Section 4.18 · PDF pages 175–177
The closed-subgroup argument for constancy
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
4.18 The closed-subgroup argument for constancy
The constancy argument is separate from the existence and matching of theta integrals. It applies to an already constructed continuous function. We give its density ingredients explicitly, since left rational invariance alone would not force constancy.
Lemma 4.80 (Detection at degree-one prime ideals). Let K be a number field and χ a continuous unitary idele-class character. Suppose there is a finite set S of prime ideals such that the entire local character χ_{w} : K_{w}^{×}→ℂ^{×} is trivial whenever w /∈S and Nw is a rational prime. Then χ = 1.
Proof. Suppose χ ̸= 1. Tate’s continuation theorem makes its finite L-function holomorphic in a neighbor-hood of 1. For a norm character χ = | · |^{it} with t ̸= 0 the possible pole is 1 −it, which is different from 1; for a character not of this form the completed function is entire. Reciprocal gamma factors are entire, so the same local holomorphy holds for the finite function. It follows that |L(χ, s)| stays bounded as real s ↓1.
Put a_{w} = (Nw)^{−s} for s > 1. At one of the specified trivial local characters the Euler factor is (1−a_{w})^{−1} and its modulus is at least exp(a_{w}). At any other prime its modulus is at least exp(−a_{w}): if ramified it is one, and otherwise |1 −a_{w}χ_{w}(ϖ_{w})| ≤1 + a_{w} ≤ exp(a_{w}). Let A be the set of prime ideals whose norm is not a rational prime. Absolute convergence and finite-product multiplication give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑ ∑ )
|L(χ, s)| ≥ exp (Nw)^{−s}−2 (Nw)^{−s}−2 (Nw)^{−s} .
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w w∈A w∈S
The second sum is bounded uniformly for s > 1: each w ∈A lies over a rational prime p with Nw ≥p^{2}, and at most [K : ℚ] prime ideals lie over any p. Thus it is at most [K : ℚ]∑_{m≥2}m^{−2}. The last sum is at most |S|. The first sum tends to infinity. Indeed the Euler expansion gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑∑(Nw)^{−js}log ζ_{K}(s) = (Nw)^{−s}+ ,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w w j≥2^{j}and the double sum is uniformly bounded by 2∑_{w}(Nw)^{−2}, while the simple pole of ζ_{K} at one makes its logarithm tend to infinity. The displayed lower bound therefore tends to infinity, contradicting local boundedness.
[Lean: hchar_eq_one, Development/WeilBound/ThetaLifts/LatticeBasics/ConstHecke.lean, 33–86. Only holomorphy at one is needed in this argument; the stronger nonzero-at-one part of the source’s published interface is not used by this caller.]
Lemma 4.81 (The norm-one density used by the determinant). Let E/F be a CM quadratic extension, assume E/ℚ is Galois, and let T be a finite set of finite places of F. Write U_{1}(𝔸_{F} ) = {z ∈𝔸^{×}_{E}: zz̄ = 1}. A closed subgroup of this group that contains U_{1}(F) and all the local U_{1}(F_{v}) at the fully split places outside T is the whole group.
Proof. First record an idele version. Let M ⊂𝔸^{×}_{E} be a closed subgroup containing E^{×}, one fixed positive infinite idele e with |e|_{𝔸E} > 1, and the entire local E_{w}^{×} outside a finite exceptional set whenever Nw is prime. The quotient 𝔸^{×}_{E}/M is a compact abelian group. To see compactness, the norm-one idele-class group is compact, and division by a power of e puts the modulus of any idele into [1, |e|]. Compactness of the norm-one class group is the usual ideal-class and unit-lattice argument: use finitely many ideal-class representatives for finite valuations, a compact product of finite local units, and a bounded fundamental parallelepiped for the logarithms of the global units at infinity. The remaining archimedean angular factors are compact. Adjoining the bounded modulus interval consequently gives a compact set surjecting onto the displayed quotient.
If that quotient had a nonidentity point, separation of points by continuous characters of a compact abelian group would give a nontrivial unitary idele-class character trivial on M. Lemma 4.80 rules this out. Thus M is the whole idele group.
Now let N be the closed subgroup in the statement. Use adelic Hilbert90 to form the continuous surjec-tion
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q : 𝔸^{×}_{E}−→U_{1}(𝔸_{F} ), q(y) = y/̄y.For clarity, local Hilbert90 gives a preimage at each place. At almost every inert place the quadratic extension is unramified; subtracting its valuation by a base-field uniformizer makes that preimage a unit. At a split place a norm-one pair (a, a^{−1}) has preimage (a, 1). The chosen preimages therefore form an idele, which proves adelic surjectivity. The subgroup M = q^{−1}(N) is closed and contains E^{×}, since q(k) = k/k^{̄} ∈U_{1}(F). It contains a positive infinite idele e fixed by conjugation, because q(e) = 1.
Exclude the primes over T and the finitely many primes ramified in E/ℚ. If Nw = p is prime outside this set, its inertia degree and ramification index over p are both one. Galoisness makes all such indices equal. The identity efg = [E : ℚ] then shows that p splits completely in E. In particular the place v under w is fully split and outside T. For a local idele y supported at w, q(y) is supported at v and has norm one, so it belongs to N. Thus M contains all the degree-one local groups required by the idele version. That version gives M = 𝔸^{×}_{E}, and surjectivity of q gives N = U_{1}(𝔸_{F} ).
[Lean: closed_eq_top, Development/WeilBound/ThetaLifts/LatticeBasics/ConstHecke.lean, 89–111; normOne_mem and its finite exceptional-set, splitting and Hilbert90 helpers, Development/WeilBound/ThetaLifts/LatticeBasics/ConstIdele.lean, 33–182. The uses of all local units, rather than just their uniformizers, are retained.]
Proposition 4.82 (Closed stabilizers of the theta constant). Let E/F and T be as in Lemma 4.81, and let V be a nondegenerate Hermitian E-space of dimension n ≥2. Every continuous function f : U(V )(𝔸_{F} ) →ℂ that is left invariant under U(V )(F) and right invariant under each U(V )(F_{v}) at a fully split v /∈ T is constant.
Proof. Choose u ∈V with h(u, u) ̸= 0 and let R be the Hermitian orthogonal projection onto Eu. Such a vector exists: otherwise polarization in characteristic zero would make the Hermitian form zero, contradict-ing nondegeneracy. Thus R^{2}= R, R is self-adjoint and has rank one. For zz̄ = 1 define
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
S(z) = 1 + (z −1)R.
Multiplication and R^{2}= R give S(a)S(b) = S(ab). On Eu ⊕(Eu)^{⊥} it acts by z and by one, respectively; hence it is unitary and det S(z) = z. It is continuous, takes rational z to rational matrices, and preserves local support: if z = 1 away from v, the same is true of S(z).
We use strong approximation for this precise classical group: SU(V )(F)SU(V )(F_{v}) is dense in SU(V )(𝔸_{F} ) at a split finite place v. Kneser’s theorem allows a finite set consisting of this single place; it does not require adjoining the infinite places [56, Satz2 and the definition in §1, pp190–192]. The hypotheses are satisfied: SU(V ) is a simply connected classical group of type A_{n−1} over F. Over the quadratic splitting field, a unitary matrix is determined by its first matrix component, its second being the inverse conjugate transpose, and the determinant-one subgroup becomes SL_{n}. At a split place this description already holds over F_{v}, giving SU(V )(F_{v}) ≃ SL_{n}(F_{v}), which is noncompact for n ≥ 2, as witnessed by diagonal matrices with entries ϖ_{v}^{j}, ϖ_{v}^{−j}, 1, . . . , 1. There is such a split place outside T: apply degree-one prime detection, or the divergence argument in its proof, to exclude finiteness of the unramified prime-norm primes of E. Galoisness gives complete splitting as above.
Let L be any closed subgroup of U(V )(𝔸_{F} ) containing U(V )(F) and all these good local unitary groups. Strong approximation and closedness give SU(V )(𝔸_{F} ) ⊂ L. The inverse image N = S^{−1}(L) contains rational norm-one elements and the good local norm-one groups, so the preceding lemma gives N = U_{1}(𝔸_{F} ). For g ∈U(V )(𝔸_{F} ) set z = det g. Then gS(z)^{−1} has determinant one and is in L, while S(z) ∈L. Their product is g, proving L = U(V )(𝔸_{F} ).
Apply this to the left stabilizer
L_{f} = {a : f(ag) = f(g) for every g}.
It is a subgroup: multiply two such equalities using associativity; for inverses use the equality at a^{−1}g. It is closed as the intersection, over g, of the equalizers of the continuous function a →→f(ag) and the constant f(g). Left rational invariance puts U(V )(F) in L_{f}. If u is supported at a good v, then so is g^{−1}ug. Right local invariance consequently gives f(ug) = f(g(g^{−1}ug)) = f(g); hence each good local group is in L_{f}. The preceding result makes L_{f} the entire group. Evaluating its defining equality at g = 1 now gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
f(a) = f(1).
[Lean: sec, su_mem, exists_sec, mem_of_good and constOfGood_of, Development/WeilBound/ThetaLifts/LatticeBasics/ConstOfGood.lean, 42–148. The source chooses the same rank-one determinant section, uses the norm-one preimage and the determinant-one correction in that order, and then forms this closed left stabilizer.]
This proposition supplies the constancy step once the matching construction has produced its continuous invariant function. The theta quotient maps and both Gauss-normalized recursions in Input 4.77 are proved in Subsections 4.21 and 4.22.