. 38 and 42. That version’s conventions 6–7, p. 5, permit singular generic fibers. In (AAG.3) the condition is nefness on every geometric fiber. The more general Theorem 6.2 has a further moderate-cohomology-growth hypothesis, so its generic-nef version is not being used in place of Corollary 6.4.

Proposition 10.17 (The actual Hilbert–Samuel input). The three assertions combined in the source’s HSUse follow from (AAG.2). The source’s MoriwakiBigStatement follows from (AAG.3).

Proof. First check semipositivity. The source assumes P_{0} ⊂P and nonnegativity of the Levi form of log h on cone tangent vectors annihilating P_{0}. A tangent vector to the cone of P annihilates P_{0}, so the restriction has nonnegative Levi form. More generally, for any holomorphic disk mapping to this cone, differentiation of the equations of P_{0} gives precisely these tangent vectors. The chain rule for ∂∂^{̄} makes the pulled-back curvature nonnegative. Local cone lifts exist on every standard projective chart, and their changes add pluriharmonic log |unit| terms. This verifies semipositivity also in the singular-variety convention used by Moriwaki.

For ArithKleiman.Statement, the assumed finite-fiber curve degrees and horizontal arithmetic curve degrees are all nonnegative. By Proposition 10.14 these are the ordinary arithmetic degrees. Together with semipositivity, they say exactly that L is arithmetically nef. Formula (AAG.2) gives its self-intersection as its arithmetic volume. This number is nonnegative: the zero section belongs to every small-section set, so every logarithm in its definition is nonnegative.

For G7.Statement, the small generating datum makes L arithmetically nef by Lemma 10.15. Apply (AAG.2) on X itself. Lemma 10.12 identifies its finite small-section set with the source set counted by smallSectionCount. The denominator is m^{D+1}/(D + 1)!, since d = D + 1. Formula (AG.4) identifies the self-intersection. The limit supplied by (AAG.2) consequently gives the requested limsup upper bound; it in fact gives equality. The extra positive generic-degree condition in the generating datum is not needed for this upper bound.

For ArithmeticVolumeNef.Statement, the multidegree is componentwise nonnegative and all its mono-mials are small. The last part of Lemma 10.15 gives small generators. They remain small generators on X^{ν}, so ν^{∗}L is arithmetically nef there. Formula (AAG.2) on X^{ν}, the second identity of (AG.2), and the degree-one projection formula for arithmetic line intersections give the specified upper bound using chartLatNm. This is why the normalization in this third assertion cannot be silently replaced by X at the level of individual section spaces. Both the count and its intersection are now matched on the correct model.

Finally consider MoriwakiBigStatement. Its NefOnFibres quantifies over all relevant primes of finite char-acteristic whose projective dimension is one. By the vertical calculation in Proposition 10.14 this is nefness on all integral curves of every finite fiber. Curves after algebraic closure descend to finite extensions of the finite field; pushing their cycles down multiplies their line degrees by a positive integer, and hence preserves the required sign. The generic condition quantifies over closures of all integral generic curves. Their geomDeg is their ordinary degree: the sheet integral is the Chern integral, and the Chern class of a line bundle is its divisor class. The curve and field-extension argument in Proposition 12.4 therefore supplies nefness on the geometric generic fiber as well. All geometric fibers are now accounted for. Semipositivity was checked above, and conjugation invariance is an explicit source hypothesis. Apply (AAG.3) on X. Identity (AG.2), the small-norm dictionary, and (AG.4) turn its two sides exactly into the source self-intersection and arVolP(IsSmallH, chartLat, 1, D). No additional normalization factor occurs.

Proposition 10.18 (Birational arithmetic degree and Chern degree). Both conjuncts of the source’s ArDegree hold, with its height and signed-measure definitions.

Proof. For the first conjunct let p : X → Spec k and p^{′} : X^{′} → Spec k satisfy IsArithVar and GenSmooth, with arithmetic dimension D + 1. The ring k is a domain finite over Z. Flatness and nonemptiness of X exclude positive characteristic, so k is an order in a number field. Forgetting k gives integral projective flat arithmetic varieties over Z. The embeddings k → C are exactly the embeddings of its fraction field; hence the source’s finite-support sum over embeddings counts all the usual archimedean places with their full multiplicities. The analytic-chart hypothesis GenSmooth gives the stated smooth complex fibers.

We check that IsSelfInter a has no extra choice of a height. For a point x ∈X, put Z = {x} with its reduced integral structure, and define h_{can}(x) to be the top intersection of the restricted hermitian line on Z. For vertical Z, this means its algebraic degree multiplied by the logarithm of its constant finite field. The section formula (AAG.1), also for a nonzero rational section and with its signed divisor, gives all three fields of IsArithHeight: the vertical clause, the dimension-one clause, and the recursion for every power L^{m}. The source logarithm is explicitly log |r_{i}| −ϕ_{i}/2, the usual log ‖r‖. Its two signed Chern measures are exactly those in Lemma 10.13. Local integrability of logarithms on a compact resolution gives the required ArchIntegrable clause.

Any other height satisfying the three clauses equals h_{can}. Induct on dim Z. Vertical values and horizontal dimension-one values are prescribed directly. In higher dimension choose a nonzero rational section of L|_{Z} and use the recursion with m = 1. Such a section exists by choosing a frame at the generic point. Its finitely many divisor components have smaller dimension, so their heights are already fixed, and the integral is fixed

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
D+1

by the metric. This proves uniqueness. Consequently IsSelfInter a says exactly a = (L | X).

The given π : X^{′} →X is an isomorphism over a nonempty open subset of the integral X. This open is dense, so π is birational and has generic degree one. It is proper: its graph is closed since X is separated over Z, and the projection from X^{′}×_{Z} X to X is proper. The generic-resolution definition and its projection formula in [13, (1.2),p. 189] give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
((π^{∗}L)^{D+1}| X^{′}) = (L^{D+1} | X).

The uniqueness just proved supplies the source IsSelfInter a for the pulled-back line, proving ArBirational.

For ChernDegree, Y is smooth, geometrically integral and projective over F, of dimension e. The em-bedding σ : F → C identifies its complex fiber with a compact smooth complex variety. A smooth source weight defines the metric ‖e_{i}‖^{2} = e^{−ϕi}: the transition rule for ϕ_{i} is exactly the change-of-frame rule for this metric. The presentation of ∆ identifies L with 𝒪(∆). By Lemma 10.13 both parts of the signed Chern measure are finite and their difference is integration against c_{1}(L)^{e}.

We identify its degree explicitly. The Poincaré–Lelong formula identifies the de Rham class of c_{1}(L) with the divisor class of ∆; this is [45, V,(13.4),p. 271]. Choose a very ample N so positive that M = L⊗N is also very ample. Expand c_{1}(L)^{e}= (c_{1}(M) −c_{1}(N))^{e}. For every mixed term choose successive general hyperplane sections from M or N. Bertini’s theorem over C makes these intersections transverse until a reduced zero-dimensional scheme is reached. Applying the divisor current formula at each step shows that the integral of that mixed Chern product is the number of its final points, with their algebraic lengths. Thus it is precisely the mixed algebraic intersection. Tensor additivity gives the same conclusion for L.

Finally the source defines Y.inter by e finite differences of the Euler characteristic. For a hyperplane section, the exact sequence 0 → N^{−1} →𝒪 →𝒪_{H} → 0, tensoring by the other lines, makes one such difference the Euler characteristic on H. Iterating for the above general hyperplanes gives the length of the zero-dimensional intersection. The differences are multilinear in the line classes in top degree: the degree-e part of the Euler polynomial is the only surviving part after e differences; its polarization gives precisely that multilinearity. Hence the expansion using M −N identifies the source integer with the same intersection. These Euler characteristics and lengths are unchanged by the flat extension F → C, since coherent cohomology of a projective scheme commutes with a field extension. This proves the claimed equality over the original F. For e = 0 the empty Chern product counts its points; geometric integrality makes this number 1, also its Euler characteristic. Thus this case is included as well.