Section 3.14 · PDF pages 46–49
Verification of the relative progression input
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
3.14 Verification of the relative progression input
Proposition 3.31 (The exceptional term is retained uniformly). The assertion (54), with exactly the exceptional-pair convention stated there, holds. The gap assertion (55) and the Page consequence used in
Lemma 3.29 also hold. All their constants are absolute.
Proof. We use Thorner and Zaman, Refinements to the prime number theorem for arithmetic progressions,
Corollary 1.4 and Remark 1.5.^{3} Write λ = log m, u = log X. Their distinguished pair, when present, is the unique possible zero of the product over characters modulo m in
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℜs ≥1 −^{1}13 log(m(|ℑs| + 3))^{.}
It is real and belongs to a unique real nonprincipal character. Denote it by (χ_{∗}, β_{∗}). Their corollary gives, for t ≥m^{12},
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ϑ(t; m, a) = H(t){1 + O(E(t))}, E(t) = e^{−d log t/λ}+ e^{−d(log t)3/5/(log log t)1/5}, (61)where d > 0 and the implied constant are absolute. Here H(t) = t/φ(m) if their pair is absent, and otherwise
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{H(t) =} t −χ_{∗}(a)t^{β∗}/β_{∗.}
φ(m)This is a relative error with the displayed H(t). The statement applies to every m ≥2 and every coprime residue, without excluding a real character.
We first record the zero bounds, including characters whose zeros lie outside this narrower region. Equa-tion (1.2) of the same paper, with its parameter ε = 1/2, gives an absolute b > 0 such that 1−β_{∗}≥bm^{−1/2}. A real zero β outside the narrower region instead satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 −β >^{1}13 log(3m)^{.}
The function m/ log(3m) has a positive lower bound on m ≥3. Decreasing b, and using m^{−1/2} ≥m^{−1}, therefore proves 1 −β ≥c/m for every real nonprincipal character and real zero, with absolute 0 < c ≤1. This proves (55). An imprimitive character causes no difficulty: its extra Euler factors have no real zero at β > 0; zeros at β ≤0 already satisfy this bound.
For the Page assertion, inflate both characters to modulus l = m_{1}m_{2}. If they are real nonprincipal, their primitive characters stay nonprincipal after inflation. Since Z ≥ 3, log(3l) ≤ 3 log Z. Thus both proposed zeros lie in the displayed zero-free region for modulus l if c_{0} = 1/39 and β_{i} > 1 −c_{0}/ log Z. Inflation preserves a positive real zero because the added Euler factors do not vanish there. Uniqueness of the exceptional character modulo l then makes the inflated characters equal. They consequently agree on every integer coprime to m_{1}m_{2}, as required.
We next pass from (61) to the unweighted count, initially using this narrower pair. Let M_{∗}(a, X) denote its logarithmic-integral main term, with the same convention as M_{m}. Increase an absolute C_{0} so that
u ≥C_{0}λ log(λ + 2) =⇒ X^{1/2}≥m^{12}, u ≥32λ, u ≥100.
Put V = X^{1/2}. For t ∈[V, X], the right side E(t) is at most
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{EX}′_{= e}−d_{1}u/λ_{ + e}−d_{1}^{√}ufor an absolute d_{1} > 0. Indeed log t ≥u/2, and v^{3/5}/(log v)^{1/5}≥^{√}v once v is sufficiently large; enlarging C_{0} covers the remaining lower range uniformly.
^{3}J. Thorner and A. Zaman, Math. Z. 306 (2024), article 54, https://doi.org/10.1007/s00209-023-03414-3. The statements used here were checked in the authors’ preprint https://arxiv.org/abs/2108.10878v2, pp. 1–3: the zero-free region immediately before Theorem 1.1, equation (1.2), and Corollary 1.4 with Remark 1.5. The preprint date is 21 September 2021.
In this range H(t) ≥0. To check the only nontrivial sign, write δ = 1−β_{∗}. Since β_{∗}≥7/8, − log β_{∗}≤ (8/7)δ. Consequently t^{−δ}/β_{∗}≤1 when log t ≥8/7. Partial summation on [V, X] now gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
π(X; m, a) −M_{∗}(a, X) =^{ϑ(X; m, a}_{u}^{) −H(X)}
_{+}∫^{ X}ϑ(t; m, a) −H(t)_{dt + O(V ).}t(log t)^{2}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
V
The absolute O(V ) includes the entire initial interval and the lower endpoints of the main term. For example π(V ; m, a) ≤V ; |H(V )| ≤3V ; and the two logarithmic integrals at V, V^{β∗} have size O(V ). The identity for the main term follows by differentiating:
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{ −χ∗(a)t}β∗−1_{H}′_{(t)}
M_{∗}^{′}(a, t) = 1 =φ(m) log t log t ^{.}
All these statements have the evident version when the exceptional pair is absent.
The sum of the positive weights multiplying H in this partial summation is M_{∗}(a, X)+O(V ). It follows from the relative weighted estimate that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|π(X; m, a) −M_{∗}(a, X)| ≤CE_{X}^{′} M_{∗}(a, X) + CVwith an absolute C. The elementary lower bound (56), whose proof uses only the gap just established, applies to this main term. In particular
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{V}_{≤}^{2}_{m}2_{ue}−u/2_{ ≤C}′_{e}−u/4_{.}
M_{∗}(a, X) cFor the last inequality, enlarge C_{0} to ensure 2λ + log u ≤u/4. Such a single choice is possible: u ≥32λ handles 2λ, and (log u)/u → 0 handles the other term, uniformly for all the remaining u. Decreasing a positive absolute d_{2}, we obtain
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|π(X; m, a) −M_{∗}(a, X)| ≤C^{′′}{e^{−d2u/λ}+ e^{−√d2u}}M_{∗}(a, X). (62)It remains to match the source’s wider exceptional interval. Its width is 1/(8λ), whereas the interval just used has width 1/(13 log(3m)). The latter is narrower. If its pair exists, choose it for 𝔢_{m}; it satisfies the source’s strict inequality. If neither interval contains a pair, choose 𝔢_{m} absent. In both cases (62) already has the required form.
In the remaining case choose any source-interval pair (χ, β); the narrower pair is absent. Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
7/8 < β ≤1 −^{1}13 log(3m)^{.}
With M_{0} = li_{2}(X)/φ(m), an elementary logarithmic-integral bound gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
li_{2}(X^{β}) ( u )_{2} ≤Cu exp − ≤C^{′}e^{−d3u/λ} li (X) 13 log(3m)
for an absolute d_{3} > 0, after increasing C_{0}. For clarity, put v = u/λ. We have v ≥ C_{0} log(λ + 2) and log u = log λ + log v. The first summand is at most v/C_{0}; the second is at most any fixed positive multiple of v once C_{0} is large. Also log(3m) ≤(1 + log 3/ log 8)λ. These facts absorb the factor u and prove the
last inequality with constants independent of m. Make this ratio at most 1/2 by one further increase of C_{0}. The source main term is therefore positive and satisfies
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
M_{m}(a, X) ≥_{2}^{1}M_{0}, |M_{m}(a, X) −M_{0}| ≤C^{′}e^{−d3u/λ}M_{0}.Combine these two inequalities with (62), now for M_{∗}= M_{0}. Taking c_{3} > 0 smaller than the finitely many positive constants obtained, and increasing A_{0}, proves (54). Our choice is absent exactly when the wider interval has no pair. Thus the implication concerning absence, as well as every modulus, residue and range quantifier in the source’s PNTAPRelW, is satisfied.
Corollary 3.32 (The prime-pair input). The assertion PairEx, with all the characters, real zeros and heights in its definition, holds.
Proof. Proposition 3.31 supplies precisely the progression, gap and Page inputs used above. Lemma 3.28 and
Proposition 3.30 give the two uniform progression estimates. Proposition 3.27 gives both the box comparison and its 4 log Y improvement. The two-stage selection in Proposition 3.25 therefore applies. It retains every real primitive character of conductor dividing 8M, and the same selected pair on the entire interval [Y, Y^{A}]; no character or height is removed when these inputs are combined.