Section 8.8 · PDF pages 482–484
The integral-homology estimate behind Lemma K
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
8.8 The integral-homology estimate behind Lemma K
Write
T_{m}(L, N) = |tors H_{m}(GL_{N}(O_{L}), ℤ)| .
The construction uses primitive families of chain functionals: they vanish on boundaries, commute with stabilisation, and evaluate a block diagonal repetition of d copies as d times the original value. The coefficient group is killed by q = ℓ^{ν}. These are three separate requirements; stability of the homology groups alone does not imply the repetition rule.
Lemma 8.18 (Counting values from a rank bound). Let H be an abelian group with finite torsion subgroup, J ≤H of ℤ-rank at most r, and f : H →B an additive map, where qB = 0, q ≥1. Every finite subset of f(J) has at most q^{r}| tors H| elements. If g : Y →B, β : Y →A are additive, A is finite, and every finite subset of g(ker β) has at most b elements, every finite subset of g(Y ) has at most b|A| elements.
Proof. For a finite set of values choose preimages and let J^{′} ≤ J be their finitely generated integer span. The finitely generated torsion-free group J^{′}/ tors J^{′} is free of rank s ≤r. Choose lifts x_{1}, . . . , x_{s} of a basis. Every x ∈J^{′} differs from ∑a_{i}x_{i} by a torsion element. Under f, each integer a_{i} may be reduced modulo q. Thus all the chosen values lie in the image of
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
{0, . . . , q −1}^{s}× tors H −→B, (a, t) −−→ a_{i}f(x_{i}) + f(t).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
i
Its domain has at most q^{r}| tors H| elements. For the second assertion, choose preimages of the finite set and partition it according to their β-values. Subtracting a fixed value in any nonempty fibre embeds that fibre into g(ker β); each fibre has at most b elements and there are at most |A| fibres.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/TorsionRankCounts/RankCountAlt.lean:5--78; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/TorsionRankCounts/FibCount.lean:5--27
For an integral homology class x in dimension N, define N_{0} = N, N_{t+1} = ℓN_{t}, z_{0}(x) = x, and
z_{t+1}(x) = (ψ_{ℓ,Nt})_{∗}z_{t}(x) −ℓ^{t+2}(stab_{Nt,Nt+1})_{∗}z_{t}(x),
where ψ_{ℓ,Nt} repeats a matrix in ℓ diagonal blocks. The rank statement used by the source is specifically
rank_{ℤ} ⟨z_{k}(x) : x ∈H_{k+1}(GL_{N}(O_{L}), ℤ)⟩≤r_{2}(L) (208)
for k even, k + 1 < r_{2}(L), and N ≥2(k + 1) + 4. This is a rank statement about this image, not about the whole odd-degree homology group.
Proposition 8.19 (Primitive-family upper bound). Assume (208), that homology stabilisation is an iso-morphism in degree m for ranks at least 2m + 4, and that its torsion is finite there. Let k be even with k + 1 < r_{2}(L). For a primitive family Φ on (k + 1)-chains with values in a ℤ/ℓ^{ν}-module B, every finite set of values of ℓ^{k}Φ on cycles, in arbitrary ranks, has size at most
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(ℓ^{ν})^{r2(L)}T_{k+1}(L, 2k + 6) T_{k}(L, 2k + 6). (209)Proof. Stabilise the finitely many realising cycles to one common rank N ≥ 2k + 6; their values do not change. A mod-q cycle y has an integral lift z, with ∂z = qv. Since the integral chain groups are free and q ̸= 0, ∂v = 0. The homology class of v is killed by q and defines the Bockstein
β : Z_{k+1}(GL_{N}(O_{L}), ℤ/q) −→H_{k}(GL_{N}(O_{L}), ℤ)_{tors}.
Changing the lift by qw changes v by ∂w, so this is well-defined and additive. If β(y) = 0, choose w with v = ∂w; then z −qw is an integral cycle reducing to y. Thus the kernel is exactly the reductions of integral cycles. Homology stability makes the target torsion cardinality T_{k}(L, 2k + 6).
The functional Φ on integral cycles descends to integral homology because it vanishes on boundaries; call it ϕ. Its stabilisation and repetition rules imply, inductively,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ϕ_{Nt}(z_{t}(x)) = ℓ^{t}(1 −ℓc_{t})ϕ_{N}(x)for an integer c_{t} independent of x. Starting at c_{0} = 0, the recurrence is c_{t+1} = c_{t} + ℓ^{t}−ℓ^{t+1}c_{t}, obtained by multiplying the preceding scalar by ℓ−ℓ^{t+2}. The integer u_{t} =∑^{ν}_{i=0}^{−1}(ℓc_{t})^{i} inverts 1 −ℓc_{t} modulo ℓ^{ν}. Consequently
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℓ^{k}ϕ_{N}(x) = ϕ_{Nk}(u_{k}z_{k}(x)).The span of the z_{k}(x) has rank at most r_{2}(L) by (208). Its ambient homology has torsion cardinality T_{k+1}(L, 2k + 6) by stability. The first assertion of Lemma 8.18 therefore bounds every finite subset of the values on ker β by (ℓ^{ν})^{r2(L)}T_{k+1}(L, 2k + 6). Its second assertion, applied to the Bockstein, introduces the factor T_{k}(L, 2k + 6), proving (209).
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SUpperOf.lean:11--66; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/TorsionRankCounts/PhiZSeq.lean:5--35
Lemma 8.20 (The weighted-norm kernel). Let Y, I be abelian groups, I torsion-free, g^{n} = g_{I}^{n} = 1, d : Y →I with dg = g_{I}d, and a ≥2, n ≥1. Put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n∑−1
δ = g −a, δ_{I} = g_{I} −a, N_{a} = a^{j}g^{n−j}, U = d^{−1}(δ_{I}I), W = U/(δY + tors Y ).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j=0
If a^{n}−1 = qu, then for an integer s the map
f : W −→Y /(qY + tors Y ), [y] −−→[sN_{a}y]
is defined, and ker f is killed by us. If W is finite, ℓ∤u_{0}, us = u_{0}ℓ^{b}, and |W[ℓ]| ≤ℓ^{r}, then
ℓ^{vℓ(|W|)}≤| im f| ℓ^{br}.
Proof. Expanding and cancelling consecutive terms gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
N_{a}δ = δN_{a} = (1 −a^{n})g.This makes the map well-defined on δY ; endomorphisms also preserve torsion. If sN_{a}y = qz + t, with t torsion, apply δ to obtain q(−usgy −δz) = δt. Torsion is saturated under multiplication by the nonzero integer q; hence usgy ∈δY +tors Y . Apply g^{n−1}, which preserves this subgroup, to obtain usy in the same subgroup. This proves the annihilator.
For a finite abelian group, |W[ℓ^{b}]| ≤|W[ℓ]|^{b}: multiplication by ℓ on W[ℓ^{b+1}] has kernel contained in W[ℓ] and image contained in W[ℓ^{b}], giving induction. On ker f, multiplication by ℓ^{b} has image killed by u_{0}, of order prime to ℓ, and kernel contained in W[ℓ^{b}]. Therefore the ℓ-part of | ker f| is at most ℓ^{br}. The identity |W| = | ker f|| im f| proves the claim.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/KerFDelNm.lean:5--128; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/PCount.lean:5--92