Section 4.17 · PDF pages 173–175
The Hecke special values in the theta constant
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
4.17 The Hecke special values in the theta constant
Let E be a CM field, let {ι_{i} : i ∈I} contain one embedding from every complex-conjugate pair, and let ν be a continuous unitary character of 𝔸^{×}_{E}/E^{×}. Suppose its infinite component on x ∈E^{×} is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{∞}(x) =∏(ι_{i}(x)/|ι_{i}(x)|)^{ni}, n_{i} ∈ℤ,
i∈Iand at least one n_{i} is nonzero. Write L(ν, s) for the finite Euler product with factor (1 −ν_{v}(ϖ_{v})q_{v}^{−s})^{−1} at an unramified place and factor 1 at a ramified place.
The classical analytic input used here is Tate’s continuation and functional equation: the completed character L-function has only the possible norm-character poles, and the local complex factor for (z/|z|)^{m} is a nonzero constant times (2π)^{−s−|m|/2}Γ(s + |m|/2). This is precisely the global theorem and local computa-tion of [55, §2.5, complex case; Main Theorem4.4.1; §4.5]. We use the ordinary complex gamma function here; its reciprocal is entire, including its zeros at the nonpositive integers. The special-value conclusion, including nonvanishing on the boundary of absolute convergence, is proved next.
Lemma 4.78 (Boundary nonvanishing with nonzero angular weight). If some complex-place angular weight of a unitary ν is nonzero, then the entire continuation of its finite L-function satisfies L(ν, s) ̸= 0 for Re s ≥
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1.
Proof. A character | · |^{it} is trivial on the unit circle in every complex completion. Thus neither ν nor ν^{2} is such a character: at the selected place their angular weights are m ̸= 0 and 2m ̸= 0. Tate’s theorem consequently gives entire completed functions for both. Multiplying each by the entire reciprocals of its gamma factors and by the inverse conductor–discriminant power gives entire finite continuations G_{1}, G_{2} agreeing with their Euler products in Re s > 1.
Fix t ∈ℝ and σ > 1. The actual Euler-product inequality needed is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 ≤||ζ_{E}(σ)^{3}L(ν, σ + it)^{4}L(ν^{2}, σ + 2it)|| . (121)Here is the local verification, including the ramified primes. Put a = q_{v}^{−σ} ∈(0, 1). If ν is unramified, put z = ν_{v}(ϖ_{v})q_{v}^{−it}, so |z| = 1 and the squared character has coefficient z^{2}. The logarithm of the modulus of this local product is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑a^{j}( ∑2a^{j}3 + 4 Re z^{j}+ Re z^{2j})=_{j} (1 + Re z^{j})^{2} ≥0.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j≥1^{j} j≥1If ν is ramified, its factor is 1. The coefficient w of ν^{2} is either zero or has modulus one. Hence the reciprocal modulus of the remaining local product is at most (1 −a)^{3}(1+ a) ≤1: indeed (1 −a)^{3}(1+ a) = (1 −a)^{2}(1 −a^{2}) ≤ 1. Every finite product therefore has modulus at least one. Absolute Euler-product convergence allows passage to its limit and proves (121).
Suppose G_{1}(1 + it) = 0. Holomorphy gives G_{1}(1 + x + it) = O(x) as x ↓0. The simple pole of ζ_{E} gives ζ_{E}(1 + x) = O(x^{−1}), while holomorphy of G_{2} gives G_{2}(1 + x + 2it) = O(1). Thus the product in (121), with σ = 1 + x, is O(x^{−3}x^{4}) = O(x) and tends to zero, contradicting its lower bound one. This proves the boundary assertion. For Re s > 1 absolute convergence of the logarithmic Euler product already gives a nonzero product.
[Lean: This is the nonquadratic branch actually sufficient for the present character: continuation_ne_zero_of_not_sq, GroundTheory/GlobalFields/TateThesis/Nonvanishing.lean, 44–143, and its Euler inequality in GroundTheory/GlobalFields/TateThesis/NonvanishingPrimes.lean, 161–212. The nonzero angular weight excludes the quadratic-twist branch before it is needed.]
Proposition 4.79 (The exact integral special-value region). For every integer z such that 2z + |n_{i}| > 0 for every i ∈ I, the entire finite continuation satisfies L(ν, z) ̸= 0. It agrees with the source’s Euler factors, with no inverse character inserted.
Proof. First identify its infinite parameters rather than assuming them. The CM type gives a bijection from I to the infinite places. At each place the chosen representative embedding is either ι_{i} or its conjugate. Set m_{w} = n_{i} in the first case and m_{w} = −n_{i} in the second. Conjugation inverts z/|z|, so |m_{w}| = |n_{i}|. On the diagonal E^{×} the product of the infinite local components of ν agrees with ∏_{w}(z_{w}/|z_{w}|)^{mw}. Both are continuous functions of (z_{w})_{w} ∈ ∏_{w}E_{w}^{×}. Weak approximation makes the diagonal E^{×} dense in this product: approximate a nonzero archimedean tuple within its open nonvanishing locus. The two continuous functions agree everywhere. Insert a tuple equal to one except at a single place to obtain ν_{w}(z) = (z/|z|)^{mw}. Its radial exponent is therefore zero.
Let Q = |D_{E}| Norm 𝔣_{ν} > 0 and put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
γ_{ν}(s) = ∏Γ_{ℂ}(s + |m_{w}|/2), Λ_{ν}(s) = Q^{s/2}γ_{ν}(s)L(ν, s),
w|∞where Γ_{ℂ}(u) = 2(2π)^{−u}Γ(u). The harmless fixed factor in this completion is chosen as in the source; the same factor occurs for ν^{−1}, so it cancels from the functional equation. Tate’s local finite factors identify
this L with the source’s factors: a local integral unit kills a ramified factor, and at an unramified place the uniformizer value is exactly ν_{v}(ϖ_{v}). The functional equation is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Λ_{ν}(s) = W_{ν}Λ_{ν}−1(1 −s).Its constant is nonzero. One can check this without choosing a phase for a Gauss sum: apply the equation twice at s = 2, where the completed Euler product is nonzero, and cancel it to obtain W_{ν}W_{ν}−1 = 1.
If z ≥1, Lemma 4.78 proves the result. Otherwise z ≤0 and 1 −z ≥1. The inverse character also has a nonzero angular weight, so L(ν^{−1}, 1 −z) ̸= 0. Every inverse archimedean argument 1 −z + |m_{w}|/2 is positive. Its gamma factors and Q^{(1−z)/2} are nonzero, giving Λ_{ν}−1(1 −z) ̸= 0 and then Λ_{ν}(z) ̸= 0. The given inequalities say exactly z + |m_{w}|/2 > 0 at every place, so γ_{ν}(z) is finite and nonzero. Dividing by it and by Q^{z/2} gives L(ν, z) ̸= 0.
[Lean: exists_weights, params_of and heckeL_ne_zero, Development/WeilBound/ThetaLifts/Reductions/WeightConstants/Bridge.lean, 98–220. The source explicitly uses z ≥1 or z ≤0, ν^{−1} at 1 −z, and the inequalities 2z + |ni| > 0. The completion and twice-applied functional-equation normalization are in GroundTheory/GlobalFields/TateThesis/HeckeTheorem.lean, 25–55, and GroundTheory/GlobalFields/TateThesis/HeckeTheoremFE.lean, 49–112.]
Removing a finite set of Euler factors preserves this nonvanishing provided each removed factor is finite and nonzero at the specified integer. At a place ramified for ν the factor is already one. This elementary qualification matters when a theta recursion uses L^{S0} rather than the full finite L-function. The source’s ramification and dimension inequalities must be applied before cancelling that partial special value.