Section 8.13 · PDF pages 498–501
Choosing one window for every exceptional twist
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
8.13 Choosing one window for every exceptional twist
The tower argument uses two estimates with different roles. For a fixed base field L_{0}, prime ℓ, and rank bound R, set j_{0} = ⌊log_{ℓ}R⌋+ 3. Its first assertion supplies c, an ultrametric field containing ℚ_{ℓ}, and at most R points σ_{1}, . . . , σ_{r} in that field, such that, whenever |e −σ_{i}|_{ℓ} ≥ℓ^{−B} for every i, every cyclotomic layer L_{m}/L_{0} of degree ℓ^{m} satisfies
s_{ℓ}(L_{m}, e) ≤R{max(m, j_{0}) + c + B}. (215)
Its second assertion is the transfer estimate
s_{ℓ}(L_{m}, e) ≤ length H^{2}(G_{Lj0,Sℓ}, ℤ_{ℓ}(e + 1)) + R(m −j_{0})_{+}. (216)
These are the precise tower estimates needed; a bare statement that an Iwasawa module is torsion gives neither one.
Lemma 8.38 (At most one exceptional integer per point). For Z ≥ 1, put b = ⌊log_{ℓ}Z⌋. For each σ, at most one integer e ∈[1, Z] satisfies |e −σ|_{ℓ}< ℓ^{−b}. Consequently (215) supplies a set 𝒳_{Z} ⊆[1, Z], of size at most R, outside which
s_{ℓ}(L_{m}, e) ≤R{max(m, j_{0}) + c + ⌊log_{ℓ}Z⌋}.
Proof. If two integers a, b^{′} satisfied the strict inequality, the ultrametric inequality would give |a−b^{′}|_{ℓ}< ℓ^{−b}. For a nonzero integer difference, this means ℓ^{b+1}| a −b^{′}. But |a −b^{′}| < Z < ℓ^{b+1}, a contradiction. Take the union of these singleton-or-empty exceptional sets for the at most R points. Every integer outside the union has all required lower distance bounds, so apply (215) with B = b.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Near1.lean:5--43; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Exc.lean:7--42
Lemma 8.39 (A logarithmic interval avoiding a finite set). Let T ⊂ℝ, |T| ≤R, B ≥1, and U > 0. There is y with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{2R+2}^{U}_{BR} ≤y, 2y ≤U,such that a ∈T, u ∈[y, 2y], and a ≤u imply Ba ≤u.
Proof. Induct on R. For R = 0, take y = U/2. For R = n+1, if some a_{0} ∈T ∩(U/(2B), U] exists, apply induction to T \ {a_{0}} and U^{′}= U/(2B). It gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
y ≥U/(2^{n+3}B^{n+1}), 2y ≤U^{′}.The point a_{0} cannot satisfy a_{0} ≤ u ≤ 2y; all other points satisfy the inductive conclusion. If no such a_{0} exists, take y = U/2. For a point a ≤u ∈[U/2, U], failure of Ba ≤u would imply U/(2B) < a ≤U, a contradiction.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Window1.lean:6--58
Corollary 8.40 (The common exceptional-twist window). Let 0 < η ≤C_{t}, X > 1, and 𝒳 ⊂ℕ, |𝒳| ≤R. With
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
J = 2^{R+2}(C_{t}/η)^{R}there is X^{1/J} ≤Y , Y^{2}≤X, such that for all x ∈[Y, Y^{2}],
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
e ∈𝒳, e ≤x^{Ct} =⇒ e ≤x^{η}.Proof. Apply Lemma 8.39 with U = log X, B = C_{t}/η, and the finite set {log e/C_{t} : e ∈𝒳, e > 0}. Put Y = e^{y}. For e > 0, set u = log x; the hypothesis on e is log e/C_{t} ≤u, and the lemma gives log e/η ≤ log x. The case e = 0 is immediate. The two endpoint inequalities follow by exponentiation.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Window.lean:7--43
Proposition 8.41 (The small-twist repair inside that window). Assume Lemma K with C_{K} ≥ 1, the two tower estimates (215)–(216), and a fixed layer L_{j0}/L_{0} satisfying
[L_{j0} : ℚ] ≤n_{0}, log(2|∆_{Lj0}|) ≤c_{0}x^{ε/4}.
Suppose X^{1/J} ≤x ≤X, x ≥1, and 𝒳_{Z} is the set in Lemma 8.38, with Z = ⌊X^{Ct}⌋. If the common-window conclusion holds with η = ε/(2C_{K}), then every 1 ≤e ≤x^{Ct} and every layer of height m ≤a_{0}(1 + log x) has finite length, with
s_{ℓ}(L_{m}, e) + 1 ≤C(1 + log x) + 2e^{Cx3ε/4}
for one constant C independent of e, m, x, X. Consequently its sum over 1 ≤e < t(x) ≤x^{Ct} is at most exp(x^{4ε/5}) for sufficiently large x.
Proof. If e /∈𝒳_{Z}, use the first tower estimate and
⌊log_{ℓ}Z⌋≤2C_{t} log X ≤2C_{t}J log x.
The factor 2 is valid because log ℓ≥ log 2 > 1/2. Thus this length is at most a fixed multiple of 1+log x. If e ∈𝒳_{Z}, the common-window property gives e ≤x^{ε/(2CK)}. The fixed layer contains the required primitive root of unity, so Lemma K applies. Dividing its logarithmic cardinality bound by log ℓ> 1/2 bounds its H^{2} length by ( ) ( )
2 exp (2en_{0})^{CK}c_{0}x^{ε/4} ≤2 exp (2n_{0})^{CK}c_{0}x^{3ε/4} .
Use the second tower estimate and the bound on m. Taking C larger than all the fixed coefficients proves the stated estimate, including its extra one. Both bounds also prove finiteness.
To sum, multiply by at most x^{Ct} terms. The logarithm of the resulting upper bound is at most
log 3 + (|C_{t}| + |C|) log x + |C| + |C|x^{3ε/4},
after bounding C(1 + log x) by its exponential. Dividing by x^{4ε/5} gives a limit of zero, since 3/4 < 4/5. It is therefore at most x^{4ε/5} eventually.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/ImportsAlt.lean:9--61; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Point2.lean:8--49; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/Final.lean:6--68
Lemma 8.42 (The base field for the two-place comparison). Let K_{ψ} be the field cut out by ψ, of degree o. For a prime pair q, d as above, put _{√√}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
L_{0} = K_{ψ}(i, −q, −d).Then [L_{0} : ℚ] ≤8o, µ_{4} ⊂L_{0}, and L_{0} has conductor dividing 4mqd. For every ψ-field E with page a ≥2, E(i) = L_{0}(µ_{2}a+2) is a cyclotomic layer over L_{0}, of height at most a + 2, and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
s_{2}(E, e) ≤1 + s_{2}(E(i), e) (e ≥1).Proof. The character definition of the fixed field gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
E = K_{ψ} ℚ(µ_{2}a+2)^{+}ℚ(^{√}−q) ℚ(^{√}−d).For q, d ≡3 (mod 4), the last two quadratic characters are their Legendre characters; their conductors are q, d. Adjoining i to the real 2-power cyclotomic field recovers the full cyclotomic field, since it is a quadratic CM extension and i is not real. This proves the claimed equality. The degree and conductor bounds follow from the four compositum factors. Since i ∈ L_{0}, the further 2-power cyclotomic extension is cyclic of 2-power degree, and its degree is at most 2^{a+1}, which suffices for the stated height bound.
Restriction preserves all the local conditions. Its cohomology kernel is contained in
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(
H^{1} Gal(E(i)/E), A^{GE(i)}).
The latter has length at most one. Indeed the quotient group is trivial or cyclic of order two, and the invariant module is a finite cyclic 2-primary group (a subgroup of ℚ_{2}/ℤ_{2}, finite because the positive cyclotomic twist has nontrivial open image). Its first cyclic cohomology is a subquotient of a cyclic group and is killed by two, hence has at most two elements. Length additivity for restriction gives the inequality.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/QuadraticExtensions/IsAlgClosureRat.lean:130--145; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LayeredIsomorphisms/PartA.lean:14--78
For finitely many exceptional coefficient primes, take the union of their sets 𝒳_{Z}, together with the set for the two-place base. If the separate rank bounds are R_{ℓ} and R_{0}, its cardinality is at most R = R_{0} +∑R_{ℓ}.
Corollary 8.40 then uses the single exponent
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
J = 2^{R+2}(2C_{K}C_{t}/ε)^{R}for all of them. The finitely many lower thresholds can be replaced by their maximum, and X can be in-creased so that X^{1/J} exceeds it. Proposition 8.41 therefore gives the simultaneous two-place and layer bounds on one window. In conjunction with the plus estimates, these are the first hypothesis of Proposi-tion 8.4.
The tower assertions used here are established below. Proposition 8.58 proves both quantitative inequal-ities from a generator bound, with the local conditions retained by Proposition 8.52. Proposition 8.61 proves the required generator bound uniformly in the two varying primes. It uses Ferrero–Washington only for the fixed abelian base, then proves the two tame prime costs and the two quadratic restriction costs. This supplies the missing uniformity beyond pointwise vanishing of the Iwasawa µ-invariant.